Correcting old scores still yields a fair amount of pp (if you correct them to SS that is). Unless you already have a really high pp. So far every map that I correct (S -> SS) gives me 2-6 PP, depending on the map.
I'm sorry, but did you mean that the scoring couldn't have been recalculated more than once today, or did you mean that my PP couldn't have changed that much, or did you mean that the PP change couldn't have been a result of recalculation?BlazingFX wrote:
NoG0r wrote:
It's funny, because over night I gained about 200 ranks worth of PP, which I guess is probably like 100 PP? I don't know exactly. Maybe the calculations were adjusted twice today; once up, and then again down.
what map give you 2-6pp by correct (S -> SS)?lolcubes wrote:
Correcting old scores still yields a fair amount of pp (if you correct them to SS that is). Unless you already have a really high pp. So far every map that I correct (S -> SS) gives me 2-6 PP, depending on the map.
They should be visible in my recent activity or history. Just keep in mind that my pp is in 4950~ range, could also be a reason.tonyzore wrote:
what map give you 2-6pp by correct (S -> SS)?
I'm sorry, but did you mean that the scoring couldn't have been recalculated more than once today, or did you mean that my PP couldn't have changed that much, or did you mean that the PP change couldn't have been a result of recalculation?It was not recalculated more than once. I did not think there was room for misunderstanding.
If you are so short with your responses, then you will be hard to understand, you know.
good for youDrafura wrote:
Okay 3 days i'm loosing pp and I only cleared top40 insanes (maybe 10-15 a day).
In the other hand I see easy players with more pp than me still gaining pp for their shitty 2 try ranks.
I'm pissed of this system from now i'll just ignore it, trying to play the best i can do is NOT FUN at all. I have no fun with osu! since this system cames out. I'm even thinking in leaving CAT cause this system is just discusting me from playing all maps in the game (and this since it has been released, that's why I wasn't very present for this)
I think there is SO many bad things in system, for example :
- Easy/normal still give pp even if your rank is high AND even if you played another diff harder with a better score.
- Wth is Acc doing here ? Acc is in the score calculation so why the hell Acc have to influence AGAIN the performance ? If this have to be taken in consideration why don't you change the scoring system ? Why the hell the performance have to be evaluated agin by your acc when your score is determined in part by your acc ?
- Why two maps totally randoms from the same style of difficulty dosen't give the same amount of pp for a #1 ? (played likely same amount of time, and even if there's a huge difference why the hell this give from 0 to 30pp ?)
- HD is giving the same bonus as DT in CtB or ? Cause HD (even in std) is THE easy way to get a better score.
- Why the hell I loose pp when I play something really hard for me and gain when I do random shits scores ?
- What the hell is the magic modifier ? a random number wich multiply your gain of pp ?
- Only top #40 should be taken in account when you reach a certain rank, and top10 when you're on top of the list and for god sake ONLY on insane diffs
- Wtf age of record ? Why a score should not be valid when you did it too long ago ?
- I think the map contention is the same for all play mode for standard maps
All of this isn't official ofc but this is the exact feeling I have from this system and I did all my "tests" watching the pp modification the next day so please no : "You just didn't wait enough for the calculation".
I'm now going back to MY old system meaning playing the shit I want to play and f*ck this system. Have a nice day.
inb4 good for you
good for you.Drafura wrote:
Okay 3 days i'm loosing pp and I only cleared top40 insanes (maybe 10-15 a day).
In the other hand I see easy players with more pp than me still gaining pp for their shitty 2 try ranks.
I'm pissed of this system from now i'll just ignore it, trying to play the best i can do is NOT FUN at all. I have no fun with osu! since this system cames out. I'm even thinking in leaving CAT cause this system is just discusting me from playing all maps in the game (and this since it has been released, that's why I wasn't very present for this)
I think there is SO many bad things in system, for example :
- Easy/normal still give pp even if your rank is high AND even if you played another diff harder with a better score.
- Wth is Acc doing here ? Acc is in the score calculation so why the hell Acc have to influence AGAIN the performance ? If this have to be taken in consideration why don't you change the scoring system ? Why the hell the performance have to be evaluated agin by your acc when your score is determined in part by your acc ?
- Why two maps totally randoms from the same style of difficulty dosen't give the same amount of pp for a #1 ? (played likely same amount of time, and even if there's a huge difference why the hell this give from 0 to 30pp ?)
- HD is giving the same bonus as DT in CtB or ? Cause HD (even in std) is THE easy way to get a better score.
- Why the hell I loose pp when I play something really hard for me and gain when I do random shits scores ?
- What the hell is the magic modifier ? a random number wich multiply your gain of pp ?
- Only top #40 should be taken in account when you reach a certain rank, and top10 when you're on top of the list and for god sake ONLY on insane diffs
- Wtf age of record ? Why a score should not be valid when you did it too long ago ?
- I think the map contention is the same for all play mode for standard maps
All of this isn't official ofc but this is the exact feeling I have from this system and I did all my "tests" watching the pp modification the next day so please no : "You just didn't wait enough for the calculation".
