don't forgetabraker wrote:
Pending proof from previous mafia gamesHika wrote:
nah if I was scum I wouldn't have voted
keep it in mind
forum
Newbie Game 15: Rise From The Ashes [Game over!]
posted
Total Posts
1,196
Haven't forgotten, I read ISOs daily
just cbf to get on my laptop at work
just cbf to get on my laptop at work
Now that Jesse answered, I can tellB1rd wrote:
But abraker, I would like it if you could redo your posts, I'm not sure what implications you're making, I'm not sure what you mean when you said 'I threw out two posts', nad you're chart is sort of complicated to read.
The first post I threw out is an attempt to move Sakura towards a side by requesting an explanation on why Dawnsday is scum. I got a neutral answer and concluded that Sakura will need to be pressured to vote on D2 whether it will be a bad or good thing to show more contrast. Just giving townreads might be just one side of Sakura 's story.
The second post I threw out is questioning Jesse why Beeboy is townie. Now this is an attack from two sides and I did get the reaction I was expecting but also got something I did not expect. First, like Sakura I pressured Jesse to shift towards a side. Spark some movement. Second, Beeboy appears on most town reads, which is kinda suspicious if you ask me. Finally, and the most intriguing thing, there were people defending that they never read Beeboy as townie which might say something in that regard.
I still need to make sense of the results, but now I got some tasty flavors to work with
I'm also waiting on a response from rEdo about Sakura, and I'm waiting for Sakura to respond to a post in which I implicated her, which she seemed not to bother to respond to for some reason. Also Hika, maybe you can elaborate on how she is acting different from usual this game.
For some reason rEdo hasn't been on for 45 hours, I assume rEdo has RL stuff but that's still pretty poor form. And about jess, that's a bit of headache... I think we can deal with that next the next day.
For some reason rEdo hasn't been on for 45 hours, I assume rEdo has RL stuff but that's still pretty poor form. And about jess, that's a bit of headache... I think we can deal with that next the next day.
This a game to find the truth you knucklehead-[Jess]- wrote:
Why townread but no sucmread
this not a game to find who is townabraker wrote:
you can a learn a thing or two from cumulative town reads. Now why do you want to know who is thinking who is scum or not?
The scumread of D1 was Dawnsday. Why to ask for anything else is beyond me, especially since you unconditionally agreed in you most recent posts
OMFG WTF JESS D2 MY VOTE IS GOING TO YOU AND IS NEVER MOVING.
I'm not sure what post you're referring to, all I remember is you asking rEdo about me playing different than usual.B1rd wrote:
I'm also waiting on a response from rEdo about Sakura, and I'm waiting for Sakura to respond to a post in which I implicated her, which she seemed not to bother to respond to for some reason. Also Hika, maybe you can elaborate on how she is acting different from usual this game.
For some reason rEdo hasn't been on for 45 hours, I assume rEdo has RL stuff but that's still pretty poor form. And about jess, that's a bit of headache... I think we can deal with that next the next day.
I don't know if you want my MS Alt meta or what, but sure i can provide that, im just not sure if you're interested on meta diving that or not:
http://forum.mafiascum.net/memberlist.p ... le&u=26607
http://forum.mafiascum.net/memberlist.p ... le&u=26607
Oh this.B1rd wrote:
There's always the chance of mislynches, but at the end of the day, you have to press on against the most likely person. What you say is plausible, but frankly, you're still just giving yourself license to hang back and stay out of the line-of-fire while being everyone's friend with town reads. In my experience, being neutral and not trying to seek out scum, especially on D1, isn't townie behaviour.
@rEdo, you mentioned that Sakura is playing different from usual, could you elaborate on this?
Yeah well i got that a lot on the alt, but everyone got used to my new playstyle there.
Someone even called it Reverse scumhunting lol.
I mean she did declare intent pages ago to be fair or do you have other reasons to think she is scum?Sakura wrote:
OMFG WTF JESS D2 MY VOTE IS GOING TO YOU AND IS NEVER MOVING.
Except she said she didnt want to hammer him Oo
what do you mean by this Jess o3o-[Jess]- wrote:
Now I know why draw is scum
Topic Starter
Do you mean my votecounts are unreliable?Hika wrote:
@MOD: Can you do an accurate vote count to make sure dawn didn't get rekt
(Anyways, I did a double check to be sure)
Huh? They already decided?!
