forum

osu! World Cup 2013 - Discussion Thread

posted
Total Posts
1,715
show more
Icyteru
Ugh god edit button disappeared.
But I just read that the maps will be jump and combo focused rather than stream speed. Ahahaha you're fucked melt3d.
Melt3dCheeze

[AirCoN] wrote:

Ugh god edit button disappeared.
But I just read that the maps will be jump and combo focused rather than stream speed. Ahahaha you're fucked melt3d.
I doubt it, you haven't considered the situations where 8 super nervous people clash into one another, shaking and losing focus. You haven't seen me in action when I've been completely nervous, nor have I ever experienced first hand so anything could go in OWC.
Almost

[AirCoN] wrote:

Ugh god edit button disappeared.
But I just read that the maps will be jump and combo focused rather than stream speed. Ahahaha you're fucked melt3d.
No faith...
Metro
According to the betting game some people including myself have a lot of faith on Latvia lol.
pooptartsonas

Metro wrote:

According to the betting game some people including myself have a lot of faith on Latvia lol.
USA
USA
USA
USA
USA
AmaiHachimitsu
Since it's unknown if SG participates fully and Latvia has a very good roster (I'd say it's perfect for tournaments, their players' consistency is very good) I'm not surprised at all.
Omgforz
Just like some people have way too much faith in Austria.
We're gonna disappoint people.

(Quick Metro, change your bet for China-Austria, because we don't have M3tr01d available for that match!)

And I wanted my avatar to stare at AmaiHachimitsu

hue
Noriko

Omgforz wrote:

Just like some people have way too much faith in Austria.
We're gonna disappoint people.
Glad Estonia doesn't have that problem 8-)
lly
We will just show our godlike powers off. And then everyone will bow to the power of Estonia! Mwhahaha
pielak213

pooptartsonas wrote:

USATEI
USATEI
USATEI
USATEI
USATEI
fixd
silmarilen
to all the ar9 haters: i hope they pick a nice jumpy ar8 map is one of the future rounds, like ivaltek or something
fartownik

silmarilen wrote:

to all the ar9 haters: i hope they pick a nice jumpy ar8 map is one of the future rounds, like ivaltek or something
Yeah, that'd result in only one thing: no one picking that map.
silmarilen
make it the tie breaker
fartownik
Tiebreaker is freemod.
silmarilen
fuck
pooptartsonas
Then the team down 2-3 would intentionally lose so they don't have to publicly humiliate themselves
Darksonic
Are there any pro player that could hate ar 9? if so this owc will be a pain for them ;)

ar 8 sucks
Froslass

silmarilen wrote:

to all the ar9 haters: i hope they pick a nice jumpy ar8 map is one of the future rounds, like ivaltek or something
this, please
buny

silmarilen wrote:

to all the ar9 haters: i hope they pick a nice jumpy ar8 map is one of the future rounds, like ivaltek or something
err, how many ar9 haters are there?

honestly i haven't seen many people that hate ar9 other than the ones that literally only play ar10 maps and get C on them.
Icyteru
wait....so people hate AR9 cause it's too slow?

Wut.
Soarezi

MaDBoY94 wrote:

We will just show our godlike powers off. And then everyone will bow to the power of Estonia! Mwhahaha
good luck.
silmarilen

[AirCoN] wrote:

wait....so people hate AR9 cause it's too slow?

Wut.
read through the past couple of pages, there was a small discussion about wether the tiebreaker should be freemod or not, and one of the arguments was that the map was hard to read with ar9
Almost

[AirCoN] wrote:

wait....so people hate AR9 cause it's too slow?

Wut.
If you only play AR10+ and nothing else, then it looks incredibly slow.
Topic Starter
Loctav
Then stop playing AR10 only :P
What's that for a world champion who can only race on high speed but fails horribly at parking the car in the parking lot.
Icyteru
I agree, osu! world cup should not be about who's the fastest player, but should be about who has the greatest cumalative skill in osu!
AmaiHachimitsu
Nothing against ar 9 or 8 even though it's harder for most(?) of us. We're in the same boat and low-ar maps can be used for strategic issues by some teams, making the show interesting.

