*This post was written in black text*
wait...Kisses wrote:
*This post was written in black text*
He wasn't involved in your set though. Doesn't make too much sense to search someone's name on a map only to find out they aren't involved in the set. If everyone did this then searching for things in your ingame library you would pull up a plethora of mapsets that many people wouldn't have any anything to do with. Tags aren't a way of showing gratitude/credit, but a way to help search for mappers that were involved in said mapsets (at least I'm 98% sure lol)Igor Sprite wrote:
iyasine helped alacat to rank your mapset and now is helping me indirectly since i got bpm, offset, bg, audio, artist and title why not all the tags?
this solve the problem with lopkyy in tagsKisses wrote:
but a way to help search for mappers that were involved in said mapsets (at least I'm 98% sure lol)
nardo *-*Nardoxyribonucleic wrote:
Disqualified so you can remove any irrelevant tags. Wafu also pointed out issues regarding general metadata so you need to address them as well.
Sorry if that sounded too harsh, but "irrelevant" is actually the most accurate word to describe that. They are not relevant to this concrete mapset. Irrelevant is not an insult, I'm not using it as: "You're irrelevant, you have no right to say your opinion about this.", I'm using it as: "These people did not directly contribute to the mapset by mapping/making storyboard for it (i.e. they are not relevant to its content), so they shouldn't be credited for a contribution in the map." They may have affected how the metadata/map looks now, but that is in no way different from simple modding. Please, don't alter meanings of words to make it sound like I despise these people.Igor Sprite wrote:
"irrelevant people" uh, you really don't choose your words right?. fixed artist and bye iyasine. i will keep the lopkyy , he is relevant to me and my mapsetWafu wrote:
I think this needs to be disqualified for putting irrelevant people into metadata (and it seems like without consent).
What problem does it solve? Giving you a general advice (essentially a mod) doesn't mean what Kisses said.Igor Sprite wrote:
this solve the problem with lopkyy in tagsKisses wrote:
but a way to help search for mappers that were involved in said mapsets (at least I'm 98% sure lol)
D:davidminh0111 wrote:
See? >√<.
1st time disqualifing a map
well you won't be able to get it re-qualified then I'm afraidIgor Sprite wrote:
D:davidminh0111 wrote:
See? >√<.
1st time disqualifing a map
i will not remove lopkyy from tags. that is all
removed produções from tags for be irrelevantKisses wrote:
well you won't be able to get it re-qualified then I'm afraid
Igor Sprite wrote:
this solve the problem with lopkyy in tagsKisses wrote:
but a way to help search for mappers that were involved in said mapsets (at least I'm 98% sure lol)
as kisses said tags is for help search and if you write lopkyy, you will find 5 maps that lopkyy helped meWafu wrote:
What problem does it solve? Giving you a general advice (essentially a mod) doesn't mean what Kisses said.
As I said "Giving you a general advice (essentially a mod) doesn't mean what Kisses said". It's hard to believe that they made something of the 3 things Kisses mentioned, there's no evidence on that.Igor Sprite wrote:
as kisses said tags is for help search and if you write lopkyy, you will find 5 maps that lopkyy helped me and writing igor sprite you will find many others without lopkyy in tags
i don't know if is required put collab when a mapper that helped you making a diff does not wantKisses wrote:
3) were part of a collab
Igor Sprite wrote:
i don't know if is required put collab when a mapper that helped you making a diff does not want
if yes, please show me and i will remove lopkyy from tags
If guest mapper (collab mappers are also guests) doesn't give a consent to put their name in tags, then agreeing with making the collab from their side would make no sense, if RC clearly says they must be credited.Ranking Criteria wrote:
The information of multiple mapset contributors must be provided in the mapset, if there is any guest mapper. This might be in the creator's words, via a storyboard or via naming the guest difficulties appropriately. You only need to provide information of guest mapper and corresponding guest part. Guest mappers must be added to the tags of a mapset. This helps others to know if the map uploader is the main contributor of the mapset and who else contributed to the given mapset.
Wafu wrote:
Igor Sprite wrote:
i don't know if is required put collab when a mapper that helped you making a diff does not want
if yes, please show me and i will remove lopkyy from tagsi will give his correct credit just waitRanking Criteria wrote:
The information of multiple mapset contributors must be provided in the mapset, if there is any guest mapper. This might be in the creator's words, via a storyboard or via naming the guest difficulties appropriately. You only need to provide information of guest mapper and corresponding guest part. Guest mappers must be added to the tags of a mapset. This helps others to know if the map uploader is the main contributor of the mapset and who else contributed to the given mapset.
Also, gave the map a quick glance. Looks relatively okay, could use some improvement, but the only thing I really want to mention is 01:35:950 (308) - in Muzukashii not having a finish here. It's inconsistent with the exact same part, and with other difficulties. fixed
Additionally, the background image doesn't seem related to the song or band in any way. The standards are changing, you can't just copy everything from the older map and hope it's correct. It would be nice if you would find some Silent Siren related image instead. The mp3 could be better too, I don't understand why to go for the lowest quality allowed (if you want help with that without having to change the offset, PM me on forums let's map a eletronic song, ANIME GIRL.jpg. see this map she ins't waking up D: .oh another "nonsense" BG
@Wafu I think the BG has taken from https://osu.ppy.sh/s/122444 and I think it's good to go, no need to fix anything elseWafu wrote:
Additionally, the background image doesn't seem related to the song or band in any way. The standards are changing, you can't just copy everything from the older map and hope it's correct. It would be nice if you would find some Silent Siren related image instead. The mp3 could be better too, I don't understand why to go for the lowest quality allowed (if you want help with that without having to change the offset, PM me on forums)
You've just proven how insensible that is. Other maps that passed qualified section don't allow you to do something. They just didn't check it or their threshold is pretty low. The second map is even a year old. Please, address the issue properly instead of using older maps as an argument.Igor Sprite wrote:
let's map a eletronic song, ANIME GIRL.jpg. see this map she ins't waking up D: .oh another "nonsense" BG
fixedSurono wrote:
wow its time to stop put memes in the serious thing such ranking map, its for offical content for this game right ? lol
1 thing for oni, 01:42:661 - change this sv to 0.90x to avoid 01:42:266 - this note 01:42:661 - blocked in the right screen, yeah just to make it neat the slowdown of sv alteration. yeah just minor
I dont find something wrong with BG, it fits well with the atmosphere of the song and yeah the song just tell about love and https://puu.sh/yO8Bz/409b90208a.png from the mapper told me, well
But it looks fine now. If not, can you raise the concern that you tell Igor?Sinnoh wrote:
bg is fine, tags are not
Sinnoh wrote:
bg is fine, tags are not
If it is moronic to pop a map over an issue that I brought up and is fully sensible, given all the arguments I've given (hence it's not just me thinking it doesn't fit, I'm explaining why it doesn't), then how is it not moronic to just say "it's fine" and bubble it without addressing it? No matter whether it fits or not, the issue was not addressed and it shouldn't have been rebubbled. Everything in the set contributes to mapset's quality, if I think it's not good enough because of any single part, I'm free to pop it.Naotoshi wrote:
Oh please, this is moronic. Will you go and pop every random map with an anime background? A background is nothing more than something to identify the map by and something the mapper thinks fits. Yes obvious this guy is rather lazy, not even bothering to write his own tags. Regardless, popping the map because he uses a background you don't find suitable is ludicrous.
I think I have started this ;w;Igor Sprite wrote:
wtf is happening with my map? ;-;
So, say why don't competent, i see all the text but i just found some vague assumptions and random words, u are sayng that are a problem here, but u don't ever show any example of how mapper can fix that, u just pop and "go find other"Wafu wrote:
Elaborate how the background is fine, using "atmosphere" as "it fits" doesn't seem very competent.
I would say, something with at least a bit of relevance. I'm not at all saying it can't be "an anime girl". It can be any wallpaper of the band, or just a nice photo of them, but it can also be a completely random anime/vn/whatever art that is irrelevant, but has a relevant theme at least (to the title or lyrics).Surono wrote:
I dont know but let other people giving more opinions about this and to determine it. as I thought, so it should be using artist, the album cover, or screenshot of the video clip from this song as bg? whats happening really
Saying that a background is not relevant to the song or the band nor the theme is not "random words and vague assumptions". It's objectively true. Surono's view is rather subjective because "atmosphere" of a song is different for everyone. Artist, lyrics and song is same for everyone, that's why I'm talking about these subjects when explaining the issue. I think that it's not my obligation to list the mapper all the possible backgrounds. If they asked, I'd be willing to help them search for some, but they may have a different taste for the concrete backgrounds. I'm not popping it only because the background is irrelevant, but also because discussion about it was skipped.Ataraxia wrote:
So, say why don't competent, i see all the text but i just found some vague assumptions and random words, u are sayng that are a problem here, but u don't ever show any example of how mapper can fix that, u just pop and "go find other"
If you see the lyrics, how BG u think that fits with the song, any example ?, if u just wanted to "say", u just pop because u want, not because there's a real problem in BG