meme4meme

[Normal]
00:09:712 (2,4) - move 2 up for some spicy symmetry?
00:57:212 (1,2) - the only thing i cant stand is this rhythm maybe try something like this https://puu.sh/wodSF.jpg and ifyou use it please apply it evertwhere thanks xd
01:00:212 (3,4,5) -pretty acute angle maybe put 5 a bit to the right,same with the later ones

[Advanced]

why dont you make the same pattern here 00:06:212 (5,6) - like you did here 00:08:212 (5,6) - where 6 changed in comparise to 5
00:09:212 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - i dont think this is really beginner friendly because stacks
00:24:212 (1,2) - why not copy paste 00:23:212 (1,2) - ?
00:31:837 (2,3) - id follow the vocal here because is way easier to follow imo
00:48:212 (1,2) - lowkey blanket? triggerd
01:05:962 (3,1) - blankets ssss

[Hard]
00:04:962 (6) - is this silenced cuz of piano in background or what
00:10:212 - imo you should use the same rhythm you used before instead of just notes,fits better imo
00:46:212 (1,2,3) - stack 2 on 3 maybe to avoid awkward angle?
00:51:212 (1,1,1,1) - why not make a square or anyhing symmetric with it?
01:00:962 (3) - ctrl+g for spicy flow?
01:06:587 (2,3) - 🅱lanket
01:08:962 (3) - same as above
01:10:712 (1) - could be mapped instead of boring 1/1 reverse slider


[Insane]

i always play maps before i mod them and the star rating was lying to me pretty hard here LOL

calling this an insane is a big lie
00:17:587 - remove nc here and 00:18:587 - ?
00:40:087 (4) - what does this do
00:55:212 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4) - i dont think the windmill of friendship in such a big size shouldnt belong in a insane diff
01:01:212 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - nor these i know they fit the music well but i think its a bit to hard for an insane at 240 bpm
01:03:212 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4) - if you start it small as you did here its fine but the rather large one at the beginning is pretty hard tbh
01:12:337 (2,3,4,1) - 🅱lanket
01:14:337 (2,3) - ^ i just dont mention blankets anymore
01:19:837 (3,1,1,2,3) - maybe space it a bit out so you dont have to watch when the approach circles hits the slider


[🍎 Insane]

00:15:712 (3,4) - why a 1/1+note over 2 1/2 sliders as before? music doesnt change at all
00:13:712 (3,4) - is pretty spaced in comparise to 00:15:712 (3,4) -
cant really see anything major in here. i really like this diff well done!

[Professionalbo...i mean pishifat's Extra]


00:40:712 (1,2,3,4) - please keep the circular movement from before this was so weird to play
01:02:212 (1,2,1,2,3) - its hard to see/notice that 01:02:962 (2,3) - are just regular sliders again
01:04:462 (2,3,4) - i think something is missing ;^)

im sorry that i couldnt really help you here

[Extra]

honestly,this is too hard for me to judge properly.I mean i could mention some stuff but i cant even be sure if the things i suggest would be better/are even right

i cant even play this diff lol


anyway great set!

got room for something inbetween top two ?

I ran out of songs to map lol

water mod xc
[EX]
00:04:962 - hs whistle, green line volume too low as well
green lines are kinda random, guess you will fix them later

[pish]
too good

[apple]
00:04:962 - weird volume
00:41:587 (2) - in the whole section, only this is stacked to to sliderend, kinda weird, just saying. 00:43:587 (2) - 00:39:837 (2) - 00:44:587 (2) -
01:10:712 (3,4) - uhm.... blanket or idk
some green lines are not used, including the last green line

[Insane]
00:04:962 - volume
00:18:712 (2) - combo burst might cover slider repeat 00:19:212 (1) - , kinda edgy, same to others in this section
00:45:212 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4) - kinda too hard to read for a insane, better as same to latter section
01:24:462 (1) - why nc
01:28:712 (1) - why nc

[hard]
00:04:962 - hs

Mazziv wrote:

meme4meme

[Normal]
00:09:712 (2,4) - move 2 up for some spicy symmetry?
00:57:212 (1,2) - the only thing i cant stand is this rhythm maybe try something like this https://puu.sh/wodSF.jpg and ifyou use it please apply it evertwhere thanks xd i can se why you dont like it but i think either version do the same xd mine trying to cover drums more tho
01:00:212 (3,4,5) -pretty acute angle maybe put 5 a bit to the right,same with the later ones