I can already see the despair when ar9 DT maps will be available
Gigo
Yeah, I guess there is something called "being too pro". In my opinion, every player should be able to read at least AR9 and AR8 properly. I know those are not as exciting and fun and fast and "Woo, look at me, I am so pro, look how fast my reaction time is" as AR10, but come on... Too slow? Really?
[Luanny]

Loctav wrote:

Then stop playing AR10 only :P
What's that for a world champion who can only race on high speed but fails horribly at parking the car in the parking lot.
damn I couldn't agree more
Aqo

silmarilen wrote:

to all the ar9 haters: i hope they pick a nice jumpy ar8 map is one of the future rounds, like ivaltek or something
I love Ivaltek please do

strategic takedown map for teams that are bad at reading jump yesss
Melt3dCheeze
I'd rather have both varying CS and AR maps, like some of AngelHoney's maps should come into OWC. So, alteration of AR with the combination of the alteration of CS would be perfect to test people's limits.
AmaiHachimitsu
I'd rather have both varying CS and AR maps, like some of AngelHoney's maps should come into OWC. So, alteration of AR with the combination of the alteration of CS would be perfect to test people's limits.
Though I agree that various maps should appear, "normal" maps should still be present, and in hefty amounts. If there happen 4 maps which are only stream-y, a team which is specialized in streaming skill only might nearly win the match only because of those. If you meant various only by AR, CS - I totally agree.
Melt3dCheeze

AmaiHachimitsu wrote:

Though I agree that various maps should appear, "normal" maps should still be present, and in hefty amounts. If there happen 4 maps which are only stream-y, a team which is specialized in streaming skill only might nearly win the match only because of those. If you meant various only by AR, CS - I totally agree.
If I was referring to a variety of maps and 4 stream maps suddenly appear, is that contradicting to the target idea? Plus, isn't OWC meant to show the best of people, also veto-ing maps out is a valid option am I correct?
fartownik

Loctav wrote:

Then stop playing AR10 only :P
What's that for a world champion who can only race on high speed but fails horribly at parking the car in the parking lot.
If you're impressed by someone parking a car in the parking lot same as a world champion racer then good luck.

Also I (personally) never said AR9 is hard, especially on those maps. I can do every map from the list without much problems, still prefer AR10 because it's less damn annoying and requires less unnecessary concentration during the match, thus causes less random misses (which really like to occur during a 1-play only matches). Yeah, yeah, go on with your 'bfut it's a pard of the gemplay to be able to rid AR9 on a turnment mach proparly" arguments. But I do already.
GladiOol
And I'm just sitting here still liking AR7.
silmarilen
tijdmachine lesjuh '09 diff 4owc
AmaiHachimitsu
^ freemod bracket, no prob
Zare
AmaiHachimitsu
we could as well introduce FlashLight bracket
Vmx
Kynan died at the end and I guess bancho didn't understand what happened, look at both screenshots in one of them you can see Blue Team wins in the other screenshot Red Team wins, so who the fk won (it doesn't even show that he died because it didn't register him) Also the lag ingame is insane bancho can't handle anything Forseen dced everymap, whenewere map starts I see people playing it while im stuck at "waiting for players" like how are we going to play this owc.
and this... I couldn't get into the room beacuse... I was in the room??? wat #bancho #logic #2k13
Then this, look at LoGo's score he has 1miss 0x100, if you count every players score 100s 300s 50s they have 757 objects and LoGo had 756. ?_? The map had 757 obejcts so where did 1 LoGo's object go?
Darksonic
Nobody would play FL bracket ever, I mean, the maps will be even harder as long the rounds finish, who will be able to memorize harder ones? It would be a waste of time only :P
Bariton
BRASIL
AmaiHachimitsu
Nobody would play FL bracket ever, I mean, the maps will be even harder as long the rounds finish, who will be able to memorize harder ones? It would be a waste of time only
sarcasm, Zarerion proposed AR 7 maps for Hidden Bracket. For me this kind of map is like flashlight since you must memorize like.. the whole map. Higher AR's are easily sightread.
Zare

AmaiHachimitsu wrote:

Nobody would play FL bracket ever, I mean, the maps will be even harder as long the rounds finish, who will be able to memorize harder ones? It would be a waste of time only
sarcasm, Zarerion proposed AR 7 maps for Hidden Bracket. For me this kind of map is like flashlight since you must memorize like.. the whole map. Higher AR's are easily sightread.
they were AR8
AmaiHachimitsu
still Low
silmarilen
not low, normal. please stop crying because you can only play by reaction.
seriously you're all just a bunch of crybaby's
"waahaaaahaaa i cant play this map because i dont know how to read low ar waahaaahaaa" grow up, you're supposed to be the best of the world, you should be able to play those maps.
fabriciorby
hi can you guys postopone our BR match by one hour so i can play thanks
Soarezi
reading low ar is boring as fuck , the maps are like 100bpm and it's just beyond boring. who cares
CXu
The mappool has 3 AR8 maps that are DT, and 3 hr AR10 maps. The rest are AR9.
Variation, right?
fabriciorby
dont ignore me i want to play against germanos
Synchrostar
pls i wanted to play ar8 hd maps

better than those 190bpm songs i cant stream
Froslass

Soarezi wrote:

reading low ar is boring as fuck , the maps are like 100bpm and it's just beyond boring. who cares
People like you make me want to quit this game.
Ugh, I'm gonna puke.
Darksonic
If you can't stream 190 bpm then I have no idea what are you doing on owc :p
buny

Blue Dragon wrote:

Soarezi wrote:

reading low ar is boring as fuck , the maps are like 100bpm and it's just beyond boring. who cares
People like you make me want to quit this game.
Ugh, I'm gonna puke.
Sakisan

Vmx wrote:

Then this, look at LoGo's score he has 1miss 0x100, if you count every players score 100s 300s 50s they have 757 objects and LoGo had 756. ?_? The map had 757 obejcts so where did 1 LoGo's object go?
He must have missed a slider that's worth 2 combo (simple start + end, no ticks or return-arrow)


And why do people talk about which kind of people shouldn't be in owc and stuff.
I shouldn't be in owc but I am, deal with it.

I think all the maps are very fun, but Kert is right : they all have pretty much the same kind of difficulty. There are a lot of styles that could benefit the lower 16 teams. Not saying it would have kicked out some upper 16 teams, but it would give them something to work with. Now we're just awaiting the execution date :P
Gigo
I feel kinda out of place, because all the players posting here are better than me... but still... you guys are considered pro players, right? So doesn't that mean that you should be good at all aspects of the game, including being able to read low AR? Why does everything have to be about reaction speed? Yes, playing fast maps and having lightning fast reaction is one of the skills required for osu, but it's not the only one. Reading low AR is just as important, it's just a different type of skill to have. Don't think of it as "boring", think of it as a challenge.

Should I complain that I can't read AR10 and above? No, I should become better, so I can read higher AR. The same goes for every pro player - don't complain that there are maps with low AR! Simply learn to read it! It's just another challenge to overcome in you path to becoming truly great at this game!

(inb4 "lol, noob 10k player telling me how to play)
AmaiHachimitsu
not low, normal. please stop crying because you can only play by reaction.
seriously you're all just a bunch of crybaby's
"waahaaaahaaa i cant play this map because i dont know how to read low ar waahaaahaaa" grow up, you're supposed to be the best of the world, you should be able to play those maps
Seems like you have forgotten about what you actually had said earlier. I mean you omitt the "hidden mod" thing.

Hidden is a total pain in the ass on low ar and it's meant to be memorized, that's why FL allusion.

I have no problems with ar 7 or lower, but HD makes it a semi-FL map.



This is funny, when I was starting playing, that is 2011, AR 10 was still fast and AR9+DT was impossibru. I wish we could see the reaction back then if there happened to be AR 9+DT map in mappool.

If you think that reading painfully low AR is a skill necessary for a player to be a champion of a rhythm game I just must disagree.

You may ask why do I flame low ar when I can actually play it?

- Because it's boring to play.
- Because it's a 1-chance tournament, to be sure of FC you will be made to memorize the map completely which is good for a fkin karuta not osu!
- The standards changed now, you know.

I've seen some racing comparisons, so it's my turn.
Forcing players to play ridiculously low ar is like telling F1 racers to drive a Smart as to measure their skill.

