19:30 Xakyrie: : gonna try and understand the mapper a bit
19:30 Xakyrie: : first off
19:30 Xakyrie: : I noticed (well I think it's sort of strange) a constant clockwise movement
19:30 Xakyrie: : it's like, really repetitiv
19:30 Xakyrie: : e
19:30 Xakyrie: : asdf
19:30 Xakyrie: : just scroll through it and you'll see
19:30 Fiya: : that
19:30 Xakyrie: : that's the thing about mapping easys symmetrically
19:31 Fiya: : was not intentional
19:31 Fiya: : orz
19:31 Xakyrie: : xD I know, I know
19:31 Xakyrie: : I'm not gonna be like
19:31 Xakyrie: : GO REMAP THIS PIECE OF SHIT
19:31 Xakyrie: : because 1, it is not
19:31 Fiya: : lmao
19:32 Xakyrie: : and 2, it's fine for your first
19:32 Xakyrie: : xD
19:32 Xakyrie: : just be aware in the future :3
19:32 Fiya: : yea
19:32 Fiya: : I just
19:32 Fiya: : wasn't really thinking about it
19:32 Fiya: : was concentrating more on
19:32 Fiya: : making sliders that I don't normally use
19:32 Fiya: : that don't look like shit
19:32 Xakyrie: : haha it's fine, they look really good for the most part
19:32 Fiya: : and not making it hard
19:32 Fiya: : xD
19:33 Fiya: : but
19:33 Fiya: : that is good advice
19:33 Fiya: : cuz
19:33 Fiya: : I never even thought of that
19:34 Xakyrie: : :3
19:34 Xakyrie: : just making sure \o/
19:35 Fiya: : I also don't normally map symetrical though
19:35 Fiya: : xD
19:35 Fiya: : but anyway
19:35 Fiya: : I'll remember that
19:35 Xakyrie: : symmetrical is best for easys o:
19:36 Xakyrie: : it's pretty and it's easier to read than flowy maps for nubs
19:36 Xakyrie: : anyways
19:36 Fiya: : ^ that is what I was thinking
19:36 Xakyrie: : :3
19:36 Xakyrie: : glad you agree \o/
19:36 Fiya: : it's much easier to predict
19:36 Fiya: : orz
19:37 Xakyrie: : mhmm! ^^
19:37 Xakyrie: : I find aesthetically pleasing maps (for easier diffs mostly) fun to play
19:38 Xakyrie: : btw what's with the DS
19:38 Xakyrie: : o.o
19:38 Fiya: : what
19:38 Fiya: : o.o
19:38 Fiya: : OH
19:38 Xakyrie: : :3
19:38 Xakyrie: : btw I'm going to like
19:38 Xakyrie: : literally
19:38 Xakyrie: : pick at everything
19:38 Xakyrie: : since it won't be worth much kudos I'd think
19:38 Xakyrie: : 1 diff mod = no kudosu
19:38 Fiya: : lol
19:38 Fiya: : the DS is
19:38 Fiya: : fur followpoints
19:38 Xakyrie: : I see o.o
19:39 Xakyrie: : anyways, the first slider
19:39 Fiya: : if you look at the space
19:39 Xakyrie: : oh I see it now
19:39 Fiya: : it's always one perfect point
19:39 Fiya: : xD
19:39 Xakyrie: : it really makes that much of a difference o_o
19:39 Fiya: : except when I broke it a little
19:39 Fiya: : it does
19:39 Fiya: : orz
19:40 Fiya: : that's why
19:40 Fiya: : the sv is 1.02
19:40 Fiya: : as well
19:41 Xakyrie: : o_o that's really exact xD
19:41 Fiya: : I have no life okay
19:41 Fiya: : xD
19:41 Xakyrie: : :>
19:41 Xakyrie: : makes for better maps
19:41 Xakyrie: : :D
19:42 Fiya: : plus my followpoints look bad if you mess them up
19:42 Fiya: : orz
19:42 Fiya: : anyway
19:42 Fiya: : there are
19:43 Fiya: : probably things that more people will notice
19:43 Fiya: : that are more important
19:43 Fiya: : xD
19:43 Xakyrie: : that's the point of modding after all =3= up to you how detailed you get with it
19:44 Fiya: : I'm okay with detailed
19:44 Fiya: : xD
19:47 Xakyrie: : mmkay so, for your first slider, I think it would be better to make it more rounded and clean first off, but more so
19:47 Xakyrie: :  flipping it helps it flow into the next slider nicely
19:48 Xakyrie: : 00:01:630 (2) - I moved this in order to blanket, but you can easily manipulate the placement of (1) to fit it 