Votecount 1.4 (D1 Final)
Dawnsday [5] - abrake, Frostings, rEdo, Hika, -[Jess]- (LYNCH)
Hika [1] - beeboy123
B1rd [0] -
Sakura [0] -
abraker [0] -
-[Jess]- [0] -
Frostings [0] -
beeboy123 [0] -
rEdo [0] -
No Lynch [0] -
Not Voting [3] - Dawnsday, Sakura, B1rd
With 9 alive, it's 5 to lynch.
Dawnsday [5] - abrake, Frostings, rEdo, Hika, -[Jess]- (LYNCH)
Hika [1] - beeboy123
B1rd [0] -
Sakura [0] -
abraker [0] -
-[Jess]- [0] -
Frostings [0] -
beeboy123 [0] -
rEdo [0] -
No Lynch [0] -
Not Voting [3] - Dawnsday, Sakura, B1rd
With 9 alive, it's 5 to lynch.
A lynch has been achieved. Scene coming soon.
^ you're amazing tbh
Topic Starter
The town decided Dawnsday was guilty for defending himself, and was quickly lynched. He did seem shady anyways - he always followed people and was fantastic at not being noticed, but he actually used his abilities for good.
The town seemed satisfied anyways. The broke up the meeting and went to see the poor mayor.
But it didn't seem this was over.
Dawnsday, Town Tracker, was lynched Day 1.
It is now Night 1. It ends 48 hours after this post, that is, February 15th, 10:00 PM UTC.
All actions are due to my inbox until that timeline.
The town seemed satisfied anyways. The broke up the meeting and went to see the poor mayor.
But it didn't seem this was over.
Dawnsday, Town Tracker, was lynched Day 1.
It is now Night 1. It ends 48 hours after this post, that is, February 15th, 10:00 PM UTC.
All actions are due to my inbox until that timeline.
Topic Starter
Sidenote: I know the ruleset says 36 hours for night, however due to the real life (work) I am unable to end the night at such hour. That's why the deadline is 48 hours, as 24 would be too short. Thanks for your understanding.
Topic Starter
"As day came, a person was missing from the town meeting. A body was found in the middle of the streets....
No wait, that's the book I'm reading. Everyone is pretty much fine and accounted for this day's meeting... well.. except Dawnday.
Was the bomb thing a prank? People didn't think so, as the mayor was still seriously injured, and were looking already for others culprits."
No one died Night 1.
It is now Day 2. It ends 8 days after this post, that is, Thursday, February 23th, 10:00 PM UTC.
No wait, that's the book I'm reading. Everyone is pretty much fine and accounted for this day's meeting... well.. except Dawnday.
Was the bomb thing a prank? People didn't think so, as the mayor was still seriously injured, and were looking already for others culprits."
No one died Night 1.
It is now Day 2. It ends 8 days after this post, that is, Thursday, February 23th, 10:00 PM UTC.
Votecount 2.0 (Day 2 Start)
Hika [0] -
Sakura [0] -
abraker [0] -
-[Jess]- [0] -
Frostings [0] -
B1rd [0] -
beeboy123 [0] -
rEdo [0] -
No Lynch [0] -
Not Voting [8] - Hika, Sakura, -[Jess]-, abraker , Frostings , B1rd, beeboy123, rEdo
With 8 alive, it's 5 to lynch.
Hika [0] -
Sakura [0] -
abraker [0] -
-[Jess]- [0] -
Frostings [0] -
B1rd [0] -
beeboy123 [0] -
rEdo [0] -
No Lynch [0] -
Not Voting [8] - Hika, Sakura, -[Jess]-, abraker , Frostings , B1rd, beeboy123, rEdo
With 8 alive, it's 5 to lynch.
mafia tried to get bulletproof townie?
Dear God why all the RETARDED stuff happens when I have other things in mind...
Claim: 1-Shot Bulletproof
Proper post in a second.
Claim: 1-Shot Bulletproof
Proper post in a second.
Makes me curious why the mafia didn't bother with you then...Hika wrote:
Alright, if I don't vote you, you'll investigate me?
I prefer you not to because I'm VANILLA TOWNIE.
Alright. This is a highly subjective thing, but I would like to address it here and now.