The same thing is with low bpm streams, for instance. Some top=tier players can't play them perfectly, but each of them has WHAT IT TAKES to play them anyway. World Champion is someone who can go beyond the limits of an average player. An average player won't stream 220 bpm easily even if he practiced for 2 weeks straight, but shouldn't have problems with attaining ability to stream 140 bpm more or less. If we had some more time to practice we'd even learn how to AR 3 and so would do a newbie, but AR 10 is something beyond imagination for many lower-tier players.

Should I complain that I can't read AR10 and above? No, I should become better, so I can read higher AR. The same goes for every pro player - don't complain that there are maps with low AR! Simply learn to read it! It's just another challenge to overcome in you path to becoming truly great at this game!
No, higher ar is a challenge. Low ar is something we had to deal in our early days in osu! It's only a matter of being used to, but getting used to demands effort, and time, which we don't have. I can assure you that there doesn't exist a player who can easily read ar 10,3 and ar 6 simultaneously. Some may be better, some may not, but they won't be good enough.

Presupposing that modern standard is AR 9, AR 8 is the lower AR I'd accept.
eldnl
I think low ar+hd is pretty fun.
jesse1412

Soarezi wrote:

reading low ar is boring as fuck , the maps are like 100bpm and it's just beyond boring. who cares
You just gave me indirect aids.

I support ar7 for nomod and ar8 for hd/nomod.
AmaiHachimitsu
low ar + EZ is fun too, but it's more like fun gotten from playing itself. We can do such thing solo too


#edit: Sakisan - The thing is that you get a hit100 for unfinished slider and LoGo's score showed no 100s, just 1x miss. So this is some kind of glitch for sure.

#edit2: I was thinking a bit and...

Every year many teams act as sth needed just to fill the hole since their line-up won't stand a chance against top teams. What about making a consolation cup or sth like that for those who couldn't make it through the group stage? 1-2 Months of supporter as a prize and let's go. Or just for a sheer fun since the matches would be more exciting than a quick 4:0 against Korea?

It's not an idea for the present OWC, but maybe in the future? It's like Champions League and Europa League
Pettanko
AR8 + DT is the best, anything higher and lower is too hard.
JappyBabes

AmaiHachimitsu wrote:

If you think that reading painfully low AR is a skill necessary for a player to be a champion of a score attack game I just must disagree.
fixerinod
Darksonic

Pettanko wrote:

AR8 + DT is the best, anything higher and lower is too hard.
no
buny

Artaxerx wrote:

I feel kinda out of place, because all the players posting here are better than me... but still... you guys are considered pro players, right? So doesn't that mean that you should be good at all aspects of the game, including being able to read low AR? Why does everything have to be about reaction speed? Yes, playing fast maps and having lightning fast reaction is one of the skills required for osu, but it's not the only one. Reading low AR is just as important, it's just a different type of skill to have. Don't think of it as "boring", think of it as a challenge.

Should I complain that I can't read AR10 and above? No, I should become better, so I can read higher AR. The same goes for every pro player - don't complain that there are maps with low AR! Simply learn to read it! It's just another challenge to overcome in you path to becoming truly great at this game!

(inb4 "lol, noob 10k player telling me how to play)
there aren't many difficult maps that are below ar9 without ar being a gimmick way of increasing difficulty

being the best doesn't necessarily mean you have to be the best in EVERY aspect either
fartownik

buny wrote:

being the best doesn't necessarily mean you have to be the best in EVERY aspect either
Wow, that's like a quote of the day.
fabriciorby
what are uo complaining
Cyclohexane
The last few pages of discussing the mapset have just been people complaining because they didn't get what they wanted. Not that they shouldn't voice their disappointment, but this is turning into a discussion of "what is a hard map" and "what makes a player good". Clearly people disagree on that. So, what do you do when you have a player base that doesn't agree on what maps they want to play? You aim broad, and try variety. Now granted I have not had the time to get a good glance of the maps this round with studies and other stuff, but I'm sure we can calm down the heat of the argument to a minimum here. We have 32 countries, each with a roster of 6 or more players, and a dozen maps to pick each round. You can't please everyone with that. It's physically impossible, and you all know this (it's the reason why there's arguing right now).

Here's my call: Discussing what makes a player good is really interesting and I can definitely see some great points coming out of it, but players are different and are more skilled in different areas. You should adapt to the mapset and work on that which you feel you are behind compared to the rest of your skill base. Now, you might not carry your team to victory, and I agree that it is frustrating to see your weapon of choice not come into play, but when it comes to OWC, versatility is the greatest asset a player can have.