[Advanced]

why dont you make the same pattern here 00:06:212 (5,6) - like you did here 00:08:212 (5,6) - where 6 changed in comparise to 5 second pattern sound pretty different tho
00:09:212 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - i dont think this is really beginner friendly because stacks
00:24:212 (1,2) - why not copy paste 00:23:212 (1,2) - ? i ran out of space xd also they sound bit different so why not
00:31:837 (2,3) - id follow the vocal here because is way easier to follow imo
00:48:212 (1,2) - lowkey blanket? triggerd
01:05:962 (3,1) - blankets ssss didnt meant to blank here xd

[Hard]
00:04:962 (6) - is this silenced cuz of piano in background or what
00:10:212 - imo you should use the same rhythm you used before instead of just notes,fits better imo wanted to make it different for the drums
00:46:212 (1,2,3) - stack 2 on 3 maybe to avoid awkward angle?
00:51:212 (1,1,1,1) - why not make a square or anyhing symmetric with it? made a little triangle
01:00:962 (3) - ctrl+g for spicy flow? i barely do minijumps in this diff, so doesnt seem to fit well
01:06:587 (2,3) - 🅱lanket
01:08:962 (3) - same as above
01:10:712 (1) - could be mapped instead of boring 1/1 reverse slider


[Insane]

i always play maps before i mod them and the star rating was lying to me pretty hard here LOL 240 bpm makes it harder i guess?uhm

calling this an insane is a big lie
00:17:587 - remove nc here and 00:18:587 - ? they fit the drums i think
00:40:087 (4) - what does this do map the drums
00:55:212 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4) - i dont think the windmill of friendship in such a big size shouldnt belong in a insane diff as an insane player, i have to say that these are p ez to play xd
01:01:212 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - nor these i know they fit the music well but i think its a bit to hard for an insane at 240 bpm these are a bit harder, but still quite doable
01:03:212 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4) - if you start it small as you did here its fine but the rather large one at the beginning is pretty hard tbh
01:12:337 (2,3,4,1) - 🅱lanket
01:14:337 (2,3) - ^ i just dont mention blankets anymore
01:19:837 (3,1,1,2,3) - maybe space it a bit out so you dont have to watch when the approach circles hits the slider

[Extra]

honestly,this is too hard for me to judge properly.I mean i could mention some stuff but i cant even be sure if the things i suggest would be better/are even right

i cant even play this diff lol


anyway great set!

@shadow, all fixed ty

Extra

00:05:712 (3,4) - Kinda weird not to map the red tick when you use extended sliders like 00:05:212 (1) - cuz those kinda imply you want players to follow the song more closely. Yea it's just weird to switch from dense rhythm in the intro with those 1/2 to 1/1 rhythms. It's fine for the other circles, but here theres clear 1/2 support xP. Applies to othe rplaces. like 00:21:712 (3,4) - etc..
00:24:962 (3,1) - SV change is really huge but imo the song doesn't really shift tempo that much... This feels really forced. Imo i would reduce the SV starting 00:24:962 (3,1) - to like 0.8x already.
00:54:712 (1,2) - They sound more like 1/3. I can't hear any support for 1/8... if anything 1/6 for the second slider.

pishi's Extra

00:15:212 (1) - The slider shape really breaks flow for me xP. Use a shape that better corresponds with the movement you want players to make xP. There's an uncomfortable hold you ahve to make on the head before moving leftward. Also cuz its going over itself the movement leftward is much lower than other sliders so the slider feels a lot slower to play compared to others like 00:16:212 (1) - .
00:22:462 (2,3) - Stacking is a bad idea tbh. Really doesn't express anything.
00:37:837 (4) - Make this circle blanket 5 instead? so theres some movement? Tbh your triple 1/2 stacks feel out of place with the slider and movement emphasis youve created with this map.