19:48 Xakyrie: : where it used to be, here's a screenshot: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/383367
19:51 Fiya: : right, instead of it dropping at the end and then making you move up, even if visually
19:52 Xakyrie: : o_ob
19:52 Fiya: : I understand how flow works, just forget about it a lot
19:52 Fiya: : xD
19:53 Xakyrie: : lol don't even question me with flow
19:53 Xakyrie: : apparently I know nothing of it
19:53 Xakyrie: : true story
19:53 Xakyrie: : O_ob
19:53 Fiya: : lolwat
19:53 Xakyrie: : yup
19:53 Fiya: : everything you just said right there
19:53 Fiya: : was flow in words
19:53 Xakyrie: : o_o;
19:53 Xakyrie: : dunno, Mark told me I knew nothing of it
19:53 Xakyrie: : so \o/
19:53 Fiya: : lol
19:53 Fiya: : xD
19:53 Xakyrie: : anyways =3= so in order to keep going, what did you do o:
19:54 Fiya: : I did flip it
19:54 Fiya: : I'm not sure I wanna change the way it looks though
19:54 Xakyrie: : that's fine, it's your map :3
19:54 Fiya: : cuz I kinda like that, and I wanted to use all kinds of things I'd never done before
19:54 Fiya: : \o\
19:54 Xakyrie: : \o/
19:55 Xakyrie: : 00:06:536 - wouldn't it be nice to keep consistent and have a 1/1 slider here
19:55 Xakyrie: : ending on 00:06:913 (1) - instead
19:55 Xakyrie: : unless you're looking for symmetry, not sure how good it'll be if you use a slider
19:56 Fiya: : that was why I didn't use one
19:56 Xakyrie: : I see I see ~
19:56 Xakyrie: : moving on then
19:57 Xakyrie: : 00:09:932 (1,2,3) - nice way of lowering difficulty and using climaxity to your advantage
19:57 Xakyrie: : wrong word but yeah whatever you know what I mena
19:57 Xakyrie: : mean
19:57 Xakyrie: : aiohff
19:57 Xakyrie: : ep[rgs
19:58 Fiya: : lol
19:58 Fiya: : I know what you mean
19:58 Fiya: : since I didn't use a lot of circles
19:58 Fiya: : it feels more like a climax
19:58 Xakyrie: : o_ob
19:58 Fiya: : and essentially it is leading into a climax
19:58 Fiya: : so yea
19:59 Xakyrie: : 00:31:819 (1) - for this, do you think it's possible to deepen the curve or something so the end doesn't go so 
19:59 Xakyrie: : close to the middle
19:59 Xakyrie: : again with the whole cursor movement thing
20:00 Fiya: : I could deepen it easily, but it already looks a little akward curving around the previous slider without blanketing imo
20:01 Fiya: : hmm
20:01 Fiya: : 'actually
20:01 Fiya: : I guess it wouldn't matter
20:02 Fiya: : so
20:02 Xakyrie: : alright then o:
20:02 Fiya: : http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/383376 like that you mean?
20:03 Xakyrie: : sort of, or you can flip the end like http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/383375
20:03 Xakyrie: : not sure how that would affect next section though
20:03 Fiya: : I was
20:03 Fiya: : about to show that
20:03 Fiya: : but
20:03 Fiya: : screenshotting too fast
20:04 Fiya: : and puush is being retarded
20:04 Xakyrie: : haha
20:04 Xakyrie: : puush is always retarded when you need it
20:05 Fiya: : no kidding
20:05 Fiya: : :/
20:05 Fiya: : http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/383381 visually it flows better, whether it plays easier or not
20:06 Xakyrie: : =3= yup, either way it's up to you what you want to do ~
20:06 Fiya: : but since I moved the red anchor it doesn't look that bad with the one before it either
20:06 Fiya: : so I'll do that
20:07 Xakyrie: : 00:39:366 (2,3) - nazi: for left move middle 1 down 1 right, vice versa for other
20:08 Xakyrie: : 00:37:102 (3,1) - I guess it would be strange to try and blanket this so no worries ther
