00:32 Mark101: Hi, here from #modreqs. I saw your request and opening the map I found some errors. I would like to suggest some fix, is it okay for you?
00:32 Itasha_S13: SYes
00:33 Mark101: 00:08:361 (3) - you should place this object a bit more up, it is differently spaced from other sliders
00:34 Mark101: Oh, i forgot to tell: I could be really bad at explaining things, so if you don't correctly understand tell me
00:34 Itasha_S13: Sure np
00:34 Mark101: I'd also like to suggest to increase the slider speed, using 0,50 and 0,35 in this part is really weird
00:35 Itasha_S13: Alright I don't know how I didnt noticed that before
00:36 Itasha_S13: 0,35 and 0,50 is okay, the song is really slow there I dont think increasing it will be better
00:36 Mark101: 00:35:960 (4) - you should change this with 2 sliders because the slider ends on a beat that is stronger than the slider-start
00:36 Itasha_S13: Like I don't want damn long sliders there
00:36 Mark101: I would use 0,75, some sliders are really short
00:36 Mark101: 00:13:847 (4) -
00:36 Mark101: like this one
00:36 Itasha_S13: Thats the point
00:37 Mark101: 00:50:532 (1,2,3,4) - the sound is not totally changing, you should follow the same spacing for all the circles
00:38 Mark101: You could not even notice this error because there is really a minimal distance, but it makes difference :w:
00:38 Itasha_S13: I start following the piano there
00:38 Mark101: there is no piano in 00:50:532 (1,2,3,4) - lol
00:39 Itasha_S13: There is not error xD Im using the DS
00:39 Itasha_S13: 2x
00:39 Itasha_S13: Piano.. hmm
00:39 Itasha_S13: that sound
00:39 Itasha_S13: Its like a high pitched piano, not sure if its a piano
00:40 Mark101: 01:13:504 (1) - the slider end is on a beat stronger than the slider-start, you should change with 2 circles
00:40 Mark101: all those jumpstreams are weird imo, but it's not totally an error
00:41 Mark101: 01:18:989 (3) - same of 01:13:504 (1)-
00:41 Itasha_S13: there are not jumpstreams
00:41 Mark101: I name "jumpstreams" things like 01:26:532 (10,11) -
00:42 Itasha_S13: Kicksliders plays as a single circle so there is not problem
00:42 Itasha_S13: 01:18:989 (3) - not gonna change, following the "wubs"
00:44 Mark101: 01:54:647 (1,1,1) - this sounds really bad with those hitsounds, you should elongate them to the blue tick
00:45 Itasha_S13: Thanks you
00:45 Mark101: 01:57:047 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - i don't hear literally any sound for the stream, is it me or that's true?
00:45 Mark101: 01:58:675 (2) - that's too much far from 01:58:418 (1) - , this should be unrankable
00:46 Mark101: it's a 175x2bpm jump
00:46 Mark101: 02:08:018 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - same of 01:57:047 -
00:47 Itasha_S13: I mappe all these wubs with a stream, I can't imagine a better way to map them
00:47 Mark101: you had to map the Drum and bass ._.
