I just want to point out, why "Artist" is the wrong definition for the Maker of Vocaloid Songs:
Definiton of Artist:
Definition of Musician:
Of course, for now, you can nagging me, because Musician would be as Artist correct too, but let's continue this:
Definition of Singer:
Definiton of Source:
It's not just that what I don't like on the new Rule. They are many songs where the creator is not active anymore and could change them for holding the new rule. And how already some/many people mentioned: The names are hard to find. For people with a high interest of the creators of the Vocaloid Songs, it won't be too hard at all to search, but things like HujuniseikouyuuP or Genjitsutouhi-P are totally retarded to set as Artist.
Some more things why I don't agree with this:
This is all what I can say to this. Of course, the Creator of all the vocaloid songs should not get ignored or forgotten, but it's not disrespectful, if you set them as Source. I mean, technically you can call the Source as Creator. Otherwise, Source should have to be Vocaloid, because the creator used this to creator the songs.
Definiton of Artist:
a person who works in one of the performing arts, as an actor, musician, or singer; a public performer: a mime artist; an artist of the dance.Source: http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/artist
Definition of Musician:
(Music, other) a person who plays or composes music, esp as a professionSource: http://www.thefreedictionary.com/Musical+artist
Of course, for now, you can nagging me, because Musician would be as Artist correct too, but let's continue this:
Definition of Singer:
a person who sings, especially a trained or professional vocalist.Source: http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/singer
Definiton of Source:
One that causes, creates, or initiates; a maker.Source: http://www.thefreedictionary.com/source
a person, group, etc., that creates, issues, or originates something
It's not just that what I don't like on the new Rule. They are many songs where the creator is not active anymore and could change them for holding the new rule. And how already some/many people mentioned: The names are hard to find. For people with a high interest of the creators of the Vocaloid Songs, it won't be too hard at all to search, but things like HujuniseikouyuuP or Genjitsutouhi-P are totally retarded to set as Artist.
Some more things why I don't agree with this:
darkmiz wrote:
We should also have respect for the illustrators/PV makers/Audio mastering engineers of these songs.arken1015 wrote:
At lest, we should have respect for composers of these songs...
niconico lists these tags for this song: VOCALOID takamatt 456 かごめP GUMI 鏡音レン
I think all should be added in osu! tag information.
This is all what I can say to this. Of course, the Creator of all the vocaloid songs should not get ignored or forgotten, but it's not disrespectful, if you set them as Source. I mean, technically you can call the Source as Creator. Otherwise, Source should have to be Vocaloid, because the creator used this to creator the songs.