20:08 Xakyrie: : 00:46:913 (1) - this is awesome
20:08 Fiya: : xD
20:09 Fiya: : for
20:09 Xakyrie: : 00:50:687 (1) - however from that slider to here I fear might be hard to read since the repeat is so close
20:09 Fiya: : 00:39:366 (2,3) - 
20:09 Xakyrie: : o.o
20:09 Xakyrie: : yup
20:09 Fiya: : if I do what you said the slidder overlap
20:09 Fiya: : lol
20:09 Xakyrie: : wait
20:09 Xakyrie: : wut
20:09 Xakyrie: : o_o
20:09 Fiya: : unless
20:09 Fiya: : you meant anchors
20:10 Xakyrie: : the middle anchor o.o should be grey
20:10 Fiya: : derp
20:10 Fiya: : thought
20:10 Fiya: : you meant left slider moving towards middle
20:10 Fiya: : xD
20:10 Xakyrie: : oh xD nope >w<
20:11 Fiya: : and 
20:11 Fiya: : I know what you mean
20:11 Fiya: : with the offbeat repeat slider
20:11 Fiya: : not sure
20:11 Fiya: : how to place it otherwise though
20:12 Fiya: : unless
20:12 Fiya: : I just
20:12 Fiya: : move the ending
20:12 Fiya: : on it
20:12 Xakyrie: : yeah that would be fine
20:12 Xakyrie: : you could flick the end up
20:13 Fiya: : http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/383383
20:13 Fiya: : is what I meant
20:13 Fiya: : lol
20:13 Xakyrie: : yeah like that
20:13 Xakyrie: : D:
20:13 Xakyrie: : http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/383384 that's what I had
20:13 Xakyrie: : same thing
20:13 Xakyrie: : anyways
20:13 Xakyrie: : 00:52:196 (2) - this slider
20:14 Xakyrie: : flows better if you change direction
20:14 Xakyrie: : into the next slider
20:14 Xakyrie: : o:
20:14 Fiya: : yes
20:14 Fiya: : xD
20:14 Fiya: : it was break flow
20:14 Xakyrie: : wooooo break flow
20:14  *Xakyrie breakdances
20:14 Fiya: : lolol
20:14 Fiya: : did it because
20:14 Fiya: : that section is different from the rest
20:15 Xakyrie: : I see I see =3=
20:15 Xakyrie: : 00:55:215 (2) - are you missing a clap here
20:15 Xakyrie: : D:
20:15 Xakyrie: : or a hitsound
20:15 Xakyrie: : or something
20:15 Fiya: : no I'm not
20:15 Fiya: : o.o
20:15 Xakyrie: : feels strange to not have one
20:15 Fiya: : slider start is clap
20:15 Fiya: : end is whistle
20:15 Xakyrie: : oh wtf
20:15 Xakyrie: : excuse me my bad
20:15 Fiya: : xD
20:15 Xakyrie: : stupid slider
20:16 Xakyrie: : no wonder
20:16 Xakyrie: : I was like
20:16 Xakyrie: : HMMM
20:16 Xakyrie: : SOMETHING'S DEFINITELY WRONG HERE
20:16 Fiya: : I'm not that inconsistant
20:16 Fiya: : derp
20:17 Xakyrie: : inconsistent*
20:17 Xakyrie: : derp
20:17 Fiya: : poot you
20:17 Fiya: : that's 4 times
20:17 Fiya: : fuck my grammer
20:17 Xakyrie: : :>
20:18 Fiya: : spelling*
20:18 Xakyrie: : huurr
20:18 Xakyrie: : lololol
20:18 Fiya: : also
20:18 Fiya: : 01:02:762 (1,2,3) - 
20:18 Fiya: : fixed derp spacing
20:18 Xakyrie: : 01:00:121 (2,1) - anyways, I think the distance/timing between this note and the spinner is a bit too quick for an
20:18 Xakyrie: :  easy...maybe place spinner where (2) is? and it was derp? o_o
20:19 Xakyrie: : hmm maybe I fixed it when trying out the flow thing
20:19 Xakyrie: : well glad you noticed it then
20:19 Xakyrie: : :3
20:19 Fiya: : you can't miss the start of a spinner
20:19 Fiya: : so I wasn't worried about it
20:19 Fiya: : lol
20:19 Fiya: : even if it does happen a little fast
20:19 Fiya: : there's more than enough time to react
20:20 Fiya: : wether you are new or not P:
20:20 Fiya: : especially with OD so low
20:20 Fiya: : lol
20:20 Xakyrie: : true I guess... feels strange going into it though
20:20 Fiya: : I guess
20:20 Fiya: : I wanted
20:20 Fiya: : 01:00:121 - hit
20:20 Xakyrie: : since spacing between (1) and (2) is 1/1 and this is 1/2 :v but it's okay if you don't want to change
