Support. Totally. I'm tired of rating.
You have a very good point there.GladiOol wrote:
Oh wow people are still posting in this. In my opinion the rating system should be completely banned because it doesn't even give the slightest reflection of the beatmap's quality.
Don't see why this is taking so long.RandomJibberish wrote:
Ratings will always suck, since most people rate for the song/mapper/NotaniNiSmapness rather than the actual map. We are moving to Like/Meh/Dislike system at some point though AFAIK - Posted: Sat Apr 02, 2011 9:12 pm (over 1 year ago)
I'd say Bad/OK/Good would make more sense. If you implement just like and dislike it'll be almost same as current system where everything is 10 stars. Just make a green, yellow and red button or something. e.etheowest wrote:
but then again, like and dislike is the simplest way to judge a beatmap, if a way to judge a beatmap should be present.
Yeah!JappyBabes wrote:
Just make a green, yellow and red button or something.
There should be at least 3 options, one for disliking, one for liking, and other for being indifferent about the map (equivalent to 5.5 stars in the 1-10 ranking system), that way you can still vote even if you didn't find the map anything special.Stefan wrote:
Bumping that.
I personally would find it better to change the current Map Rating System as Like/Dislike System. 10 Stars are a quite big selection where many people often picks the wrong Rating. And I don't mean the 1-Star-Troll Votes or the I-like-the-Anime-10-Star Votes but these where people have played one Diff and judging it by only this Diff.
However, it's pretty dumb that if you give a Map six Stars that it still counts as positive.
It makes way more sense to say "I like it." or "I don't like it." instead of "Yeah maybe 8 Stars because xyz and abc.". And since some people are whining about every Rating under nine Stars it would be just the best to change it to a Like/Dislike System. OR to change it from 10 Stars to 5. At least you can say to five Stars great, to four good, to three okay, to two not so good and to one bad. How people judge the Map is subjective but I find it currently in that way bad how it is.
I don't think censorship is the answer.Kodora wrote:
Good idea, support this.
I also propose add option to disable user's rating on map if mapper wants it like it was done on youtube.
Reason why i think its needed: User's rating may be important for some mappers, and some troll downvotes may look too unfair. We cant stop people from troll downrating but we can disable user's rating at all.
Comments/suggestions please.
People got different opinions if they vote 1 they got they reasons, same when some one vote 10, you make maps for all the players then all of they have they opinions about your work.Kodora wrote:
This is not "censorship", this is one of the ways how to stop troll voting 1.
This ^ and when you get alot of 1 you know somethink is wrong with the beatmapLuna wrote:
If it's just a few troll votes, it'll even out soon enough.
If it's a ton of "troll" votes, there's some reason for them voting like that.
Well.. there you can see the problem which occures when all diffs share 1 ranking The ppl playing the [insert diff] will vote for theirs. And especially on diffs where the mapping style is varying much (like when all diffs are from different mappers) there is a fairly high chance you will get downvotes from one...Kodora wrote:
https://osu.ppy.sh/b/260734?m=0
Not sure that something really wrong with beatmap, but it downvoted too much. Probably it will be fair to consider those downvotes as trollish.
It really destroys the "proper" ratings.Stefan wrote:
1-Star-Troll Votes or the I-like-the-Anime-10-Star Votes
It's easy to see and know. As simple as that!JappyBabes wrote:
Just make a green, yellow and red button or something.
I agree with this.JappyBabes wrote:
Just make a green, yellow and red button or something.