Good luck, y'all.
Noriko

AmaiHachimitsu wrote:

#edit2: I was thinking a bit and...

Every year many teams act as sth needed just to fill the hole since their line-up won't stand a chance against top teams. What about making a consolation cup or sth like that for those who couldn't make it through the group stage? 1-2 Months of supporter as a prize and let's go. Or just for a sheer fun since the matches would be more exciting than a quick 4:0 against Korea?

It's not an idea for the present OWC, but maybe in the future? It's like Champions League and Europa League
That actually sounds like a good idea.
Wishy
Problem with low ARs is that the game requires you to play high ARs in order to be good.

DT makes AR go higher.
HR makes AR go higher.
Luffy-Kun

Wishy wrote:

Problem with low ARs is that the game requires you to play high ARs in order to be good.

DT makes AR go higher.
HR makes AR go higher.
Most players add DT or HR to improve their skills. When they see them selves getting faster, reading notes more quickly and with a faster reaction, it gets more fun. I remember when I started osu! I use to go and play multiplayer and when higher rank players chose a higher ar map, I was like to my self "how da fuq can they do this" And then you just want to be able to read and play at that kind of fast pace. Many players on osu! suffer when they come back to play low ar, after them playing high ar maps for months etc...So they will develop lots of hate towards low ar and such. Some players avoid playing high ar and end up actually playing maps with high bpm on low ar with ease, while players who play at higher ar, can not... So, it's up to the players choice on how he/she progresses through osu!
LoGo

Sakisan wrote:

Vmx wrote:

Then this, look at LoGo's score he has 1miss 0x100, if you count every players score 100s 300s 50s they have 757 objects and LoGo had 756. ?_? The map had 757 obejcts so where did 1 LoGo's object go?
He must have missed a slider that's worth 2 combo (simple start + end, no ticks or return-arrow)


And why do people talk about which kind of people shouldn't be in owc and stuff.
I shouldn't be in owc but I am, deal with it.

I think all the maps are very fun, but Kert is right : they all have pretty much the same kind of difficulty. There are a lot of styles that could benefit the lower 16 teams. Not saying it would have kicked out some upper 16 teams, but it would give them something to work with. Now we're just awaiting the execution date :P
No, we are not talking about combo here, look at objects, i got 1xMiss, but if i hit slider i get 1x300. So there is still 1 object missing.
Gigo

Luffy-Kun wrote:

Most players add DT or HR to improve their skills. When they see them selves getting faster, reading notes more quickly and with a faster reaction, it gets more fun. I remember when I started osu! I use to go and play multiplayer and when higher rank players chose a higher ar map, I was like to my self "how da fuq can they do this" And then you just want to be able to read and play at that kind of fast pace.
It is just as fun, for example, when I watch MillhioreF play EZ on some map with like 1 million objects on the screen at the same time and hitting them all. This kind of play also gets a reaction like "How the fk can he do this?" And you just want to be able to read and play at that kind of pace. You see? Your argument can be applied in this situation too. The problem is, like Wishy said, that the game pretty much requires you to play high AR... No respect for low AR at all! :(
Soarezi
So because most prefer more fast paced over slow paced makes you want to puke and quit the game? alright
Froslass

Soarezi wrote:

So because most prefer more fast paced over slow paced makes you want to puke and quit the game? alright
Yes, exactly.
Soarezi

Blue Dragon wrote:

Soarezi wrote:

So because most prefer more fast paced over slow paced makes you want to puke and quit the game? alright
Yes, exactly.
get stronger son
GladiOol
haha AmaiHachimitsu your posts make no sense at all :)


and why is everybody comparing this with a race. if anything, you guys are playing fucking nascar. driving fast and going left. driving fast and going left. driving fast and going left. driving fast and going left. driving fast and going left. driving fast and going left. driving fast and going left. driving fast and going left.
Soarezi

GladiOol wrote:

haha GladiOol your posts make no sense at all :)
fix'd
ToGlette

Aqo wrote:

silmarilen wrote:

to all the ar9 haters: i hope they pick a nice jumpy ar8 map is one of the future rounds, like ivaltek or something
I love Ivaltek please do
I would love to see ivaltek on the mappool XD
GladiOol

