You could have made bmin11's name darker so it will not blend too much with the bg

lepidopodus wrote:

For Fhatii Taiko Futsuu, I think HP drain rate is a little high for Futsuu. (under 5 is fine for Futsuu as I think...)
...and MAX Overall Difficulty? even Oni don't set overall like that. I suggest to lower under 5 (5? ok, but It Futsuu...)
(Futsuu means Normal, right? So let's make them like Normal diff....)
(Well actually this seems a little harder than what we called Futsuu... but much easier than Muzukashii, as there are no 1/4 continuous notes.)

Teta268 wrote:

Difficulties Available:

1. Collaboration (4,96000003814697 stars, 647 notes)
2. Fhatii Taiko Futsuu (3,74000000953674 stars, 250 notes)
3. MattWin's Easy (0,959999978542328 stars, 39 notes)
4. Medium (3,24000000953674 stars, 171 notes)

1. The .osb file is still there.
2. Maybe include the season in the Source field?

1. Maybe force default skin?
2. The "spinner-clear.png" image is transparent, but why is it so big? A 1x1 transparent image would be enough. As far as I know, this is unrankable.

1. This difficulty is too short...
2. Replace the current storyboard with this:

Sprite,Foreground,Centre,"mattwinsb.png",160,438
 F,0,498,849,0,1
 F,0,68218,68569,1,0

1. It would sound better if you use the Normal sampleset. That, or raise the hitvolume.
2. Storyboard:

Sprite,Foreground,Centre,"tetasb.png",150,437
 F,0,148,498,0,1
 F,0,128218,128569,1,0

1. Storyboard:

Sprite,Foreground,Centre,"fhatiisb.png",216,434
 F,0,148,498,0,1
 F,0,128218,128569,1,0

1. Raise hitvolume in Teara's part.
2. Storyboard:

Sprite,Foreground,Centre,"bminsb.png",123,438
 F,0,148,498,0,1
 F,0,128042,128393,1,0
Sprite,Foreground,Centre,"tearasb.png",507,435
 F,0,128042,128393,0,1
 F,0,236814,241880,1,0

bmin11 wrote:

I believe that Teara didn't fix her part yet

Colab feels just a tiny bit overmapped, but what isnt these days?

RemmyX25 wrote:

02:46:365 (1,1) - These aren't really needed are they? They sound unnecessary.

tmokb93 wrote:

Source: Full Metal Alchemist OST

Xgor wrote:

[Easy]
Why does you need to call it MattWin's Easy when MattWin is storyboarded in the map anyway

Well it's ok, could be better but no real faults.
I wish you mapped all though

[Medium]
The hitsounds bugs me a on this difficulty (Mainly the claps), but i suck way on hitsounds to mod that....

00:39:786 (7,8) - Maybe make these to a slider
01:10:663 (8,9) - ^
01:32:066 (1) - Maybe make this into many shorter sliders instead

[Taiko]

[Collab]
I do not like the low stacking latency on this :<

00:18:558 (1) - I kinda wish that this spinner was shorter and then was some beats after it where the spinner was before..

02:29:610 - Add circle here
I don't like how the difficulty starts of good but then jumps so much at 00:56:979 >.< Then when it comes to Tearas part in feels more like an Normal >.<
It's bad when the difficulty is so horrible inconsistent....

Well it's ok but the Collab bugs me ALOT!!!! *Sigh* (And the fact that only one map is mapped to the end)
.........
I-I won't star this..... sorry... The Collab buggs me waay to much

Teara wrote:

If the my part is so horrible, remove it and have someone else map it then.

problem solved

Teta268 wrote:

:/
Damn, why tatsuya deleted it - -

Teta268 wrote:

is it my fault that i have 2 personalities? ¬¬
i don't think so, and the beatmap is mine after all.
"they worked hard and etc on collab" and blablabla will not change anything, it's deleted.

Teara wrote:

You fail.

it was a good diff, true, bmin's part was insane, and my part was hardish, I mapped it like THAT because YOU wanted me to keep the min score low enough so that the diff can be ranked, no approved. So I went easy with my part on notes, but still tried to make it creative.

both me and bmin worked hard on that diff, and if you look at previous mods, you will note most loved it.

the reason, and only reason you decided to remove it, was to get the beatmap itself ranked faster, and this is wrong IMO

if it was a bad diff, like it sucks, realllly realllllly suck, and most modders complained about it, then I think it would have justified your reason to remove it, but in fact this isn't the case.

you only think about yourself, and not the other people around you. you are a bastard.and yes I'm pissed off now.

1. add all guest mappers to all difficulties (add them on [Collaboration] and use the same capitalization for the names)
2. the spinner-circle is not aligned properly to the center, you might consider taking the spinner from this map: http://osu.ppy.sh/s/11945 (you should ask the mapper, though)
3. there is no scorebar-ki, you should add this to your skin

1. seems too short, I would extend it to the part [Medium] is ending

1. 01:59:786 (6) - there is no need for the green lines around this slider, you should remove them

1. 00:31:365 (48) - slider with finish seems weird in taiko
2. 02:02:593 (167) - same
3. 02:07:505 (173) - same

RemmyX25 wrote:

This STILL feels unfinished. I don't believe this is ready for ranking yet.