BeatofIke wrote:

[Normal] Because Railgun shows no signs of Life or whatsso ever, I will do his changes for now

1. The hitsounds I mentioned on Hard difficulty could also applied here as well. That's up to you though.
2. 00:06:543 (1) - You don't really a finish here since there are no strong sounds here. A soft-whistle is good enough. Done
3. 00:25:743 - 00:49:743: Repeat hitsound pattern. Nothing has changed here since it's just a loop.
4. 00:49:743 (1) - This is where a soft-finish will fit good. Try adding one here.

Done

[Hard]

1. For the hardest difficulty in the mapset, I would recommend using a higher Drain Rate and OD like 6 or 7. Why?I Don't believe this should have high diff setting, as I'm trying to make a friendly user map, moved to 6 both, but I Don't plan on making it higher
   ,
2. 00:00:543 (1) - Remove clap at the end. It's not really needed and it sounds pretty strange imo. Done
3. 00:01:142 (2,3,4,5) - Replace clap with Normal sampleset. It sounds better with the drums/percussions imo. Done
4. 00:01:743 (1) - Add finish at start and remove finish at the end. You can hear a cymbal sound here. Done
5. 00:04:143 (5) - Try adding a new combo here. You can also add a new combo at 00:06:543 (4) as well. Done
6. 00:08:343 (4) - You should continue with the melody sound here by adding a soft-whistle at start and end of this slider. Done
7. 00:10:293 (1) - Remove finish here. You don't hear the loud drum here. Not changed, there's clearly a strong sound here, I don't use only drum for Finish.
8. 00:10:593 (3) - Add a note here (with a finish). You can hear the loud drums here too. Done
9. 00:11:343 (1) - Try adding soft-whistles at the start and end of this slider. Done
10. 00:11:943 (2) - To stay consistent with the normal-whistles, you should add one at the start of this slider. Done
11. 00:20:943 (7) - New combo should start here. Not at 00:21:243. Done
12. 00:25:743 - 00:49:743: Repeat hitsound and combo pattern. Nothing has changed here since it's just a loop. Also, you have an unsnapped inherited (green) sections at 00:30:538. Please re-snap the green timing section to 00:30:543

Done

popner wrote:

Forgot to mention: add 1500 AudioLeadIn in every diffs.

Edit: The source should be game title but not album title. You should add the album title in tags.

BeatofIke wrote:

I re-checked the map once more and found no issues.
Moving this map to Qualified!
EDIT: 8 maps has been reached! Can't quality yet!

1. Halving the BPM (Please increase it to 200. If you want to save time with the readjusting of your map, just halve the SV, so you'll have the same slider speed as before!
2. The way it got ranked (BeatOfIke Bubbled it, the bubble got popped, so he already used his action as BAT and is not allowed to rank it.)
3. Some concers about the quality of the map itself. (See my mod below)

Irreversible wrote:

Hey there!

First of all, take my apologies that we happen to unrank it that late, but technically this mapset isn't even allowed to be ranked.

Disqualified for following reasons:
[list][*]Halving the BPM (Please increase it to 200. If you want to save time with the readjusting of your map, just halve the SV, so you'll have the same slider speed as before! Changed on all diff. Next time people will ask me to overmap the fuck out of it because it's "200 BPM" now, amirite?
[*]The way it got ranked (BeatOfIke Bubbled it, the bubble got popped, so he already used his action as BAT and is not allowed to rank it.)
[*]Some concers about the quality of the map itself. (See my mod below)

[Te-Te-Te]

The hitsounding itself appears really unconsistent to me, and I'd prefer if you had a closer look at the hitsounding pattern yourself. not really.

