Megurine Luka wrote:

Hi.
/me from Yukari's Queue and "cmn & Luka's Queue" lol

I suppose to mod hard and insane, but since I still get req from Yukari's Queue so I will take a look at all diffs. :3 cmn will still come and mod her parts

[General]

Seems none

[Easy]

00:20:419 (3) - leave from 2? i have no idea what you are trying to tell me lol. nothing looks wrong with that either ._.

[Normal]

Looks all good.

[Hard]

nothing lol

[Insane]

00:06:407 (2) - try http://puu.sh/awf2 no sorry. I want them facing each other
00:51:407 (x) - why stop :< a continuous stream is awesome doesn't fit imo. I only put a stream on the held vocal note.
01:14:311 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1) - I will recommend from up to down. Try select them all and ctrl+J I did not change the actual stream, but i moved the square shape around so that it flows more. I want that stream to go up.


hmm that's all
Very good map :3 Get my star ヽ(*￣o￣)ノ

No_Gu wrote:

request from my queue

[easy]
00:39:820 (2) - avoid overlaping 1 sorry, i like it like that.
00:51:317 00:51:497 useless green lines lol k. forget to delete them
01:02:814 (1) - finish instead of clap huh, interesting, i never thot about that. sounds quite good actually. fixed
01:15:030 (1) - please surrounded 2 well I never wanted to blanket that note. idk why, but i like it better just leaving it like that. so no change

[normal]
fine

[hard]
00:28:772 (5) - move to 00:28:593 ? I actually like this. fixed. Old map, so i guess i thought a little differently back then

[insane]
fine

L_P wrote:

this is a good map, and probably the best map in my que this round.
im giving you 2 star as promised
however this map is a bit too "regular" and you can make it more interesting

INSANE
00:07:485 (1,2) - exchange position to create a jump since you have jumps every four beat (if you like it change 3, and 4 also) There is no reason to add even more pointless jumps. These types of jumps just completely break the flow and don't really make sense. My other jumps actually have context behind them.
00:27:964 (3,4) - not really good rhythm , suggest slider 3 shorten by half, 4 moves to previous white tick I don't see why it's not good rhythm, but I did change it a bit to match previous similar patterns. This rhythm is the same as 00:27:605 (1,2,3) - and as 00:10:359 (1,2,3,1,2,3,4,5). The context of these two patterns are quite similar as well.
00:52:575 (5) - shouldnt be a slider here, it breaks the rhythmic structure. should be a note, then after that you can adjust something? I don't see a problem with this. If you mean by breaking "rhythmic structure" as in this slider starts on a red tick, then it doesn't break any sort of structure. Having sliders always starting on white ticks makes songs boring. It also flows perfectly fine imo. I've played it many times.
01:16:287 (6) - why not stack with slider1 because i didn't want to? I like it better like this to be honest. I did on purpose.
01:23:473 (5) - ctrl + R? This makes the flow really weird. You have to move your cursor back to hit this note which is weird, and the player also must make another diagonal jump from this note to then next one, which is weird. It flows better the way it is now.

Hard
00:07:305 (4,1,2,3,4) - stack note 4 and note 1, that note 4 in the picture is purple combo's WIth the way you suggest I have this random jump from combo 4 to the next new combo. Also, the stacks look nice to me.http://img193.imageshack.us/img193/3189/1213131.jpg
i really think this pattern is better...
00:28:682 (4,5,6,1) - spacing this is intentional.
00:47:545 (6) - what a slider, maybe can blanket next note I have no idea what you mean. THis note doesn't blanket anything to begin with. ?_?

normal
00:26:706 (7) - a slider? no sorry, this will mess up the triangle shape. I think it's fine anyways.

thats all, enjoy my second star after kudos ; )

cmn_891127 wrote:

Hi, winber1~
/me from cmn & Luka's Queue

It seems like the song is difficult to make a Easy and Normal, since most of the voices are in the red line, but you really done well. All suggestion~ I do agree that some of my patterns could have been better mapped for beginners to read, as you suggested below.