I also start to question beeboy's alignment due to him getting too silent when the lynch occured. But hey, the same argument applies to me then xd
Jess, why did you hammer Dawnsday. Just what the fuck, we weren't even done with discussion. If I had been on the forum the moment you said you're gonna hammer, or at least hours after that, I would unvote >_> Don't take it too personally, but why do you even bother signing up to these games if you're not even reading what we're doing here?
I find it really disturbing that abraker didn't point to anyone else as scum besides a safe lynch guy Dawnsday. To me it looks like a try to letting the lynch pass after a very long inactivity.abraker wrote:
Going to bed. Will be around 7pm EST
Need -[Jesse]-'s response
So far by the looks of it, -[Jesse]- might be mafia trying to be silent and out of trouble by voting Dawnsday. It may be a good way avert eyes on you especially if everybody is convinced that person you are voting for is mafia.
Frostings is a compulsive doo-hikey. Sporadically votes based on latest developments. Aka doesnt have an opinion. Playing mind tricks on him might suffice. Can't read him
B1rd is as objective as me. Can't read
Honestly I voted for Dawnsday just because of his evil like avatar. Needless, to say he dug himself into a hole and will need better justification to get out. At least he should explain why someone else is mafia dammit. Also waiting for his response of my showing evidence of his lies. I think he is the safest vote.
Sakura needs to be pushed to vote for somebody. Can't read.
rEdo, Beeboy123, and Hika you guys have been more active, so I will need to figure you guys out tommorow.
I would consider to unvote Dawnsday just to see who else may try to jump on him, but not declaring that beforehand may be a rather unwise decision on my part. And now that I do declare, that action would be pointless.
I also start to question beeboy's alignment due to him getting too silent when the lynch occured. But hey, the same argument applies to me then xd
Jess, why did you hammer Dawnsday. Just what the fuck, we weren't even done with discussion. If I had been on the forum the moment you said you're gonna hammer, or at least hours after that, I would unvote >_> Don't take it too personally, but why do you even bother signing up to these games if you're not even reading what we're doing here?
Reading Jess as scum doesn't count to me. She's playing terrible both as town and as scum.rEdo wrote:
I find it really disturbing that abraker didn't point to anyone else as scum besides a safe lynch guy Dawnsday. To me it looks like a try to letting the lynch pass after a very long inactivity.
I didn't point anyone else as town either. There are a handful of people here I can't read. However, I shouldn't make up excuses for Hika and Beeboy. I need to look over their data asap. Also Hika's response to my previous statement will be importantrEdo wrote:
Reading Jess as scum doesn't count to me. She's playing terrible both as town and as scum.rEdo wrote:
I find it really disturbing that abraker didn't point to anyone else as scum besides a safe lynch guy Dawnsday. To me it looks like a try to letting the lynch pass after a very long inactivity.
Also I didn't read Jesse as scum but only provoked the thought. I don't give readings unless I have evidence to back things up
Because they're not gonna waste their breath on me.abraker wrote:
Makes me curious why the mafia didn't bother with you then...Hika wrote:
Alright, if I don't vote you, you'll investigate me?
I prefer you not to because I'm VANILLA TOWNIE.
They're just causing WIFOM because I can't get anyone to check me.
If there is an investigative role, please crumb.
Crumb cleverly if you can, at least.
Is that an official claim though?
Scum is good at framing people right now. This isn't anything new. If someone you thought was scum didn't end up getting NK'd, then your first suspicion is because I'm scum and your second thought would be, since I claimed my role, I should've died first.
No. Scum believes my claim at least 75%. Had I been an important role, I wouldn't have fake claimed and taken the risk for claiming.
Scum doesn't want to kill a VT unless they are swaying town to a proper day lynch. They will simply take me last or just hope you all lynch me out.
No. Scum believes my claim at least 75%. Had I been an important role, I wouldn't have fake claimed and taken the risk for claiming.
Scum doesn't want to kill a VT unless they are swaying town to a proper day lynch. They will simply take me last or just hope you all lynch me out.
As i said to bee yesterday, she said the opposite of wanting to hammer, then just came and said "now i see why dawn's scum" and hammered without declaring any sort of intent.rEdo wrote:
Jess, why did you hammer Dawnsday. Just what the fuck, we weren't even done with discussion. If I had been on the forum the moment you said you're gonna hammer, or at least hours after that, I would unvote >_> Don't take it too personally, but why do you even bother signing up to these games if you're not even reading what we're doing here?
