pife1 wrote:

Te Te Te:

00:01:142 (2,3,4,5) - Sugiero volverlos un stream ya que asi como estan tienden a confundir a la gente, con un stream es mas compresible el patron. Denegado
00:04:143 (1) - Continuar con el combo, aunque suene al arriesgado siento que se ve mejor por si miras hay unas notas rojas antes de esta y se poco estetico dejarlo asi echo
00:23:043 (7) - Este siete se ve un poco raro, deberias hacer que se integre con el nuevo combo y hacer que el combo azul inicie con el. echo
00:28:143 (1) - New combo aqui para que se integre mejor con los amarillos. Ya tiene New Combo
00:28:593 (1) - New combo para continuar con el patron de colores Echo
00:32:193 (1) - Nuevo combo? Cambiado a 1
00:34:893 (1) - Aqui deberia de continuar el combo Nope

Eso es todo, espero haber sido de ayuda

tellertheworld wrote:

Te-Te-Te

1. Please tick: Enable custom colours. ooooh good catch, Done!
2. You can make more special shape. Special shape?, if Slider then No, I like to keep them simple for the most part
3. 00:11:343 - circle here? look like 00:13:743 (1,2) - . Circle Here felt weird following the strong beat, there was one before and I changed for a reason
4. 00:30:543 (1) - I think it is not need thhe change SV. Changed, deleted the first slow down too

Good luck~

tellertheworld wrote:

Railgun's Normal

1. 00:12:393 (2) - same as 00:14:793 (2) - . I think you can make their shape similar. Or make 00:14:793 (2) - some change. There is leap rhythm~. no change ◕ ‿‿ ◕
2. 00:38:793 (2) - ^
3. 00:47:943 (2) - ◕ ‿‿ ◕ fix ◕ ‿‿ ◕
   

1. 00:01:743 (1) - Minor Nazi: x200 y220 to be perfectly stacked with the other notes.
2. 00:08:193 (3) - I feel the song would be much more enjoyable without this note here. When I play this section, I begin to follow the chime, which this whole combo does, except for this (3).
3. 00:08:793 (5,1) - (or 4,1 if you did apply the above mod.) You could probably make the (5 (or 4),1) flow a bit more cleaner if you wanted. Try something like this: http://puu.sh/aoogr.jpg | Maybe reshape the last slider from the pic as well to be similar like the first slider.
4. 00:10:443 (1) - This would feel so much better to play 1/4 back at 00:10:293 - as it follows the music appropriately and even matches up the finish you have.
5. 00:10:893 (3,1) - Instead of having the tail of (3) landing on such a dominant note, Try this! | Remove one reverse from the (3) and have a slider start at 00:11:343 - and end where the (1) is in the timeline. If you don't want a slider, you can try having a circle instead!
6. 00:20:793 - Consider adding a circle here with a clap. to better catch the BGM clap sounds.
7. 00:22:443 (4) - Consider removing this (4) as well to get somewhat of a similar rhythm to 00:44:943 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - | I'm really having difficulties adjusting to how this plays. Something like http://puu.sh/aoq3I.jpg really makes this section feel more natural in a way. Having 00:22:743 (6,1) - connect through a slider somehow feels more natural as well.
8. 00:29:643 (4) - Another rhythm suggestion. This is mostly due to consistency. When you make your 3/4 patterns like you are here, it's honestly best to follow them through to the end. A person trying to use the music as a guide to know when to hit the next note would click 1/4 later because you are following the chimes. To me, I don't think this reverse slider is really complimenting the song much. A simple circle at 00:29:793 - is more than enough to fully enjoy the song.
9. 00:32:193 (3) - I'll poke this one for the same reason as 00:08:193 (3) -
10. 00:40:743 (3) - I love how powerful you get here but uh.. It actually would probably surprise people more than actually help carry the song. in otherwords, I don't really believe this is necessary. Try hitsounding similar to the first kiai maybe?
11. 00:44:793 - Consider adding a circle here with a clap. to better catch the BGM clap sounds. Similar to 20 secs.