00:01:134 (2,3,4,5) - This stack appears rather boring to me, the music isn't even the same. Why not putting some more movement in this pattern? Dude, My mapping style is boring, I like to map boring stuff to people who like boring maps., I like Stacks I like the hold on here before the song finally kicks In, is exactly what you say BORING, because I want it to be boring. I Hope that, as the original mapper, at least gets respected.
00:05:035 (3,4,5) - Imo quite bad flow, would be better if it was placed to the bottom side of 4, because straight flow in general generally plays awkward to me. 00:05:785 (5) - I suggest 288 296. Yep, feels better, Done
00:06:535 (1) - I honestly think you can improve this slidershape. If you insist leaving it, at least make improve the bulb in the middle of the slider. "Improve the bulb", what does this even mean?, what?, Improve the slidershape?, HOW?, I like how they play, Me, as the original mapper. that means nothing right?.
Took out this slider to a more basic one.
00:07:885 (1,2,3,4) - These whistles feel spammed, but in the part before, it lacked whistles imo. You should reconsider the hitsounding. Dude, Turn Sample Volume to 0%, CHECK WHERE I'm using Whistle, Not gonna reconsider it because there is nothing wrong, I talked with very experience hitsounders about What I wanted to do with them (complement to the main song along other things), there is nothing wrong with them.
00:10:285 (1,2,3,4) - I honestly don't think this finish spam isn't doing the trick as well, please use the finishes less spammed! .[/color] ok there is one wrong, I'm retarded, there is no sound backing 00:10:285 (1) - . I took that one off.
00:21:235 (2,3) - Again, I wouldn't stack those. Some movement feels more intuitive! Nope.
00:20:185 (5,6,1,2,3) - I can see a Problem in this pattern anyway, 00:20:785 - why didn't you map this beat? You've mapped less important beats so often, why leaving this out? You could reconsider the rhythm and placement here! If you Need suggestions, feel free to catch me ingame. Because you see, the density of Notes here is REAAAALLY HIIIIIIIIGH, compared to, for example 00:44:785 (7) - , it's the same but I added the note, why?, because if I added a note in the first section (the one you want fixed), it would end "o - o o o -" <<<<<< a HUGE clusterfuck, while in the second section, adding still looks clean ("- o - ") 0 = notes - = sliders. so in short words, I didn't added a note because the entire pattern would be annoying to play and looks ugly.
00:23:335 (2,3,4,5,6) - The overall way of the pattern could me made smoother. (00:23:935 (4) - rotate this one a bit, 00:24:535 (6) - same) I fail to see it, sorry, I believe this play good moving the player around the playable area. changed the first sliders a bit.
00:34:135 (3) - Rotate a bit to the left, to increase its Transition. Done
00:49:735 - This should be the end, I strongly suppose? It appears to be really anticlimatic to finish a map like that imo. End it on a strong beat! sigh... Done
00:44:935 (1) - Would look cleaner if you simply copied 00:44:335 (6) - Done
00:47:185 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Nice transition, that's how i'd like it to look in the pattern before.


That's it from my side! If you have any questions, or need help to understand my modding more, please feel free to catch me ingame, to have a talk about it.

Lach wrote:

Step it up QAT, or you're going to make a lot of people mad with this finding a reason to unqualify right before it goes into ranked bullshit. There's a 7 day period, I'm aware, but surely it doesn't take 6 days and a few hours to get off (on?) your arse and look at a map. Two of the things you noted would have been blindingly obvious the moment you downloaded the map. The rest are shit nobody really cares about.

Want to uphold "quality"? Do it in a timely fashion.

Lach wrote:

Step it up QAT, or you're going to make a lot of people mad with this finding a reason to unqualify right before it goes into ranked bullshit. There's a 7 day period, I'm aware, but surely it doesn't take 6 days and a few hours to get off (on?) your arse and look at a map. Two of the things you noted would have been blindingly obvious the moment you downloaded the map. The rest are shit nobody really cares about.

Want to uphold "quality"? Do it in a timely fashion.

Konei wrote:

Lach wrote:

Step it up QAT, or you're going to make a lot of people mad with this finding a reason to unqualify right before it goes into ranked bullshit. There's a 7 day period, I'm aware, but surely it doesn't take 6 days and a few hours to get off (on?) your arse and look at a map. Two of the things you noted would have been blindingly obvious the moment you downloaded the map. The rest are shit nobody really cares about.

Want to uphold "quality"? Do it in a timely fashion.

Uhmm well, you see, it's not 7 days because it sounds more fun, it's 7 days because it IS 7 days, so it's totally legit to take it out of qualified status to fix issues.

And if those things are so obvious, why don't you point them out? Probably because you either didn't see them or the map itself, and that probably is the same reason the QAT did what it did.

Irreversible wrote:

Disqualified for following reasons:

1. The way it got ranked (BeatOfIke Bubbled it, the bubble got popped, so he already used his action as BAT and is not allowed to rank it.)

popner wrote:

The BPM is obviously 100.

Please don't make simple mistakes like this, QAT. This is really unprofessional.

peppy wrote:

fuck off and never map again.