Vote: Jess
Claim: VT
bold is the only way to be official apparently.
bold is the only way to be official apparently.
Sakura wtf
I'm live on a computer in a approximately 2 hours max.abraker wrote:
Pending proof from previous mafia gamesHika wrote:
nah if I was scum I wouldn't have voted
keep it in mind
I'll answer this for you shortly.
Mind you, the not voting thing is a 50% thing.
Also:
Only possible setups atm are 3 and C, if rEdo's telling the truth then we're on C, Hika that claim came out of nowhere.
I'm not sure why abraker was so sure that a 1-shot BP was hit, since it's also possible that Doctor protection was hit.
Only possible setups atm are 3 and C, if rEdo's telling the truth then we're on C, Hika that claim came out of nowhere.
I'm not sure why abraker was so sure that a 1-shot BP was hit, since it's also possible that Doctor protection was hit.
This came out before rEdo's claim.abraker wrote:
mafia tried to get bulletproof townie?
He has to be lying. There's no way he's bulletproof.
Vote:redo
Now this.abraker wrote:
Makes me curious why the mafia didn't bother with you then...Hika wrote:
Alright, if I don't vote you, you'll investigate me?
I prefer you not to because I'm VANILLA TOWNIE.
Assuming Hika's telling the truth the way for mafia to hit a Town PR, a normal mafia would be looking for a town doctor to shoot, since they wouldnt know which of the 2 cases it is considering they wouldn't have a roleblocker in either of the 2, if anything they WOULD be aiming away from Hika, unless they want to get rid of threat in non PR forms, in which case Hika's claim would be irrelevant.
I take that is a CC?
Yes. I WILL CC THIS ALL MY LIFE.
There is no way he's bulletproof unless Zexion is fucking us up.
There is no way he's bulletproof unless Zexion is fucking us up.
Unvote
There's some things i need to parse in my mind first, as of yesterday's lynch i had a TR on rEdo, and wasnt reading Hika as town, a town BP generally doesnt claim out of the gate when shot by scum unless they are about to be lynched, since scum doesnt know if they hit BP or Doctor a BP not claiming will force scum to keep PR hunting or worst case scenario shoot again.
But that day opening idk, abraker opening with "Scum shot BP?" with then rEdo claiming "i'm BP" and then abraker going "i wonder why scum didnt bother with claimed VT then".
All these things are bothering me, and will need further inquiry.
@B1rd: how experienced is abraker at mafia (the general game, not the alignment)?
There's some things i need to parse in my mind first, as of yesterday's lynch i had a TR on rEdo, and wasnt reading Hika as town, a town BP generally doesnt claim out of the gate when shot by scum unless they are about to be lynched, since scum doesnt know if they hit BP or Doctor a BP not claiming will force scum to keep PR hunting or worst case scenario shoot again.
But that day opening idk, abraker opening with "Scum shot BP?" with then rEdo claiming "i'm BP" and then abraker going "i wonder why scum didnt bother with claimed VT then".
All these things are bothering me, and will need further inquiry.
@B1rd: how experienced is abraker at mafia (the general game, not the alignment)?
Besides, I claimed myself D1 because people still wanted to push my wagon.
That's two scumreads for me.
Ok so he's confscum unless he flips town, in which case you're confscum.Hika wrote:
Yes. I WILL CC THIS ALL MY LIFE.
There is no way he's bulletproof unless Zexion is fucking us up.
So i'll put that in the back burner for now and will try to figure out what's with abraker's posts at the start of the day and wont vote yet coz i dont want any more funny hammers from certain Jesses
Sakura you're my townread.
because you voted Jess.
because you voted Jess.
I think this suspicion with abraker is valid because his graphs and stuff are very fluffy. He's going to generate attention to him, negative or positive, so abraker you should probably fix your game play
in an honest, hypothetical way.
Sakura, so far what are your estimations on who is town.
Because it can either be town-scum or town-town.
And I don't wanna vote redo now after reading first page a few times.
Sakura, so far what are your estimations on who is town.
Because it can either be town-scum or town-town.
And I don't wanna vote redo now after reading first page a few times.
Topic Starter
"Isn't that time of the day when you start posting random stuff?"