1. 00:04:143 (1,2,3,4) - in all honesty. This makes me a bit sad. I really really recommend that you use 3/4 sliders with reverses so the music gets some love.
2. 00:20:943 (1,2) - Slider and then circle imo would fit the song much better.
3. 00:23:343 (1,2) - As for these. Try two 1/2 sliders. Since this part has two things that sound the exact same. the 1/2 sliders would work beautifully.
4. 00:47:343 (1,2) - same as 23 secs.

1. add 1500 AudioLeadIn, since your diffs are starting really soon
2. Tick rate 2 fit this song a lot better too.
3. I'm not sure about your timing, but since not time to check this today 5 am xD, try to ask to some pro timer
   

1. OD 4.5 seems not ok IMO, use OD5 to balance the settings is better
2. 00:02:793 (3,1) - this part is weird to play, since is hard to keep the rhythm mainly cuz you are ignoring the downbeat here 00:02:943 -, this can be easy to fix adding a circle there.
3. 00:03:243 (2) - this slider doesn't fit the song properly, if you listen careful both places at 00:03:243 - and 00:03:543 - have the same sound in the music, so the best rhythm here should be 2 circles instead of the slider, to represent the song better.
4. 00:04:443 then again the rhythm is going a bit weird to follow, maybe add circles in 00:04:443 - and 00:04:743 -, following the main beats in the music?
5. 00:05:643 same as above, also here 00:05:943
6. 00:05:343 remove NC is not necesary here, since the music is the same with the previous part, make more sense adding a NC in 00:06:543 were the music is changing
7. 00:07:743 same this feel really empty to play, but should be ok I guess
8. 00:10:143 yup and you should add a circle here, so the players can keep the rhythm when playing,
9. 00:10:893 (3) - try todont end sliders and such important beats like the one in 00:11:343 - since is where the music change you can feel the strong song and the change of the music, also this is the place where the NC should be, try to map that beat as a circle or slider head
   
   
   I'll continue in some houers need to sleep

Lanturn wrote:

Well, since I'm here, and this is a very very short song. Why don't I drop a few rhythm opinions and such from playing the set. Don't KD this since you already did in the previous post Ok, Thanks


[CodeS]
When I play this, I already have a set rhythm in my head. What goes in my head has some of these notes conflict. Most of the stuff written below is the oddities I find when playing. What you have right now is still correct to the song since it is chock full of noises. I only tend to focus on the main noises when playing though. Take what you want, leave the rest. https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1851228

1. 00:01:743 (1) - Minor Nazi: x200 y220 to be perfectly stacked with the other notes. Done
2. 00:08:193 (3) - I feel the song would be much more enjoyable without this note here. When I play this section, I begin to follow the chime, which this whole combo does, except for this (3). The Song is constant, Not putting a note here feels ultra weird when the background keeps going.
3. 00:08:793 (5,1) - (or 4,1 if you did apply the above mod.) You could probably make the (5 (or 4),1) flow a bit more cleaner if you wanted. Try something like this: http://puu.sh/aoogr.jpg | Maybe reshape the last slider from the pic as well to be similar like the first slider. Done
4. 00:10:443 (1) - This would feel so much better to play 1/4 back at 00:10:293 - as it follows the music appropriately and even matches up the finish you have. So.. Move to 10:293 ?,, Done I think lol
5. 00:10:893 (3,1) - Instead of having the tail of (3) landing on such a dominant note, Try this! | Remove one reverse from the (3) and have a slider start at 00:11:343 - and end where the (1) is in the timeline. If you don't want a slider, you can try having a circle instead! . Done, Feels better now thanks.
6. 00:20:793 - Consider adding a circle here with a clap. to better catch the BGM clap sounds This is one of those cases where Yes, you're right, but I won't do it because is not in my vision of how I want this map to be played, as I want this part to be simple and clean as posible, and I circle Here would overcomplicate with the Note-Slider-2notes follow up and then space and another note-slider, too crowded, thanks for the suggestion tho.
7. 00:22:443 (4) - Consider removing this (4) as well to get somewhat of a similar rhythm to 00:44:943 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - | I'm really having difficulties adjusting to how this plays. Something like http://puu.sh/aoq3I.jpg really makes this section feel more natural in a way. Having 00:22:743 (6,1) - connect through a slider somehow feels more natural as well. Yeah that was one of the few parts I was not happy how it was, thanks for the suggestion, feels much better now
8. 00:29:643 (4) - Another rhythm suggestion. This is mostly due to consistency. When you make your 3/4 patterns like you are here, it's honestly best to follow them through to the end. A person trying to use the music as a guide to know when to hit the next note would click 1/4 later because you are following the chimes. To me, I don't think this reverse slider is really complimenting the song much. A simple circle at 00:29:793 - is more than enough to fully enjoy the song. Done
9. 00:32:193 (3) - I'll poke this one for the same reason as 00:08:193 (3) - Keeping Consistency as the same reason as before
10. 00:40:743 (3) - I love how powerful you get here but uh.. It actually would probably surprise people more than actually help carry the song. in otherwords, I don't really believe this is necessary. Try hitsounding similar to the first kiai maybe? Funny enough, Hitsounds of this map were suppose to be done by another player, but because He couldn't, I grabbed it as a Hitsound practice one, this section was one of my experimenting bits lol, Anyway, Changed to Fnish-clap-Whistle, same as first Kiai
11. 00:44:793 - Consider adding a circle here with a clap. to better catch the BGM clap sounds. Similar to 20 secs. And now I do agree with this change, using the same reason as before,this time, even with adding the note, still feels clean and simple, and the follow up is great with Slider-Note-Slider space slider and doesn't feel as crowded as in the same suggestion before,.

