forum

T-Pistonz+KMC - Tsunagari Yo (TV Size)

posted
Total Posts
132
show more
Topic Starter
Kogure
  1. rEdo
  2. YGOkid8
  3. Mikarunoel131
Mods done 8-)

Muya
Thx 4 star, that makes 50 :)

Moar :D
Ekaru
Hard: Good~

Normal:

00:18:412 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - The whole red-tick thing made this part feel weird. I would smooth that out a bit, maybe using sliders so that you don't have hit circles on red-ticks that don't have anything there.

00:43:456 (4,5) - (4) is where (5) ends; this causes (4) to look like a slider and is thus unrankable. Move the end of (5) so that it's nowhere near (4).

Easy:

<3

Insane:

I can confirm that it's sightreadable on the first try. And fun.

Giant improvement, here, have a star, and a kudosu star while I'm at it!
Luneko
Red = Fix this!
Blue = Suggestion~
Green = Design.

[Easy]
00:04:875 (4) - New Combo
Nice easy ^^

[Normal]
Great!

[LuPiiTa's Hard]
01:23:103 (3,4) - 2 Grids down :P
Some sliders could be sexier but overall its a nice diff :)

[Insane]
Ok :3

[Overall]
- There's an unused .osb file in the songs folder. Delete it.

[Skin]
- The shadow is cut off in scorebar-ki, scorebar-kidanger and scorebar-kidanger2.
- spinner-spin would look better without the guy, only the text IMO.


Have a Star
The 08 team_Bourdon
HiHi~~
i just can give you some suggestion ;)

Easy
00:14:760 (1) - delete this slider, and add a circle at here?
01:02:499 (2) - make it more beautiful

Normal
- Circle Size +1?
- too much note on red line. a bit hard to hit for Normal Players.
00:08:125 (2) - a bit hard for [Normal Players] to hit. maybe change to a repeating slider is better?
00:43:195 (3) - ^
01:00:151 (1) - too short for this spinner. change to a slider?

LuPiiTa's Hard
00:38:755 (2,3,4,5) - make them close a bit?
01:22:581 (2) - down 1 grid

Insane
00:38:630 (1,2,3,4,5) - make them more beautiful.
00:43:717 (1) - too short of this spinner
01:00:282 (1) - ^

-------
you got a cute skin :D
star!!~!!!!
Sallad4ever
Hi Kogure
sorry for the late reply

[General]

- set another uninherited timing section on 00:11:108 to fix the metronome
- I see that you only use a custom hitsound for the slider tick, if it is then you won't need other custom hitsounds except normal-slider tick2 as it is similar to the non-custom ones
- lol endou lost his eyes on the score-bar

[Easy]
00:04:875 (4) - NC this
00:10:065 (2) - I don't really recommend slider end stacking on the easiest diff
00:27:804 (1) - finish sounds better here
00:29:891 (1) - maybe add finish at the beginning of this slider
00:36:151 (1) - hmm you're not adding a clap on the ticks here?

[Normal]

00:10:978 (1) - I think this is sounds better if you add a finish just like in easy diff
00:19:195 (2) - I think finish fits here too
00:56:499 (5) - uhh spacing is too far :o
00:57:021 (1) - add finish or whistle here?
01:10:847 (3) - reduce the repeat by 1
01:12:934 (3) - ^
01:16:064 (6) - NC this

[LuPiiTa]

00:15:146 (3) - don't really like the jump here, mostly because it's on 1/4 I guess
00:34:451 (3) - I suggest to change it into 2 circles instead of a kick slider
00:43:451 (2) - maybe add a finish here too
01:00:146 (2) - ^

[Insane]
00:01:223 (1,2,3,4) - rather than adding extra beat to it, I suggest to follow the vocal here as it is very noticeable then using notes on every 1/2 like this
00:30:804 (1) - remove the NC from this then add NC on 00:30:934 (7)
00:36:021 (1) - remove NC then add one on 00:36:151 (9)

Interesting song:3
Good Luck with your map
Star
Topic Starter
Kogure
  1. Ekaru
  2. KillerRind
  3. The 08 team_Bourdon
  4. Sallad4ever
Mods done, only some of the suggestions :oops:
Ekaru, thanks for all your help (Since 3 months ago :o) and for those pinky stars :>
Endo's eyes in score bar fixed :lol:
Keep those mods coming! :D
Yuzeyun
These are all suggestions.

