a
Column:
_ _ _ _
4K - |1|2|3|4|
arcwinolivirus wrote:
"Arcwinolivirus' Beatmap Nominator checking/modding"
Take note that I am focusing on note patterns, densities, comfortability, placements and consistency.
Also, do not be afraid to reject some parts of my mod but please reason them out with sense.
Also, if I suggest to remove or ctrl function moves on certain note/s, be sure to move the hitsound on the other note beside the suggested note.
[General]
Audio: OK!
BG: OK!
BPM: OK!
Offset: OK!
Preview Time: OK!
Metadata:
Seems no problem
Hitsounds:
Seems no problem as well
AiMod:
• No problem!Column:
_ _ _ _
4K - |1|2|3|4|
[Lv.10]SPOILER[Lv.15]00:08:971 - add note for that castanette-like sound like you did at 00:11:714 (11714|2) - X For Clap here
00:19:943 (19943|3) - remove as you did not make snare-like sound 3-noter at 00:18:571 (18571|0,18571|3) -
00:22:000 (22000|0) - remove as well. Also Lv.15 does not have this 3-noter here.
01:22:686 to 01:33:314 - Suggesting to add notes for the snare-clap-like sounds so it won't be too far in terms of difficultness in this part to Lv.15 (Lv.15 has alot of 2-noters here). E.g. 01:22:686 - , 01:23:371 - , 01:24:057 - , and etc.
01:34:686 (94686|1,94857|0,94943|0) - swap column so the first chord will be different than 01:34:343 (94343|2,94343|1,94343|3) - and the jack will be a counter part of 01:36:228 (96228|2,96314|2) -
great difficulty~SPOILER[Overall]00:01:429 (1429|0,1429|3) - Suggesting to change one of the note to be an LN just like Lv.10s and if applied, 00:02:457 - add LN as well
00:06:571 (6571|1) - Change to LN like Lv.10's For same with 00:12:057 -
00:17:028 - add note, there is a sound here. X. But remove 00:17:371 - For here
00:22:599 - ^ X. Same
00:23:028 - ^ X. Same. Here for main sound
00:25:171 - ^ (optional) X. Same
00:25:771 - ^ (optional) can be also an LN for the rising effect sound. X. I guess none here better
00:26:800 - add note to 4 just like 00:26:628 (26628|0,26628|1) - for the scratch effect. Fixed. GOOD ONE
00:51:828 - add note to 1 for that castanette sound. X. and 00:51:486 - here only snare
01:33:314 to 01:34:343 - you can add note for those low-volume melody since this is the hardest difficulty (optional)X. none here for feeling
Fun to play~
Cool 4K mapset, call me back when done~ Good luck ^o^)b
update http://puu.sh/goAL6/0a92ba5dc5.rararcwinolivirus wrote:
[Lv.6]sup pux mah man~ :3/ sup mah man /
Seems quite hard for a Lv.6 @,@ #RankHarder2015
00:23:371 - add note to 1, strong impact sound here. It shouldn't be too hard since we have this 00:25:300 (25300|3,25343|2,25386|1,25428|0) - which is quite similar in terms of key presses. added lmao
01:27:828 - add note to 3 just like other notes like 01:29:028 (89028|0,89028|2,89200|1,89200|3) - added
01:44:286 - add note to 2 for a strong finish since you didnt note for the synthesizer there. added
01:34:686 - as for this chorus which is surprisingly easier than the first notes, with this I came up with a suggestion of how to reduce star rating. In this chorus, you did not used any 1/4 notes. How about removing the some 1/4s and 1/6s on the other parts as well? those notes are the only reason why there are high spikes of note densities and also we seldomly see 1/6th notes on a NM level difficulty (also if you compare your usage of 1/6th on Lv.10, it is almost similar). You decide mah man :3/ remapped my diff lmao
If you do agree then you can put more notes on part: lmao
01:22:343 to 01:27:828 - which you only note for the bass sound. Better if note all 1/2 of that melody sound we can hear there~
LMAOpuxtu wrote:
hype.
Taiwan-NAK wrote:
Hi there 87. It's 1/12. and Lv15. That's not 1/6 absolutely
Thanks. See you
RuberusuScarlet wrote:
00:59:371 - to 00:59:500 - hear sound five times = 1/8
Incorrect snapping:shionelove wrote:
title conflict
Oukaranman and OukaRanman
Consider to fix those things...Starry- wrote:
As shionelove mentioned, the title and romanised title are conflicting.
I'm pretty sure there should be more tags too. Just 'puxtu' isn't really that effective here.
In a few patterns, pitch relevancy is sometimes quite off, although it isn't unrankable so I'm not stating them here.
[Lv.15]01:31:657 (91657|1,91714|0) - Definitely isn't 1/6Actually I can hear 1/6 sounds (not the lead instrument, but drums) so this is okay for me
01:35:114 (95114|2) - Ghost note.
01:36:486 (96486|1) - ^
01:40:600 (100600|2) - ^
01:41:971 (101971|0) - ^ , Pretty sure you can hear this in the same chorus/repeated part. There's quite a few more like this but they're in the exactly the same parts of the music.
01:43:086 (103086|3,103128|1,103171|2,103214|0,103257|1,103257|3) - Should be 1/6. PROOF.
In Lv.10, this issue is also present. (Used 1/4 to represent the 1/8, but it's actually 1/6. 01:43:086 (103086|3,103171|1,103257|3,103257|2) - )
Rest of snaps are fine (That 1/12 mentioned before is fine. Zen provided proof which I also checked.)
Fixed. ThanksRoxas wrote:
Going to disqualify this due to incorrect snapping and title conflict. I will edit this post for further issues and I will mod it.
Title conflict:Incorrect snapping:shionelove wrote:
title conflict
Oukaranman and OukaRanman
01:43:128 (103128|1,103171|2,103214|0) - This is 1/6 snapping. Confirmed by me, Charles445 and some BNs like Harbyter and Starry-
EDIT - okay, just quoting Starry atmConsider to fix those things...Starry- wrote:
As shionelove mentioned, the title and romanised title are conflicting.
I'm pretty sure there should be more tags too. Just 'puxtu' isn't really that effective here.
In a few patterns, pitch relevancy is sometimes quite off, although it isn't unrankable so I'm not stating them here.
[Lv.15]01:31:657 (91657|1,91714|0) - Definitely isn't 1/6Actually I can hear 1/6 sounds (not the lead instrument, but drums) so this is okay for me
01:35:114 (95114|2) - Ghost note.
01:36:486 (96486|1) - ^
01:40:600 (100600|2) - ^
01:41:971 (101971|0) - ^ , Pretty sure you can hear this in the same chorus/repeated part. There's quite a few more like this but they're in the exactly the same parts of the music.
01:43:086 (103086|3,103128|1,103171|2,103214|0,103257|1,103257|3) - Should be 1/6. PROOF.
In Lv.10, this issue is also present. (Used 1/4 to represent the 1/8, but it's actually 1/6. 01:43:086 (103086|3,103171|1,103257|3,103257|2) - )
Rest of snaps are fine (That 1/12 mentioned before is fine. Zen provided proof which I also checked.)