Again. No KD please since you gave me one. Only use what you feel you like for rhythm ideas since well, your rhythm you create is what defines your mapping. You Clearly Deserve KD for this.. but if you don't want Ok lol

Natsu wrote:

Random mod

General:

1. add 1500 AudioLeadIn, since your diffs are starting really soon There is enough time.
2. Tick rate 2 fit this song a lot better too. Changed
3. I'm not sure about your timing, but since not time to check this today 5 am xD, try to ask to some pro timer I Don't see anything weird in the Timming. Will ask around for a check tho.

Te-Te-Te:

1. OD 4.5 seems not ok IMO, use OD5 to balance the settings is better Done
2. 00:02:793 (3,1) - this part is weird to play, since is hard to keep the rhythm mainly cuz you are ignoring the downbeat here 00:02:943 -, this can be easy to fix adding a circle there. I Don't feel mapping the Downbeat here is necesary, as the sound you're asking me to map is not as strong as the overall of what I'm mapping.
3. 00:03:243 (2) - this slider doesn't fit the song properly, if you listen careful both places at 00:03:243 - and 00:03:543 - have the same sound in the music, so the best rhythm here should be 2 circles instead of the slider, to represent the song better. There should Be 3 circles, but instead I used a Slider as a transition to the next section. same as 00:27:093 (1,2) - which is note only heavy
4. 00:04:443 then again the rhythm is going a bit weird to follow, maybe add circles in 00:04:443 - and 00:04:743 -, following the main beats in the music?
5. 00:05:643 same as above, also here 00:05:943 Nop, The notes are in the sounds I want them to be, and I want this part to be as simple as how it is right now.
6. 00:05:343 remove NC is not necesary here, since the music is the same with the previous part, make more sense adding a NC in 00:06:543 were the music is changing There is no Combo bigger than 8 in the entire map, I did this to keep consistency (unless it was a mistake during one of the Mods)
7. 00:07:743 same this feel really empty to play, but should be ok I guess That's my Idea
8. 00:10:143 yup and you should add a circle here, so the players can keep the rhythm when playing, Again, I'm not mapping that background sound you're asking me to. no point adding a circle here.
9. 00:10:893 (3) - try todont end sliders and such important beats like the one in 00:11:343 - since is where the music change you can feel the strong song and the change of the music, also this is the place where the NC should be, try to map that beat as a circle or slider head Yeah, Fixed this

Lanturn wrote:

[Railgun]

