frukoyurdakul's mod
frukoyurdakul wrote:
Hello from my queue :3 :3
[Oni]
00:23:868 (2) - Didn't see the difference of using a finisher on this. The sounds are basically the same like 00:20:286 (2) - this note and yet you didn't use finisher. Keeping it consistent would be good. Valid point, but if I do so it'd be inconsistent with softer 00:27:450 (1) - which creates the pattern of K->K->K->k. I'd keep the current K->k->K->k pattern for now unless more modders point this out.
00:58:345 - For this part, I recommend 00:58:345 (1) - don, 00:58:681 (1,2) - kat on these. It'll follow the drums better. True, but I'd like to keep the consistent vocal/pitch-oriented style throughout the song (considering pitch rise at 00:57:450 (1,2,3,1) - )
01:55:659 - Same suggestion I did before. ^
The diff is very good, sorry for the short mod ;w; It's fine :3
[Muzukashii]
00:41:107 - Add a note? You have a triplet on Oni diff, it'll create a better spread. I'd prefer empty here, because of consistent rest sections in this diff at 00:33:271 - and 00:36:853 -.
00:58:345 (1,2) - Not sure about this gap. Rhythm-wise this is the hardest part on Oni diff and yet you leave it completely blank on Muzukashii. It'll be better if you follow the drums on that spot, like you did in Oni. If you accept it, remember to fill this part on Futsuu and Kantan. My suggestion will be adding a slider, or using a triplet which goes kkk on 00:58:793 - this spot. True, but I personally care more about difficulty balance and consistency of one diff rather than consistency or gradual difficulty rise among all 4 diffs. If I add objects because of your reasons, similar changes would have done on 00:44:017 -
etc too. To prevent muzukashii having too little rests I will keep this unchanged for now.
01:55:659 (1,2) - ^ ^
I believe the last kiai can be a bit harder. For instance, after you use 1/4 doublets which are going on kk, you left some huge blank spots. If you add one more note on these gaps, it'll make the kiai more dense, since it's the hardest section in Oni diff. Current setup seems to be one of the hardest parts in muzukashii already (harder than 1st kiai, comparably difficult with section 00:16:256 -). I might consider changing doublets to kkk, but using kkk at 02:16:928 - doesn't sound good unless I use kkd which can be quite difficult. As for the blank spots issue, I think that's part of the consistency (comparing with 1st kiai which also have similar rests, but already denser and more difficult) Good point, but let's see how others think for now.
[Futsuu]
-Kiai suggestions-
01:09:763 (2,3) - How about starting the slider from 2nd note instead of where it is now? There are no additional vocal sounds 01:09:987 - on this spot, so the slider feels unneccessary. Deleting the don before the slider and moving the slider 1/2 snap back will be good. Remember extending it to 01:10:883 - here if you move the slider. Possible, but 01:09:763 - is part of the 01:07:748 (1,1,2,3,1,2) - vocal which I don't want them separated. Keeping unchanged for now
01:11:554 - ^ ^
-End kiai-
01:53:644 - Add a note? You are following vocals since then and this will support the vocal sound. I recommend kat, and if you add it change 01:53:420 (1) - this to don in order to follow the vocal pitch. I can do this, but if so 01:54:316 - would be changed to 01:54:204 - and k would be added at 01:54:539 -. Same things would be applied at section 00:56:107 -. Not sure if this is too complicated for futsuu. Will wait for some more feedback.
[Kantan]
Same suggestions on sliders in Futsuu diff I mentioned. ^ Similar concerns with futsuu. In kantan's case, starting slider at 01:09:763 - doesn't seem to fit the 1/1 rhythm from the past few notes, but I might consider this.
Good, solid mapset and nice choice of song, I hope my mod helps~ Good luck! Thank you
Nyan's mod
Nyan wrote:
[Kantan]
00:14:465 (2) -
I'm not sure if this is to provide more space for incoming notes, but if it is, I'd like more feedback because current slider length seems to fit the song's context better?
01:09:987 (3,4) - same as above ^, but this time the next object is slider too?
02:07:301 (3,4) - same as above ^
02:23:420 (1) - like 01:26:107 (1,1) , add Finisher (don) on the endpoint See muzukashii.
[Futsuu]
02:23:420 (1) - like 01:26:107 (1,1) , add Finisher (don) on the endpoint See muzukashii.
[Muzukashii]
00:47:599 (1) - d o n I guess you suggested this for pattern variations (avoiding dkkdk x3), but since 00:47:487 - suggests a higher vocal pitch I prefer k here. For now I changed 00:46:704 - to dkddk for better contrast with 00:44:913 -.
00:56:778 - add a kat Good suggestion, but I wonder if this 1/4 would be too sudden (compared to other sections where 1/4s exist on certain parts repeatedly). Would like more modders' suggestions.
01:22:301 - add a don Possible, but I'm not sure if 01:22:301~01:25:659 is too dense, and whether I should break the o ooo pattern at 01:20:734 - and 01:22:525 -.
01:33:942 - add a kat v Applied.
01:41:107 - add a don Doesn't seem to be harder than oni. Good suggestion :3
02:17:599 - add a kat Similar concern with 01:22:301 - above.
02:23:420 (1) - like 01:26:107 (1,1) , add Finisher (don) on the endpoint Might consider this. Spinner end seems to be a better way to end a difficulty? (considering a note afterwards seem to suggest some more notes incoming?)
[Oni]
00:29:689 (2,1,1,2,3) - kd kk k Nice observation. Changed to kd kkkk K
01:01:704 (2,3,4) - kk Do you mean kk instead of kkk? That was actually my original plan before completion, but I felt 01:01:928~01:02:263 a bit too empty if I do so. Also kkk gives some more rhythm consistency with 01:05:286 which uses 1/4 x3 as well, although for a different reason. Might change this if more modders concern about this
01:05:286 (2,1,1) - kd ^, I used kdk because I see this as kd + k d d k k at 01:05:510 (1,2,2,1,2) -.
01:16:032 (2,3,4) - kk ^ 01:01:704 -.
01:19:614 (2,1,1) - kd (no changes on 2nd kiai) ^ 01:05:286 -.
Thanks both for your mod