PSA: Votecounts on weekdays (Mon - Fri) can only be done between 9 PM and 1 AM UTC. Please don't request votecounts outside that time range!
Votecount 2.1
rEdo [1] - Hika
Hika [0] -
Sakura [0] -
abraker [0] -
-[Jess]- [0] -
Frostings [0] -
B1rd [0] -
beeboy123 [0] -
No Lynch [0] -
Not Voting [7] - Sakura, -[Jess]-, abraker , Frostings , B1rd, beeboy123, rEdo
With 8 alive, it's 5 to lynch.
rEdo [1] - Hika
Hika [0] -
Sakura [0] -
abraker [0] -
-[Jess]- [0] -
Frostings [0] -
B1rd [0] -
beeboy123 [0] -
No Lynch [0] -
Not Voting [7] - Sakura, -[Jess]-, abraker , Frostings , B1rd, beeboy123, rEdo
With 8 alive, it's 5 to lynch.
PSA: Votecounts on weekdays (Mon - Fri) can only be done between 9 PM and 1 AM UTC. Please don't request votecounts outside that time range!
I'm sorry. I'm stupid. I'm still town :p
Currently im thinking the team might just be rEdo + abraker.Hika wrote:
in an honest, hypothetical way.
Sakura, so far what are your estimations on who is town.
Because it can either be town-scum or town-town.
And I don't wanna vote redo now after reading first page a few times.
abraker's Day 1 was a lot of IIoA, and his entrance today felt coordinated with rEdo to say the least.
i had a townread on rEdo at the end of day 1, which makes me go more wtf with that claim.
I'm fairly certain on my townreads on bee and frosty, then i have a townread on B1rd.
I'm not in favor of not punishing what Jess did coz otherwise she wouldn't learn, but if the above is the team then why the hell waste more time.
Whether you're town or not depends a lot on what rEdo flips, but... do you think rEdo's motivations were something else (i.e fake claiming as Town) and abraker just happened to be on the wrong place at the wrong time with his words?
Oh I'm sorry, I meant in reference with M6 setup between redo and I.
I never looked this deep into the setup of M6 and currently am confused with it.
So there can only be one scum between me and him or can we both flip town together?
I never looked this deep into the setup of M6 and currently am confused with it.
So there can only be one scum between me and him or can we both flip town together?
Also if the possibility is town-scum, me being town, then I think he used that excuse because they couldn't find a good NK at the time.
Second, if the possibility is town-town, if that's even possible (please fact check this statement), then abraker had to have been scum.
Either way, he just could be scum. See how he got into Dawn and now me?
Second, if the possibility is town-town, if that's even possible (please fact check this statement), then abraker had to have been scum.
Either way, he just could be scum. See how he got into Dawn and now me?
Ok so i'll explainHika wrote:
Oh I'm sorry, I meant in reference with M6 setup between redo and I.
I never looked this deep into the setup of M6 and currently am confused with it.
So there can only be one scum between me and him or can we both flip town together?
The mod randomizes either 1,2,3,A,B,C.
Depending on the one selected that's the setup the game will have in terms of the 2 town PRs and 1 scum PR.
So for instance if setup is 3, the 2 Town PRs are "Town Tracker" "Town 1-shot Bulletproof" and the 1 scum PR is "Mafia Goon" (So scum doesnt get a PR in this setup).
If setup C was rolled then the 2 Town PRs are "Town Tracker" "Town 1-shot Buletproof" and again, the 1 scum PR is "Mafia Goon" so scum also doesnt luck out in this one.
With any of the columns OR rows the same thing applies, a setup CANNOT have one role from 2 of them if they dont intersect.
So Town Doctor/Cop/Bulletproof counterclaim Bulletproof for example.
Just like Town Tracker/Jailkeeper/Bulletproof/Cop counterclaim Cop.
If you're either Doctor OR bulletproof then the only way rEdo is town is if he's fakeclaiming AS town (and i dont really see the need for a BP to claim or a town to fakeclaim BP, because scum knows very well who they shot).
What makes sense however is a claim to draw out a CC to find the last PR.
Thanks for explaining. Sorry for not reading that clearly. I just remember my last M6 game on here, I was hospitalized therefore force replaced so I didn't get to play long enough to understand the setup.