[Gen.]
Why is there a second timing section at 00:11:108 ? It just resetted the bars but whatever.


[EASY]
00:10:065 (2,1) - You could make a slider between those notes (start at 2 and end at 1) instead as Easy rarely have 1/4s.

[NORMAL]
Circle Size -1 ?
00:20:238 (4,5,6,7,8) - spacing
maybe ? (bad slider rendering fml orz)
01:25:717 (4) - You can move it 2 grids right to keep symmetry between the sliders.

[HARD]
01:24:151 (1,2,3,4) - Symmetry them ?

[INSANE]
00:55:456 (3) - :V a point is on -32y but lucky you it's not covered by the HP bar. so it is fine.

[TAIKO]
wait there isn't any taiko orz

well I didn't help that much... but I think that you can get a taiko for it. I may not map it as I have some of my own projects to do, but you can ask some taiko mappers such as lepidopodus or climbb.

You deserve a star from me. May 04 be with you ;)
Kiddo-Kun
[Normal]
00:04:875 (2) - Add a finish to this note.

The only problem I had with this diff was that it was a bit on the linear side, but that's not a huge problem.

[Hard]
00:52:325 (1,2) - Remove this new combo and add a new combo on (2) to match the vocals.
00:53:630 (1) - Remove new combo on this if you agree to take the top suggestion

Great map. Impressive knowing you're a beginner.
Have a star~
indyinyou
[Normal]

00:48:673 : add fin

[LuPiiTa `s Hard]

00:35:629 : add fin
00:43:455 : ^
00:52:847 : ^
00:57:021 : ^
01:11:629 : ^
01:12:673 : ^
01:18:412 : add silder to 01:18:934 and whistle at head add fin at end
01:19:455 : add silder to 01:19:977 add whistle at head add fin at end

they're just suggestions

star ~
Zelos
Folder:
All sparkly clean here.

General:
Change the tick rate on Lupiita's to tick rate 2. (It sounds nicer and its better to keep the tick rate the same in all difficulties.)

Easy:
00:18:412 (1,2,3) - move note number 2 so that it is centered among sliders 1 and 3.

Normal:
00:41:369 (3) - the ending of this slider isn't snapped to the white tick. this needs to be fixed.
00:41:369 (3,4,1) - please fix this spacing inconsistency. (after the previous mod)

Lupiita's Hard:
Nothing wrong here. Its pretty.

Insane:
00:18:412 (1,2,3) - stack the ending of slider 1, note 2, and the beginning of slider 3 on top of each other directly please, they are slightly off.

That's all.
I would feel fine bubbling this if I were MAT.
But for now, star.
Katsuri
Add Brazil to tags jk

Guest Hard

00:25:456 (1) - Sudden Slowdown. I lost my combo here because It's impossible to read. I suggest you to make this slowdown 0.75x and it will be too much better.

00:43:717 (1,2,3) - Something that would be cool is increase the volume on each note like:

Note 00:43:717 (1) - Volume 40%
Note 00:43:978 (2) - Volume 50%
Note 00:44:238 (3) - Volume 60%
Slider 00:44:499 (4) - Volume 70% and kiai start.
Try it! :D

Insane

Overmapped, but ok.
01:10:586 (6) - Add New Combo

Pretty Nice mapset, You have a star!
Topic Starter
Kogure
_Gezo_Kiddo-KunindinyouZelosKatsuriMods done, but ignored some issues.
Moar Mods?
Megurine Luka
Hi. Mod Time. :D

[General]

[Easy]
00:36:151 (1) - This look more symmetrical.
01:14:238 (2) - Move 3 grids right and 1 grid up
Good map.

[Normal]
Circle Size-1
00:11:630 (2) - del
00:41:369 (3) - 1 grid up
01:19:195 (2) - 1 grid right

[Hard]
01:13:456 (4,1,2,3) - 1 grid right and 1 grid up. What I mean is like this

[Insane]
00:21:282 (10) - this looks strange
00:24:673 (7) - NC


Quite good map so no more suggestions.