Soarezi wrote:

GladiOol wrote:

haha GladiOol your posts make no sense at all :)
fix'd
There hasn't even been a part which coul'dve made sense in them, so commenting on them for not making any sense while they aren't even capable of containing the slightest bit of sense is quite funny as well :)
Soarezi

GladiOol wrote:

haha AmaiHachimitsu your posts make no sense at all :)


driving fast and going left. driving fast and going left. driving fast and going left. driving fast and going left. driving fast and going left. driving fast and going left. driving fast and going left. driving fast and going left.
buny
i believe mappers use ar to control the amount of visible objects on the field, a slow map with a high ar is going to look bad because there aren't as many objects visually appearing at the same time and also gives the vibe that the map is fast.
a fast map with a low ar is going to look bad because there are too many objects visually appearing at the same time and so it confuses the player into thinking the map has a slow rhythm/flow, and also looks very clustered/messy.

You won't see many low ar maps in the map pool simply because a good mapper will always pick the ar that makes their map looks best in. ar10 is generally used for maps that have high flow speeds i.e. image -material-, big black whereas ar9 is "not too fast" but also "not too slow" for moderate/high bpm maps. maps that are ar8 and below tend to be maps that are easily dt-able; the map is going to be at a relatively low bpm ~160 with pretty low spacing and sv which doesn't meet the difficulty requirements to be an owc map (unless in dt bracket), or maps that have a very low amount of hit objects.

Personally i don't enjoy hitting a circle and then looking at my background waiting for the next one to pop up, but i also don't like to focus on so many objects appearing at once creating confusion, and my playfield looking incredibly messy too.



tl;dr version: mappers pick ar depending on the speed of the flow of the map, and to not make their map look empty or clustered which is why not many ar8 and below maps are picked because they are generally easy and do not meet difficulty requirements
Almost

Artaxerx wrote:

Luffy-Kun wrote:

Most players add DT or HR to improve their skills. When they see them selves getting faster, reading notes more quickly and with a faster reaction, it gets more fun. I remember when I started osu! I use to go and play multiplayer and when higher rank players chose a higher ar map, I was like to my self "how da fuq can they do this" And then you just want to be able to read and play at that kind of fast pace.
It is just as fun, for example, when I watch MillhioreF play EZ on some map with like 1 million objects on the screen at the same time and hitting them all. This kind of play also gets a reaction like "How the fk can he do this?" And you just want to be able to read and play at that kind of pace. You see? Your argument can be applied in this situation too. The problem is, like Wishy said, that the game pretty much requires you to play high AR... No respect for low AR at all! :(
It looking awesome does not equate to fun.
Luffy-Kun

Artaxerx wrote:

Luffy-Kun wrote:

Most players add DT or HR to improve their skills. When they see them selves getting faster, reading notes more quickly and with a faster reaction, it gets more fun. I remember when I started osu! I use to go and play multiplayer and when higher rank players chose a higher ar map, I was like to my self "how da fuq can they do this" And then you just want to be able to read and play at that kind of fast pace.
It is just as fun, for example, when I watch MillhioreF play EZ on some map with like 1 million objects on the screen at the same time and hitting them all. This kind of play also gets a reaction like "How the fk can he do this?" And you just want to be able to read and play at that kind of pace. You see? Your argument can be applied in this situation too. The problem is, like Wishy said, that the game pretty much requires you to play high AR... No respect for low AR at all! :(
As I said before " it's up to the players choice on how he/she progresses through osu!" Every player is different. Some people might like to be able to be more professional at low ar with high bpm and some would want to be professional at high bpm with higher ar. Although, you say "No respect for low AR at all!" Is because most players on osu! end up playing higher ar later on (Cause lower ar gets boring for them) so you won't see much players defending low ar... Although, I respect both of them.
CXu
Well, my main gripe with the mappool is the lack of variation really. The mappool strongly favors one type of player over another. We're also playing all 3 group stage matches with this mappool afaik, so there's even less variation than last year on that aspect.
I thought we introduced group stages in the first place so that all countries participating would atleast play and enjoy 3 matches? Now, I'm not trying to claim that some countries can't play these maps or anything, but a varied pool would give higher chances for low-tier players to pick maps strategically. Well actually that goes for all teams.

