[ General ]
- How about changing diff name here to something that isn't the translation of the title. Something like Drowning Emotions would be cool
- You could use a better sample for the hitwhistle, use this one that I used in my own map for this song https://celerih.s-ul.eu/meCPPmUU
- Also there's an unused bg in the song folder, or that the hard diff doesn't have it set for some reason, might want to fix that
- 01:26:408 - Timing point here is late, your map needs to be perfectly timed, move it to 01:26:360 -
[ Normal ]
- 00:08:168 (5) - NC here, combo gets a bit long afterwards
- 00:38:238 (4) - To make the pattern look cleaner move this up and reduce the curve of the slider
- 00:43:042 (2) - To follow the piano better move this to start on 00:42:741 - and have it end at the same place as it did before. This way both piano and vocals are followed better
- 01:07:958 - Would add a circle here since the all the other vocals in the kiai are followed except for this one
- But I'd still make some more 1/1 gaps in this, rhythm is dense and should be made easier. It is lowest diff after all
- 01:11:858 (7) - make into 2 circles at the start and end of the slider and reduce density
- 01:07:058 (3) - Same thing as above, could even make 01:07:658 - a 1/2 slider from here to cover vocals and circle on 01:07:058 - instead of slider
- Nice normal, good job
[ Jennglebell's Hard ]
- 00:08:168 (1,2) - Would reduce distance here in favor of higher distance for 00:08:778 (2,3) - since there's much stronger piano there
- 00:24:769 (4,1,2) - Once again kinda backwards emphasis, 1 should get more spacing that 2 here
- 00:27:141 (4) - Note here is overmapped, there's no sound to support it as there is a break in both piano and vocals
- 00:42:741 (2,3,4) - Rhythm here could be improved upon since going for faint vocals over strong piano is confusing when playing. See box below for a suggestion
- 00:59:274 (2,3,4) - Overmapped note on 00:59:840 (3) - makes rhythm here improvable, mostly making a 1/1 slider on 00:59:543 - . See box below
- 01:02:852 (1) - Both vocals and piano hit on 01:03:155 - so shorten this by 1/4. It's a shame that the slider shape will have to be changed since it's really nice but the song just doesn't support it :/
- 01:08:258 (1) - Another case of a slider being 1/4 too long. If the vocals aren't being extended and just last 1/2, extended sliders won't fit
- Main problem here is rhythm and overmapping imo. Apart from that I really like how this map looks and the fun use of slider movement
[ Deep Sea Girl ]
- 00:09:084 (3) - Such strong piano on a slider reverse isn't the best. circle + 1/2 slider would be a better rhythm here
- 00:22:615 (1) - The very straight and "sharp" shape of the slider here clashes with the rest of the sliders as of yet, and there aren't any distinct sounds that really justify it
- 00:28:040 (2) - 00:37:639 (2) - Once again the reverses here could be make into something more appropriate, like 1/2 slider + circle
- 00:42:741 (2,3) - Here a reverse would actually work wonderfully, since you'd get the reverse on a pretty weak sound on 00:43:042 - instead of a clickable slider head. Something more passive would be better for a faint sound like this
- 01:01:367 (3,4,5,6,7) - A more clean progression of spacing would fit well into other patterns you did on 00:12:987 (4,1,2,3,4) - and 01:25:451 (2,3,1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1) -
- 01:26:089 (1,1) - Would use a slider here, the random change in timing (btw fix timing I mentionned it earlier) would easily catch players off guard
- That's all I'll touch on, nice diff overall
Good luck with the set!