Deserve a star.

Good luck 8-)
Topic Starter
Kogure

Megurine Luka wrote:

Hi. Mod Time. :D

[General]

[Easy]
00:36:151 (1) - This look more symmetrical. Looks the same to me :S
01:14:238 (2) - Move 3 grids right and 1 grid up It wont look symmetrical.
Good map.

[Normal]
Circle Size-1 Yesh :3
00:11:630 (2) - del Noes
00:41:369 (3) - 1 grid up Noes
01:19:195 (2) - 1 grid right Yesh :3

[Hard]
01:13:456 (4,1,2,3) - 1 grid right and 1 grid up. What I mean is like this Didnt get this one either :S

[Insane]
00:21:282 (10) - this looks strange But i like it
00:24:673 (7) - NC Noes

Quite good map so no more suggestions.

Deserve a star.

Good luck 8-)
Mod Done :D
NoHitter
General
Is it just me or does the BG look stretched?
The combobursts have some white around them.
IMO the spinner-spin is very distracting. Just make it the text only.
Endou's picture in the scorebar-bg looks stretched too.

Easy
The slidertick claps sound odd. Maybe overlap the hit-normal with them so they sound like the hit-clap on a note.
00:11:891 (2,3) - Don't put these at the offbeat of the song. It's sounds odd. Maybe something like this?
00:36:151 (1) - Maybe lessen the repeats and map the other parts.
00:40:325 (3) - Same as above.

Normal
00:43:456 (4) - Maybe change this into a Spinner for consistency at 01:00:151 (1). Or vice versa, make 01:00:151 (1) a slider.

LuPiiTa's Hard
00:25:456 (1) - IMO remove the slowdown.
00:35:630 (1) - Plays oddly. There's really no musical cue for a Crumpled Slider.

Insane
00:21:282 (10) - Plays very oddly.

Overall good.
Topic Starter
Kogure

NoHItter wrote:

General
Is it just me or does the BG look stretched? A little bit, but its not that noticeable
The combobursts have some white around them. I removed them now
IMO the spinner-spin is very distracting. Just make it the text only. Done since it was requested some time ago
Endou's picture in the scorebar-bg looks stretched too. Unstretched a bit

Easy
The slidertick claps sound odd. Maybe overlap the hit-normal with them so they sound like the hit-clap on a note. Will do soon
00:11:891 (2,3) - Don't put these at the offbeat of the song. It's sounds odd. Maybe something like this? Done
00:36:151 (1) - Maybe lessen the repeats and map the other parts. Done
00:40:325 (3) - Same as above. Done

Normal
00:43:456 (4) - Maybe change this into a Spinner for consistency at 01:00:151 (1). Or vice versa, make 01:00:151 (1) a slider. Done, changed to spinner.

LuPiiTa's Hard
00:25:456 (1) - IMO remove the slowdown. I'm still not sure about removing this
00:35:630 (1) - Plays oddly. There's really no musical cue for a Crumpled Slider. It sounds cool imo

Insane
00:21:282 (10) - Plays very oddly. I like how it sounds like, and how it looks like

Overall good.
Thanks for suggestions :D
Breeze
Yea, nice map
I have nothig found
have a pink star
Your message is too short. Please do not post messages like "star", and make sure you are constructively adding to the thread in question.
Revengexsoyah
Hola amigo
he visto que haz pedido mods en diferentes queques asi ke me anime a dejarte un mod (algo pekeño :3) y mas encima en español :D

aqui va

Solo Sugerencias

~Easy~

00:39:281 (3) : ese spacing nose , tomando en cuenta que es easy para novatos ammm podria ser mas lineal con el (2)
prueba esto aca
00:50:760 : clap
00:51:281 (2) : whistle
veras que queda clap whsitle clap y suena bien :3 xD

01:05:890 : clap
01:06:934: whistle
01:07:977 : clap
01:09:021 : whsitle
01:10:586 : clap
01:12:673 : ^