00:48 Itasha_S13: That would make my map really boring tho
00:48 Mark101: Sorry but you can't use elements which aren't in the sound of the songs
00:49 Mark101: 02:11:961 (5) - make this a 5 ticks sliders instead of 6 and make the slider end a circle (because the slider end is on a strong beat)
00:50 Mark101: 02:57:904 (2,3) - this change of spacing is weird, not that wrong but i'd change this and move it closer to (2)
00:52 Itasha_S13: Is more further because the sound, I do emphasis on that sound since the beginning of the song by spacing it more
00:52 Itasha_S13: Like 00:40:761 (2,3) -
00:53 Mark101: 03:33:389 (1,1,1) - change like i said before even here
00:53 Itasha_S13: Yea I already changed all of them
00:53 Mark101: 03:35:789 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - you already know what to do here
00:54 Mark101: 03:41:275 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - ^
00:54 Mark101: 03:44:704 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - ^
00:54 Mark101: 03:46:761 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) -
00:54 Mark101: ^
00:54 Itasha_S13: Im not gonna delete almost all the streams in my map, its just my way to map the wubs
00:54 Mark101: no why did I use the ^ as an "I agree" lmao
00:54 Mark101: You can't map those "wubs" like this
00:54 Itasha_S13: Ikr
00:54 Mark101: There is literally no sound for the stream
00:55 Mark101: This is unrankable
00:56 Mark101: 04:51:561 (7,8,9,10,11,12,13,1,2,3,4,5) -
00:56 Itasha_S13: well, until now no one have complain about these streams.. I will consider deleting them only if more modders tell me to
00:56 Mark101: there is no sound for this stream
00:56 Itasha_S13: I don't think its unrankable stuuf
00:57 Mark101: i've never seen a map with streams used like here tbh
00:57 Mark101: 04:56:704 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - no sound for streams
00:57 Mark101: 05:02:361 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - ^
00:58 Mark101: 06:02:532 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - i'm not gonna mention anymore those streams, this is the last time
00:59 Mark101: 06:06:904 (2) - this is a bit far from (1), you should short the distance
00:59 Itasha_S13: Yea, I will not change them anyways
00:59 Mark101: 06:09:646 (2) - absolutely short the distance here, thats again a 175 x 2 bpm jump
01:00 Mark101: 06:24:046 (2) - short the distance a bit also here
01:00 Mark101: 06:26:103 (2) - must short here because of the fast jump
01:00 Mark101: 06:31:589 (2) - ^
01:01 Mark101: 06:56:275 (2) - ^
01:01 Mark101: 06:56:961 (2) - ^
01:01 Mark101: 06:59:018 (2) - ^
01:01 Itasha_S13: Not gonna change all of them since its playable
01:02 Mark101: things like 06:09:646 (2) - MUST be changed, that's too much far
01:02 Mark101: 350 bpm jumps
01:02 Itasha_S13: It doesnt like like a 360bpm jump because that slider-.follow thing
01:02 Itasha_S13: the same reason why the kicksliders plays as a single circle
01:04 Mark101: even if there is a sliderend before you have to do this, have you ever seen jumps like these somewhere? It's even really bad to read
01:05 Itasha_S13: from all the playtest on this map no one ever have complain about them
01:05 Itasha_S13: because they really play good
01:05 Itasha_S13: Also not really bad to read since all the map is full of them
01:05 Mark101: if people can do a such jump it doesn't mean that this is 100% playable, and i'm almost sure that those people didn't consider this like an error
01:06 Itasha_S13: other thing is, reduce the volume of the effect to 0 and listen carefully to the song
01:06 Itasha_S13: in streams like this
01:06 Itasha_S13: well, in all the streams
01:06 Itasha_S13: 01:57:047 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) -
01:06 Mark101: I've modded the whole map without effects volume
01:06 Itasha_S13: there is a soft- sound that you can hear
01:07 Itasha_S13: then
01:07 Mark101: there is no soft sound lmao
01:07 Itasha_S13: you can clearly listen to the sound
01:07 Mark101: there is vocal+"wubs"+dnb
01:07 Itasha_S13: Yes it is
01:08 Itasha_S13: there a streamy sound all over the song
01:08 Mark101: btw, That's all, you haven't followed many suggestion, I think/hope that some more modders will say that so you'll agree
01:08 Itasha_S13: the same sample sound I used as soft sound
01:08 Mark101: You're the only one hearing that sound tbh
01:08 Itasha_S13: listen carefully
01:08 Mark101: and by the way even if there was a soft sound it shouldn't be mapped with a such spacing
01:09 Itasha_S13: Is not high spaced or anything
01:09 Mark101: Metadata: change 熊谷絵里(cv.瀬戸麻沙美) with 熊谷絵里(CV.瀬戸麻沙美)
01:09 Mark101: it should be in caps
01:10 Itasha_S13: Thats not really a problem since I copy the metadata from this map
01:10 Itasha_S13:
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/46776101:10 Itasha_S13: and Its not with CAPS
01:10 Itasha_S13: I copied the metadata for artist from that song because its the same artist
01:10 Itasha_S13: the same singer
01:10 Itasha_S13: the same producer
01:10 Mark101: many maps have wrong metadata, let me check on internet if this is exact
01:11 Itasha_S13: a ranked map can't have wrong metadata
01:11 Itasha_S13: and this map is recent
01:12 Itasha_S13: Its ranked like 2 or 3 weeks ago
01:12 Itasha_S13: And you can find the metada and source of everything clicking the banner of my map
01:13 Mark101: looks right. that's weird because i've never seen a map with a CV in undercase. my bad
01:13 Mark101: Do i post the log in the topic?
01:13 Itasha_S13: Ofc