The only problem I can see is that me (and probably other people) will be too nice about rating and will like the amazing as well as the okay...but not bad enough to dislike maps. I suppose there will also be people that tend to dislike more maps that will even the ratings out, so I would be fine with this change.
And also... about the playing 3 times before rating... DISAGREE. sometimes if I play through a really bad map I just want to finish it, give it the 7-star or whatever it deserves, and DELETE IT. Not torture myself even more D: The people who like the bad map will play it 3 times, give it a 10 star (or like, if the rating system is changed) while the people who don't like it will play one time and not bother with 3 more to give it a low rating or dislike. So, a bad map would end up with a higher score than it really deserves. Does that make sense or am I spouting nonsense again? o_o
And also... about the playing 3 times before rating... DISAGREE. sometimes if I play through a really bad map I just want to finish it, give it the 7-star or whatever it deserves, and DELETE IT. Not torture myself even more D: The people who like the bad map will play it 3 times, give it a 10 star (or like, if the rating system is changed) while the people who don't like it will play one time and not bother with 3 more to give it a low rating or dislike. So, a bad map would end up with a higher score than it really deserves. Does that make sense or am I spouting nonsense again? o_o