Spyrunite wrote:
This song seems really under-valued to me. - http://osu.ppy.sh/b/137166?m=0
I spent quite a while getting a DT HD FC on it and got basically nothing, some of my other top scores though I would say are no where near as hard as it was for me to FC doll house.
For some reason this seems to be giving a lot of PP - http://osu.ppy.sh/b/95431?m=0
It doesn't seem like that hard of a map to me, not easy, but not worth the points it is giving imo.
I think that speed is being overvalued. Almost all of my top ranks are songs that just put out a lot of notes with not too much difficulty in-between them. Anyway just stuff I've been noticing and don't quite agree with. This system is already miles ahead of PPv1 so I'm happy with it, but it can always be better.
I personally consider the second map you linked harder, than the first one. While having less demanding jumps, there still are quite a few near the end and it also challenged the streaming aspect of the game while those are pretty much inexistent in the first map you linked. Also the different ApproachRates are considered equally difficult when they lie in the interval 8 to 10, since many players have different subjective opinions about those.
Not saying, that your opinion is invalid, this is just my personal view on it. If the future feedback will go further in the direction you suggested, then I'll tweak the algorithm a bit.