1. 00:04:143 (1,2,3,4) - in all honesty. This makes me a bit sad. I really really recommend that you use 3/4 sliders with reverses so the music gets some love. I don't want to use reverse here, especially a 3/4 reverse, but it is an option.
2. 00:20:943 (1,2) - Slider and then circle imo would fit the song much better. I prefer the current stress.
3. 00:23:343 (1,2) - As for these. Try two 1/2 sliders. Since this part has two things that sound the exact same. the 1/2 sliders would work beautifully. I prefer the slider because it sounds better and plays better IMO.
4. 00:47:343 (1,2) - same as 23 secs. ~

Not really much to say about this. One thing that you could try to do is add a few more hitsounds as there is really the bare minimum in it. especially when hearing CodeS' map. Will add more hitsounds, then~

1. 00:36:393 (3) - not consistent here. Maybe use previous pattern and change 2 to slider, or add a circle a tick before 3?

Hat600 wrote:

Town was included in THE IDOLM@STER MASTERPIECE 05 in 2005, although also included in BEST OF 1641,
according to I know but this specific file was taken from THE iDOLM@STER: BEST OF 765+876=!! BGM Collection , most of the keyswords are already here and in the TAG's, no need to add more

SPOILER

http://dic.nicovideo.jp/a/%E3%82%A2%E3%82%A4%E3%83%89%E3%83%AB%E3%83%9E%E3%82%B9%E3%82%BF%E3%83%BC%E3%81%AE%E6%A5%BD%E6%9B%B2%E3%81%AE%E4%B8%80%E8%A6%A7#BGM (japanese)

... but it's fine to use THE IDOLM@STER rather than a CD name as source.

Te-Te-Te

1. 00:36:393 (3) - not consistent here. Maybe use previous pattern and change 2 to slider, or add a circle a tick before 3? Not Changed

kakifly wrote:

hello~ quick m4m from #modreq since i was bored lol.. m4m?

Te-Te-Te

IMO doesnt look good when words on the BG are cropped off, i suggest you crop the picture so the words either dont show or fix it so the words show completely

SPOILER

I Don't see this a necessary as the title is visible enough at the end of the song and start., won't change it for now.

-hitsound 60% is a bit loud in the beginning imo Changed, Move to ascending from 45 to 55.
-00:32:343 (4,5,6) - can be arranged like this for better flow

SPOILER

Move but didn't changed DS
-00:33:543 (1) - the current rhythm doesnt follow the instrumentals that well, try this No change
-00:34:893 (1,2,3) - lower hitsounds on these Nope, clearly strong sounds in the background
-00:39:543 (2) - move to x152 y128, adjust blanket of next note if you do Nope, that puts a DS of x1.0 from the current note, I'm clearly using 0.8 for these
-00:49:143 (5) - remove clap No, I'm using this clap to complement the sound the next note is sitting On.
-00:49:743 (1) - should have hitsound (whistle maybe??) Listening to the song, now that I put attention, there is a strong sound going On, added Finish there.


thats all for this diff, good luck with your beatmap :3

CodeS wrote:

kakifly wrote:

hello~ quick m4m from #modreq since i was bored lol.. m4m?

BeatofIke wrote:

Modding this map soon! Stay Tuned! :3

1. For Finish hitsounding, I like to add them in parts where I can hear the cymbal crashes (like a loud "pssshh" sound) in the music. The finish hitsounding is often the easiest to do, since most of the time you just add finishes for cymbal crashes or just any loud prominent sound your hear in the music.
   
   For clap hitsounding, almost ANY type of music (other than those with complex beats, break rhythms, guitar riffs, and what not such as in dnb, metal, etc.) will sound good if you add claps on every 2nd and 4th beats in respect with a 4/4 measure (4 beats per measure). More often, you will hear a constant percussion (drum) sounds on every 2nd and 4th beats. This is also considered to be relatively easy to hitsound if used carefully. Again, you can use any type of clap hitsound you like (soft-clap is often my personal preference, but I sometimes use normal-claps and drum-claps if I feel that it sounds better on some parts of the music). And lastly, they the whistle hitsounding.
   