I don't see the world where scum Hika CCs for the fun of it.
vote: rEdo
vote: rEdo
As long as there's no possibility of redo being town, then I am fine with today's lynch.
I needed to read your explanations to know what the possible scenarios are. I forgot about the doctor role entirely. Only remembered the BP townie as I was quickly checking the email notification of this thread when gathering my stuff to leave from work.Sakura wrote:
@B1rd: how experienced is abraker at mafia (the general game, not the alignment)?
It's a pretty interesting setup, makes town and scum think more about what to claim / fakeclaim, and punishes people that blindly trust claims.
I've seen instances were Setup 1 is played (JK / VT / Goon) and scum fake claim BP making town think it's A ( JK / RB / BP) since scum already would know which of the 2 would be simply by the existance or lack of a roleblocker.
I've seen instances were Setup 1 is played (JK / VT / Goon) and scum fake claim BP making town think it's A ( JK / RB / BP) since scum already would know which of the 2 would be simply by the existance or lack of a roleblocker.
Hmm now i actually find this scenario possible tooabraker wrote:
I needed to read your explanations to know what the possible scenarios are. I forgot about the doctor role entirely. Only remembered the BP townie as I was quickly checking the email notification of this thread when gathering my stuff to leave from work.Sakura wrote:
@B1rd: how experienced is abraker at mafia (the general game, not the alignment)?
I would've preferred B1rd to answer first, ah well his answer is still relevant.
[/quote]Wait given there is a vanilla townie and rEdo is lying, where would we be?Sakura wrote:
Also:
Only possible setups atm are 3 and C
Oh I missed bee's post, damn you non existance of post review due to new posts thing
Take in mind that puts rEdo at L-2 and i would prefer he not go to L-1 coz he can self hammer to cut discussion short.
Take in mind that puts rEdo at L-2 and i would prefer he not go to L-1 coz he can self hammer to cut discussion short.
@abraker: Because Hika's not a VT silly.
I can keep silent about my progress about analysis if that's fineHika wrote:
I think this suspicion with abraker is valid because his graphs and stuff are very fluffy. He's going to generate attention to him, negative or positive, so abraker you should probably fix your game play
Hypothetically is that possible?Sakura wrote:
@abraker: Because Hika's not a VT silly.
I mean for there to be a vanilla townie at all in this game with how things stand
hiding your progress is anti town. threatening us doesn't help your case.
if your town you wouldn't be saying that.
if your town you wouldn't be saying that.
I mean if you're a PR and you want to direct scum attention away from you what do you claim ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
I saw that coming since like Page 20 when i mentioned the possibilities and Hika immediately said that it was impossible for rEdo to be BP.
I saw that coming since like Page 20 when i mentioned the possibilities and Hika immediately said that it was impossible for rEdo to be BP.
Oh all remaining players are VTs and a Goon.abraker wrote:
I mean for there to be a vanilla townie at all in this game with how things stand
Hika was fake claiming VT to protect her being PR, i realized this with her reaction to my post about the setup possibilities.
ok I have fake claim apparently
As i said earlier
If Hika's a BP or a Doc, then yeah her role cant coexist with rEdo's which makes rEdo's role a fake claim.
If Hika's a BP or a Doc, then yeah her role cant coexist with rEdo's which makes rEdo's role a fake claim.
So i'm just gonna make this clear for everyone so there's no misunderstandings about the setup.
We're either on
C:
1x Town Tracker
1x Town Doctor
5x Vanilla Townie
V.S.
2x Mafia Goon
or
3:
1x Town Tracker
1x Town 1-Shot Bulletproof
5x Vanilla Townie
V.S.
2x Mafia Goon
We cant be in both simultaneously save some serious mod error which i doubt, with this in mind Hika, you're 100% sure rEdo's fake claiming correct?
We're either on
C:
1x Town Tracker
1x Town Doctor
5x Vanilla Townie
V.S.
2x Mafia Goon
or
3:
1x Town Tracker
1x Town 1-Shot Bulletproof
5x Vanilla Townie
V.S.
2x Mafia Goon
We cant be in both simultaneously save some serious mod error which i doubt, with this in mind Hika, you're 100% sure rEdo's fake claiming correct?
If redo is fake claiming AND is mafia... only if, then this is how I interpret this
If beeboy is not mafia: Attack someone else so it's not suspicious it's just me.
