Bobbias wrote:

None of us are trying to create drama, DrawdeX. However, logical arguments and real discussion are something very lacking in the current osu community, which I consider a particularly large problem. When puxtu created that list, he effectively invited discussion on the issues and reasons that those people in that list might not already be BNs.

DrawdeX wrote:

If you guys (the ones on puxtu's list) don't want to be BN, then you could've just said so.

JamesHappy wrote:

well i agree to some on your list, but at least reword the topic "List of decent people who are really capable to judging / nominate Osu!mania beatmaps and should be Beatmap Nominators" to avoid any offenses you make.

DrawdeX wrote:

Hydria wrote:

All puxtu is doing is suggesting new BNs for the list of 14 we have at the moment, picking people with beatmap skill and expertise over activity. Simple as.

Exactly.

If you guys (the ones on puxtu's list) don't want to be BN, then you could've just said so.
Instead of "blah blah blah" here, then "blah blah blah" there, then there wouldn't be any more arguments for this.

It's like girls doing their movie called "World War III", no offense.

-Kamikaze- wrote:

That's kind of a pointless post because I for instance didn't know about this post until puxtu pm'ed me on fb with it and guys like Tear, Agka or Yuno aren't as active nowadays if at all.
I don't really see the point of this list though, if any of mentioned ones want to be BN, they have to fulfil requirements first (which I myself am trying to do atm) and those who don't fulfil them will not be taken into consideration by staff, regardless of how much community wants them to. This post only started this rather heated discussion, which I think would be better if it didn't happen in the first place.
I'm glad that you think of me highly enough to put me on it thought puxtu

puxtu wrote:

Wait, suwako already quit mania like months ago (because you know why) and more focus on other game mode, taiko. Not sure if you should keep him on the list or not.

-Kamikaze- wrote:

I don't really see the point of this list though, if any of mentioned ones want to be BN, they have to fulfil requirements first (which I myself am trying to do atm) and those who don't fulfil them will not be taken into consideration by staff, regardless of how much community wants them to. This post only started this rather heated discussion, which I think would be better if it didn't happen in the first place.

Baraatje123 wrote:

Also, Puxtu, please not that many BN
O!M already has the most out of 3 game modes (not counting std) and we don't need more for that reason
Okay, maybe people who specialise in 'weird' keycounts, like (5, 6, 8, 9), but the Qualification cap will be ridiculous if much more are added

juankristal wrote:

O!M Ranking is pretty dead right now.

OnosakiHito wrote:

If you ask me, you should shorten the list to people who only / mostly concentrate on mania to make it more organized and let people know who they can count on. That's why the Taiko list isn't so big. Though, beside that, the bigger the group, the more people relay to each other.

Additional to this, if mania really has significant problems (since a longer time?) in the ranking process, you could try something like this. Having a Mania Nominator Association with people who are interested and dedicated to bring mania ranking forward. If there is any interest from side of the mania community and BNs, I could try to help you in this matter, as Taiko had the same problems for months, and now our situation has become much better.

Have a picture of how the structure is.

OnosakiHito wrote:

If you ask me, you should shorten the list to people who only / mostly concentrate on mania to make it more organized and let people know who they can count on. That's why the Taiko list isn't so big. Though, beside that, the bigger the group, the more people relay to each other.

Additional to this, if mania really has significant problems (since a longer time?) in the ranking process, you could try something like this. Having a Mania Nominator Association with people who are interested and dedicated to bring mania ranking forward. If there is any interest from side of the mania community and BNs, I could try to help you in this matter, as Taiko had the same problems for months, and now our situation has become much better.

Have a picture of how the structure is.

OnosakiHito wrote:

If you ask me, you should shorten the list to people who only / mostly concentrate on mania to make it more organized and let people know who they can count on. That's why the Taiko list isn't so big. Though, beside that, the bigger the group, the more people relay to each other.

Additional to this, if mania really has significant problems (since a longer time?) in the ranking process, you could try something like this. Having a Mania Nominator Association with people who are interested and dedicated to bring mania ranking forward. If there is any interest from side of the mania community and BNs, I could try to help you in this matter, as Taiko had the same problems for months, and now our situation has become much better.

Have a picture of how the structure is.

neonat wrote:

Fix issues? Make things better? I see the opposite happening.

OnosakiHito wrote:

If you ask me, you should shorten the list to people who only / mostly concentrate on mania to make it more organized and let people know who they can count on. That's why the Taiko list isn't so big. Though, beside that, the bigger the group, the more people relay to each other.

Additional to this, if mania really has significant problems (since a longer time?) in the ranking process, you could try something like this. Having a Mania Nominator Association with people who are interested and dedicated to bring mania ranking forward. If there is any interest from side of the mania community and BNs, I could try to help you in this matter, as Taiko had the same problems for months, and now our situation has become much better.

Have a picture of how the structure is.

Nanatsu wrote:

OnosakiHito wrote:

If you ask me, you should shorten the list to people who only / mostly concentrate on mania to make it more organized and let people know who they can count on. That's why the Taiko list isn't so big. Though, beside that, the bigger the group, the more people relay to each other.

Additional to this, if mania really has significant problems (since a longer time?) in the ranking process, you could try something like this. Having a Mania Nominator Association with people who are interested and dedicated to bring mania ranking forward. If there is any interest from side of the mania community and BNs, I could try to help you in this matter, as Taiko had the same problems for months, and now our situation has become much better.

Have a picture of how the structure is.

that's exactly same what we had before but not now. t/253778

[GraveChaos] wrote:

Mania Nominator Association

I can't see the future with it lol

Slap me

E x e wrote:

OnosakiHito wrote:

If you ask me, you should shorten the list to people who only / mostly concentrate on mania to make it more organized and let people know who they can count on. That's why the Taiko list isn't so big. Though, beside that, the bigger the group, the more people relay to each other.

Additional to this, if mania really has significant problems (since a longer time?) in the ranking process, you could try something like this. Having a Mania Nominator Association with people who are interested and dedicated to bring mania ranking forward. If there is any interest from side of the mania community and BNs, I could try to help you in this matter, as Taiko had the same problems for months, and now our situation has become much better.

Have a picture of how the structure is.

I'd like to see this happen.

PyaKura wrote:

Well I'm quite honestly not surprised.

PyaKura wrote:

Well I'm quite honestly not surprised.

puxtu wrote:

From what I heard, actually there were 20 bns kicked due inactivity and some poor qualitiy mod and 4 bns kicked because meme-ing too hard.

OnosakiHito wrote:

I wonder how you know, Baraatje. Is it anywhere written down?

Daeris wrote:

would it also be possible to separate out the mania BN list even further by adding what keymodes they're able/prefer to do?

Daeris wrote:

would it also be possible to separate out the mania BN list even further by adding what keymodes they're able/prefer to do?

Gravey- wrote:

More active BNs and Modders pls ! ! ! ' w'

Baraatje123 wrote:

Applications for new BN are open. Taiko/CtB/Mania only!

puxtu wrote:

Well done lads