20:20 Fiya: : 01:00:309 - hit
20:21 Fiya: : but I couldn't do that
20:21 Fiya: : so I stuck a spinner on the second one
20:21 Fiya: : idk
20:21 Xakyrie: : or 
20:21 Xakyrie: : you could try...
20:22 Fiya: : both spots feels wierd for spinner
20:22 Fiya: : xD
20:22 Xakyrie: : 00:58:988 - start spinner here?
20:22 Fiya: : isn't that a little long though?
20:22 Fiya: : orz
20:22 Xakyrie: : 01:01:630 - end here
20:22 Xakyrie: : o.o
20:22 Xakyrie: : it's kind of strange to end a spinner on a downbeat
20:22 Xakyrie: : since technically you should be hitting a note there
20:22 Xakyrie: : D:
20:22 Fiya: : not to me o.o
20:22 Fiya: : the end of a spinner is a note to me
20:22 Fiya: : :o
20:23 Xakyrie: : alright then =3=
20:23 Fiya: : because
20:23 Fiya: : you build up all that energy during spinning
20:23 Fiya: : xD
20:24 Fiya: : the end of the spinner should be a climax of that energy
20:24 Fiya: : and then you go into whatever is next
20:24 Xakyrie: : good reasoning , that's fine xD makes a lot of sense
20:24 Fiya: : I did
20:24 Fiya: : 01:00:498 - move the start to there
20:25 Fiya: : still feels a little wierd, but it is easier to see IU guess
20:25 Fiya: : no not IU Zach this is Duca
20:25 Fiya: : e.e
20:26 Xakyrie: : o_o
20:26 Xakyrie: : loooooooooool
20:27 Xakyrie: : 01:12:196 (3) - this is a big no no
20:27  *Xakyrie cries
20:27 Xakyrie: : sad but yes
20:27 Xakyrie: : it's a no go
20:27 Fiya: : ahaha
20:27 Fiya: : okay
20:27 Xakyrie: : :<
20:27 Fiya: : I can change that
20:27 Fiya: : xD
20:27 Xakyrie: : slider track aint visible is why, yes I'm sure you can replace it with another awesome slider
20:27 Fiya: : that's what experimenting is for P:
20:27 Xakyrie: : yup!
20:28 Xakyrie: : 01:17:102 (1) - ohoho lone slider I see
20:28 Xakyrie: : 01:20:121 (1,2) - would you like to make these more smooth at the red anchor points? there's a trick to it
20:29 Fiya: : sec
20:29 Fiya: : I'm
20:29 Fiya: : still fixing that other slider
20:30 Xakyrie: : yup yup, just pointing stuff out
20:30 Xakyrie: : I know it'll take a bit
20:30 Xakyrie: : xD
20:32 Fiya: : http://puu.sh/M1Af
20:32 Fiya: : O.o
20:32 Fiya: : not sure if want
20:32 Fiya: : xD
20:34 Xakyrie: : lmfao
20:34 Xakyrie: : that's amazing
20:34 Xakyrie: : xD
20:34 Fiya: : it looks
20:34 Fiya: : funky
20:34 Fiya: : xD
20:34 Xakyrie: : wouldn't fit this song but omg it would be soooo funny to put in like
20:34 Xakyrie: : a dubstep map
20:35 Fiya: : derp
20:35 Fiya: : how's
20:35 Fiya: : http://puu.sh/M1C4
20:35 Xakyrie: : looks good :3
20:35 Fiya: : I'll keep that for now then
20:35 Fiya: : xD
20:36 Fiya: : and
20:36 Fiya: : wtf
20:36 Fiya: : how did I not see that love slider
20:36 Xakyrie: : love slider? o.o
20:36 Fiya: : lone
20:36 Xakyrie: : you mean lone slider?
20:36 Xakyrie: : LOL
20:36 Fiya: : xD
20:36 Xakyrie: : ahaha
20:36 Fiya: : how  the hell
20:36 Fiya: : did I not notice that
20:36 Fiya: : Orz
20:37 Xakyrie: : orz(
20:37 Xakyrie: : ..
20:37 Xakyrie: : wow wtf is going up his butt
20:37 Xakyrie: : that looks
20:37 Xakyrie: : so wrong...
20:37 Xakyrie: : x~x
20:37 Fiya: : lmao
20:37 Xakyrie: : so how do we fix the lone slider issue
20:38 Xakyrie: : I would suggest a slider straight down but then you'd have to fix the next patter
20:38 Xakyrie: : n
20:38 Fiya: : lolwat no
20:38 Fiya: : http://puu.sh/M1F3
20:38 Fiya: : xD
20:39 Xakyrie: : ggg
20:39 Xakyrie: : wwoooow
20:39 Xakyrie: : didn't even notice that
20:39 Fiya: : lolol
20:40 Xakyrie: : 01:20:121 (1,2) - anyways, make sure the red anchors aren't showing so much here
