thank you for good sugestionpimpG wrote:
general
missing skin files for a complete spin set
spinner-approachcircle.png, spinner-clear.png, spinner-spin.png, spinner-osu.png
inconsistency in combo colors between the standard mode diff's
audio lead-in inconsistency. easy hard and insane are 1508.. make them exactly 1500
offset is different in the taiko diff's. timing must to be the same in all difficlties
i sugest adding timelines with 126 bpm to: 00:01:740 - 00:22:692 - 00:49:358 - 01:25:548 - (they won't affect gamelpay) ADDS
because this tv size song does not follow correct measure order, if you dont unsderstand what i mean, make a backup diff and add this timelines to it, and then play with nightcore.
the nightcore cymbal finish appears every 4 measures starting from the timeline, and the order changes if there is more timelines, with this extra timelines nightcore mod will follow music perfectly in the his cymbal finishes
compare playing any other diff without this extra timelines
anyways the timeline at -164 should not exist, since the measure starts at 00:01:740 - i would sugest you to remove this -164 timeline, but you are using a slider speed change in normal before 00:01:740 so it would break the notes
i won't sugest you to remove the slider speed change in normal but if at some point you decide to remove it, you can delete the -164 timeline FIXS
gunslinger-girl 1.jpg has a word whritten in the top right, i mean the "TAPETUS.pl". consider using a bg without this things[/color] FIXS
easync sugestionsFIXS00:04:359 (3) - new combo? (optional, this intro works with a long combo too, i'm sugesting new combo because you added one to next part that follows same rhythm)
00:11:978 (3,1) - (i was talking about this nc) if you follow previous sugestion, use new combo to (3) and remove at (1). or if you prever the long combo above, just remove the new combo at 1 for consistency
00:37:931 (3) - new combo since vocal restarts here FIXS
00:39:835 (1) - remove new combo FIXS
00:40:788 (2) - new combo FIXS
00:44:121 (6) - new combo FIXS
00:49:359 (5) - new combo for kiai start FIXS
00:49:835 (1) - remove new combo FIXS
00:53:645 (4) - new combo FIXS
01:07:455 (4) - new combo FIXS
01:10:788 (1) - remove new combo FIXS
01:17:455 (1) - remove new combo FIXS
01:18:883 (3) - new combo FIXS
01:19:835 (1) - remove new combo FIXS
01:21:740 (5) - new combo FIXS
01:23:169 (8) - new combohitsoundsChange15% volume is too low and you are using it until kiai starts, please make it louder
no hitsounds until the 1st spinner, intentional?
why dont you use claps to follow drums instead of whistle? i see you tried to follow vocal too, using whistle to follow vocal and drums at the same time is not good[/color]
It ok i'll change to clap at all
00:00:550 (1) - whistle at slider end? Change
00:02:455 (2) - whistle at slider end? Change
00:04:359 (3) - whistle at slider end? Change
00:06:264 (4) - whistle at slider start? Change
00:08:169 (1) - whistle at slider end? Change
00:10:074 (2) - whistle at slider end? Change
00:13:169 (2) - whistle at slider start / end? Change
00:14:359 (3) - whistle at slider end?]Change
00:26:978 (1) - remove finish in slider end, if you wanted to follow vocal here i sugest whistle Change
00:30:312 (5) - finish Change
00:31:740 (2) - missing clap at slider start (or whistle, if you deny my sugestion to use clap to follow drums) Change
00:33:169 (4) - missing clap at slider end (or whistle, if you deny my sugestion to use clap to follow drums) Change
00:48:883 (4) - clap (or whistle, if you deny my sugestion to use clap to follow drums) Change
00:51:740 (3) - missing clap at slider start (or whistle, if you deny my sugestion to use clap to follow drums) Change
00:54:121 (5) - missing clap at repeat (or whistle, if you deny my sugestion to use clap to follow drums) Change