   Whistle hitsounding is often the hardest to hitsound and often easy to get inconsistent with them, because there are SO MANY ways to use whistles. You can use whistles for keysounds (piano for example), synths, vocals, guitar, finger snaps, and any other melodic sounds out there. You can even use whistles as the same for claps (every 2nd and 4th beats for example), usually for softer parts of the music. There are obliviously many other ways to use whistles, but for now....only focus on the softer parts of the music since this is instrumental (non-vocal) music with no keysounds in it. It may helpful to look at other ranked mapsets to discover other ways you can use whistles. Anyways, that's all I can really help you with. Hope this advice helps and good luck!

1. The hitsounds I mentioned on Hard difficulty could also applied here as well. That's up to you though.
2. 00:06:543 (1) - You don't really a finish here since there are no strong sounds here. A soft-whistle is good enough.
3. 00:25:743 - 00:49:743: Repeat hitsound pattern. Nothing has changed here since it's just a loop.
4. 00:49:743 (1) - This is where a soft-finish will fit good. Try adding one here.

1. For the hardest difficulty in the mapset, I would recommend using a higher Drain Rate and OD like 6 or 7.
2. 00:00:543 (1) - Remove clap at the end. It's not really needed and it sounds pretty strange imo.
3. 00:01:142 (2,3,4,5) - Replace clap with Normal sampleset. It sounds better with the drums/percussions imo.
4. 00:01:743 (1) - Add finish at start and remove finish at the end. You can hear a cymbal sound here.
5. 00:04:143 (5) - Try adding a new combo here. You can also add a new combo at 00:06:543 (4) as well.
6. 00:08:343 (4) - You should continue with the melody sound here by adding a soft-whistle at start and end of this slider.
7. 00:10:293 (1) - Remove finish here. You don't hear the loud drum here.
8. 00:10:593 (3) - Add a note here (with a finish). You can hear the loud drums here too.
9. 00:11:343 (1) - Try adding soft-whistles at the start and end of this slider.
10. 00:11:943 (2) - To stay consistent with the normal-whistles, you should add one at the start of this slider.
11. 00:20:943 (7) - New combo should start here. Not at 00:21:243.
12. 00:25:743 - 00:49:743: Repeat hitsound and combo pattern. Nothing has changed here since it's just a loop. Also, you have an unsnapped inherited (green) sections at 00:30:538. Please re-snap the green timing section to 00:30:543

BeatofIke wrote:

[Normal] Because Railgun shows no signs of Life or whatsso ever, I will do his changes for now

1. The hitsounds I mentioned on Hard difficulty could also applied here as well. That's up to you though.
2. 00:06:543 (1) - You don't really a finish here since there are no strong sounds here. A soft-whistle is good enough. Done
3. 00:25:743 - 00:49:743: Repeat hitsound pattern. Nothing has changed here since it's just a loop.
4. 00:49:743 (1) - This is where a soft-finish will fit good. Try adding one here.

Done

[Hard]

1. For the hardest difficulty in the mapset, I would recommend using a higher Drain Rate and OD like 6 or 7. Why?I Don't believe this should have high diff setting, as I'm trying to make a friendly user map, moved to 6 both, but I Don't plan on making it higher
   ,
2. 00:00:543 (1) - Remove clap at the end. It's not really needed and it sounds pretty strange imo. Done
3. 00:01:142 (2,3,4,5) - Replace clap with Normal sampleset. It sounds better with the drums/percussions imo. Done
4. 00:01:743 (1) - Add finish at start and remove finish at the end. You can hear a cymbal sound here. Done
5. 00:04:143 (5) - Try adding a new combo here. You can also add a new combo at 00:06:543 (4) as well. Done
6. 00:08:343 (4) - You should continue with the melody sound here by adding a soft-whistle at start and end of this slider. Done
7. 00:10:293 (1) - Remove finish here. You don't hear the loud drum here. Not changed, there's clearly a strong sound here, I don't use only drum for Finish.
8. 00:10:593 (3) - Add a note here (with a finish). You can hear the loud drums here too. Done
9. 00:11:343 (1) - Try adding soft-whistles at the start and end of this slider. Done
10. 00:11:943 (2) - To stay consistent with the normal-whistles, you should add one at the start of this slider. Done
11. 00:20:943 (7) - New combo should start here. Not at 00:21:243. Done
12. 00:25:743 - 00:49:743: Repeat hitsound and combo pattern. Nothing has changed here since it's just a loop. Also, you have an unsnapped inherited (green) sections at 00:30:538. Please re-snap the green timing section to 00:30:543

Done

popner wrote:

Forgot to mention: add 1500 AudioLeadIn in every diffs.