~Normal~
por lo que tengo entendido las notas deben ir en los ticks blancos y rojos en 1/4 (sino me equivoco XD)
00:10:978 y aca hay una nota en el tick azul (aparte que suena como incosistente, no como aca 00:42:803 )
lo que se me ocurre que puedes hacer seria esto :
00:10:586 (x) : agregar nota con clap
00:10:978 (1) : mover al tick blanco xD
nose si te gusta ahi tu vees (aunque consultalo bien con un MAT o un BAT para que estes seguro)

00:41:368 (3) : idea mia o esta algo chueco (movido de su lugar ) Alinialo con el (2) y el (1)


~Lupiita~
00:04:354 : whistle
00:04:615 : clap
00:05:658: whistle
00:06:180 : clap
00:06:441 : ^

00:38:108 : siento qe esta nota como que esta sobrando nose porque xDD , pero ponla en el tick blanco y ve si te gusta como suena con un clap

muy bien lupita haz mejorado mucho :D

~Insane~
Very very Fine xDD
:D

Star amigo mucha suerte y gL adios
Esupanitix
Moddan tiem :Y

Easy
No problems here.

Normal
00:10:978 Combo
2,5,6,7 - Misspaced, though only slightly.

00:14:760 Combo
4 - Misspaced.

00:29:890 Combo
1 - Misspaced.

00:32:499 Combo
2,5,6 - Misspaced.

00:36:140 Combo
1,2,3,4 - Misspaced.

00:40:325 Combo
2,3,4 - Misspaced.

00:45:021 Combo
7 - Misspaced.

00:48:673 Combo
2,5 - Misspaced.

00:50:760 Combo
2,3 - Misspaced.

00:52:847 Combo
5,6 - Misspaced.

1:09:548 Combo
1 - Misspaced.

1:11:629 Combo
1 - Misspaced.

1:13:630 Combo
1 - Misspaced.

LuPiiTa's has no problems I should identify.

Nor does Insane.

The map is very nice, altogether.
Sakura
Oh a fellow Colombian mapper, what a coincidence =O
[General]
Your background still looks somewhat stretched as pointed out before, aditionally i would try to remove the LEVEL-5 text at the bottom left and the ign.com watermark at the bottom right.

[Insane]
Why does your 1st kiai end 1/4 later here?
00:09:030 (1,1) - The problem here is that u have an orange note in the center, with a spinner with an orange background, considering the note is right in the middle and there was a hitburst there the note is Very difficult to see also it's kinda close to the spinner as well, i'd suggest moving it 1/4 later so it fits the lyrics better.
01:00:282 (1,1) - I'd really like this slider to be closer to the center of the spinner, but up to you.
Heh a bit overmapped but it's intuitive so i dont mind =P

[LuPiiTa's Hard]
00:25:456 (1) - Slow down is really unintuitive.
OzzyOzrock
Done! About a... I can't say 6 star because of the rap bit... and ..u uh... oh who cares, it's done.

Download: T-Pistonz+KMC - Tsunagari Yo (TV Size) (K o g u r e) [Ozzy's Taiko, Yo mah homie bro].osu
Yeah, don't make that the name... just make it Ozzy's Taiko or something... lol

Hi Sakura! EDIT: Olvide que los colombianos hablan español lol.
Topic Starter
Kogure
  1. Revengexsoyah's Mod: Hice muchas de tus sugerencias, solo ignore algunas.
  2. Esupanitix's Mod: Still not sure about changin the spacing.
  3. Sakura Hana's Mod: Its kind of difficult to remove those texts, i try but i fuck it up. I changed the color of the note, see if it is more visible now.
    Also tried changing its position, but IMO it doesnt fit the lyrics if i move it.
    If i change the position of the slider after the spinner, i would have to change all the notes coming, what would be a pain in the ass :o
    About Lupiita's hard Slowdown, isnt there a way to avoid removing it? Coz i like how it sounds there
    PS: Colombia FTW :D
  4. OzzyOzrock: Thanks for the diff :D
    Btw, do i need another bg for the taiko map?
OzzyOzrock
Yeah, made one.

DON'T KUDOSU! ;_;
Kytoxid


Haha, posting so that it stays around even if you edit it later~
OzzyOzrock
I've done that SO MANY TIMES.