Tbh all the 1/2 stacks you use in kiai also feel out of place when you use this kind of concept xP. Like, you're pushing the player to make really fast movements, considering how high the BPM and SV multipliers are. The stacks really kill momentum. For example 00:57:212 (1,2,3,4) - You want even more momentum going into 4 for the pitch change, and you indicate that with a larger jump, but you end up having to go into the pattern without the momentum you built up from earlier.

I could say the same about the 1/1 stacks like 01:06:212 (1,2) - . They also contribute to this stop-go type of flow that just feels really uncomfortable when you're using high speed sliders.

apple's Insane

00:23:212 (1,2,3) - Rhythm felt a bit weird. I don't really see why there needs to be two circles there, specially since you mapped the vocal on 00:23:337 - to a slider-end.
01:21:712 (3,4,5) - Same, I would do some ctrl+G thing here. It's like, an unnecessary shift to offbeat rhythm imo. Especially since you don't attempt to repeat it or variate that particular rhythm afterwards and instead stick with normal 1/2 rhythms.

<3

Insane

00:49:337 (2,4,2) - The overlaps look off.. Maybe copy/paste them again idk.
00:54:712 (1) - 1/6 imo.
01:06:587 (2,3) - Just use the same rhythm as 01:07:212 (1,2,3,1) - ? I don't see a need to do 3/2 rhythm here.
01:17:962 (4,1,2,3,4) - Some stacks to fix.

Hard

00:16:587 (2,3) - Eh blanket
00:24:087 (4,2) - Clicking on these notes just felt really forced. Are they really necessary for this rhythm on a Hard? I think you could hav ejust stuck to clicking on white ticks.
00:48:712 (3) - I would make this two 1/2 sliders instead too keep the rhythm more straight forward. The 3/2 slider feels out of place when you're using 1/2 clicks. 1/2 sliders leads into denser rhythm better than simpler slider too.
00:54:712 (1) - 1/3 etc..
01:10:712 (1,2) - Ctrl+G? Or just make the white ticks clickable instead? More straightforward. Really not sure why 01:11:087 - is prioritized as something clickable.

Normal

00:35:212 (1,2) - Spacing got kinda messed up here. It's 1.00 instead of your usual 1.5

[]

Should be all I think.

Mazziv wrote:

[🍎 Insane]

00:15:712 (3,4) - why a 1/1+note over 2 1/2 sliders as before? music doesnt change at all // there are 1/2 sliders here already tho?
00:13:712 (3,4) - is pretty spaced in comparise to 00:15:712 (3,4) - // true
cant really see anything major in here. i really like this diff well done! // <3

Shad0w1and wrote:

[apple]
00:04:962 - weird volume // yes
00:41:587 (2) - in the whole section, only this is stacked to to sliderend, kinda weird, just saying. 00:43:587 (2) - 00:39:837 (2) - 00:44:587 (2) - // good point
01:10:712 (3,4) - uhm.... blanket or idk // meh i tried
some green lines are not used, including the last green line // blame hs copier, since they dont do much i will keep them

Monstrata wrote:

apple's Insane

00:23:212 (1,2,3) - Rhythm felt a bit weird. I don't really see why there needs to be two circles there, specially since you mapped the vocal on 00:23:337 - to a slider-end. // its a slider now
01:21:712 (3,4,5) - Same, I would do some ctrl+G thing here. It's like, an unnecessary shift to offbeat rhythm imo. Especially since you don't attempt to repeat it or variate that particular rhythm afterwards and instead stick with normal 1/2 rhythms. // its not offbeat anymore, but i did use two circles instead, i think thats okay since object density increased