Edit: The source should be game title but not album title. You should add the album title in tags.

BeatofIke wrote:

I re-checked the map once more and found no issues.
Moving this map to Qualified!
EDIT: 8 maps has been reached! Can't quality yet!

1. Halving the BPM (Please increase it to 200. If you want to save time with the readjusting of your map, just halve the SV, so you'll have the same slider speed as before!
2. The way it got ranked (BeatOfIke Bubbled it, the bubble got popped, so he already used his action as BAT and is not allowed to rank it.)
3. Some concers about the quality of the map itself. (See my mod below)

Irreversible wrote:

Hey there!

First of all, take my apologies that we happen to unrank it that late, but technically this mapset isn't even allowed to be ranked.

Disqualified for following reasons:
[list][*]Halving the BPM (Please increase it to 200. If you want to save time with the readjusting of your map, just halve the SV, so you'll have the same slider speed as before! Changed on all diff. Next time people will ask me to overmap the fuck out of it because it's "200 BPM" now, amirite?
[*]The way it got ranked (BeatOfIke Bubbled it, the bubble got popped, so he already used his action as BAT and is not allowed to rank it.)
[*]Some concers about the quality of the map itself. (See my mod below)

[Te-Te-Te]

The hitsounding itself appears really unconsistent to me, and I'd prefer if you had a closer look at the hitsounding pattern yourself. not really.

00:01:134 (2,3,4,5) - This stack appears rather boring to me, the music isn't even the same. Why not putting some more movement in this pattern? Dude, My mapping style is boring, I like to map boring stuff to people who like boring maps., I like Stacks I like the hold on here before the song finally kicks In, is exactly what you say BORING, because I want it to be boring. I Hope that, as the original mapper, at least gets respected.
00:05:035 (3,4,5) - Imo quite bad flow, would be better if it was placed to the bottom side of 4, because straight flow in general generally plays awkward to me. 00:05:785 (5) - I suggest 288 296. Yep, feels better, Done
00:06:535 (1) - I honestly think you can improve this slidershape. If you insist leaving it, at least make improve the bulb in the middle of the slider. "Improve the bulb", what does this even mean?, what?, Improve the slidershape?, HOW?, I like how they play, Me, as the original mapper. that means nothing right?.
Took out this slider to a more basic one.
00:07:885 (1,2,3,4) - These whistles feel spammed, but in the part before, it lacked whistles imo. You should reconsider the hitsounding. Dude, Turn Sample Volume to 0%, CHECK WHERE I'm using Whistle, Not gonna reconsider it because there is nothing wrong, I talked with very experience hitsounders about What I wanted to do with them (complement to the main song along other things), there is nothing wrong with them.
00:10:285 (1,2,3,4) - I honestly don't think this finish spam isn't doing the trick as well, please use the finishes less spammed! .[/color] ok there is one wrong, I'm retarded, there is no sound backing 00:10:285 (1) - . I took that one off.
00:21:235 (2,3) - Again, I wouldn't stack those. Some movement feels more intuitive! Nope.
00:20:185 (5,6,1,2,3) - I can see a Problem in this pattern anyway, 00:20:785 - why didn't you map this beat? You've mapped less important beats so often, why leaving this out? You could reconsider the rhythm and placement here! If you Need suggestions, feel free to catch me ingame. Because you see, the density of Notes here is REAAAALLY HIIIIIIIIGH, compared to, for example 00:44:785 (7) - , it's the same but I added the note, why?, because if I added a note in the first section (the one you want fixed), it would end "o - o o o -" <<<<<< a HUGE clusterfuck, while in the second section, adding still looks clean ("- o - ") 0 = notes - = sliders. so in short words, I didn't added a note because the entire pattern would be annoying to play and looks ugly.
00:23:335 (2,3,4,5,6) - The overall way of the pattern could me made smoother. (00:23:935 (4) - rotate this one a bit, 00:24:535 (6) - same) I fail to see it, sorry, I believe this play good moving the player around the playable area. changed the first sliders a bit.
00:34:135 (3) - Rotate a bit to the left, to increase its Transition. Done
00:49:735 - This should be the end, I strongly suppose? It appears to be really anticlimatic to finish a map like that imo. End it on a strong beat! sigh... Done
00:44:935 (1) - Would look cleaner if you simply copied 00:44:335 (6) - Done
00:47:185 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Nice transition, that's how i'd like it to look in the pattern before.