I need to get my eyes checked, because this is happening too much with other things.
Topic Starter
Kogure
Done updates Ftw
I just hope I can get moar mods to get this ranked >_>
Kiiwa
Hi~

Insane
I feel you use too much notes in places they don't really fit. For example: 00:01:484 (2) - 00:02:528 (4) -
01:07:325 (2) - delete
01:11:108 (5) - remove reverse and add a note at: 01:11:629 - and make that note a new combo

Hard
Nice GD
00:27:021 (4) - shorten by one reverse
00:36:412 (2) - new combo?
00:39:281 (1) - add finish
00:44:499 (4) - new combo for Kiai time, 00:45:543 (1) - remove new combo, 00:46:586 (4) - add new combo

Normal
I feel the spacing is a bit too big


Nice maps, good luck
Behon
Easy:
- 00:01:223 (1,2,3): Move these 1 square to the left if you want them to be perfectly symmetrical.
- 00:17:890 (4): Make this a new combo.
- 00:18:412 (1): Get rid of the new combo here.

Normal:
- 00:08:513 (3,4): These might work better with claps instead of finishes.
- 01:00:151 (Spinner): Add a finish.

LuPiiTa's Hard:
- 00:53:629 (1): This doesn't need to be a new combo.
- 00:58:847 (5): Make this a new combo.
- 00:59:108 (1): Get rid of the new combo here.

Insane:
No problems here.
Chewin
Hayo ~
They are suggestions, you will decide if you want follow them or not.

Easy:
Ok.

Normal:
It's ok too >.<

LuPiiTa's Hard:

  1. 00:25:456 (1) - I don't like the shape of the slider D: You could move 2nd waypoint at x424 y352 and the last at x344 y328. It's better.
  2. 00:48:412 (1) - Remove NC
  3. 00:48:673 (2) - NC here
  4. 00:53:630 (1) - Remove NC
  5. 00:57:543 (2) - 1 Grid left
  6. 01:05:108 (1) - Remove NC
  7. 01:05:369 (2) - New combo
  8. 01:14:760 (1) - Remove NC
  9. 01:15:282 (2) - New combo
Insane:

  1. 00:10:325 (1) - Move it at 00:10:456?
  2. 01:06:543 (4) - Delete circle?
  3. 01:07:325 (2) - ^
Good maps, I wish you good luck ^^
Shulin
General:

-- Timing seems a bit off too me, I was using +12 offset but it might just be me.
-- Can you get rid of the ign watermark on the BG?

Easy:

00:10:065 (2) - Stacked notes under a slider are generally confusing for new players.
00:38:760 (2) - It's not in the centre of 00:36:151 (1) - just move it 1 grid left and 1 grid up on grid level 4 if you care
00:48:673 (1) - I don't like the way this overlaps with 00:48:673 (1) - maybe reposition it slightly or change the shape to avoid this?
00:54:934 (1) - The slider tick clap on this slider sounds odd imo, I'd suggest removing it.
00:58:065 (3) - ^

Normal;

00:58:065 (2,3) - The way these overlap with 00:57:021 (1) - and 00:59:108 (4) - looks ugly, maybe space them out more?

LuPiiTa's Hard:

00:25:456 (1) - Don't understand why you have a slowdown here, but meh it plays fine.
00:27:021 (4) - Remove a return? It sounds like you're following the drum roll (also weird you end at the start of a vocal), but if you end it earlier it follows the synth ^_^

Insane:

-- Reduce overall difficulty by 1?

00:10:325 (1) - Delete? It sounds a bit strange to me (the vocal seems to start at 00:10:391). But if not please place it directly in the centre =P
00:27:412 (1,2,3,4) - Move these closer together or change the pattern? The hitbox is really small right now and it's hard to adjust after a spinner ._.
00:39:151 (5) - Whistle the end?
00:39:804 (6) - Whistle?
01:25:195 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - I think it sounds better if you remove 1/4 from this combo and follow the song. Maybe put in some more jumps?