I mean, right now I don't even need to pick a map. I can just hit f2 and play whatever map I get since they're basically the same thing.
Ilye_old
Focusing on low ar just because OWC will require this is pointless. If you want to rank high you need to play with high ar, if you play with high ar you simply will suck at <ar9. So what is the point to force top players, who play mainly ar10 or higher to play something what is not connected with advancing in ranking? Low AR may be fun, but osu is all about improving speed and fast sightreading, you need to deal with that. If you not consider high rank players as the best in the world then who is best? If osu counted EZ mode as a multiplier like HR (x1,06) playing low ar would be ok, but its's not. As I said earlier, improving unnecessary skill is meaningless when it's only for OWC's purpose.
You can create tournament for low ar players, but don't confuse World Cup with it.

@edit
I'm not saying low ar players are worse than high ar, but considering every similliar aspect will lead to CS1 fans etc. playing with low ar is not being awarded in game so shouldn't be at owc as well.
Almost

[-Aoi-] wrote:

Focusing on low ar just because OWC will require this is pointless. If you want to rank high you need to play with high ar, if you play with high ar you simply will suck at <ar9. So what is the point to force top players, who play mainly ar10 or higher to play something what is not connected with advancing in ranking? Low AR may be fun, but osu is all about improving speed and fast sightreading, you need to deal with that. If you not consider high rank players as the best in the world then who is best? If osu counted EZ mode as a multiplier like HR (x1,06) playing low ar would be ok, but its's not. As I said earlier, improving unnecessary skill is meaningless when it's only for OWC's purpose.
You can create tournament for low ar players, but don't confuse World Cup with it.
Ladies and gentlemen, the mindset of new single-minded players who only care about speed. I'm not going to question you, but there are many players who are considered top players who can't play AR10.3 insanes.
Lach
I'd rather watch people consistently playing somewhat difficult maps more than getting fucked over by round 1 maps that are harder than finals maps from last year.
buny

CXu wrote:

Well, my main gripe with the mappool is the lack of variation really. The mappool strongly favors one type of player over another. We're also playing all 3 group stage matches with this mappool afaik, so there's even less variation than last year on that aspect.
I thought we introduced group stages in the first place so that all countries participating would atleast play and enjoy 3 matches? Now, I'm not trying to claim that some countries can't play these maps or anything, but a varied pool would give higher chances for low-tier players to pick maps strategically. Well actually that goes for all teams.

I mean, right now I don't even need to pick a map. I can just hit f2 and play whatever map I get since they're basically the same thing.
specifically what type of player is it favouring?

Almost wrote:

[-Aoi-] wrote:

Focusing on low ar just because OWC will require this is pointless. If you want to rank high you need to play with high ar, if you play with high ar you simply will suck at <ar9. So what is the point to force top players, who play mainly ar10 or higher to play something what is not connected with advancing in ranking? Low AR may be fun, but osu is all about improving speed and fast sightreading, you need to deal with that. If you not consider high rank players as the best in the world then who is best? If osu counted EZ mode as a multiplier like HR (x1,06) playing low ar would be ok, but its's not. As I said earlier, improving unnecessary skill is meaningless when it's only for OWC's purpose.
You can create tournament for low ar players, but don't confuse World Cup with it.
Ladies and gentlemen, the mindset of new single-minded players who only care about speed. I'm not going to question you, but there are many players who are considered top players who can't play AR10.3 insanes.
i am sure anybody that could play hr consistently and well can play ar10.3
Ilye_old

Almost wrote:

Ladies and gentlemen, the mindset of new single-minded players who only care about speed. I'm not going to question you, but there are many players who are considered top players who can't play AR10.3 insanes.
Im just saying that for example someone who play with HR getting 95% have higher score than someone who SS same map without mods. If game is built that way you can't consider AR7 or even 3 players better than AR10+ players, it doesn't mean AR3 is easier than AR10, but if u want to consider ability to play low ar as a additional indicator of being pro, change score system.
Froslass
People consider me a kinda good player and i cant do AR10.3 lol
fartownik
Even Cookiezi said AR9 is annoying, deal with it 8)
CXu

buny wrote:

CXu wrote:

Well, my main gripe with the mappool is the lack of variation really. The mappool strongly favors one type of player over another. We're also playing all 3 group stage matches with this mappool afaik, so there's even less variation than last year on that aspect.
I thought we introduced group stages in the first place so that all countries participating would atleast play and enjoy 3 matches? Now, I'm not trying to claim that some countries can't play these maps or anything, but a varied pool would give higher chances for low-tier players to pick maps strategically. Well actually that goes for all teams.

