mapped by BPChingu
submitted
last updated
Hype Train9 / 5
Nomination Status0 / 2
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

Mapping 00:16:358 without 00:16:136 feels a bit off to me as in this section start you mapped mostly drums + vocals and here this is just drum.
I suggest deleting 00:16:3 58 to keep it simple as mapping 00:16:136 is not really an option as snapping would be Under 1/1.

permalink

sure... long ahh break moment.

permalink
Marked as resolved by BPChingu

Same issue as for 00:16:358, you are mapping the second hit of 2 drums while 01:23:247 as guitar + drum support while 01:23:469 as only drums support.
Condsider either not mapping 01:23:247 or mapping 01:23:469 instead could help make the rythm easier to understand for players.

permalink

went for not mapping 01:23:247

permalink
Marked as resolved by BPChingu

00:18:136 - this nc is very long (yes it's only 22 notes but it's almost 20 seconds), and there are very sensible spots to split it up. i suggest ncs at 00:23:469 (7) - and 00:30:581 (15) -

permalink

ncing 01:23:914 (11) - helps in the same way for the long nc after first kiai

permalink

sure

permalink
Marked as resolved by BPChingu

00:48:136 (7) - it's the only diff without a finisher here. forgot it or intentional?

permalink

oops i forgor

permalink
Marked as resolved by BPChingu

01:03:025 (9) - move to 01:03:247 and finisher
01:03:469 (10) - move to 01:03:914

permalink
permalink

doubt, 1/2 in kantan

permalink
Marked as resolved by BPChingu

I'm not seeing the 1/2, the gaps should still be 1/1 and 3/2... in the end the decision is yours I just think kantans can be fun and have cool patterns too!

permalink

what i mean is the 1/2 doublet, im doubtful about it in kantan even if song is slow

permalink

the reply on this is for consistency, you are supposed to do what you did in the first section to the second. when applied correctly https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/19497408/2619

permalink

oops mb i misread the mod

permalink

(๑ˇεˇ๑)

permalink

01:03:247 (9) - for this specific one, i'd probably avoid following it.
With 01:01:692 (7,8) - being 2/1 appart and 01:03:914 (10,11) - being 1/1 appart, it can be suprising. Unlike others patterns like 01:12:803 (1,2,3,4,5) - they have 3/1 rest making it easier to hit 3/2 snaps. moving 01:03:247 (9) - back to 01:03:025 - kinda feel wrong, so best spot for it would probably be here 01:03:469 - with the same color as 01:03:914 (10) - to make it sound like a drum roll before the strong finisher.

permalink
Reopened by Kin

same thing apply here 02:53:469 (8) -

permalink

sure

permalink
Marked as resolved by BPChingu

01:05:692 (1) - move to 01:05:247 don't worry about the guideline on this one because, it's counterintuitive if this is not mapped on the vocal for consistency

permalink
permalink

sure

permalink
Marked as resolved by BPChingu

p.s: mapset verifier didnt like that so i have to find a way to find a break

deleted 01:12:358 and 03:02:581 but deleting 01:12:358 in first kiai didnt shut MV up because 1st kiai is slightly longer than 3rd (3rd kiai doesnt have the 1st line of chorus 02:40:358 - 02:43:914 mapped coz only bass is playing)

permalink

01:12:358 (1) - move to 01:12:803
01:13:692 (3) - move to 01:13:914 and finisher
01:14:136 (4) - remove

permalink
permalink

added 01:13:247, 03:03:469 pattern is kinda weird for kantan imo

permalink
Marked as resolved by BPChingu

01:18:136 - could optionally nc this note to split up the (kinda hard) x x x rhythm, it also repeats twice so i think giving one repeat to each player in tag2 is cute
also kind of works for the pattern at 00:08:803 - , it's not quite the same since it repeats 3 times instead but might still be nice

permalink

sure, applied 01:18:136

permalink
Marked as resolved by BPChingu

01:21:026 - I would either move this to -> 01:21:248 or delete it entirely since the drum and guitar both have an impactful hit there. There's also no cymbal crash at 01:21:026 compared to 01:17:471 and 01:19:248 making it feel a bit off.

permalink

sure

permalink
Marked as resolved by BPChingu

Reasoning: Your current placement is OK since there is musical support for that. But there are stronger sounds nearby so I suggest snapping to those here. I personally believe it would make it much more intuitive and straightforward for the players. Just a suggestion, though... do what you will :3

permalink

i get your point

permalink
Marked as resolved by BPChingu

01:26:358 - if it's mapping stronger sound, i'd suggest to move that note to 01:26:803 - . drum is pretty much the same but with specific guitare sound support

permalink
Reopened by Kin

sure

permalink
Marked as resolved by BPChingu

01:31:804 - blue tick rhythm is a bit out of nowhere considering the rest of the map thus far has been 1/2 and 1/1 gaps. I would simplify this by moving it to 01:31:915

permalink
permalink

02:11:804 - yeah no new player is reading that correctly lol

permalink

applied with 02:11:803 removed

permalink
Marked as resolved by BPChingu

01:31:469 could be mapped instead of 01:31:914 as there is more drum support

permalink
Reopened by Eloxrad

sure

permalink
Marked as resolved by BPChingu

01:56:358 (8,9,10,11) - if your aim is to make a proper crescendo with the guitare, perhaps change it into ddkK ? current dkkK is fine but lack of emphasis on the K

permalink

sure

permalink
Marked as resolved by BPChingu

02:08:804 - seems a bit strange to have this note here considering your previous 3-plets and 5-plets all have a rest moment after a downbeat in this section like for 02:01:248 - 02:03:026 - 02:06:582 -. You could make it stand out less by simply deleting 02:07:915 - if you want to keep 02:08:804 - for the drum and guitar representation

permalink

sure

permalink
Marked as resolved by BPChingu

You have an inconsistent kiai end. Other diffs kiai end at 02:11:803 but on kantan it ends on 02:10:803. Consider moving the kiai end from 02:11:803 to 02:11:803

permalink

applied

permalink
Marked as resolved by BPChingu

02:43:471 - changing this to k would represent the musical shift more. Keeping it as a don indicates you want some correlation between 02:43:471 - and 02:43:915, yet these two sounds are very different

permalink

sure

permalink
Marked as resolved by BPChingu

02:43:914 (1) - could remove this nc and let 02:43:469 (1) - be the only one here, having 2 player changes only 1/1 apart might confuse kantan players

permalink

oops that definitely wasnt intentional, fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by BPChingu

02:47:469 (1) - could move this nc to the note after it, same for 03:05:247 (1) - ; player changes at the end of a pattern instead of after it are usually weird to play

permalink

sure

permalink
Marked as resolved by BPChingu

I suggest moving 03:13:912 to 03:13:690 and 03:15:690 to 03:15:467 because of how loud the drums are.

permalink

sure

permalink
Marked as resolved by BPChingu
/