20:40 Xakyrie: : you can see where they are since the protrude a bit where the curves are
20:40 Xakyrie: : xD
20:40 Fiya: : lol
20:40 Fiya: : could just
20:40 Fiya: : stuff two normal anchors ontop the red one
20:40 Fiya: : xD
20:41 Fiya: : one before and one after it
20:41 Fiya: : then stick them ontop
20:41 Fiya: : smoother curve 
20:41 Fiya: : without changing slider shape
20:41 Fiya: : derp
20:41 Xakyrie: : o.o wut
20:41 Xakyrie: : omg I gotta try this
20:41  *Xakyrie processing
20:42 Xakyrie: : ...
20:42 Xakyrie: : HOLY SHIT
20:42 Xakyrie: : wtf
20:42 Xakyrie: : that actually worked
20:42 Xakyrie: : xD
20:42 Fiya: : lolol
20:42 Fiya: : brb
20:42 Fiya: : and
20:42 Xakyrie: : alright o:
20:42 Fiya: : I experimented
20:42 Fiya: : a lot
20:42 Fiya: : with the editor 
20:42 Fiya: : just never with sliders
20:42 Fiya: : lol
20:42 Xakyrie: : haha well now you are and have :3
20:46 Fiya: : back
20:46 Fiya: : what
20:46 Fiya: : was that trick
20:46 Fiya: : that you were gonna say
20:46 Fiya: : before I said mine
20:46 Fiya: : lol
20:47 Xakyrie: : oh uhh
20:47 Xakyrie: : just make sure that the two grey points used to make it smoother are aligned straight with the red anchor
20:47 Fiya: : lol
20:49 Xakyrie: : 01:37:102 (2) - last suggestion, wouldn't you rather make this 01:34:083 (2) - but inverted?
20:49 Xakyrie: : 01:34:083 (2) - whoops no highlight
20:50 Fiya: : It was initially, but I changed it for some reason or another
20:50 Fiya: : lolz
20:50 Xakyrie: : D:
20:50 Xakyrie: : but it's more consistent x~x
20:50 Fiya: : lol
20:50 Fiya: : okay
20:50 Fiya: : xD
20:51 Xakyrie: : okay back to the beginning for a sec, (looking over hitsounds)
20:51 Xakyrie: : 00:11:441 (3) - are you by chance missing a whistle
20:51 Fiya: : nope
20:51 Fiya: : there wasn't one there
20:51 Xakyrie: : shouldn't there be one?
20:52 Fiya: : yeap
20:52 Fiya: : xD
20:52 Xakyrie: : 00:15:970 (3) - no whistle on end?
20:52 Xakyrie: : question as in, shouldn't you remove it? xD
20:53 Xakyrie: : er
20:53 Xakyrie: : wait
20:53 Xakyrie: : it's consistent
20:53 Xakyrie: : nevermind
20:53 Fiya: : Why, most certainly, dear person in question.
20:53 Xakyrie: : =3=
20:53 Xakyrie: : lmfao at the '^' text they implemented
20:53 Xakyrie: : I love it
20:53 Fiya: : me too
20:53 Fiya: : xD
20:53 Fiya: : I don't normally
20:53 Fiya: : overlap hitsounds
20:53 Fiya: : but it sounded good there
20:53 Fiya: : P:
20:54 Xakyrie: : 00:18:234 (2) - whistle on end to be consistent? or are you being consistent like every other phrase
20:55 Fiya: : everyother
20:55 Xakyrie: : then what about here
20:55 Xakyrie: : 00:22:762 (1) - 
20:55 Fiya: : it's a 2 part phrase
20:55 Fiya: : end phrase is different
20:55 Fiya: : it signifies change
20:56 Xakyrie: : alright alright
20:57 Xakyrie: : 01:13:705 (4) - kinda quiet
20:57 Xakyrie: : probably forgot about
20:57 Xakyrie: : it
20:57 Fiya: : well
20:57 Xakyrie: : er
20:57 Xakyrie: : wait
20:58 Fiya: : I just used those's volumes
20:58 Xakyrie: : ahh alright that's fine
20:58 Xakyrie: : xD
20:58 Fiya: : lol
20:58 Xakyrie: : yup all is good
20:58 Xakyrie: : thanks for letting me mod \o/
20:58 Fiya: : thx for modding it
20:58 Fiya: : annnnnnnnd
20:59 Fiya: : look at the 3rd to last post in the first page of the thread
20:59 Fiya: : he will probably KD you
20:59 Fiya: : if you post
20:59 Fiya: : or I could just ask him now
20:59 Xakyrie: : lol I talked to him, he said to post :3
20:59 Fiya: : or that
20:59 Fiya: : xD
20:59 Fiya: : thank you~
21:00 Xakyrie: : no problem, thank you :3

