mapped by Aruel
submitted
loved
This beatmap was added to loved on 31 December 2024!
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

00:00:815 (815|1,934|2) – You could improve the current pattern by changing it into 1/2 LN because the sound itself is longer than the current pattern. Pattern suggestion: https://puu.sh/GfBVG/68c5f7a526.png

permalink

Also, for the pattern afterwards, there’re 2 things that I want to say. First, 00:01:053 (1053|0,1112|1,1172|3,1231|2) - should be more complex by judging through the sound since by using the current pattern it feels a bit off, besides this is the hardest diff so you can make it harder. Second, if you accept the mod above, the suggestion and 00:01:053 (1053|0,1112|1,1172|3,1231|2) – are collide with each other so you might want to come up with something new or you can just flip it from 00:01:053 – to 00:01:886 -. Pattern suggestion: https://puu.sh/GfC6k/e20f36c641.png

permalink

00:00:815 - 00:00:934 - are changed to LN
00:01:053 (1053|0,1112|1,1172|3,1231|2) - should be more complex by judging through the sound since by using the current pattern it feels a bit off -> Actually 1243 or 1324 doesn't effect so much in harder difficulty like this set ,
00:01:053 - ~ 00:01:529 - You might realize that I'm doing stairs structure like 12 43 or 1234 so keep mod in below

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

00:02:005 - 여기도 00:02:124 - 와 같은 맬로디음이 있는데 노트 넣어보는건 어떰?

permalink

상당히 흐려서 이건 패스할게요

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

00:02:005 – Could add another note at col 3 for piano sound even though it’s not really noticeable. Goes the same for 00:03:275 - , 00:03:354 –, 00:03:354 -, 00:04:703 - , 00:04:783 -, 00:05:180 -

permalink

00:03:275 - , 00:03:354 –, 00:03:354 -, 00:04:703 - , 00:04:783 -, 00:05:180 -they're intentionally ignored, so keep for this but

00:02:005 - I'll open this, I'll follow yours when I got same suggestion here, seems it's kinda fainter than 00:02:124 (2124|3) - this but well, it's definitely audible too.

permalink

00:02:124 (2124|3) – Because this pattern is dense already, you might want to move 00:02:124 (2124|3) - to either col 1 or 2 (1|2|3|4) for the balancing.

permalink

hmm ok changed to 2, but when I follow
00:02:005 - your suggestion, I'll change back to 4 it again

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

00:02:957 - 00:02:719 - 여기랑 같은 맬로디음인데 서로 싱글 더블로 사용이 다름 더블로 바꾸는게 좋아보임

permalink

위쪽도 전부다 롱놋 1개 + 단놋 2개로 의도했어요

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

00:03:374 - 여기 노트없는 피아노가 하나 있는데 노트 추가하는게 흐름에도 좋을거같아요

permalink

일부로 비워둬씀 LN -> 더블 패턴 강조로

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

명색이 막난인데 00:04:565 - 00:04:803 - 00:05:279 - 얘내들 다 표현해주는게 낫지 않을까요

permalink

위와 같은 의견...

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

00:05:180 – Missing note for piano but it’s different from 00:04:703 – which only has 2 pianos (including 00:04:783 -), because this section consist of 3 pianos that you can hear using 25% 00:05:180 -, 00:05:219 -, 00:05:259 -. Therefore, I’d come up with 2 solutions. First is simplify with by changing 00:05:180 – into single LN until 00:05:338 – (pattern suggestion: https://puu.sh/GfCn3/9e3cf2c0b1.png) or just add 2 more notes at 00:05:180 – and 00:05:259 – (pattern suggestion: https://puu.sh/GfCnk/0bd5b6ed7a.png) since 00:05:219 – is kind of hard to hear so you can ignore it.