Good luck ~
Topic Starter
Kogure
Done all mods and changed the BG
Getting closer and closer x_x
Pereira006
hello~~

IMO -> my opinions

Some Suggestions
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
[Easy]

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
[Normal]

00:19:717 (3) - for me this is weird play gameplay i will be happy you change like this http://puu.sh/5ARL just change at 00:19:195 (2,3)
00:33:543 (3) - too hard see hitburst with slider 00:35:108 (6) so maybe stack it?
00:34:065 (4,5) - Incosiente spacing
00:35:108 (6,1,2,3,4) - I can see is 1.40 spacing so Why spacing is increassing? i suggest you fix this spacing
00:54:412 (2,3,4,5,6) - I understand you logic but 00:54:934 (4,5) I can see is incosiente spacing but try this code this going better gameplay IMO
SPOILER
112,224,54412,1,8
184,264,54673,1,0
184,352,54934,2,0,B|328:352,2,140,2|0|2
328,264,56499,1,8
400,224,56760,1,0
01:12:934 (3) - Slider hitburst with 01:14:238 (2) try get another place?
01:22:064 (1,2) - Grid 1 right ? if you change try fix spacing at 01:23:108 (1)

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
[LupIIta'sHard]

00:25:456 (1) - I agree with Shulin's mod but well orz

this really fine
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
[Insane]

omg HP -1 pleasse Y_Y

this is fine for me but lot stream is overmapped because blue tick i can't hear drums soft or strong but that's okay because this is insane
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
That all i think
well good luck and good mapset :)
Topic Starter
Kogure
Thanks for your modding :D

Checking all the normal diff i realized there is a huge mislead spacing in 01:11:630, and i didnt notice till now :S
well, fixed now
Elly-chan
[General]
Delete .osb and full submit!!

(Easy)
Are you trolling me with the 1.40 slider velocity?
00:29:890 (1) - It'd look better if it was curved! Please do this?~

K, this is good.

(Normal)
HR +1?
00:15:803 (4, 5, 6) - From where 4 was placed, 5 and 6 look ugly. Change this pattern?

(Hard)
00:48:412 (1) - Remove NC
00:48:673 (2) - NC

(Insane)
00:21:281 - very ugly slider. Please change this, or just add a slider velocity slow-down on this part.

Can't explain much more, this map could be better then it is atm though imo. ;o; I see stuff, but I just don't know how to tell you to fix it without editing the whole entire map
Verdisphena
General
Borra el archivo T-Pistonz+KMC - Tsunagari Yo (TV Size) (K o g u r e).osb, no sirve para nada si no tienes un SB, luego de borrarlo haz un fullsubmit
spinner-background pesa mucho (tambien pause-overlay y fail-background)

Easy
AR -1

01:19:977 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - Encuentro esto dificil para un easy, pone algunos sliders.

Hard
HP -1
00:25:455 (1) - De verdad necesitas un slider lento aqui?, no le va
00:38:760 (2,3,4,5) - Y si comienzas este stream en 00:38:499 - ?

Insane
CLAP,CLAP,CALP,CLAP
00:12:542 (1,2,3,4) - Ese stream es muy innecesario
00:16:586 (2,3,4,5,6) - ^
00:22:064 (1,2,3,4) - ^
01:02:499 (3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - ^
01:03:542 (1) - Copia el slider de 01:04:325 (2) -

Muchos de los streams que tienes aqui no le van a el mapa, recomiendo remplazarlos con otras cosas, eso hace que la diff no me guste...
Ademas, esta diff (todoelmapa) tiene muchos claps, pone mas variedad de hitsounds ._.

Taiko
I love you

00:01:745 (2,3) - k ?
00:42:412 (1,2,1,2) - D K K K ?
00:59:108 (1,2,1,2) - ^
PoochyEXE
First of all, I love a lot of the skin elements. Could I please borrow some pieces for my own beatmaps? I'm working on one for "Katte Nakou ze!" and I'd love to use it there.

Now for my suggestions:

The spinner could use something in the foreground that makes it a bit clearer that it's a spinner. A soccer ball spinner would be perfect!

Easy
0:21:281 - End the slider on 5 a half a beat earlier.

Normal
0:18:412~0:23:108 - The positions are a bit awkward. Here's how I suggest you position 2 through 7 (use grid level 3):
1: x:256 y:64 (no change)
2: x:376 y:152
3: x:328 y:296
4: x:184 y:296
5: x:136 y:152
6: x:256 y:64 (same as 1)
7: x:376 y:152 (same as 2)
0:32:499~0:35:629 - Also feels a little odd. Try making a hexagon out of the orange 3 and the yellow 1~5. Here are my suggestions for yellow 1 through 5 (use grid level 2):
1: x:176 y:320
2: x:112 y:192
3: x:176 y:64
4: x: 336 y:64
5: x:400 y:192
Then nudge 6 downwards just a little (y:224 perhaps).