01:00:312 (1) - missing clap at start / end (or whistle, if you deny my sugestion to use clap to follow drums) Change
01:01:740 (2) - missing clap at end (or whistle, if you deny my sugestion to use clap to follow drums) Change
01:03:169 (4) - missing clap at end (or whistle, if you deny my sugestion to use clap to follow drums) Change
01:10:788 (1) - missing clap at start (or whistle, if you deny my sugestion to use clap to follow drums)notesFIXS00:00:550 (1,2) - slider ends in red ticks follows music better FIXS
00:04:359 (3) - i sugest slider end in the white tick, since the stronger vocal is there, also i feel like should be a larger gab between this slider and the next, fits the vocal. FIXS
00:06:264 (4) - slider end in the red tick, since you are following vocal, there is no vocal in the current slider end FIXS
00:08:169 (1) - make this slider start at 00:08:407 and end at 00:11:502 for same reason above FIXS
00:12:931 (1) - move this circle to 00:12:693 to follow the stronger vocal? FIXS
00:23:169 (2,3,4) - spacing issues here, you should keep using 1.0x. you are not using this at 00:31:740 (2,3,4) - FIXS
00:28:407 (3,4) - spacing issue, intentional? not good imo FIXS
00:34:121 (1) - make spinner end at 00:35:312 - or 00:35:074 - because there is no much time for newbies recover after spinning FIXS
00:42:693 (5,6,7,8) - spacing is messed here, its probably intentional but. i advice you newbies can find it very confusing FIXS
bacause anything that is too far or too close can make them think the note is earlier / later in the timeline since they are newbies FIXS
00:45:550 (1) - make spinner end at 00:46:740 - lets give more time to newbies recover after spinning FIXS
or remove the notes at 00:47:455 - and 00:47:931 - and make spinner end at 00:47:455 - (recomended) FIXS
00:47:455 (1,2,3,4,5) - this placement can be very confusing for newbies, let the notes as so visible as possible in diff for newbies, so stacks are not encouraged FIXS
00:51:740 (3) - make a circle at 00:51:740 and make this slider start at 00:52:216 - end at 00:53:169 - because kiai calls for complex rhythm, the current slider was too long FIXS
recheck your spacing, if you are using distance snap1,0x dont let the notes be spaced less than 0,98x or more than 1,02x
normal
your combo colors are too similar as you can see here, and here ...please use colors that can be distinguished more easilly
slider velocity looks too high for this song in kiai time. please reduce the multiplier a bit, i sugest you using maximum of 1,20 multipliernc sugestionsFIXS00:04:359 (4,1) - swap new combo FIXS
00:08:169 (5,1) - ^ FIXS
00:28:407 (1) - remove new combo FIXS
00:37:931 (3) - new combo FIXS
00:48:883 (4) - new combo FIXS
00:54:121 (4) - new combo FIXS
01:01:502 (4) - new combo FIXS
01:05:550 (5) - new combo FIXS
01:09:121 (4) - new combo FIXS
01:12:931 (4) - new combo FIXS
01:16:502 (4) - new combo FIXS
01:23:645 (5) - new combohitsoundsADD00:00:550 (1) - whistle at slider end
00:03:883 (3) - whistle ADD
00:05:550 (1) - whistle at slider end ADD
00:06:978 (3) - whistle ADD
00:07:216 (4) - whistle at slider end ADD
00:08:407 (1) - whistle at slider end ADD
00:09:121 (2) - whistle at slider end ADD
00:10:788 (4) - whistle ADD
00:11:026 (5) - whistle at slider end ADD
00:12:693 (3) - whistle at slider start ADD
00:13:407 (4) - whistle at slider end ADD
00:14:597 (6) - whistle at slider end ADD
00:15:312 (8) - whistle ADD
00:15:550 (1) - finish ADD
00:25:550 (5) - whistle at repeat /end ADD
00:29:359 (2) - whistle at slider start ADD
00:31:502 (2) - whistle at repeat ADD
00:32:216 (3) - whistle at start ADD
00:41:740 (1) - finish, its the same sound as 00:37:931 (3) - ADD
00:42:931 (4) - whistle at start
editing
Big edit map again!