1. 01:00:309 (3) - Follow the heavy music plz~ :> It was a nice place to have matching sliders here, though I tried to follow the rest of the music as accurately as possible.

1. 00:06:913 (2,3) - Do anti-jump? Don't think too greatly of this suggestion.
2. 00:43:517 (9) - How about this beat? 00:43:894 (1,2,3) - maps to hi-hats.
3. 00:59:083 (1) - This spinner should be end at 01:00:121 - Because the drum Ended the spinner at its current position because I'm not placing a circle 1/2 away from finishing a spinner.
4. 01:07:479 (7) - Oh.. You can't miss the drum.. QAQ Maybe end at 01:07:668 - to follow the drum and then add note at 01:07:856 - Was following high pitched melody here. Tried to replicate snare drum with slidertick.
5. 01:13:517 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - All clap sounds better IMO All claps this section too loud, and I don't think I'm willing to decrease volume because the claps in this section, whether it is improvised or not, should definitely be audible.

RoxasGrylls94 wrote:

[Easy]

HP drain +1
Okay I guess
There are unnecessary green lines like Fixed un-used lines...

tutuhaha wrote:

[Easy]


00:36:347 (2,3) - I dont really agree put some slider like this in easy diff They really seem fine to me...

01:00:498 (1) - you dont need whistle I think The whistle accents the start of the kiai.

01:04:271 (3) - move to x176 y240 Why? That's even farther from the average distance snap.

01:13:705 (4) - too low this hitsound It's the same volume as the other diffs in the set.

01:34:837 (3) - NC begin there? No, the entire diff has 2 bar phrase combo'ing.

BeatofIke wrote:

Easy
-> Increase the HP Drain to 2 so beginners can have a challenge.

00:33:328 (2) - Make this slider a bit nicer (or just change the shape). It looks a bit uninteresting. Changed somewhat.

01:20:121 (1) - I'm not sure if this is an accident, but one of the white anchors is too close to the red anchor point. Make combine the two anchors so it makes only white anchor? It is like this so that the curve of the slider is less pointed than with just the red anchor, and to use only white anchors there would take too much effort and amount of anchors to get the exact same slider.

01:21:630 (2) - ^ ^

HakuNoKaemi wrote:

[Fiya's Easy]

1. [Rhythm]
   
   
   1. 00:09:932 (1,2,3) - Since (1) doesn't really follow anything but a standard rhythm not present in the song you can do this (rhythm+graphic) It's not present in just one instrument/voice, but over everything playing there it is. Plus I don't want a random note on a red line like you suggested.

jonathanlfj wrote:

[Fiya's Easy]

00:15:970 (3) - make this slider look like the 2 before it? No

00:27:290 (2) - make it like this for better blanket Done

00:40:121 (3) - add clap to slider end oops, fixed

01:13:705 (4) - it says there is a clap here but i can't hear it...

12BARRY21 wrote:

<Fiya's Easy>

1. 00:01:630 (2) - Try to wrap complete~~ It isn't a full blanket on purpose.
   
2. 00:36:347 (2,3) - These twist sliders may hard for beginner, consider change to another shape? :> They really aren't any harder than all the other slider shapes, they just seem like it since the slider is shorter.
   
3. 01:00:498 (1) - This spinner start at 01:00:309 - is better IMO~ No, it was like that before; was decided that it would be better with more time before spinner start.
   
4. 01:08:422 (1,2) - How about this? I think it's better! @w@ http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/384450 There are already so little circles that I don't want to be removing any at this point.
   
5. 01:11:064 (1,2) - ^ ^

DaxMasterix wrote:

Fiya's Easy:

1. 00:01:630 (2) - Move the 2nd SliderPoint to x:456|y:160 [Grid lvl: 3] This is really such a small change that I don't see the point in doing it tbh.
   
2. 00:04:649 (3) - Yes.. Copy pasta here with ^ ~ ^
   
3. 00:27:290 (2) - dasas Move this Slider to x:168|y:184 [Grid lvl: 3] ... Distance Snap? .. Grid lvl 3.. It's ok. Changed it through a previous mod.
   
4. 00:40:121 (3) - You forget Add a Clap in the End of the Slider for Continue your Hitsouding o3o.. ^
   
5. 01:00:498 (1) - I think this Spinner can Start in the Time: 01:00:309 Explained in one of the mods in this post orz
   
6. 01:18:611 (3) - You can Delete the 2nd And the 8th SliderPoint o3o... Symmetry?.. This don't break the Symmetry.. They are just there to give the slider more form.

Chewin wrote:

[Fiya's Easy]

00:15:215 (2) - You have used whistles on these sliders' start 00:14:460 (1,3), so what about to add it on this slider's head too to keep consistency? It's a two bar hitsound phrase, not one bar.

00:34:837 (1) - To keep a certain symmetry I would remove NC from this slider adding it on 00:36:347 (2) instead All of the combo'ing in this diff is every two bars.

00:52:196 (2) - Whistle on the end? It would fits the music The whistle fits much more on the 4th beat of the bar rather than the down beat imo.

JudgeTheDude wrote:

[Normal]
01:15:404 Replace it by a Slider, its end would be at 01:15:781 Nah.

