mapped by myucchii
submitted
ranked
This beatmap was ranked on 6 August 2023!
nominated by Unpredictable and Ilham
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

00:13:391 - falta una nota aqui por tu esquema de layering

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by -Kazu-

00:15:491 (15491|1) - is there any particular reason to have this single? coz it is being inconsistent with previous layering on the heavy kick sound like 00:13:091 (13091|2,13091|3)

I think it's fine to have double here

permalink

ill be responding in kazus behalf later since hes busy

permalink

double applied

permalink
Marked as resolved by myucchii

00:18:491 (18491|2) - I think this note is misplaced, this looks like to catch the vocal sound but the layering here was supposed to be instrument focus which should be here 00:18:341 I suggest move that note into this timestamp

permalink

that's right

permalink
Marked as resolved by myucchii

00:19:991 - I think should have note here to maintain the flow and it has similar sound with 00:20:141 (20141|0)

permalink

added note

permalink
Marked as resolved by myucchii

00:21:941 (21941|0,22091|1,22241|2,22391|3) - this 1-2-3-4 placement seems abit out of the pitch, moreelse it's being similar with 00:20:591 (20591|0,20741|1,20891|2,21041|3) but clearly different sound in the short period is abit weird for me, may differentiate them

I suggest 00:22:241 (22241|2,22391|3) - ctrl+J into 4-3
00:24:641 (24641|2,24791|3) - ^

permalink

sounds good!

permalink
Marked as resolved by myucchii

00:23:291 - I guess note here on col1 wouldn't hurt the pattern? pretty clear sound right here I suggest to add

permalink

added

permalink
Marked as resolved by myucchii

00:30:941 (30941|0) and 00:32:141 (32141|0,32141|1) - have same sound but with different amount of note(s), may better to make it same

permalink

they do now

permalink
Marked as resolved by myucchii

00:37:391 (37391|2) - there is no vocal here, so I think sacrifice this kick with this (maybe trumpet) sound is not really good, I suggest to move this note into 00:37:241 for the kick

permalink

moved there

permalink
Marked as resolved by myucchii

00:42:491 (42491|2,42641|2) - abit weird minijack choice, the vocal is "ko" and "ro", if needs to make minijack here I would make it into the two "ko" vocals here 00:42:341 (42341|3) - 00:42:491 (42491|2)

something like this
00:42:041 -

permalink

that's fair, added

permalink
Marked as resolved by myucchii

00:46:991 (46991|3) - this one should be unnoted to make it same with 00:37:391 - it also gives impact on the vocal stop. also might move 00:46:841 (46841|1) - into col3/col4 to make the trill pattern

permalink

00:49:241 (49241|3) - ^ same issue should be unnoted and add double here instead 00:49:541

permalink

it's okay to have different layering but I think better to make consistent in one section, since you map kiai 2 in different layering so variation should be in there

permalink

added double, also kept those notes atm to keep up with the instruments in the background, fits better imo

permalink
Marked as resolved by myucchii

01:03:791 (63791|1,63941|3) - it will be better to shift this up 1/2 beat to follow the kick, most prominent sound around here is 1/4 snare that abit confusing if we have note on the red line

01:03:941 -

permalink

applied

permalink
Marked as resolved by myucchii

01:06:491 (66491|3) - here there is no percussion sound you've tried to layer, suggest to remove and arrange some notes around

permalink

thats applied

permalink
Marked as resolved by myucchii

01:17:928 (77928|3,77928|1,77928|0) - not triple, normal is discouraged to have triple, double is enough

permalink

okok

permalink
Marked as resolved by myucchii

01:18:003 (78003|3) - I feel like map this cymbal sound is not really good, since there is more prominent sound (snare) here 01:17:928 (77928|0) that might make player reflected to press here rather than the cymbal sound

*you can map both but snare should be prioritized

permalink

changed 01:17:928 (77928|0) to a triple

permalink
Marked as resolved by myucchii

01:23:291 (83291|0,83441|0) - there is no music cue that can be expressed with this minijack, tho I think instead of note at here 01:23:291 (83291|0) - should be better to note the snare here 01:23:141 - since sound right there is very quiet and having pretty low impact in compare with the snare

permalink

okay

permalink
Marked as resolved by myucchii

01:23:440 (83440|1,83440|3,83740|2,83740|0) - if you're gonna chart these out like [13] to [24], then you should probably do the same thing but flipped here 01:24:640 (84640|2,84640|3,84940|0,84940|1) - ([24] to [13]). you do this in the first kiai so its a bit weird to break this consistency here for that reason.

permalink

02:22:241 (142241|1,142241|3,142541|2,142541|0) - so same thing but ya just flip these

permalink

-responding on kazu's behalf-
should be good

permalink
Marked as resolved by myucchii

01:26:290 (86290|1,86290|2,86740|1) - so instead of this, make this so all the doubles during this part are [13]. you do something similar in the first kiai with [12] (00:43:089 (43089|1,43089|0,43539|1,43539|0) - ) so im thinking u can do the same thing here but [13].

permalink

01:27:791 - okay consistency mod based on prev section

01:28:091 (88091|1) - should be double looking at 01:18:491 (78491|0,78491|3)
01:30:041 - should add a note and remove 01:30:341 (90341|2,90341|1) looking at 01:20:441 (80441|2,80591|1,80891|0)
01:30:641 - should add a note looking at 01:21:041 (81041|1)
01:31:991 (91991|3) - should be removed looking at 01:22:391
01:32:741 - should add a note and remove 01:32:891 (92891|1) based on #3720668

permalink

true

permalink
Marked as resolved by myucchii

02:06:641 - now for kiai 3

02:11:141 and 02:20:741 - I think can add double here, or single if you think too dense for double, since it is the last kiai so issokay to make it more dense?
02:15:791 (135791|1) , 02:34:991 (154991|1) and 02:44:591 (164591|1) - is there any reason for making this single that it was double on previous kiai?
02:16:241 - should add for consistency 02:06:641 (126641|0)
02:18:191 (138191|3,138491|3) - you don't do this stack of the trumpet emphasis on previous, you want to keep this, at least also do stack on 02:08:591 (128591|0,128891|2)

permalink

applied all of those

permalink
Marked as resolved by myucchii

02:46:691 (166691|3) - you might wanna connect this to the 1/1 tick since i dont think this is snapped properly

permalink

oh, for some reason this was unsnapped when i checked it my b.

permalink
Marked as resolved by Unpredictable

02:46:691 (166691|2) - this LN looks like follow the trumpet, then it should be longer since the sound is still there after 02:48:641 , should snap the slider end until here 02:49:109 (169109|1)

permalink

sure

permalink
Marked as resolved by myucchii

03:13:841 - I barely hear anything after this timestamp. also for normal diff, I think it's better to do this LN 03:07:691 (187691|0) ends on more prominent sound at this ending

03:11:441 - maybe here is better since the wind sound already ended here

permalink

yes

permalink
Marked as resolved by myucchii
/