Play the "But I did same, so idk" card an attempt to look innocent
Otherwise, take it with a grain of salt
Try to attack me. Create a common enemyrEdo wrote:
I find it really disturbing that abraker didn't point to anyone else as scum besides a safe lynch guy Dawnsday. To me it looks like a try to letting the lynch pass after a very long inactivity.
If beeboy is mafia: Weaken the bond between redo and beeboy.rEdo wrote:
I also start to question beeboy's alignment due to him getting too silent when the lynch occured. But hey, the same argument applies to me then xd
If beeboy is not mafia: Attack someone else so it's not suspicious it's just me.
Play the "But I did same, so idk" card an attempt to look innocent
Agree with popular opinion; Townie thinkingrEdo wrote:
Jess, why did you hammer Dawnsday. Just what the fuck, we weren't even done with discussion. If I had been on the forum the moment you said you're gonna hammer, or at least hours after that, I would unvote >_> Don't take it too personally, but why do you even bother signing up to these games if you're not even reading what we're doing here?
Otherwise, take it with a grain of salt
I am 100% claiming I am VT.Sakura wrote:
So i'm just gonna make this clear for everyone so there's no misunderstandings about the setup.
We're either on
C:
1x Town Tracker
1x Town Doctor
5x Vanilla Townie
V.S.
2x Mafia Goon
or
3:
1x Town Tracker
1x Town 1-Shot Bulletproof
5x Vanilla Townie
V.S.
2x Mafia Goon
We cant be in both simultaneously save some serious mod error which i doubt, with this in mind Hika, you're 100% sure rEdo's fake claiming correct?
I still dont know what you base your town reads on. Can you give an explanation on how you do town reads and why they are town reads?Sakura wrote:
i had a townread on rEdo at the end of day 1, which makes me go more wtf with that claim.
On redo's defense, his last statement about Jess, that's kinda how we all feel though... whether you're town or not
I also can't figure much about frosty Sakura, how can you?
Frosty's key events
1) Frostings votes Hika
Frostings x→ Hika
1) Frostings votes Dawnsday
Frosting x→ Dawnsday
3) Frostings reads B1rd as townie
Frosting !→ Roles:Townie = B1rd
4) Frosting’s claims that Frosting’s vote on Dawnsday is reaction testing
Frostings !→ (Frosting x→ Dawnsday = (Dawnsday ?→ Players:any)))
What am I missing?
Frosty's key events
1) Frostings votes Hika
Frostings x→ Hika
1) Frostings votes Dawnsday
Frosting x→ Dawnsday
3) Frostings reads B1rd as townie
Frosting !→ Roles:Townie = B1rd
4) Frosting’s claims that Frosting’s vote on Dawnsday is reaction testing
Frostings !→ (Frosting x→ Dawnsday = (Dawnsday ?→ Players:any)))
What am I missing?
Looking over Frosting's posts and there is his stance about Hika
Frostings wrote:
Hika is suspicious if Dawnsday flips town, because I've seen her pull L-1 at the first opportunity multiple times as scum
So it was all a misunderstanding then. That's why i asked again.
Vote: Jess
Vote: Jess
I'm still confused as hell about rEdo's out of the gate claim tho.
Apparently i missed some questions.
Most of the way i read Frosty's due to a lot of experience with him.
Most of the way i read Frosty's due to a lot of experience with him.
actually frosty hates me :^)
Sakura, it has come to my attention that you currently hold much of the opinion sway at the current moment. You know how other players react while players like me need to go by raw data, putting most newer players at a disadvantage. A scary disadvantage in the worst case or a really good advantage in the best case scenario.
I have reason to believe your past mentioning of past experiences with players might be telling half truths. I expect you to defend your claims by explaining why I should believe someone who might be mafia.
I have reason to believe your past mentioning of past experiences with players might be telling half truths. I expect you to defend your claims by explaining why I should believe someone who might be mafia.
I want Jess to answer this.beeboy123 wrote:
what do you mean by this Jess o3o-[Jess]- wrote:
Now I know why draw is scum
unvote
Also rEdo is conf town then.
That disadvantage will always be a thing. although in MS newbie games actually have way more newer players than in the case here.
But meta works as a disadvantage to me as well since people do think i have a good pokerface so i wouldnt blame someone getting paranoid about me (I mean that is half the reason i made an MS alt to begin with).
