Very good Idea! Supporting 
forum
Cumulative rank
posted
Total Posts
153
Good idea
I always wondered, as an all-mode player myself, who is the best at playing all modes. I would like to compare my 3455pp average with others. I think the best one would be Remilia-Scarlet if he was still playing.
I always wondered, as an all-mode player myself, who is the best at playing all modes. I would like to compare my 3455pp average with others. I think the best one would be Remilia-Scarlet if he was still playing.
Topic Starter
Defintely Remilia-Scarlet.
Too bad all her Taiko/CtB/Mania pp is gone, so we don't know ;-;
Too bad all her Taiko/CtB/Mania pp is gone, so we don't know ;-;
his*
Topic Starter
How did I have to know sil?
you didnt:P but now you do.
i like your idea btw.
i like your idea btw.
Topic Starter
Then shoot some stars 
Hier hadden een paar mensen in #dutch het over, dat Jacky zo geel goed zou staan, dus ik dacht, laat ik t eens requesteren
Hier hadden een paar mensen in #dutch het over, dat Jacky zo geel goed zou staan, dus ik dacht, laat ik t eens requesteren
not bad. it's just like the idea they're talking about in clan system
i really love this idea, its only a think if peppy wants to use so much server space to do another ranking calculation, but if he does then it would be so fucking awesome..im gonna give this idea all my stars since i love all-mode playing ^^
Topic Starter
Thanks.
Most stars I ever had on a feature request ;-;
Still thank guys!
Most stars I ever had on a feature request ;-;
Still thank guys!
Spro would be top afaik.
Let's see who is the best all around player \:D/
+Support
+Support
no thanks. Seems pretty unnecessary ;A;
Topic Starter
For you probably (since you don't play CtB/Mania), but for the all mode players (like me) this would be very cool, and this would also support all-modeing @Yazawa
Mine is 3,621 + 4,083 + 3,362 + 1,126 = 12192 (3,048 average) ^^
Topic Starter
That's good.
Still think Remilia-Scarlet and spro would be the best
Still think Remilia-Scarlet and spro would be the best
Though it's unnecessary, I feel like it would be a 'fun' addition.
However I do feel this a bit of a problem:
- Doing it the way you suggested would mean going to the rankings-page and having to look up every single player I'd want to know the cumulative ranking of.
- Not doing your way would mean everyone's profile would have to be changed and I can see a lot of people not wanting that.
However I do feel this a bit of a problem:
- Doing it the way you suggested would mean going to the rankings-page and having to look up every single player I'd want to know the cumulative ranking of.
- Not doing your way would mean everyone's profile would have to be changed and I can see a lot of people not wanting that.
Topic Starter
It can also display on the profile as a new 'tab', like Kudosu, Beatmaps, Achievements.
Cumulative stats maybe?
Rank
Rank in Country
Total play count
Total score
Ranked score (can be messed up bcz Mania/Taiko)
Accuracy
Cumulative stats maybe?
Rank
Rank in Country
Total play count
Total score
Ranked score (can be messed up bcz Mania/Taiko)
Accuracy
Topic Starter
Bumpp!
Something like this?
Topic Starter
Yeah
But... why?
Topic Starter
1.) Why not
2.) It shows who is the best all-rounder
3.) Adds a new ranking to the game
4.) Supports people to play all modes, like me
5.) Hopefully there will become more hybrid mapsets, as all modes are going to be together for an extra ranking, so more mode-scecifics would be good
2.) It shows who is the best all-rounder
3.) Adds a new ranking to the game
4.) Supports people to play all modes, like me
5.) Hopefully there will become more hybrid mapsets, as all modes are going to be together for an extra ranking, so more mode-scecifics would be good
Why not? Different game modes are basically different games. Why does a cumulative rank across different games make any sense?
Never mind the fact that pp differs wildly across all osu!'s game modes.
Never mind the fact that pp differs wildly across all osu!'s game modes.
An average rank makes slightly more sense (but still is nearly pointless), but a rank determined by simply adding your ranks for each mode together makes no sense at all. Each gamemode has a variable number of players active, meaning ranks in each mode have different levels of value. If you're ranked 3k in std, that is worth a LOT more than 3k in mania. Also, how do you handle players who only play some of the modes, but not all?
It doesn't add any new mechanics to the game, nor does it add anything particularly useful (such as editor improvements, new mods, etc.). I suppose the one thing it has going for it is that it would be relatively easy to implement.
This assumes that ranks are actually a useful measure of skill. They aren't.baraatje123 wrote:
2.) It shows who is the best all-rounder
A new ranking that is entirely tied to other rankings, which makes it lose most of it's meaning.baraatje123 wrote:
3.) Adds a new ranking to the game
Assuming everyone cares about ranking in the first place. It hardly adds any real value to the game since it's just doing a bit of math for you.baraatje123 wrote:
4.) Supports people to play all modes, like me
It doesn't add any new mechanics to the game, nor does it add anything particularly useful (such as editor improvements, new mods, etc.). I suppose the one thing it has going for it is that it would be relatively easy to implement.
Topic Starter
It doesn't add up the ranks
It adds up the pp
It adds up the pp
That's just as bad.
I like this idea. It wouldn't personally affect me, but I think it would be a cool feature.
It's like a slap in the face when the only game mode is play is standard, yet say a 10k ranker is higher than me in a ranking scoreboard that I don't care about.
If this is implemented, at the very least don't include players that don't actually have performance in all modes.
I don't want some ugly 5/6 digit rank in my profile simply because I don't play other modes.
If this is implemented, at the very least don't include players that don't actually have performance in all modes.
I don't want some ugly 5/6 digit rank in my profile simply because I don't play other modes.
Topic Starter
This is to support all-modeingbuny wrote:
It's like a slap in the face when the only game mode is play is standard, yet say a 10k ranker is higher than me in a ranking scoreboard that I don't care about.
If this is implemented, at the very least don't include players that don't actually have performance in all modes.
I don't want some ugly 5/6 digit rank in my profile simply because I don't play other modes.
So IMO it should do it for EVERYONE,
Makou wrote:
i support you to the very end baraatje123 :3 i like the idea
Thank you!slapper334 wrote:
Good idea :3
What he saidbuny wrote:
I don't want some ugly 5/6 digit rank in my profile simply because I don't play other modes.
And one more thing - we can already call an all rounder someone, who plays standard mode, and excels in all of the elements: streaming, aiming, single tapping, alternating and so on. Dunno about the other play modes, but i think you could find something like that as well.
Topic Starter
Novalogic wrote:
What he saidbuny wrote:
I don't want some ugly 5/6 digit rank in my profile simply because I don't play other modes.
And one more thing - we can already call an all rounder someone, who plays standard mode, and excels in all of the elements: streaming, aiming, single tapping, alternating and so on. Dunno about the other play modes, but i think you could find something like that as well.
Lolwut?
Also, if you play CTB only once and got 1pp, you also have an 'ugly' 6-digit rank, do I do NOT see the problem there
This ofc also applies to the other modes
The point is that there isn't any way to implement a cumulative rank that would hold any meaning as a ranking metric. The inherent dissimilarity of osu!'s game modes invalidates the very notion of a cumulative rank.