I'm now going back to MY old system meaning playing the shit I want to play and f*ck this system. Have a nice day.
inb4 good for you
Complaining helps for the improvement of a game.BrokenArrow wrote:
@Drafura
Seriously, I hate people like you. Everything you do is complaining about how bad everything is. Why don't you quit osu! and try to develope your own game if osu! doesn't make fun anymore?
Oh, and if rank really is the only think you care about, you may be wrong at this place anyways.
EDIT: By the way, I don't see your pp decreasing "that" much.
Complaining about pp doesn't change a thing. peppy has his vision of how it should be, and it will be like that. No amount of whining w/o proper explaining and a decent way to explain the thing will ever do a thing to change peppys mind to any direction.VelperK wrote:
Complaining helps for the improvement of a game.BrokenArrow wrote:
@Drafura
Seriously, I hate people like you. Everything you do is complaining about how bad everything is. Why don't you quit osu! and try to develope your own game if osu! doesn't make fun anymore?
Oh, and if rank really is the only think you care about, you may be wrong at this place anyways.
EDIT: By the way, I don't see your pp decreasing "that" much.
In that same thread I posted the problems i saw in that system (or the one wich could be in the system) and I just get ignored. But you're right i'm a very bad troll I was just here to complain. And yes I'm thinking in playing only offline and just go online to FC with a D in CtB all new maps <- this is how much I care about stats/rank and all these crap.BrokenArrow wrote:
@Drafura
Seriously, I hate people like you. Everything you do is complaining about how bad everything is. Why don't you quit osu! and try to develope your own game if osu! doesn't make fun anymore?
Oh, and if rank really is the only think you care about, you may be wrong at this place anyways.
EDIT: By the way, I don't see your pp decreasing "that" much.
lol, and you're still wondering why your pp isn't increasing?Drafura wrote:
FC with a D in CtB
And now you're telling me i'm stupid in a nicer way. So let me return you the favour.BrokenArrow wrote:
lol, and you're still wondering why your pp isn't increasing?Drafura wrote:
FC with a D in CtB
This concept is a lot harder to grasp than you would imagine.CXu wrote:
This game is about clicking circles. Everything else is secondary.
Sometimes I lose pp for nothing ...Aqo wrote:
You can't lose PP for your plays. The system only rewards you for good plays, it does not denote points for any plays. PP decays over time and if you get knocked out of top 500 for a reasonable PP-giving score you had that can lead to losses as well; however it is definitely not a result of a play you played.
you lose pp because people beat you on maps you have played.eldnl wrote:
Sometimes I lose pp for nothing ...Aqo wrote:
You can't lose PP for your plays. The system only rewards you for good plays, it does not denote points for any plays. PP decays over time and if you get knocked out of top 500 for a reasonable PP-giving score you had that can lead to losses as well; however it is definitely not a result of a play you played.
jesse1412 wrote:
I personally believe this is what peppy means by 'lose pp over time'. I don't think the value of a score decreases unless someone beats it and likewise I don't think it increases after the map has been played more.
Pretty sure it does increase with more plays from others. I went ahead and tested PP farming a few weeks ago, played some hards with DT+HD on recent maps that looked popular through playcount (which was jokingly easy to top rank on)... stopped pretty fast because it was boring, but anyway my PP kept going up over the week even though I only played on the weekend, and this is after it hasn't been going up for months.jesse1412 wrote:
I personally believe this is what peppy means by 'lose pp over time'. I don't think the value of a score decreases unless someone beats it and likewise I don't think it increases after the map has been played more.
U don't get a lot of pp from easy and normal maps, unless u rank like in the top 40. If older scores of yours got beaten when you scored the new ones today, it's not unlikely that you didn't get many pp.Thelostcup wrote:
So I went back today and improved my ranking on maps that I had FC'd before with mods and ended up getting above 500 on a lot them but no pp.
Does this mean that we don't get them right away or can't get them on maps we've already ranked on?
Seems to explain what just happened like 2 seconds ago. I just gained 3 pp, even though I'm not rank #1 anymore on those recently ranked songs lol. By the time I lost first place, the pp should have already finished updating. Then I lost first place (nothing happened), then like 2 seconds ago I gained 3 pp despite doing absolutely nothing.Aqo wrote:
Pretty sure it does increase with more plays from others. I went ahead and tested PP farming a few weeks ago, played some hards with DT+HD on recent maps that looked popular through playcount (which was jokingly easy to top rank on)... stopped pretty fast because it was boring, but anyway my PP kept going up over the week even though I only played on the weekend, and this is after it hasn't been going up for months.jesse1412 wrote:
I personally believe this is what peppy means by 'lose pp over time'. I don't think the value of a score decreases unless someone beats it and likewise I don't think it increases after the map has been played more.
PP went up over 4 days I didn't play on. So... yes it 100% went up by other people playing and falling under existing ranks. The idea of comparing people's plays to each other is cute in theory but not everybody wants or has the time to play all maps ever so in practice... this is just silly. Until this system starts taking into account only map difficulty and nothing else, it won't be an indication of anything.
