Byakugan249 wrote:

[BakaQuill's Muzu]
00:28:736 (9) - i'm feeling a k here just because there's a loud "thump" in the drums. generally it's a d, but, the d's in this part follow a different part in the drums. ehhh not doing this one only because I can't tell the difference

wcx19911123 wrote:

here's your ticket

[General]
preview time in Haruka's Taiko Oni is different from other diffsI actually checked this and it says its the same. Can someone paste me what AI BAT says? Too lazy to go grab it right now orz.
red timing sections are not the same in all diffs(mainly the offset), remember to resnap all notes/green sections after fixed timing yeah I will need to check what AI BAT says. +1/-1 找起来好困难。。。

[Taiko Muzukashii]
why not use taiko bg? rofl errrrrrrrrr idk， 好像给忘掉了
cancel letterbox during breaks did this

[Insane]
01:21:584 (12) - why not put it in the middle? people won't know it's stack on 01:20:590 (4) - when playing okay,

[Overall]
maps still need more works 嗯，我继续找mod去。

wcx19911123 wrote:

[Haruka's Taiko Oni]
I'm not sure using D/K in streams is fine or not, better not to do this the 1/4 finishers are rankable.

wcx19911123 wrote:

[Xakyrie's Normal]
00:14:829 (2,3) - not parallel? It wasn't meant to be, but sure.
00:38:670 (1,2) - stack better plz Oh I didn't notice that, thanks.
00:58:537 (3,4,1) - this sliders can blanket better It's blanketed fine?
01:00:922 (2,3) - ^ Fixed.
01:00:922 (2,3) - make them parallel? What?

wcx19911123 wrote:

[jonathanlfj's Hard]
HD+1 plz, it's low imo i did HD+1 and OD-1...trying to keep the star rating (i think od 5 is fine for hard on such a slow song)
lead-in should be 2000, now it's not enough got it
00:25:557 (6,7) - ctrl+g? flow can be better, also now it's kinda hard to play as a Hard diff aite
00:43:239 - add note here? to follow the durm, also the same rhyme 00:40:061 - here has object added
00:50:094 (2) - if you are following vocal, this note should be at 00:49:994 - nice catch, fixed
00:58:139 - try this? http://puu.sh/1guRF it's now kinda hard to play, and I don't know why jump at here the jump is intentional to form the triangle on 00:58:139 (6,7,1), which i think is not very hard (unless you dt)
01:17:609 - try this? http://puu.sh/1guUS flow better changed to a triangle pattern...just realized how unfit this square is
there're many sliders can blanket better in this diff alrite fixing it

[Overall]
maps still need more works its all my fault orz

mintong89 wrote:

Taiko Modreq~ <3 I didn't expect you to end up modding this lololol

[Taiko Oni]
00:12:246 (2,1) - maybe K D is better? the finish sequence of D K kD sounds better than K D kD.
00:16:319 - k this needs to be a d in order to keep the ending patterns consistent in this phrase: kdd, kkd, kdd, [dk]ddk; kdd is used to end the first and third bars respectively, and the end of the second bar should compliment the end of the fourth bar.
00:18:604 - d I know what your intention is here (even though you didn't state it), but there is no sound here and I want the note density to gradually build up until the first verse; no change.

sorry because i can found this.....good job~ thanks for modding \o/

mintong89 wrote:

[Taiko Muzukashii]
00:12:246 (2,1) - maybe K D is better?yes it is. Done.

Sonnyc wrote:

jonathanlfj's Hard:

00:33:703 ( ) - Prefer adding a note, since there is a lyric here done by redoing sliders
00:59:729 ( ) - Add a note? following vocals here, plus adding a note disrupts distance spacing
01:02:113 (5) - Maintain distance with previous note 01:02:113 (5) is directly under 01:00:126 (5), this was done intentionally
01:22:775 (2) - Jumping or not is your choice, but I prefer you to maintain distance here too it is on 1.0x with the slider before, and 01:23:172 (3) is a flip of that slider so i think its fine

Sonnyc wrote:

Makar's Easy:

00:19:597 (1) - Finish doesnt suit well here, IMO Fits to me, it's my hitsound pattern :v
00:53:769 (1) - Delete NC? Change this for me, Nyquill
01:05:688 (1) - ^ And this too.

NoHitter wrote:

[Haruka's Oni]
- 00:09:862 (1) - Doesn't seem to fit quite well. Make it a k instead. this is a k o.o
- 00:12:644 (1) - D here instead. The music is similar to 00:12:246 (1), so why make it into a K? wait what, you're confusing me as to what you want me to change it to. Anyways, it is similar but there is a noticeable pitch change here, and that's why this is a K.
- 01:04:498 (1,1,1,1) - These doubles don't fit that well IMO. Place a d at 01:04:694 then delete 01:04:796 (1). okay I changed this and also changed 00:52:577 (1) - to your suggestion to keep it consistent.