I mean, right now I don't even need to pick a map. I can just hit f2 and play whatever map I get since they're basically the same thing.
specifically what type of player is it favouring?
All maps are AR9-AR10
The BPM range is 170~200bpm (except the DT maps)
Most of the maps focus on midsize jumps (about 1/4 to 1/2 of the screen) and shorter 3~7 note streams.

I'm not saying all the maps are similar, but I'd like more variety than this, especially since these maps are going to be used for 3 matches, and not 1.

Well, it's not like this'll change anything, but yeah.
Soarezi

buny wrote:

i am sure anybody that could play hr consistently and well can play ar10.3
Sure, but are they fast enough to compensate with their readability for 10.3?
fartownik
@CXu: I'd only complain about the jump-stream variety. There are only 2 purely streamy maps in the entire pool - Seijin no Tou and Bird Sprite, from which the second is most likely not to be picked anyways since it's Hidden. Everyone knows jumping is not the only skill required in this game, I'd like to see some high BPM streamy maps in the next stages as well.
silmarilen

fartownik wrote:

Even Cookiezi said AR9 is annoying, deal with it 8)
and what does that have to do with anything? he also said 180 bpm streams are too slow, so by that logic bird sprite is boring and i dont understand why it would be picked as an owc map
Almost

[-Aoi-] wrote:

Almost wrote:

Ladies and gentlemen, the mindset of new single-minded players who only care about speed. I'm not going to question you, but there are many players who are considered top players who can't play AR10.3 insanes.
Im just saying that for example someone who play with HR getting 95% have higher score than someone who SS same map without mods. If game is built that way you can't consider AR7 or even 3 players better than AR10+ players, it doesn't mean AR3 is easier than AR10, but if u want to consider ability to play low ar as a additional indicator of being pro, change score system.
The thing is, if OWC only had AR10+ maps, then the pro players who struggle with high AR would have problems competing. And OWC has map selection as a strategy so that pro players of all specialties can compete against each other.
Allas
OWC has map selection as a strategy so that pro players of all specialties can compete against each other.
But current OWC don't have that.

This rule make it even worse :
Selection out of mod-specific brackets is limited. Each captain may only select one map from each mod-restricted bracket during the match.
fartownik

silmarilen wrote:

fartownik wrote:

Even Cookiezi said AR9 is annoying, deal with it 8)
and what does that have to do with anything? he also said 180 bpm streams are too slow, so by that logic bird sprite is boring and i dont understand why it would be picked as an owc map
I was obviously joking.

But it's something when the best player of the game ever says something like that, right?
Ilye_old
There is no way to create mappol accepted by all community, but selectors can make some categories like fast streams map, low ar map, high ar map, jumpy map or fast singles map and find 1-2 maps for each of them. I dont think this will solve the problem, but most of the participants will get their favourite type of map. Just an idea for the future
kriers

fartownik wrote:

I was obviously joking.

But it's something when the best player of the game ever says something like that, right?
Considering the standard point of view in 2013, it's hard to get the joke.

Let's all be elitist AR10 players.
AmaiHachimitsu
Ladies and gentlemen, the mindset of new single-minded players who only care about speed. I'm not going to question you, but there are many players who are considered top players who can't play AR10.3 insanes.
2 years ago people also cared about speed, but they had few good maps to play as to go beyond this AR10 limit. Now those "modern" players cannot help about being unable to accept low ar since even 140 bpm Insanes are now AR9 and it's a common occurence. Hello Frostmourne





Do whatever you want with this AR, I can't wait till I see Marisa in semifinals. But you should remember that though reading is very important, what should be really measured is the ability to aim at circles and click the circles, this is basically what this game is all about.

"He can play bpm from 120 to 240 with <100 unstable rate, he can easily reach all the jumps and aim the streams. But he needs AR 9 or higher to do it, he sucks balls at this rhythm game" - This is how I imagine some of you thinking.
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply