My Dearest (Cut Ver.)

Don't agree, I'm only following the vocals in this section so replacing 2 and 3 here with a 1/1 slider would mean one of the vocals would be mapped passively which wouldn't make sense here.

remapped

should be good now

will try fix all of these in my remap - thanks for the mods <3

resolved

prefer the break here personally

remapped/redundant.

In regards to me adding triples instead of doubles, that was a conscious choice I made when considering the fact that I want this map to play comfortably; when playing the map I feel that doubles make the patterns far more awkward to play, especially considering the people playing this star range likely would be lower ranked than I am.

I ignored some of the quiet tones in the song by using sliders in order to keep the difficulty down.

About the 00:14:174 (4,5,6,7) "1 - 1 2 3" rhythm, could I get some more clarification on this? When I looked at the timestamp and played it in 25% speed, all the notes were mapped correctly, and the beats weren't timed in a way where "1-2 1-2" rhythm would fit. Did you mean 00:15:067 (1,2,3,4) - ?

00:14:353 (5) - well this note for example doesn't exist. i get you wanting to not have doubles that play weird but creating sounds that are not there isn't the solution. instead you could do something with a slider for example like that https://puu.sh/JM4wJ/523d40ebc9.png - the marked ones being the double in that case.
and to "keep the difficulty down" you shouldn't just ignore a lot of sounds, instead you could lower the spacing of jumps or reduce active streams for example

00:14:174 (4,5,6,7) - about this section, you added a note then a pause and then 2 notes plus a slider (essentially a triple). Although the rhythm is more like a double and another double like this
You could of course use a slider instead of a double.

To shane-sama, thanks for clarifying - I tried both two doubles and then a slider into a double and think I prefer the slider way however I see what you mean about the rhythm now. I've removed all of the triples from that section and replaced them with doubles+sliders. Have also gone through my map and tried to improve the rhythm as you mentioned.

To Emychi, again thanks for clarifying, I've changed 00:14:353 (5) to a slider like you mentioned. as for difficulty I'll be working on my maps spacing today.

Thanks both for the help - let me know if I've missed anything major.

00:16:317 (2,5) -

00:20:246 (2,5) -

fixed ty

remapped/redundant.

remapped/redundant.

fixed ty

remapped/redundant.

Read other suggestion (:

like 00:20:248 (2,3,4) -

remapped/redundant.

remapped/redundant.

01:29:357 (1) -

01:31:678 (1,1) -

01:35:071 (1) -

fixed ty

remapped/redundant.

remapped/redundant.

remapped/redundant.

remapped/redundant.

I like this, made 3 and 4 curved.

Actually making them curved didn't really fit, especially since I've now changed the rhythm slightly right before it and made the sliders before it straight aswell.

.

00:27:389 (1) -

While I see what you mean here, I have longer sliders on these notes because the instrument here is louder and more drawn out compared to the other sections. I just tried your rhythm here and I think mine works better.

definitely think it could be made slightly more active at least, for example a reverse slider might still keep with your intentions but feel way less empty

true

Again, I don't agree with making these parts more active. I mapped 1/1 sliders on the sounds at 00:24:534 (1) - and 00:27:381 (1) - because these are very unique sounds + very high pitched and I wanted to emphasise them by changing the rhythm. If I change either of these sliders to just two 1/2 sliders or even a reverse slider it completely goes against what I was going for here as it would be actively mapping the drums in the background like the rest of this section's 1/2 sliders are (basically removing the emphasis I was going for on the high pitched important sounds).

fixed thanks

remapped/redundant.

remapped/redundant.

remapped/redundant.

fixed ty

remapped/redundant.

remapped/redundant.

I did try this before but since there's a double there its a bit too hard to play if I make every beat clickable, especially since it's not really intense here.

fixed

fixed (:

fixed ty (:

going to keep this as a reverse slider. it passively maps the quieter sounds in the background here so a 1/1 slider would not fit.

the reason why you should do a 1/1 slider is to be consistent with 00:41:675 (1) - because it's the same sound there and you don't do a reverse

it is the same sound, however here 00:43:103 (1) - it is noticeably louder, which is why I mapped a reverse here and a couple times more in this section.

fixed ty

I like the reverse sliders here as imo the rhythm is less monotonous this way.

bn told me my slow part is handled well so I'd rather not change this.

lmaoo aight

remapped/redundant.

tried this and I think it works fine as is. though I'll ask others for opinions and change if necessary ty

removed the burst and replaced with two circles, hopefully this works better

agree though i'd rather do something like this personally

Honestly I like the fact there is nothing mapped here while the singer is holding the note.

remapped/redundant

https://imgur.com/a/gvOdFZv my pattern recommendation to include all of the sounds

disagree, im following the piano mainly here and passively mapping the small sounds with slider ends. adding more sliders aka having more clickable objects ruins the rhythm i made here, as I already make it more active here 00:57:746 (1) - as the song gets more intense.

resolved

I can't really tell what this is referring to anymore because the combos or timing of the map have changed, but I'm pretty sure I just disagree. All of the hitsounds are on sounds in the music removing some is just unnecessary.

celektus

disagree with this. from 00:57:746 (1,1,1) - onwards I'm mapping the vocals so I think this rhythm choice works.

unfortunate but ill let u cook

Agreed, made it so theres more movement here.

While this section would be calm if it was on it's own, it being directly after the slowest section of the map, which is full of 1/1 sliders, makes putting 1/1 sliders here not make sense as it is comparatively much more intense.

did a 1/2 slider, works well ty

I personally don't think having a clickable object here is good, only solution I can think of is extending the slider here 01:05:068 (5) - but the vocal isn't drawn out enough to extend this.

remapped/redundant

Fixed. Going to leave the other unchanged as I'm sure it would create confusion having unstacked doubles on a section that is 1/3 as well as 1/4.

fixed ty

fixed

done ty (:

remapped/redundant

did nc's since it's a 1/3 section. imo looks fine

@Melae when you copied over hitsounds from my diff instead of Akitoshi's this was indirecly fixed btw.

thanks for letting me know (:

02:19:531 (1) - To some extent same issue with the ending starting from here to 02:24:352.
Adding some variation will keep it a bit more interesting for players

tyvm, currently remapping with everyone's mods in mind <3

finished remap so now redundant.

the most prominent sound of that section is the slider right before it so I don't think nc here works.

Makes sense, but i mean 01:10:776 (2) it looks like a new pattern where the slider isn't involved, and it would be logical to start with nc, don't you think?

It might, but I think the slider is a good transistion into the next section.

really like this pattern as is sorry

Little heads-up on this, streams made using slider to stream can actually also look deformed when using really low spacing after reloading a map since slider to stream places notes without regard for the actually grid notes are limited to. After reloading a map notes will basically be snapped to the next closest point on that grid.

Example of a slider to stream before reloading a map:
And after reloading a map:

Generally the best thing about slider to stream is that it can be used to make the spacing and curvature of streams more consistent, which in most cases looks the best.

done - thanks celektus as well for the tip