Easy

00:22:934 (1,2) - change to 00:22:754 (6,1,2,3), like sure.
[attachment=1:6333e]1.png[/attachment:6333e]
00:50:419 (1) - change to a 1/2 slider from 00:50:239 no sorry
01:24:012 (2) - change to a 1/2 slider from 01:23:832 ok sure
00:52:754 (2,3) - remove (2), and add a reverse doesn't reallymake sense

Normal

00:27:245 (?) - add a 1/1 slider i don't see the point in adding this if I'm following the vocals. The space in between is fine,.
00:35:869 (2,3,4) - change to 00:36:048 (2,3),like I did not change this pattern they way you asked. in fact I added a slider. I think that place is fine. But i changed something because of this suggestion ( since it made me rethink something) so that's why its blue.
[attachment=0:6333e]2.png[/attachment:6333e]
01:04:251 (1) - this spinner does not fit here. fits fine imo

Good luck~

Star Stream wrote:

hi~
from my queue

Easy
01:06:048 (4) - 2grid down? oh. my spacing seems to be off. fixed

Insane
00:22:754 (5,6) - like this? http://puu.sh/aCuJ no sorry, the extra doesn't fit imo.
00:39:820 ~ 00:40:539 - stream? a stream does not fit imo. nothing in the music provokes one

sorry, can't find more.. no problems :3

nich95 wrote:

hi, winber1

from my modding queue

Black = My instructions
Purple = In my opinion

[General]
no problem~

[Easy]
00:08:922 (3) - add new combo no sorry
00:11:437 (5) - move to x:188 y:340, would be better. this is more of a opinionated suggestion; I tend to like having notes like this. it just looks good to me. so no change.
00:20:419 (3) - add new combo no sorry
00:15:748 (4) - try move is centarl likely would be better. (May need to move (2,3) too.) to be honest, i didn't really like putting combo 4 in the center, so ileft it like that. This was something intentional. Things like this I am very aware if I want to put things in the center or not. This particular case I did not.
00:21:497 (4,5) - This is too hard for easy diff it's fine. If the first time they fail, they will easly understand what they did wrong. It follows the music very well and the notes are stacked. It should not be a problem
00:37:664 (5) - add new combo no sory
01:07:485 (2,3) - too hard same same as above

[Normal]
00:22:395 (5) - maybe made​​ slider is curve better. this is intentional
00:38:922 (3) - maybe add new combo?no sorry
00:51:317 and 00:51:497 - remove green line (There isn't advantage to using it.)ok
00:51:856 (2) - maybe move end from slider to x:352 y:336k
00:54:910 (5) - ^ nah, i didn't want he slider to look straight at the next note

[Hard]
HP +1 k
AR -1 i decided to fix this cuz i deicded to decrease the AR on insane
00:47:545 (6) - maybe add new combo? no sorry

[Insane]
AR -1 I know people will start complaining about "omg AR 9" on a 161 bpm map. to be honest, I feel it fits really well and it is easy to read. AR 8 is harder to read for me, but i'll just change it for now to remove later complaints about it
00:25:090 (5) - maybe add new combo? no sorry
00:48:263 (6) - ^^

That's all, nice map and good song.
I'll give +star.

good luck.

SuperMICrophone wrote:

Lol, sorry I took so long, my Internet blewup for a day. :3

Queue~

---

[Easy]

For the Easy map, I feel it's a bit too difficult for it's level name. I don't recommend you use off-beats regularly on the Easy map. Look at [1:07:485] (2,3). Those two hitcircles are way too close rhythmically for an Easy map. That would go in Normal. So just for this map, all I have to say is lower difficulty note-wise. a little tougher than the average Easy, but still not that hard.

[Normal]

Again, I feel like it's a bit hard for a normal map, but eveyrthing else was done very well. yes, a little tougher than usual I will admit, but playable by a beginner still.

[Hard]

With this map, I'm not sure about the beat spacing. For me it makes the map really confusing. I'll list the parts with the most issues.

[0:15:928] (1-5) You see, hitcircle 1 should be closer to the sliuder and hitcircles 2-3 should be MUCH FARTHER apart. It just makes it really confusing.
[0:19:341] (1-3) Pretty much same deal here. These hitcircles need to be further apart. Also remove combo.
[0:25:090] (1-3) ^, Remove combo. fixed none of the above. All intentional and all makes sense, at least to more experienced players.

[Insane]

After playing this map, I see that the hitcircles that are distance spacing-wise off are really style. IMO, it makes the map confusing, but for the previous notes if you don't move the notes at least remove combos. to more experienced players this is very readable and not that hard of a map. The notes are quite clear imo, and im not just saying this cuz i mapped this song.

[0:40:539] (1-4) Mean pattern. Maybe straighten it out...? no sorry

---

Oh god, please don't say my Mod sucks. Everything seemed fine, that's all. D: Sorry I didn't change anything. Thanks for your efforts tho!

-SMIC

wcx19911123 wrote:

from my queue

[General]
I think you need to add some tags
#3 kiai time in Easy diff end at 01:24:012 - , make kiai time all the same plz oops, i deleted this timing section by accident lol
lead-in=0 plz , I don't think this map need this lol. i added lead-in time cuz im an impatient noob, because this way I am able to skip the beginning (if you make lead-in time 0, i need to wait like 3 seconds for the song to start and I don't like waiting xD)
00:06:148 - unsnapped timing section
01:26:418 - ^ ok fixed both

[Easy]
00:14:670 (1,2,3,4) - I feel this is kinda noisy , remove some claps or volume down a bit plz i removed clap from combo 2
00:21:497 (4,5) - I don't think newbies can read this , the AR is low , it is hard to know the rhyme of the stack. if you want to keep this rhyme , I suggest repeat 00:20:419 (3) - and delete 00:21:497 (4) - i'm leaving it as is. to be honest i think it's fine
01:01:557 (2,3) - line up ? this now looks not good imo this is a matter of opinion, i like it like this some reason ._.
01:07:485 (2,3) - this is hard to read or play imo , I suggest 01:06:407 (1) - repeat at 01:06:946 - end at 01:07:485 - and then delete 01:07:485 (2) - as stated above, i feel this stack is actual quite easy to read. I may end up removing other stacked 1/1 tick notes cuz those may be confusing.
01:17:904 (1,2) - line up ? i moved combo 2 a tiny bit to the right if thats wat you mean

[Normal]
AR-1/2 plz , this is too high as a Normal diff .. this is weird. I know i didn't put AR on 6. fixed. The AR was definitely meant to be on AR 5. weird.. thanks for catching that
nothing found..

[Hard]
00:17:006 (4,5) - OMG , this is very confusing.. with the anti-jump of 00:15:928 (1,2,3) - , 00:17:185 (5) - this note is easily read as at 00:17:545 - .. huh... i'd like to get a little more input on this before changing it.
00:48:982 (1,2) - this jump is a bit too far imo , whit the huge jump , someone may click 00:49:880 (1) - too early the player should be able to read this on the next attempt imo if they are skilled enough to play this map :/
00:51:497 (2) - I suggest not to slow down this slider with using timing section , but change its shape like this http://puu.sh/aRFM . or it is too hard to know this is a slow-down slider I don't really want to make a squiggly slider here (to me it looks ugly). there's also an extra tick to signify a timing change, but it may not help as much as i would think
01:22:755 (1) - move to 01:22:575 - and repeat , or it is too hard to know when it start after the spinner , someone may click at 01:22:575 - as they think this slider is following drums here ok

[Insane]
HD+1/2 , don't you think it is too low for such a crazy diff? the reason why it's so low is cuz i've realized that the hp drain is being really annoying if I make it any higher. to me this HD seems to work best/
I think this diff is too hard for this song.. kinda overmapped
00:26:706 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - this jumps are too huge.. and I don't think here needs some jumps , song is soft at this time
00:40:539 (1,2,3,4) - this is very confusing.. I strongly suggest to change pattern here. anyway , if want to keep this , add newcombo on 00:40:898 (3) - at least
00:49:880 (1,2,3,4) - jump too huge..orz
00:51:407 - add note here and make the notes in a stream , sound better to me
sorry nothing changed above. Yes i know it is a litter overmapped, but i also find it quite fun. pretty good difficulty fit for me, but obviously thats just me and it does not apply to other people
I think Insane diff is overmapped.. beside this , it is awesome map
good luck

merchat7 wrote:

As requested

[General]

- Consider adding opening to tags since this is the opening to the anime.
- Please include video considering there is a ranked map with video and you can't add video to already ranked map (while you can always play without video in a ranked map). asdfasdfa. If someone wants to supply me one then I would be happy to apply it. Frankly, I don't really know this anime at all and I don't have anything right now to record the opening.
- Change the audio lead in for Taiko Oni from 993 to 1000. Just for cleanliness. k
- And no BG for taiko? Maybe you forgot to full submit? Either way, please full submit if there is a taiko BG for the taiko. If not please include one. ok thats weird. Perhaps something went wrong with the ful lsubmit idk, fixed

[Easy]

- Quite a high star rating.

00:11:437 (5) - Perhaps remove this note, but I guess you did since it would be boring to just play 1/1 sldiers here. fine imo. yes it makes it more fun, but it sounds nice to me, since it's the fourth measure after the first one and this song is in 4/4. It just kinda signifies a new phrase, or a new sections, or something.
00:14:670 (1,2,3,4) - I'm more fond of a repeating slider here starting on (1), repeat on (2) and end at (3) and just removing (4) to make it more clear that a spinner is coming. I would also make the spinner start where (4) was. This pattern feel more fitting for a Norma than an Easy. i find four notes to have more of an impact to this song at this particular part
00:21:497 (4) - I strongly discouraging doing 1/2 stack like this on Easy since they are not nice to play with this approach rate. Since just removing the note will make this play weird, I suggesting changing the beat rhythm to like this http://puu.sh/beb3 (making 3 end on the white tick, moving 5 to the white tick). Sound good and make this part more simple. Ideas for placement http://puu.sh/bebl. ok you guys keep complaining about this, so I decided to change it, tho not the way you asked. You can check the diff for more details
00:46:287 (1) - The clap on the red tick (repeat) sound really weird to me, I would just remove it. Since it sound a little empty, perhaps a lowered volume finish would be good. If you remove the clap, also remove from (2) on the first repeat to keep the claps consistent. fixed. replaced the clap with a whistle, and removed next clap
00:47:724 (2) - Don't feel this kick slider is intuitive considering slider speed, length and bpm of song, I would do a hit circle > repeating slider (one repeat) instead. seems fine imo. I guess this still counts as a kick slider, tho I never thot about this being one. The player would definitely realized something about the next note tho and that it is spaced quite close to the end of this slider and I would suppose that it would become pretty intuitive that this slider was repeating.
00:56:347 (2) - A little nazi here, but this overlap with (1) just a bit, adjust so they don't? This doesn't look intentional compare to the other overlaps. lol i realized this a long time ago, but i never changed it ._.
01:07:485 (2) - Same comment about this 1/2 stack. I also find the rhythm here a little weird in general. How about this http://puu.sh/bedB (it's harder. but considering the overall difficulty of this diff, fits perfectly imo). Ideas for placement http://puu.sh/bedO. yes, many peoiple complained about this, so i decided to change it, but not the way you suggested.
01:22:933 (1,2) - You could just delete (2) and add a repeat to (1) no sorry, i like it the way it is.

Feel a bit like a Normal due to note density, but I guess rhythm is easy enough to follow. really? I'd like to say the opposite. THe amount of notes is like an Easy, but the rhythm is quite hard for an easy. There are a lot of red ticks. If I put all these notes on white ticks, the note density would be fine imo, but it wouldn't sound as nice imo.

[Normal]

00:13:233 (3) - Kinda feel like saying curve this slider, so how about copying 00:11:078 (4), Ctrl+H and R it and fix spacing? copy pasting and moving it around is too much effort, I just added an extra node lol >_>. but sure, I don't mind.
00:18:443 (2) - This slider feel offbeat to me, doesn't really feel like it's following anything although I guess you could argue it follow the ticks sound. This instead for rhythm? http://puu.sh/begk and placement http://puu.sh/begq.it's fine imo. this slider follows the vocals, so i'm not sure what you are talking about. the only part that doesn't really follow anything is 00:19:161, but that repeat is there for readability issues and it looks nicer imo.
00:22:395 (5) - Really don't think the red point on this slider looks good. lol matter of opinion, but i'm just gonna keep it.
00:26:527 (6,7) - I think a short slider fits better with the vocal and to give it more of an "end" feel since you use stack like this at the start of patterns so I feel like there is going to be more notes. to be honest, i like these notes. fits better imo.
00:45:389 (1,2,3) - Thought this was a stream :S Space out perhaps? Don't really feel like this part should be stack. we all randomly misread easy songs with slow approach rates. Stacks seem fine. Fits the music imo.
00:47:365 (2) - Highly recommend to change, I was surprise by the repeat and nothing in the map/music really say there is going to be another repeat. I suggesting repeating slider > hit circle. you might be speaking of the incorrect spot, because this is a hitcircle, not a slider lol. perhaps you are talking about combo 4? in which it's the final notein that phrase and is readable imo.
00:52:869 (3) - Remove, I'm sure this note was put here by accident. LOL, god i'm making random mistakes everywhere. iadsfanlgas

Not too fond of the 1/2 double stacks, but I guess it's fine.

[Hard]

00:48:982 (1,2) - Quite a big jump for Hard, reduce a bit perhaps. idk, i like it actually. All of these difficulties are a little tougher than the average diff I guess due to the insane, but it's a good diff spread imo.
00:52:844 (5) - ??? Not stack properly? LOL, god damit. i keep adding random notes in places. idk what is happening... I had some random data loss and computer problems lately anyways. well, fixed.

Really nice diff.

[Insane]

*read previous mod post/replies* I agree that ar 9 fits much better until I saw these stream jumps (like 00:11:078 (1,2,3,4), this is when I'm thankful it's ar 8. Well I guess it's your choice, if you ever feel like doing ar 9 again, I would prefer if you remove these stream jumps or do something else if possible, really hard to play for me.

00:17:006 (4,5) - I dislike how this goes from anit jump then jump then stream, you have barely any time to react. I guess it'd feel better if you make the jump between these two a little smaller so you have more time to react? either you will definitely realize this on the second attempt, or it will be obvious that the approach circles are much closer to together. I think this will apply to basically any insane player. I feel it fits the music well so i will keep it
00:26:706 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - What's the reason for this big jump here? Would be nicer for more sliders (to fits with how the singer is holding a note here). I do not know what I was thinking like 5 months ago, but this plays well to me some reason and it makes it fun for me, tho thats just my personal opinion. Best explanation i have is that it's just a jumpy (ish) map
00:36:946 (1,2,3,4) - Similar comment here about the jump.Weird to have a big jump on the hit circles that are following soft sounds in the background. similar to above. i guess my best answer is that it's how i mapped. this diff has a lot of jumps and spacing changes.
00:40:718 (2,3) - This pattern doesn't fit because of the reduce spacing here. The music doesn't feel like the spacing is reduced here. The most accented note here is (3) and not (2) or (4) so if you can come with a pattern where the jump is on (3) and (1) in the next combo, would be much better. above. jumpy map i guess
00:49:880 (1,2,3,4) - 2.5x plays better for me. Jump feel just a little too big. doesn't look as nice to me if I scale it down a bit. certain things I wanted lined up aren't lined up. to be honest, i don't feel .16x will even make that much of a difference. I play these fine. If you can play 2.5x spacing fine, I don't think 2.66x should be any harder. tho I guess you personal opinion kinda just did disproe that statement. basically, i still feel that it's fine
01:13:593 (1,2,3,4) - Accent is on (1) and (3), but jump is on all the note so this felt a little weird. Try to rework it perhaps. You could try stacking (2) with (1) and (4) with (3), but then playing the next stream feel really weird. to be honest i don't see how this affects gameplay. From all the past stuff I've been doing with this map, I would've realized this map is definitely not even following the vocals anymore, it's just gonna have some drum like rhythm and I would follow every half measure or quarter note or so unless something dramatic happens.
01:20:060 (1,2) - I think the clap hitsounds sound a bit weird on these slider. sure. i just removed them. I put them there it felt a little empty to not be able to really hear the hitsounds, but i guess it's okj
01:23:473 (5,1) - The transition from playing a 1.2x slider to 0.5x is really bad. I suggestion making the slider speed for (5) 1.0x instead and just use 0.75x for (1). no sorry. This is legitimately not me being lazy. I like it, and it was something that suddenly occured to me while mapping this months ago. Some reason i really liked how it played, but i may end up changing it if it truly becomes a problem,. which, however, I do not think it will become.

Well I guess it's overmapped/overjumpy, but pretty fun and plays pretty well.

Think your Hard/Insane is better than Easy/Normal. No real issues really so starred.

Good luck!