permalink

As I said on above, they're intentionally ignored,
00:02:481 ~ 00:03:196 - they actually have 1/1 -> 1/3 -> 1/1 -> 1/3 piano sound which is definitely audible with hard pitch, it's kinda awkward for me to follow 1/1 to 1/3. like back and forth
00:03:434 ~ 00:04:386 - but they kinda have 1/3 sounds ongoing,

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

00:08:196 (8196|2,8196|3) – should be snapped at 00:08:196 (8196|2,8196|3) – according to the patterns above 00:08:434 (8434|3,8434|1,8672|0,8672|1)

permalink

00:08:196 - Removed a note in here and added a note at 00:08:116 - here instead, nice catch

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

00:12:838 - 마무리 맬로디음이 있는데 LN을 넣어서 마무리하는게 어떰? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/15149809/e444

permalink

이것도 너무 흐려서 패스

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

갠적으로 너무 선명하게들리는데 한번만 더봐주실래요? 저는 항상 00:12:838 - 에 있는 소리까지를 멜로디로 인식하고있었어가지고

permalink

저는 00:16:529 (16529|3,16648|0) - 이거랑 똑같은 강도로 들려요

permalink
Reopened by arpia97

00:16:529 (16529|3,16648|0) - 로 보니까 맞는듯 ㅇㅋ

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

00:23:434 – to 00:24:148 – You can exactly do the same as 00:24:386 – to differentiate it with 00:25:338 – that also consist of same pattern density but different instrument and this kind of make players a bit ambiguous imo. Pattern suggestion: https://puu.sh/GfCxh/a1372c842e.png

permalink

it was intended to like 00:23:434 - ~ 00:24:148 - hard stream with kinda mixed trills -> 00:24:386 - 00:25:338 - more harder than before, but well ya it's awkward with compared with 00:25:338 - here,
not samely followed suggestion but increase note density

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

great

permalink

00:24:148 - add note 3col?

permalink

여기는 일단 전부다 싱글 트릴로 강조해놨기때문에 keep it f

permalink

,

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

00:25:815 (25815|2,25874|0,25934|1,25993|2) - 00:26:053 (26053|3,26112|2,26172|1,26231|0) - 얘내 둘이 같은 소리로 들리는데 통일하는건 어떨까요

permalink

북진통일 ㅇㅋ

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

00:29:862 - 1/2로만 사용했는데 여기도 노트를 넣는게 빈느낌도 줄여주고 좋다고 생각함 3col이나 1col

permalink

굿

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

00:31:410 - 00:32:124 - 이거 앞부분은 단놋이던데 그냥 단놋이나 롱놋 한개 정도로 넣는게 더 낫지 않을까요 별 차이가 안느껴져서

permalink

앞부분을 롱놋으로 끌었음

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

00:33:672 - 이 파트도 나머지 구간은 맬로디에 다 노트를 구성했는데 이자리만 비어서 좀 아쉬운데 2col에 넣어보는게 어떰?

permalink

3콜에 추가

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

00:36:112 (36112|2) - 고스트노트인듯?

permalink

그런듯 제거완료

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

00:38:791 - 여기만 맬로디음을 뺀건 의도적으로 한거임?

permalink

네 100%로 들었을떄 잘 안들려서요 일단 열어놓고 추가지적받으면 바꿀게요

permalink

00:40:041 (40041|3) - 여기도 고스트노트인듯

permalink

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

00:40:160 - 여기도 00:40:100 - 리드음의 연장음이지 여기서 음이 따로 갈라진다고 생각되지 않음

permalink

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

00:40:418 - 00:40:497 - 맬로디음이 점점 올라가니까 34 34 12로 구성하는것보다 배치도 살짝 바꿔주는게 어떰? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/15149832/932e

permalink

위쪽이랑 대칭을 의도해서 패스할게요

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

00:45:815 - 여기 더블써보는건 어떰? 보컬음같은게 있는데

permalink

음 이건 패스할게요 굳이 두개를 넣을 부분이 아니라고 봄

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

00:52:005 (52005|0) – Should be stopped at 00:52:719 – and continue again at 00:52:957 – by hearing to the synth carefully. But since 00:52:005 (52005|0) – and 00:52:957 (52957|0) – are the same you can either make it as the suggestion above or 00:52:005 (52005|0) – stop it at 00:52:898 –. Both of them are okay imo but I prefer the first suggestion which most acceptable. Pattern suggestion: https://puu.sh/GfCOi/18eab43cc6.png.