If someone sees this post just as flame, he or she has a problem about critic :/ ... and if someone says anything about the fact that I talked here about CTB.... T_T it's a part of this game as well.Aqo wrote:
Until this system starts taking into accountonlymap difficultyand nothing else, it won't be an indication of anything.
pp award often have delay for me. I often got the pp after 2 hour i finish a song.Nharox wrote:
Could someone explain me why I get no pp? I just played Avril Lavigne - What The Hell and got a hidden SS. No pp. Yesterday I tried a popular map with Hidden and got #13 (dropped to #18), no pp either.
this map http://osu.ppy.sh/s/52361 which is the one you talking about only have 6149 plays, so is not as popular as you think.Nharox wrote:
One of the scores were yesterday. It doesn't take that long, does it?
may be it is not popular in ctb,(the playcount is still 200k when i switch to taiko and standard.)MrSake wrote:
I have recently got pp with fairly good rate thanks to good hidden+nightcore/doubletime ranks, but yesterday&today I didn't gain any points even though I did some good top10 ranks like http://osu.ppy.sh/p/beatmap?b=43603&m=2. It has over 200k playcount and I got rank#3 with SS so I though it would give atleast some points...
Well, even with all these obfuscations this new pp system is much better than the old score ranking.
Yeah, I though something like that too. Because if the system isn't farmable, that means that at some point ranks with certain difficulty must stop giving pp, and maybe I'm just at my limit now.Valentiino wrote:
and the higher you progress, the better scores you always need. So perhaps that map was too easy based on your "playstyle" /speculation
Old maps are easier to farm rank because few people play them. Some old maps give tons of pp.Ekaru wrote:
That said, I like how 8 of my top 10 pp givers were mapped by me and the other two are really, really old.
[AirCoN] wrote:
Talking about fluctuations, if you click my profile, check the beginning of my graph.I have yet to see another profile like it.
easies and normals played with only DT and bad accuracy \o/Valentiino wrote:
It's funny how my top ranks are almost all hards played so long ago w/o mods :I
It just updated a few minutes ago, and seems much better nownrii wrote:
the top ranks thing is not correct at all, i have A's on mine that are not even top 200 (yet many top 6's)Valentiino wrote:
It's funny how my top ranks are almost all hards played so long ago w/o mods :I
http://osu.ppy.sh/b/144810 <== My "Best" performance (Yes, this map isn't ranked anymore)Valentiino wrote:
It just updated a few minutes ago, and seems much better now
Altough a bit funny in a way
I guess someone went and stole all of your scores :<xsrsbsns wrote:
My pp dropped from 6045 (#43) to 5205 (#612) this afternoon, very interesting.
and lol graph:
I have the same problem. I don't think it's because of this.Mithost wrote:
I guess someone went and stole all of your scores :<xsrsbsns wrote:
My pp dropped from 6045 (#43) to 5205 (#612) this afternoon, very interesting.
and lol graph:
wow that is messed upxsrsbsns wrote:
My pp dropped from 6045 (#43) to 5205 (#612) this afternoon, very interesting.
and lol graph:
There was another recalculation I think. I went from 4994 to 5129 also by doing nothing haha.silmarilen wrote:
i also just gained almost 70pp for doing nothing
heh... so I'm not the only one... (and my pp isn't updating after playing some random map, I guess I'll just wait...)Nashmun wrote:
http://osu.ppy.sh/b/144810 <== My "Best" performance (Yes, this map isn't ranked anymore)Valentiino wrote:
It just updated a few minutes ago, and seems much better now
Altough a bit funny in a way
lolcubes wrote:
There was another recalculation I think. I went from 4994 to 5129 also by doing nothing haha.
Was an assumption on my part and I was joking about that too. Pretty sure i would have gained way more than 450 ranks if unranked maps were being counted. lolsilmarilen wrote:
i doubt that because i rarely play unranked maps
I cried when I saw that LOLkriers wrote:
no pp for yoda
This.lolcubes wrote:
It seems something is going on with this again haha. Back to low pp/acc. ;_;
Yeah, me too. +75 yesterday.AkiShizuha wrote:
I was so happy to see a large increase yesterday
And now they're gone ;w ;
peppy wrote:
Fixed a bug that I introduced a while back when caching per-map weightings. Get prepared for a bit of a bumpy ride as I also plan on changing some more weighting elements based on user feedback. In other good news, pp can be calculated fast enough that it can be run in realtime now; just need to finish the logistics of that.
Can I please take a moment to urge everyone to ignore changes to their pp, instead focusing on changes to their performance *rank*. pp changes mean nothing if they affect everyone, which they do if you see a sudden drop/increase.
peppy wrote:
...Can I please take a moment to urge everyone to ignore changes to their pp, instead focusing on changes to their performance *rank*. pp changes mean nothing if they affect everyone, which they do if you see a sudden drop/increase.
is it really that hard to read? or your need of crying is overwhelming your common sensepeppy wrote:
Yes, I am making constant changes to the calculations. Your pp might drop or rise, but so will everyone else's. For more specifics on what I am working on, you can check this changelog.
1. Ignore the fact pp existsG0r wrote:
Someone brought it to my attention that their PP was a good bit higher than mine, but their rank was a good bit lower. Is this a part that whole "ignore changes to PP and focus on rank" thing, or what? Just curious.