I'd like to think most of them should be up for consideration - however, given that the concept of KD was somewhat exploitable, I feel like maps whose KD totals were contributed largely by small amounts of individuals shouldn't be given the opportunity to get to loved status (primary example: Another Lie's Beethoven Influenza, which only got loved because Another Lie KD farmed and literally dumped 100 of their stars into it). It's not "loved" if it doesn't really have support.Weber wrote:
I'd like to hear about the maps which people raised to the previous 100kds requirement months ago before the system was "officially" put on hiatus that still haven't been added to Loved.
Otherwise this sounds great.
Xeo: I appreciate the compliment about my map, hahaha. That being said, 30 favorites might be a little high; however, but I don't think it's an unreasonable total simply on the concept of loved maps now: if the community really enjoys a particular map and it's well done/understandable, it'll likely get noticed. It's pretty easy to tell the difference between a map that is forcefully nominated as a result of recommendation and nothing, versus telling the difference from something that is nominated because it is truly different, and stands out for some reason.
I definitely understand the concerns about loved being a "ranked v2", and I'll certainly be keeping that in mind as well.