all fixed from JBH's mod
You don't use album names as sourcesNostalgic wrote:
Not sure if it's mentioned before but shouldn't the source be KAKATTEKOYEAH!!!!?
Thanks!Sinnoh wrote:
lets take a look see, I more just check for playability
[notice] CtB Collab
Neonat
00:40:580 (2,3) - Reduce spacing a bit I made the spacing between 1-3 equal
00:47:961 (2,3) - imo 3 should be a little closer, since the tail is farther away + harder to reach than normal the distance from 3 to the next is still decent, as for between 2 to 3, I think the spacing would not be an issue here
00:50:317 (6) - This could really use a hyperdash though it has a point, I do not really want to implement a dash in the 1/4 beat, it's quite sudden
01:43:092 (1) - Increase movement here, unexpected for a stronger sound here to have less movement. shifted slightly more as well
01:47:804 (1) - weird flow, use something like this instead what 'this' is I am not sure, but I ctrl + G
01:54:087 (9,1) - spacing too large
01:57:228 (4,5) - ^ I made some slight 1 note adjustments on these
02:00:684 (1) - just replace with 4x repeat instead ok
01:58:014 (8,1,6,7) - bit of inconsistency with patterns, can you reduce spacing on second ok
05:16:548 (3,1) - 1/4s + antiflow is overdoing it, I tried to ctrl + g it
05:19:061 (6,1) - edge dash, remove I made it a hyper
hey not bad tbh
Ming
03:02:569 (2) - really missing out on the 1/3s here
04:47:176 (3,1) - Can you adjust these so that the droplets are easier to catch, just move them out a bit
these 2 were edited from the suggestions
Others were changed, thanks!Sinnoh wrote:
[notice] CtB Collab
Xinely
00:09:165 (3) - This piano could use some more emphasis here, could ctrl-g + move right. the main emphasis is on every first beat of a bar
01:26:757 (1) - For this part, reverse flow hypers are used on quiet sounds, and follows slider body on strong sounds. The jump at 01:27:699 (4,1) - breaks this though, change flow a bit. imo i’d just ctrl-h the pattern after the jump at 01:27:699 (4,1) is the same though, as for the quiet sounds, I don't really see what these sounds are, for they seem pronounced, as in where the current sliders start, and where the hypers are located in the song
01:29:270 (1,2) - Spacing too large here for soft sound
01:37:752 (5,6) - smaller spacing here despite higher pitch sound those are the secondary layer of the song and is not the layer being idealized
02:33:982 (3,4) - spacing too large it's equal with the rest
04:26:443 (1) - to 04:28:642 (4) - this is pretty much the same pattern, mix up well the rhythm is the same, but the movement differs
04:36:338 (6) - reduce spacing, little unexpected leads to the next section, higher strength
Spec
00:30:213 (1) - This could use more emphasis just a slight increase
00:52:359 (4,5,6) - Not sure if three hypers are fine here considering they’re unmapped in some other places, fairly inconsistent. song does gradually start increasing in volume, tune of the song changes eventually as well, it changes as you go along and may seem irregular
00:59:977 (6) - sounds a bit odd not to map the snare here having it continuous makes it harder to emphasize the gap, I think it better to have the 5 note lead-in instead of a connector from the last slider
Thanks for looking though, Unmei Muma will reply to the rest soon!Toehoe wrote:
Mania 4k Collab
1|2|3|4Good luck! Hope I was helpful!
- 04:11:207 (251207|1,251207|3,251207|2) - I think remove |2| here as 3-note seems too over the top. It would still be emphasised by the jack, plays nicer leading in into the next section, so it is stronger with 3 notes
- 04:45:370 (285370|3,285448|2,285527|1,285605|3,285605|0) - I think you should continue this through 04:45:605 - here there really isn't anything there though, the 1/4 ends at the current location
- 05:16:705 - This section should really be the same as 05:06:652 - , they sound identical. I don't think intensity should decrease it is true the collab of the other diff differs, but the progression of slowing down differs between them, this one is leaning more towards the increasing slowdown shown in the ctb and std as well
ty mateToehoe wrote:
Mania 4k Collab
1|2|3|4Good luck! Hope I was helpful!
- 02:04:453 - 02:09:480 - I think you should have 1/2 notes on both, instead of 1/1 then 1/2 while the idea is good in essence, i'd like to keep the current pattern to show a buildup instead of having the same density throughout.
- 02:50:946 - I suggest adding 3-note chords on 1/1 for emphasis on heavy sound for this part done
- 03:06:652 - make it more like 03:09:480 ? changed the pattern of the beginning a bit to fit more what was done a bit later
- 03:16:705 - Same here. I think the LN section should match the music more, right now I don't think it fits at all changed to 1/2 LNs
- 03:37:438 - 03:39:951 - I think 3-note chords would be good here i would rather keep the current structure as it is building up - the reason why it's not a handstream later is because well lol handstreams
- 04:06:024 - I'm not sure about this part. It sounds like 04:06:338 - should be heavier. Maybe make LN end earlier and have a big chord? And add more jack? I think it definitely fits, but not sure how to add it likely to be caused by the change, but i shortened the LN@3 to give way to a double, even triple chord
lol.Sinnoh wrote:
um why are there still replays and user rating from when it was loved