DaxMasterix wrote:

Suzully's Normal:

1. 00:09:177 (1) - This Slider is Touching the object 00:07:668 (2) >A< ... You can Rotate the Slider by -8º or -7º and Move to the same original place. [x:500|y:244] It's not a matter and I don't like rotating here.
2. 00:18:611 (3) - This Slider isn't in The correct place :33 ... Move it to x:148|y:264 [Grid lvl: 4] Okay fixed.
3. 00:32:951 (2,3) - sdasad Stack in Normal Diff?.. Without change color? .. Shhh I never see a problem with this.. So don't change this.. But all the modders says this is bad :I If stacking with the end of slider, it's kind of bad for normal-diff. But if with top, I don't see it's bad or problem.

Chewin wrote:

[Suzully's Normal]
00:07:668 (2,3,1,2,3) - Select them and move at x:168 y:176? In this way the 00:07:668 (2) would be centered and so symmetric. Hum, fixed.
01:08:422 (2,3,4,5) - I think that this part with this low AR is enough confusing to play for a Normal diff.
I mean that the overlap between 01:08:422 (2,4) would confuse completely the beginners..
Maybe you should make something like this that is really more flowing: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/391447

28,128,68422,1,8
96,60,68800,1,0
164,128,69177,1,8
232,60,69554,2,0,B|256:36|300:44,2,60,0|0|8

I see your point, but this is not the easiest diff, so I think the beginner who cannot read such a overlapping won't play this diff, or even if they'll play, I don't need to make it easier for them imo. Anyway, this stack seems not so difficult.

Fine, just small suggestions :3

Saten wrote:

hi those

Armpit elbow


[Engage]
00:05:026 (5) - Reverse this? I find such patterns quite nice
00:05:781 (7) - ^ The (4,5,6) pattern is a theme I'm using throughout the map.
00:39:743 (6,7,8) - forth and back patterns are always fun Yeah, they are, but I want something more linear to represent bass slide.
01:04:083 (8,9) - just my opinion but this feels kinda weird that it starts from down to up instead of the opposite. I think it was http://osu.ppy.sh/s/50988 that inspired me.
00:51:630 (6) - reverse this? If I do that there's a bit of a stall before (7) since it drops straight down. With the way it is now on an angle it's not as obvious.

[Hard]
00:58:234 (5) - 1 grid left to somewhat stack with 00:59:932 (2) Wasn't my intention at all, but I fixed by rotating 00:59:926 (2) - instead.
01:20:121 (8) - kinda unexpected within a long combo imo. put NC on it? dakishimete yo~ in one combo, mentioned above.
00:54:649 (4,5) - reverse these? Downward motion to copy (3) intended.

Melophobia wrote:

oh boobs (´^Σ^`)

Hi, picked this from #modreqs

[Engage]
01:15:781 (6,7,8) - this pattern is quite linear and not very comfortable to me. i prefer something like this. it's not a decent alternative though I was going after a wide spacing here.

Kitsunemimi wrote:

[Fiya's Easy]
00:16:724 (1,2) - Do you think you make these sliders a bit prettier? :< I think just sticking to two round curves would be nice (like this: ω, in proper orientation) They look fine to me lol
01:23:894 (2) - I think this would look better if it were more rounded out. Done
Other than that, great polished diff. The sliders look very nice :3 Thanks

Saten wrote:

[Fiya]
When are you going to finish your diffs on my maps? ;w; I don't even remember half the things I was supposed to map for you those months ago........
AR 3 fits better overall imo I like the way 2 looks.
Such weird sliders lol, but still nice~♪ (but you didn't make any hearts D:) Not all unconventional sliders have to be hearts orz
01:00:121 (2) - this might be too harsh, but make this into a 1/2 slider and add a finish on the tail lol too harsh it is imo
lol 100% symmetry, nothing really fatal to point out here It's more like 98%

Melophobia wrote:

[Fiya's Easy]
00:07:668 - remove whistle for consistency with the previous part It's consistent with the next measure not the previous one.
00:10:687 (2) - ^ Same as above but with the previous instead of the next.
00:14:460 (1,2,3) - would prefer something like this I like using both curves and corners instead of just one.
http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/424085
00:24:649 - sampleset should be N:C1 here No, it shouldn't, it sounds much better as it is now than with N:C1.
00:57:479 (3) - finish is too much imo, whistle would be enough It's to help represent the general crescendo/build up of that section before the kiai.
01:02:007 - default finish will be more suitable for the beginning of Kiai time Custom one fits my previous hitsounding better imo.

Chewin wrote:

Hi those, mod requested via game.

[General]

1. Set AudioLeadIn: 2000 to all diffs 1885+offset=2000 ms
2. I have 112(-3 ms) as offset. Try it and if it works better for you don't forget to resnap all elements and green lines after timing changes. Better accuracy on Taiko with 115.