<3 // <3

thank you guys!! http://puu.sh/wta98/afc0f1eb5c.zip

getting ur gd'er to mod

i liked the old bg more. girl looked more like a lunatic but up to u

extra
- 00:04:462 (6) - makes more sense to increase/keep the same sv bc the increase in pitch of the piano is much more prominent than the woosh sound thingy
- 00:04:712 (7) - idk drum finish here sounds bit weird bc theres no drum. would either lower volume a bit or use other hitsound like whistle instead
- 00:12:212 (1,2,3,4) - maybe ctrl+g? hitsounds increase in volume so itd b cool if spacing did too
- 00:13:962 (5) - normal sample? clap is more logical bc when do u use normal lel
- 00:17:587 (3) - clap instead??
- 00:25:837 (3) - 00:29:837 (3) - idk with all those red tick rhythm stuff it really makes this part feel so vocal centered (which these sliders are not, vocal on red tick skipped). combined with how everything gets offbeat with these 1/1 sliders too it sound pretty weird`
- 00:44:462 (2) - cymbal so strong, offbeat is sad
- 00:50:337 (2) - bc u make this guitar clickable it makes (not) sense to have the sound completely skipped at 00:49:837 (4) -
- 00:54:712 (1,2) - i trust pishi with snapping so i dont think this is correct (check his diff, would use 1/3 and 1/6 respectively)
- 00:56:962 (5) - clap supposed to b on head instead?
- 00:58:899 (5) - 01:06:899 (4) - maybe im hearing stuff wrong but there are multiple beats before this (like on 1/6 or smth) but not here
- 01:10:212 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - uh idk if theres spacing logic behind this or if u just blindly placed the back and forth, but idk if you did some spacing decrease here would b cool 8)
- 01:14:962 (4,5) - there r snares too so maybe claps as well
- 01:19:462 (2,3,4,5) - hmm these seem a bit large for my taste. the song, aside from the vocal, has practically faded out here. even with the high spacing section before, i think spacing can be lowered a bit here to fit music more, would help too bc the notes after this are dense 1/4 with hard jumps lol
- 01:27:212 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,1) - have my babies
- hitsounds might apply to other diffs

pishi
- 00:35:587 (4) - still trying to figure out why u skipped this? like u skipped stuff on purpose for vocal (00:32:337 (2,1,1) - ) before so skipping this + drum makes me very confused
- 00:58:899 (3) - etc. i had the same comment in milans diff; like theres some weird snap sounds on the body of (2) but i cant really here anything on the blue tick here at all so idk if it was just misheard or overmap on purpose
- 01:14:962 (1,2) - 01:28:212 (1,2,3,4) - why not 1.5 like 00:12:712 (1,2) - lol its red and loud, would b more consistent and cooler ofc 8) (or 1.25 like 01:19:962 (1,2,3) - ) idk now they look pretty standard which this map is not

what is modding

Monstrata wrote:

Extra

00:05:712 (3,4) - Kinda weird not to map the red tick when you use extended sliders like 00:05:212 (1) - cuz those kinda imply you want players to follow the song more closely. Yea it's just weird to switch from dense rhythm in the intro with those 1/2 to 1/1 rhythms. It's fine for the other circles, but here theres clear 1/2 support xP. Applies to othe rplaces. like 00:21:712 (3,4) - etc.. i see what you mean, but i wanted to focus more on the drums in these sections compared to the beginning which is just piano. and i use 3/4 for the big impact and 1/2 so it doesnt feel weird to stop with a circle

Insane
01:06:587 (2,3) - Just use the same rhythm as 01:07:212 (1,2,3,1) - ? I don't see a need to do 3/2 rhythm here. but they're 1/1 uh, it makes sense as they're mapping the drums

Should be all I think.

appleeaterx wrote:

getting ur gd'er to mod god modder

i liked the old bg more. girl looked more like a lunatic but up to u i kinda do too, (but xexxar is using it as avatar so uhhhm) can change your diff bg if you want

extra
- 00:25:837 (3) - 00:29:837 (3) - idk with all those red tick rhythm stuff it really makes this part feel so vocal centered (which these sliders are not, vocal on red tick skipped). combined with how everything gets offbeat with these 1/1 sliders too it sound pretty weird` uhm it may be weird cuz they're not mapping a specific sound like 00:27:837 (3,4) - , but i wanted to make it less dense and fits the melody well i think ;;
- 00:50:337 (2) - bc u make this guitar clickable it makes (not) sense to have the sound completely skipped at 00:49:837 (4) - but im mapping drums mixed with a bit of vocals here. technically should've done the same with 00:49:212 (1,2) - so did that instead xd
- 00:58:899 (5) - 01:06:899 (4) - maybe im hearing stuff wrong but there are multiple beats before this (like on 1/6 or smth) but not here i hear just 3 beats, but they're a bit off with the song so maybe it's that?
- 01:27:212 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,1) - have my babies apple, the only loli in my life

what is modding diks

fixed the rest, thank you ><

nyan

[general]
00:55:212 - this downbeat feels rly odd cuz i hear a drum beat before the note kicks in lol 00:55:712 - too kinda