I suppose it's hard for a mechanical player like you to understand, but the way i get reads mostly come from gut feels which i no doubt usually get asked about and that's when i have a hard time putting those into words or evidence.
But meta works as a disadvantage to me as well since people do think i have a good pokerface so i wouldnt blame someone getting paranoid about me (I mean that is half the reason i made an MS alt to begin with).
I suppose it's hard for a mechanical player like you to understand, but the way i get reads mostly come from gut feels which i no doubt usually get asked about and that's when i have a hard time putting those into words or evidence.
B1rd you need to post more
B1rd wrote:
I'd rather lynch deadweight on policy before going after scumreads.
vote: Frosting
Justify your erratic behavior. First vote and then you voted Dawnsday the second everybody start bad mouthing him. Also your explanation are too simply to hold any water.
Justify your erratic behavior. First vote and then you voted Dawnsday the second everybody start bad mouthing him. Also your explanation are too simply to hold any water.
What was this answer to (might have missed something, but)? Were you just throwing this out to look innocent?Frosting wrote:
I voted Dawnsday because his posts up to my vote on him were all commentary with little analysis and initiative to find scum
also he keep using the "new to the game" card but I don't believe him
While I won't let my guard down of Jesse, a Sakura and Frosting duo might be a possibility worth looking intoFrosting wrote:
I like Sakura so far
From my experience scum doesn't play that simplyI think we have a hammer on the nail here. This guy just described EXACTLY what he was doing.
They don't have as much an incentive to quickly get rid of town than making themselves look innocent. Depends a bit on the scum players of course, but I will give the benefit of the doubt they are experienced
It's more likely wagons form with town players voting scummy players.
At the point in time writing this, he didn't know that my vote for Dawnsday was a null vote based on nothing. So him being second to vote was a safe vote. However my vote removed, he is the first actual vote. The wagon with town player followed. While he tries to make himself look innocent.
That comment answering idk what, and him being the first to jump on the bandwagon when everybody was starting to suspect Dawnsday. Is all of this coincidence?
Yes, Frostings, scum players ARE experienced, but it does help to keep operations a bit of a secret.
And you thought nobody will think of a scum player describing him self. I laugh.
boy will I dig myself into an early grave if I'm wrong
Either Hika or rEdo. 50/50. Waiting for rEdo's responcebeeboy123 wrote:
Who do you think is town Abraker?
Maybe i should do 2of4 again at some point.
People seem very confused by this setup ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
People seem very confused by this setup ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Jess isn't scum though. She just plays like that all the time @abraker
>All the time
I am well aware of that being Jess, but it's not like i can ignore it when she does scummy things like D1's QH.
Besides implying she does that all the time means she does it as either alignment, and that's what you're telling him.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
You do realize that VT doesnt counterclaim a thing? or are you still insisting you're a VT coutnerclaiming rEdo
I am well aware of that being Jess, but it's not like i can ignore it when she does scummy things like D1's QH.
Besides implying she does that all the time means she does it as either alignment, and that's what you're telling him.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
You do realize that VT doesnt counterclaim a thing? or are you still insisting you're a VT coutnerclaiming rEdo
literally said I don't care
I'm VT
believe it or not, if you're surprised I'm sorry
wasting an investigative check on me is pointless, and to a doctor, it's pointless to protect me
I don't do anything but vote. If me not being VT doesn't help then sorry but I literally claimed my role D1, all before this soooo
I'm VT
believe it or not, if you're surprised I'm sorry
wasting an investigative check on me is pointless, and to a doctor, it's pointless to protect me
I don't do anything but vote. If me not being VT doesn't help then sorry but I literally claimed my role D1, all before this soooo
If it CCs him. Okay. If it doesn't and it's irrelevant. Okay. I just wanted everyone to know my role.
Hika why are you so concerned about being investigated >.>
As a doctor not wanting to be framed for being tracked while blocking a kill is fine.
But as a VT it's just kinda weird.
But as a VT it's just kinda weird.
In terms of using it for better things for town is what my intention is
Besides, didn't I just say that's what I claimed D1... it doesn't matter anymore
You know, the more you tell someone to do something, the more they have the urge to do it. I think telling not to bother investigating you will just make it more tempting.