Contact me for a recheck afterwards.
After you fix the inconsistent preview points/timing sections the previous mods talked about.

Edit:
Don't forget to resnap notes. Atm there are a lot of unsnapped notes. done.

Sonnyc wrote:

Xakryie's Normal:

00:14:829 (2,3) - Parallel They are parallel in my previous change, Nyquill didn't update it.
00:32:114 (4) - Finish here doesnt sound well. Rather put in at 00:32:312 (1)? Mmm, no. This is here to accentuate the strong drum sound at this point. It's intentional for the downbeat to not have a finish; I don't believe it suits the part.
01:26:352 (2) - ^ I...don't get it. Either way, there's still a finish here and I just changed it to a drum sound.

NoHitter wrote:

[Xakyrie's Normal]
- 00:18:206 (3,4) - Plays kind of awkwardly. Unlike in 00:11:650 (3,4), there's no loud rhythm to follow. It's like this to keep consistency. There is a slight sound there, and obviously the rhythm might be hard to follow, but it's easier to read than a huge white-red gap.
- 00:23:968 (2,3) - Same as above. ...okay, this one is easy to follow. I don't see a problem with this :V
- 00:39:663 (2) - [nazi] Stack this properly? Fixed in update that Nyquill never submitted.

NoHitter wrote:

From special request.

[jonathanlfj's Hard]
- Clean difficulty.
- My only qualm is that from 00:25:955 to 00:48:206, the 1/2 notes could be spaced further apart so they won't overlap partially like they do at the moment. tried to fix some without too much alterations of ds
- 01:03:603 (2,3) - [nazi] (3) is not properly aligned with (2)'s end. fixed

Makar wrote:

Doing a quick rankability check:

-Disable middle kiai bursts in the Taiko diffs
-Haruka's Taiko preview point needs to be 48020ms
-Why does jonathan have a audio leadin and nobody else?
-Fix the Kiai in my diff
-Taiko Muzu and Xakyrie's Normal has the last kiai ending at 01:21:584 - instead of 01:21:583 - (lol)
-Though it doesnt matter, you could disable letterbox during breaks in the standard diffs so that they are consistent (even though there are no breaks)4
-Xakyrie's Normal has two red timing points at the end that are inconsistent. Add +1ms to the last two (01:03:304 and 01:05:688)

Makar wrote:

Doing a quick rankability check:

-Disable middle kiai bursts in the Taiko diffs
-Haruka's Taiko preview point needs to be 48020ms
-Why does jonathan have a audio leadin and nobody else?
-Fix the Kiai in my diff
-Taiko Muzu and Xakyrie's Normal has the last kiai ending at 01:21:584 - instead of 01:21:583 - (lol)
-Though it doesnt matter, you could disable letterbox during breaks in the standard diffs so that they are consistent (even though there are no breaks)4
-Xakyrie's Normal has two red timing points at the end that are inconsistent. Add +1ms to the last two (01:03:304 and 01:05:688)

no kds

Xakyrie wrote:

sorry, last minute pointers to jonathan:

00:48:206 (1,2,3,1,2,3) - huge polarity issue. can you please just change this to 2 3/4 repeat sliders? I mean, considering the timing, the slider would be predicted to be the same timing as the current notes, while it's actually theoretically in 1/1.
01:03:603 (2) - hugely inconsistent; only 3/4 slider (without noting previous suggestion; without repeat) in the diff. Sort of a misfit; hard to read considering all sliders are usually 1/2 or 1/1.
01:11:649 (x) - a note here to mimic 01:09:265 (3) for consistency.

oops, and 00:59:729 (x) too ^.

Xakyrie wrote:

01:03:603 (2) - hugely inconsistent; only 3/4 slider (without noting previous suggestion; without repeat) in the diff. Sort of a misfit; hard to read considering all sliders are usually 1/2 or 1/1.

