1. Belief (3.1 stars, 37 notes)
2. Hard (1.97 stars, 27 notes)
3. Normal (1.17 stars, 22 notes)

Yuuki Konno wrote:

Normal

objective

00:00:914 (1) - Questionable Starting point, the sound seems to start 1/4 earlier. I could see this being simplification for lower ranks, but it seems like it would just confuse them. yea wel.. its the only starting point that, otherwise requires 1/16 slider and or move it back and have odd rhythm
00:23:208 (1) - Questionable Ending Point building of intensity through rhythm, ends on the 2nd note of the violin

subjective

00:04:550 (5) - I might move this a hair over for visuals, just preference. distance snmap
00:30:777 (1) - I might make the end of this spinner have no sound for a clean ending. 5% is lowest u can go

Hard

objective

00:00:914 (1) - Starting time is questionable. yea wel.. its the only starting point that, otherwise requires 1/16 slider and or move it back and have odd rhythm
00:04:095 (5,1) - Distance is larger than the ones before it by a noticeable amount. its a jump
00:26:427 (2,1) - This distance should be larger. Not too much, I agree with the concept of it being smaller than the others, but still it looks like another 1/4 jump not the 1/2 beat jump it is. there isnt a 1/4 jump but meh, even if they get the rhythm slightly wrong between 1/3 and 1/2, thers slider leniency

subjective

00:30:777 (1) - 00:30:777 (1) - I might make the end of this spinner have no sound for a clean ending. 5% is lowest u can go

Belief
Objective:
00:04:095 (5,1) - Too large of a distance compared to previous ones. reduced a bit
00:26:427 (1,1) - This seems too similar to this 00:14:827 (3,1) - but it has an immensely different timing. changed second a bit
Subjective:
00:30:777 (1) - I might make the end of this spinner have no sound for a clean ending. 5% is lowest u can go

Nostalgic wrote:

o/ m4m just bought nier and yet my ps4 broke down ytd somehow lol

belief

1. 00:01:368 (2,3) - blanket? nah
2. 00:25:761 (1,2,3) - didn't realize they were snapped 1/6 when sightread... it should be fine bcz sv doesnt change inbetween

hard

1. 00:01:368 (2) - reduce spacing cuz it's a rather weak sound imo did something different

normal

1. 00:01:823 (2,3) - fix spacing theres nothing to fix, its ds'd, sure stacking moves it down a bit but meh
2. 00:04:550 (5) - According to the ranking rubric, time-distance equality should be used. Interestingly, the bpm change makes it no longer a constant time-distance snap and this applies to all the following notes and sliders. idk if u need to fix all of them manually... changed everything below 1/1, 1/1 is large enough rhythm spacing at this bpm that it really shouldnt make that much a difference in reading

GL

Celektus wrote:

very simple and short map so sorry if I pulled suggestions out of my A** and might got a bit pandering.

[ Normal]

1. Not really an issue per se, but mixing stacks for both 1/1 and 1/2 can be confusing. Tho you used it early on and consistently so you might just wanna make everything spaced out for consistency. spaced out the first, left second to make it easier
2. You could blanket the slider end better by using a placebo circle like this maybe. Also the fist curve could be rounder like the other curves in the slider. ya
3. I would rather use a soft-hitfinish at the slider end 00:30:627 - since in most skins the normal finish also has added hit... and soft just fits more imo. tru

[ Hard]

1. just as a little suggestion, I would add another read anchor at the beginning of this slider to emphasize the piano glissando a bit more 00:19:499 (1) - this could be done with other sliders, but it's fine either way. makes it look odd so no
2. similar tips as in the normal 00:27:027 (1) - also you might wannna overlap this shape again over itself to remove some anchors, If you don't know what I mean here's an example. I personally think the red ones specifically sometimes can take away smoothness and the fist curve since it is connected to a red anchor is bezier so adding 2 grey anchors there might be better to make it rounder. All of this is still only aesthetic choice ofc on purpose tbh

[ Belief]

1. I think a more gradual transition from the lower diff to this CS might be good. going from CS4 to CS7 is a bit much in terms of spread theme normal or hard player case be expected to play CS5 or even 6 at this level since the maps is REALLY short. It would add a interesting idea to the whole set I think. hmmm... maybe, cs 5 seems reasonable, spread would also be 3,5,7 so ye
2. I don't really care about the aesthetic of this overlap, but I think it could have some more logic behind it 00:14:827 (3,1) - like perfectly overlapping red anchors, parallele lines or whatever. made it so angle on slider edge

gl with the set~

-Aerith- wrote:

Hello ~ hitsound mod as your request from my queue :3

just going to mod the hardest since this is just hitsound ~

Belief

-00:23:839 and -00:24:471 and -00:25:116 you can remove whistle and add sampleset drum if you want :3

this is the shortest mod i have done lol , anyway Good luck ~

its kinda funny that my name is kinda same like you lol im Aerith you're Aeril XD

pacsu wrote:

hi m4m

00:00:004 - place the offset here , not after an object sur

belief
00:01:368 (2,3) - make a blanket here https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8688446 na
00:26:877 - put a circle here or make the slider longer , because the sound is long no sound there

hard
same 00:26:877 - n

normal
maybe place 00:21:333 (4) - in blanket whis 00:19:499 (3) - blanketed something else

99% sure my mod is useless
sorry

walter85 wrote:

Hi! From my queue

Map is already short and good, so I won't be writing much and they'll be almost all aesthetic things

[Normal]
00:04:095 (4,5) - check ds and also fix triangle ds like that cuz changes bpm, also fixed
00:12:058 (3) - It's kinda bad to see that this doesn't follow correctly the curve of 00:10:183 (2) -. You could move these 00:08:308 (1,2) - to the left to fix it while keeping ds the same i think its fine? large space in time and its barely off the curve
00:19:499 (3) - Personally i don't like using these shapes for shorter sliders but that's up to you i like it
00:27:027 (1) - How about making the end a bit more circular? Like this i prefer this

[Hard]
00:05:502 (2) - Maybe make it follow the slider's curvature? changed slider
00:19:499 (1,2) - I'd make them symmetrical like these 00:15:750 (1,2) -. Also, if you rotate (2) by 5-6° it'll look better nah, i prefer this because the 2nd has a different trill than the first

[Belief]
00:01:823 (3) - Imo it'll look better if you rotate it 10° anti-clockwise and you blanket it to 00:01:368 (2) - nah
00:13:904 (2) - Wrongly snapped, just make it a circle if you don't wanna move it 1/12 earlier o
00:15:811 (1) - Check your snapping moved to 1/12
00:21:391 (2) - These S shapes can be made much better if you enable the grid and draw it symmetrically, then you can scale and rotate it as you want nah i wanted it asymmetrical
00:27:027 (1) - Make the start more curved and the end more circular, like this prefer mine

That's all! Good luck!

Kisses wrote:

Normal

1. 00:19:499 (3) - big CS and small slider body makes the wave a bit ugly imo why does noone like that wave slider ;-; changed
2. 00:23:208 (1) - Finish isn't necessary, there isn't a sound here which differs much from the other objects with just whistles. tru
3. Settings could do with looking over to me, especially the AR. The AR seems too much looking at the really low object density tied with the bpm changed ar and od for all diffs

Hard

1. 00:23:208 (1) - same as normal k
2. 00:01:368 (2,3) - in terms of flow it's a bit weird having such a dramatic dip in spacing between 2 and 3 made same spacing
3. settings, same as normal

belief

1. 00:00:800 (1,2,3) - https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8705988 ? no
2. 00:14:827 (3,1) - how about muting the end of 00:14:827 (3) and using this rhythm https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8706008 (ignore object placements). Having a double at 00:15:750 would fit nicely with the rest of the map such as 00:17:625 (1,2,1,2,1,2) true, changed
3. 00:23:208 (1) - same as normal

[]
I feel like AR and OD should be reduced across all diffs, it does feel kinda of forced for the song and map of this sort. Since the timing of these objects requires you to be so precise the high settings, OD in this case, can cause it to be rather frustrating especially as most ppl are going to be playing this with DT and HR and well, you know how it goes

Naotoshi wrote:

mrm

[general]
add a silenced sliderslide for the love of god k
or reduce the volume
or something
it sticks out way too much

also metadata (http://www.square-enix.co.jp/music/sem/page/nier/automata/) 3rd CD Track 1
[belief]
00:25:761 (1,2,3) - this is a giant diffspike. i suggest you do a progression of difficulty starting at 00:23:208 (1) - something like repeat slider, slider+circle, circle circle circle, slider slider slider cuz atm the 3 sliders just pops out of nowhere and kills you yea, also slightly reduced spacing there
also making 00:26:427 (1) - 2 sliders would be kinda nice i like thuis
[hard]
00:25:761 (1,2,1) - ncing should be in groups of 3 1/4 gaps here too, as should patterning
and same thing about the last slider at 00:26:427 (2) - , 2 clicks is cute
[normal]
00:12:058 (3,4) - with a time gap this big its better not to use normal DS cuz the circle doesnt appear, so the noob player won't move over and suddenly it appears and they panic about this giant jump they have to do. you can use a smaller but still noticeable ds or stack to avoid this issue

ur ncing at the end needs to be consistent with other diffs, nc on the 3 1/4 gaps plz k

[]
you can call me back after

Mir wrote:

Do you need someone to qualify?

Also, can you lower the volume overall by about 10%? It sounds a bit loud for me x.x