That's it from my side! If you have any questions, or need help to understand my modding more, please feel free to catch me ingame, to have a talk about it.

Lach wrote:

Step it up QAT, or you're going to make a lot of people mad with this finding a reason to unqualify right before it goes into ranked bullshit. There's a 7 day period, I'm aware, but surely it doesn't take 6 days and a few hours to get off (on?) your arse and look at a map. Two of the things you noted would have been blindingly obvious the moment you downloaded the map. The rest are shit nobody really cares about.

Want to uphold "quality"? Do it in a timely fashion.

Lach wrote:

Step it up QAT, or you're going to make a lot of people mad with this finding a reason to unqualify right before it goes into ranked bullshit. There's a 7 day period, I'm aware, but surely it doesn't take 6 days and a few hours to get off (on?) your arse and look at a map. Two of the things you noted would have been blindingly obvious the moment you downloaded the map. The rest are shit nobody really cares about.

Want to uphold "quality"? Do it in a timely fashion.

Konei wrote:

Lach wrote:

Step it up QAT, or you're going to make a lot of people mad with this finding a reason to unqualify right before it goes into ranked bullshit. There's a 7 day period, I'm aware, but surely it doesn't take 6 days and a few hours to get off (on?) your arse and look at a map. Two of the things you noted would have been blindingly obvious the moment you downloaded the map. The rest are shit nobody really cares about.

Want to uphold "quality"? Do it in a timely fashion.

Uhmm well, you see, it's not 7 days because it sounds more fun, it's 7 days because it IS 7 days, so it's totally legit to take it out of qualified status to fix issues.

And if those things are so obvious, why don't you point them out? Probably because you either didn't see them or the map itself, and that probably is the same reason the QAT did what it did.

Irreversible wrote:

Disqualified for following reasons:

1. The way it got ranked (BeatOfIke Bubbled it, the bubble got popped, so he already used his action as BAT and is not allowed to rank it.)

popner wrote:

The BPM is obviously 100.

Please don't make simple mistakes like this, QAT. This is really unprofessional.

peppy wrote:

fuck off and never map again.

Lach wrote:

Stuff I don't care about

Konei wrote:

More Stuff I don't care about

Kibbleru wrote:

Go Make another thread

Sonnyc wrote:

Yep. I was really mad about this

peppy wrote:

Yeah Yeah. w/e you say dude

peppy wrote:

FUck the fuck off you dicks. 7 days is the amount of time during which a map can be unqualified. If you are going to complain about your map getting dequalified on day 6 ITO IMPROVE ITS QUALITY then fuck off and never map again.

Zero__wind wrote:

Let's just do something, in a timely fashion

Te-Te-Te
00:07:435 (2,3) - viewing through your whole diff, I'd asume that you use normal samples for the kick drum, so I would say that these two normal beats are a bit surprising. turn down the volume to about 45% for these two beats sounds better to me. of course you can consider using other hitsounds instead Changed Volume on this and 00:31:435 (2) -
00:08:185 (3) - for this one, I'd recommend to remove the whistle because there's no keyboard(?) melody at this point in the point 00:07:885 (1,2) - but only hit-hat sound, while you didn't add whistles to the other hit-hat beats in this part like 00:09:985 (3) - . Rejected, I'm clearly using those <I don't know how to explain the way they sound > sounds in the background as base for whistle. not what you're exactly saying to put whistle On.
00:17:935 (6) - unwanted sliderwhistle I think, as it breaks your consistency. better remove it Sorry but no, Sliderwhistle are the soul of my Hitsounding, I love them and I love the way they sound complementing the song. sames goes for all the sliderwhistle in te map.
00:25:135 - this clap is abrupt imo, as there's actually no such sound in the music which could correspond to it. if you wanna keep this, you'd better add soft claps at 00:23:635 - and 00:24:235 - as well and change 00:25:135 - to soft clap instead of normal ones so that they will correspond with each other and provide a better sound effect than the current Removed clap at 00:24:535 (6) - end and 00:49:135 (7) -
00:25:435 (7) - if you agreed with the above, you may wanna remove this clap and leave the whistle alone as I think it's already not a part of the pattern 00:23:335 (2,3,4,5,6) - . this is rather optional though
------------------------------------------------------------------
obviously the above is all as the following part simply repeats. so if you changed anything above, plz do the same to the similar one in the part from 00:25:735 - till end to keep consistency.
for example, you forgot to remove the finish at 00:34:285 - after you removed the one at 00:10:285 (1) - according to Irre's post Good Point, Changed.

00:44:335 (6) - unwanted sliderwhistle I think, better remove it Sorry, I don't plan to remove any of the sliderwhistle. They're perfect in my opinion.

00:23:185 (1,2) - exchanging NC here makes more sense. it's 00:23:335 (2) - that starts a new phrase Done
00:47:185 (1,2) - ^ Done
00:31:885 (1,2,3,4) - maybe you could unstack them making them similar as 00:07:885 (1,2,3,4) - , not a big dealol

Easy
00:08:335 - a whistle here is worth considering as that beat is in the keyboard track just like 00:04:135 (2) - and 00:08:935 (1) - so it deserves to be hitsounded the same way Accepted, also added 00:32:335 (2) -
00:12:385 (2) - you may want to use whistles to decorate these damn soft and empty sliders like what you did in Hard, also for 00:14:785 (2,2,2) - of course
00:23:935 - maybe this beat should have a whistle like 00:23:335 (1) - as well because they really share the same sound. I tried and I remember why I didn't, the big difference on SV clearly affects how I see the hitsound. I don't believe these sounds as good as in the hard when the slider is so slow and there aren't that many other hitsounds happening besides the slider whistle. (that's why I preffer to keep hitsound on this Easy as Simple as possible) Added Whistles (not Sliderwhistles)
00:29:335 - whistle for consistency with 00:28:135 - Done
00:32:335 (2) - ^ referring to 00:30:535 - ^
00:36:385 (2) - same things for this kiai ^
00:47:935 - same as 00:23:935 - ^

Railgun's Normal I Won't touch Railgun Hitsounds, I believe he doesn't want them changed, and I respect that, I will contact you tomorrow.

00:05:335 (3) - shuold better have a whistle on head like 00:04:135 (1) - , they are just so alike
00:08:335 (3) - whistle on head like 00:06:535 (1) - is recommended
00:23:335 (1,3) - adding whistles to 1's end and 3's head as well, because 00:23:335 - 00:23:935 - 00:24:535 - are really similar beats, right? whistle at 00:24:535 - if you think it's too much
00:25:435 (4) - a whistle is supposed to be there as you used one for 00:49:435 (4) -
the following are all the same as above. plz make these consistent with the things in the first part ↓
00:29:335 (3) - 00:32:335 (3) - 00:47:335 (1,3) -
and for the kiai time, see if you want whistles on 00:12:385 (4,4,4,4) - 00:36:385 (4,2,2,2) - like Hard/Easy diff. I think they would sound good on them

it seems the mapset has been updated rebubbled lol during I was modding, never mind if any of the above doesn't work anymore

must sleep now, too late, plz possibly catch me ingame tommorrow

CDFA wrote:

or you can just update zero__wind's stuff, he can bubble, and des-nyan can rank or uhh

CodeS wrote:

I want this mess to be over already.