Makar wrote:

And since It's going to be looked at later, might as well give a few suggestions on jonathan's diff
00:10:856 - I thought you were going to add beats to follow the bass drum since you kinda do that at 00:06:882 (1,2). I suggest adding a note here or adjusting the previous pattern so that there is some kind of hitsound. swapped note for slider
00:32:312 (1,2,3,4,5) - This timing pattern is very inconsistent with the same part in the previous phrase (00:25:955 (1,2,3,4,5) - ) Is this intentional...? this was intentional...i have a tendency of placing notes in one verse and then swap all for sliders in another lol
00:48:206 (1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2) - fix like Xakyrie said please ;_; or some other way so that there is no polarity issue. Another way to fix this is to make the 3/4 spacing in the circles sliders instead (non-repeating) and the pattern will be easily playable in a slider-circle-slider-circle pattern. It also brings out the accents in the vocals more. Change 00:48:206 (1,2) to a slider and 00:49:001 (1,2) to a slider and see if you like it, or just go with her suggestion. went with plain old repeat sliders cause the spacing is easier to fix lol

Xakyrie wrote:

01:03:603 (2) - hugely inconsistent; only 3/4 slider (without noting previous suggestion; without repeat) in the diff. Sort of a misfit; hard to read considering all sliders are usually 1/2 or 1/1.

Well, it should also be noted that this is the only part where the music does this too (the vocal timing is inconsistent in the music), so following it and not using 1/1 or 1/2 sliders wasn't really a bad thing, but could be done better. Since no suggestion was given, how about making a circle at 01:03:106, and a 3/4 repeat slider at 01:03:305 like this http://puu.sh/1kRvE did this...yeah that vocal is so troll
00:59:729 - Fix like Xakyrie again ;w; her reasoning here goes with my first suggestion. alrite...had previous suggestions to do this too, i guess ds doesnt really matter in this case
01:11:649 - ^ yep
01:22:576 - Add a note? Reason is obvious but its nbd ok
01:24:165 - ^ done
01:27:741 - Maybe add a circle here and use a spinner like the insane instead? It's not too hard for a hard diff imo. used to have it like that and a mod told me to change it...i think rite now this is fine as it is

Nyquill wrote:

At least it didn't take a year this time.

Haruka wrote:

Nyquill wrote:

At least it didn't take a year this time.

Nyquill wrote:

At least it didn't take a year this time.

jonathanlfj wrote:

Nyquill you sure you have the latest version of my diff? i think you took the wrong one, this is the one after xakyrie and makar's mods were applied (and with 2000ms leadin):
http://puu.sh/1l8cr
please check it over for any issues and update it when bat pops bubble or something

MMzz wrote:

[Normal]
01:01:517 - Skipping this beat is a bad idea. It's probably the most powerful part of this section musically so you should try and bring it out in the map. I did this: http://puu.sh/1lEnN Spacing won't be an issue with this because you don't need to move your cursor at all the get a full 300 on the slider. You could add this, or do something more to your preference. Agreed.
01:13:437 - Same case as above. You can put a circle and it should work fine. Yup.

MMzz wrote:

Hi. Thanks for the mod. \o/

[Taiko Oni]
The volume is so loud, try putting it at 65. Sounds so much better, thank you.
00:32:511 (1) - Delete this note. Gives more feel to the music instead of just a nonstop pattern. (Also it's unrankable to have very long strings of 1/2 beats. I like to think 4 measures is the longest a string of notes should be. But there can be special cases) Alright~
00:49:796 (1,2,1,1,2,1,1,2,1) - This would be better if you put the focus on the vocals instead of the drums. The vocals are overpowering this part of the music. I did this http://puu.sh/1lEBR ( D D K d dddk ) Yes that last bit is 1/6, listen to it on 25% and you'll hear the 4 beats. You could also add a beat inbetween D and K at 00:50:193, but this takes more feel away from the vocal part. Yes I heard the 1/6 in the music when I was mapping this and your suggestion is good, but I have a personal opposition against 1/6 even sometimes when they are called for. The emphasis towards the vocals in your suggestion is clever, though I'm going to keep what I have currently since I want to keep following the drums and it plays and sounds fine as well.
00:55:954 - add a note here? Gives a better feel to the music imo. Done.
01:01:517 (1) - finisher? I hear a crash symbol. If you do so you can also delete 01:01:716 (2) - . Flows nice and breaks up the pattern a little. Not to be repetitive but it gives a better feel to the music. Nono, you're not repetitive. xD And actually, this sounds really nice! Good suggestion~
01:07:874 - add a note here like before k
01:13:437 (1) - Do the same thing with the finisher and note deletion. yup
01:19:794 (1,2) - You can also do the same here as above. Sounds good.

jonathanlfj wrote:

reserving post to make changes when i get home

Haruka wrote:

jonathanlfj wrote:

reserving post to make changes when i get home

GOSH HURRY UP JONATHAN

Quilt wrote:

gratz

NoHitter wrote:

Gratz.
Now go rank that F/Z OP.

NoHitter wrote:

Gratz.
Now go rank that F/Z OP.

Nyquill wrote:

Thank you everyone!

NoHitter wrote:

Gratz.
Now go rank that F/Z OP.

Maybe in 9001 years then it might be bubbled...

NoHitter wrote:

Gratz.
Now go rank that F/Z OP.