[Hard]

1. 00:34:077 (6) - x:284 y:244? It'd be centered between 00:33:699 (5,7). Reason why this wasn't changed before was because I didnt' want to increase the spacing of 00:33:699 (5,6) - any more.
2. 01:20:114 (8) - We have already talked about the SV changes via IRC but I think using NC here would be really much better. Would it be better if sv change wasn't as much? Perhaps 75%? As mentioned above I wanted "dakishimete yo" in the same combo, but if 50% is too much of a decrease then I think we can work something out that doesn't require a new combo here.
3. 01:33:507 - What about to add a circle here to keep consistency with previous parts? It seems there is a missed sound here :\ This part is a mix between the intro part and the part before the first verse. Perhaps you're feeling like it's missing something because I have 01:32:756 (2) - , but that's used as a transition from a faster to a slower rhythm

[Engage]

1. 00:41:247 (2) - x:376 y:80 so that to be equidistant from 00:40:869 (1,3), it flows better. It's an optical illusion, slider end > circle > slider head in a straight line is a feature in this map.
2. 01:04:454 (9) - CTRL + R? Also to make a jump between 01:04:454 (9,1) :3 I feel the jump should be at 01:04:077 (8,9) - instead. Also mentioned above: http://osu.ppy.sh/s/50988

[Taiko Lite]

1. 01:29:548 (2,1) - k d
2. 01:31:058 (3,1,1) - k d k
3. 01:32:567 (3,1) - k d
4. 01:35:586 (2,1) - ^ This part is copy paste from part in the beginning.

That's all, those owo
Call me back when you've looked over the mod. :3

Melophobia wrote:

[zully's Normal] だからそこを抜くなと
00:24:083 - (1,2)のhitsoundの流れ的にここもfinishの方が気持ちイイと思いました 消した
もしくは音も十分大きいので両方つけちゃってもOKだと思います
00:25:215 - finishだとえこー的なのが強すぎてここでは音が一旦抜けるため合わないと思います なるほ。削除
00:34:837 (1,2,3) - このwhistleたち僕の耳にはややうるさいので減らしてほしい(願望　僕なら(2)外します んー、バックの音には合ってるしキープで。
00:49:932 - デフォのfinishの方が音に合うと思います 確かに！
00:55:592 - ここはnormal samplesetだと思います そうかな？
01:03:517 - whistle? イイね！
01:15:592 - ^ ^
01:23:517 (2,4,6) - custom clapの都合でちょっとアレかもだけど聞いた感じそんなに違和感もないのでこんな感じにしたらどうでしょう
カスタムfinishチャリチャリ言わせるだけよりすきです んー、まぁバックのベルには合ってるしこのままでいこうかなって
http://puu.sh/12p9Z
01:30:498 (3) - 少し下げて完全に重ねた方が綺麗です いえす
http://puu.sh/12pcS
01:33:139 (3) - このあたりwhistle多いような・・・？01:27:102 (2) - を考えるとこのwhistle要らないんじゃないかな せやな
01:39:366 (3) - those先生のdiffみたいにnormalにしてみては　softは少し違和感あります いぇあ

Chewin wrote:

[Suzully's Normal]

1. 00:09:171 (1) - You could improve this blanket to have a better flow: Yes, it's a good view, but I've avoided hiding the end of slider under (2).
2. 00:14:454 (1) - I think that this whistle together with the previous custom slider's point on 00:14:831 sounds really bad. Removing it would emphasize better the whistle on 00:15:964 (3). Okay, removed a whistle from the end of a slider.
3. 00:16:718 (1) - ^ ^
4. 00:19:737 (1) - ^ ^
5. 00:48:605 (3) - Clap on this slider's end too? It'd be consistent with 00:48:039 (2). Yeah, sounds better.
6. 00:49:926 (1) - Default soft finish would sound better here than the custom one. Changed.
7. 01:07:662 (1) - Remove new combo and add it on 01:08:416 (2) instead. I think the current pattern is better, so no change here.

Chewin wrote:

[Fiya's Easy]

1. 00:12:190 (1) - I'd end this slider with a default soft finish. It would emphasize the cymbals in the song much better. I think the current one fits better.
2. 00:19:737 (1,2,3) - You should use the same hitsound pattern of 00:14:454 (1,2,3) to keep consistency. They are already the same? lol
3. 00:39:360 (2) - Finish on this slider's head? It'd sound nice together with that sound in the music, especially together with the previous slider's point on 00:38:605 I don't think a finish really fits here.
4. 01:00:492 (1) - This spinner should start 1/2 earlier. I believe so as well, but there are people who have been telling me that the spinner starts too early for newer players if I were to do this.
5. 01:00:492 (1) - Same of 00:12:190 (1)? Like the other diffs. I guess it does fit better after trying it a couple more times.
6. 01:02:756 (1) - Whistle on slider's head? Nope, I don't think that really fits anything.