permalink

I actually followed synth with LN that definitely audible while playing, but hey00:52:005 (52005|0) - it seems it must be 00:52:957 - finished here, kinda arranged with based your suggestion

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

01:05:874 – You could add another note for the drum. I mean, you can clearly differentiate it with 01:05:457 (65457|2,65517|1,65576|3,65576|2) –. Pattern suggestion: https://puu.sh/GfD1m/acf332228e.png.

permalink

you're right , but I intended 1/4 stream with 3 times on purpose, and I believe that players would have better experience with current pattern

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

01:07:303 - 여기도 음이 나뉜다는 느낌이 없는데 한번 체크해봐야될듯

permalink

피아노 있어용

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

01:10:576 - 여기 맬로디는 의도적으로 빼둔것?

permalink

네 너무 흐려서요

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

01:11:886 - 여기서부터 01:12:005 - 여기까지 1/6 맬로디로 구성되있는데 1/4로 하면 안되니까 배치를 바꿔야될듯 https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/15149849/e4de 이건 어떰?

permalink

1/6 트릴로 변경했어요 저건 좀 쉬워보여서 ㅋㅋ

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

01:12:243 (72243|3,72243|0,72243|1) – You can add another note here for more impact since this is the last pattern for this section.

permalink

fair, but I open it cuz 01:12:005 (72005|0,72005|3,72005|1,72124|1,72124|3,72124|0,72243|0,72243|3,72243|1) - they're definitely same sound

permalink

01:18:136 (78136|0) - 여기도 고스트같음 채크필요

permalink
permalink

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

01:25:874 (85874|1,85993|0) - 마찬가지로 고스트 인거같음 리체크 필요

permalink

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

01:29:862 (89862|1,89862|0,89862|2,89862|3,90100|0,90100|1,90100|3,90100|2) - 이 노트들 사이에있는 소리들을 표현해도 괜찮지않을까요

permalink

지적많이 들어오네 오케이

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

01:29:981 - 중간이 너무 비는느낌인데 4col에 노트하나 넣는건 어떰?

permalink

열어두고 의견 받아볼게용

permalink

01:31:291 (91291|1,91291|0) – Should be added another note at col 4 since there’s also a piano here which you mapped it by adding another note at this section.

permalink

keep, triple parts are definitely high pitch, but it isn't

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

01:33:910 - 좀 불편하겠지만 add note?

permalink
permalink

모든 구간을 1/4 잭은 사용안하는 구조로 만들어놔서 추가는 ㄴㄴ해

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

01:37:719 - 이구간 멜로디 표현이 좀 더 확실했으면 좋겠습니다. 약간 지저분한 느낌이라서 멜로디 위주로 정리하면 깔끔해질거같습니다

permalink

일단 보류, 1/4 와다다다다다다하는 부분만 트릴식으로 다 살려둔거라 ㅋㅋ

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

01:47:243 - 01:47:719 - 바로 앞에 파란 줄에 노트 하나 빼고 이 부분도 3노트 점핸으로 넣는 것도 나쁘지 않다고 생각해요

permalink

두박자 스트림, 한박자 점핸 으로 의도한거라 패쓰

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

01:49:148 – You can add another note here for the impact purpose even though this will affect the gameplay harder.

permalink

umm okidoki

permalink
Marked as resolved by Aruel

01:55:100 - 01:55:457 - 일부러 빼놓은거같은데 2겹 해달라고 건의안하고못배기지ㅋㅋ

permalink

아 ㅋㅋ 열어두고 같은 모딩 오면 받겟움

permalink
/