[normal]
00:15:962 (2) - 00:57:837 (2) - 01:05:838 (2) - shorten to 1/1 and put on downbeat for vocal sounds better i think
00:51:212 (1,1,1,1) - why nc spam lol

[adv]
tbh i got kinda confused cuz ur 1/2 spacings is rly similar to the 1/1 spacings
^ especially like 00:20:587 (2,3,1) -
otherwise not much to say tho some flow bothers me even tho they're alright playability wise lol

[hard]
00:14:962 (3,1,2) - shud keep ur stacks consistent between 1/2 and 1/1 esp since they're right after eachother

[insane]
00:19:212 (1) - 00:20:212 (1) - reverses are pretty hidden imo
01:19:837 (3,1,1,2) - this is rly hard to read even with the ncs imo

[apple u still have my ticket from like 2 years ago btw]
00:58:837 (4) - 01:06:837 (4) - 1/3
01:19:587 (3) - too close to (2) i think, also the stream doesn't start until 01:19:837 - and u can extend the slider to 01:20:149 -

[learn to map with pishizor`]
00:17:587 (2) - no need to be so far away tho, if anything the stress shud be on (3) instead
00:58:712 (2,3) - 01:06:712 (2,3) - these r 1/3

[nya]
00:58:837 (4,5) - 01:06:712 (3,4) - are 1/3
01:28:212 (1,2,3,4) - rly sudden sv change (pishi's diff is same but at least his is colourhaxed lol

holy how do i mod this lol
call me if u want a test play too :3

cRyo[iceeicee] wrote:

nyan
[apple u still have my ticket from like 2 years ago btw]
// cryo ticket lolol maybe ill claim when i ever finish a set w
00:58:837 (4) - 01:06:837 (4) - 1/3 // woa good catch but that plays beyond retarded... ill see what pishi's judgement is, if he keeps 1/2 i will too xd
01:19:587 (3) - too close to (2) i think, also the stream doesn't start until 01:19:837 - and u can extend the slider to 01:20:149 - // oki

thank uuu http://puu.sh/wz6FR/29fa71f46f.zip

!!!!!!ty!!!!!!!

what a madman

Gaia wrote:

nyan

[general]
00:55:212 - this downbeat feels rly odd cuz i hear a drum beat before the note kicks in lol 00:55:712 - too kinda blame the song

[nya]
00:58:837 (4,5) - 01:06:712 (3,4) - are 1/3 d edits
01:28:212 (1,2,3,4) - rly sudden sv change (pishi's diff is same but at least his is colourhaxed lol [color=#00BFFF]i do it before too, added another nc if that's the any help ;;[color]

holy how do i mod this lol
call me if u want a test play too :3

fixed the rest ty ><

Pho wrote:

what a madman

PunkRockGirl

Bubble! Bubble! Bubble!

Heart! Heart! Heart!

Congratz pishi milan and apple
Very well-done mapset

yey yey finally gratz!!

nice song

wow nice

idk anything about ranking criteria and junk but shouldnt combo colors be consistent throughout the mapset even with guest difficutlies? every diff is the same except pishi who uses harder oranges and reds in the more intense sections

someone give me the knowledge

anyways nice set, every diff is fun to play

-Vanilla wrote:

idk anything about ranking criteria and junk but shouldnt combo colors be consistent throughout the mapset even with guest difficutlies?

I checked, and there's nothing in the ranking criteria that mentions that.

colorhax

thank you all! w

Congrulations!

-Vanilla wrote:

idk anything about ranking criteria and junk but shouldnt combo colors be consistent throughout the mapset even with guest difficutlies? every diff is the same except pishi who uses harder oranges and reds in the more intense sections

someone give me the knowledge

anyways nice set, every diff is fun to play

Combo colors don't have to be the same for the entire mapset. They just shouldn't blend too much with the BG

there could have been more diffs imo
but whateva

The beginning of the pishi's extra map is just boring ans hitty mapped imho.

agreed

pishifat wrote:

agreed

Same