Insane (Disclaimer: This beatmap is above my current skill level.)
0:21:281 - The slider on 10 is ugly and awkward. Make it a normal U-shaped one.
0:23:108 - Move 6 to the left a bit. x:280 should work.
0:25:065 - Move 10 down.
0:43:194 - Move 5 and 6 down. Make the triangle equilateral. Try y:104.
1:23:629 - 3 and 4 are WAY too far apart. Move them closer together. Try 3: x: 336 y:328 and 4: x:176 y: 328.
lolcubes
Hey there, answering your request.

[General]:
  1. Timing: Offsets are a bit funky. Stuff felt mistimed.
    Settings I used:
    115bpm offset 702
    116bpm offset 6962
    115bpm offset 10083
    115bpm offset 11126
    115bpm offset 44503
    115bpm offset 77894
    115bpm offset 79996
    115bpm offset 84160
    114bpm offset 88284 - This one is required for taiko. I am not entirely sure about this one though. It felt kinda okay, but I had too much variations. It would be best that taiko had nothing mapped there, then it would be unnecessary, else this would have to be nicely timed. These timings did work somehow, but I am not too confident in this one. I could SS those 9 notes every time with OD8, but every try I had either slightly early or slightly late.

    The red ones are missing ones you don't have, rest are just slightly reconfigured.
    With these I rarely had a 100 on the map (I could SS it if I give it some tries hehe). If you don't trust these settings, ask a very experienced timer to help you, I think these work good enough though.
    It could be just me being bad, but I definitely had problems in insane with your current timings, so you could check them out with a BAT just to be sure.
  2. The custom 1 normal sounds are exactly the same as the default ones. This makes them redundant. Just use default normal set instead of custom 1, and delete all of these and do a full submit.
[Insane]:
  1. Note: I will be using my own timings for this diff because I checked the timing first. Some stuff may appear slightly different to you because of the timelines, but I hope you can figure it out.
  2. 00:10:343 (1,2,3,4) - These are a huge problem. Because the music is very strange here, they fall on these funny ticks. You probably shouldn't map these at all because they are unplayable. Try this: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/153650 . You don't map the first parts of the voice because you just can't follow them unless you really know the song by heart, and then you just make a pre-note before the slider, because that's a "heavy" spot where the voice ends. The slider is this long because of the odd rhythm and is necessary for people to get used to the rhythm that follows. With this, I doubt people will have much trouble playing this map, while with your current mapped stuff, unless you really watch approach circles to the millisecond, or know the song by heart, you will be 100 or 50ing those stuff. Ofcourse, the slider placement is just random, but I wanted to make it clear so you understand it best, you can place it anywhere if you want.
  3. 00:49:720 (6) - This slider won't work. Usually, what I think is that when you are forced to map a slider tick in the highest diff, you're doing it wrong. Shorten it to 00:49:981 and then just map a circle at 00:50:111. This sounds the same, but it's much better because you aren't forced to use gimmicks to map stuff.
  4. some thoughts
    You should probably remove 00:01:484 (2) and 00:01:745 (3) and then instead of the slider 3 map 2 circles at 00:01:755 and 00:02:277. Also remove 00:02:528 (4). The reason is, those notes don't really follow the music, and would feel much better if you only had 3 notes with huge spacing, those jumps would be fun and it would sound better. Some other notes after these aren't exactly following the music either, but those are fine because they give you the sense of rhythm I guess.
[Hard]:
  1. 00:01:223 (1,2,3) - Refer to the "some thoughts" section in the Insane. Should probably do the same.
  2. 00:33:804 (1) - Remove this new combo and place it on 00:34:065 (2) instead, follows the music better.
  3. 00:48:412 (1) - ^, just place it on 00:48:673 (2).
  4. 01:05:108 (1) - ^, just place it on 01:05:369 (2).
  5. 01:06:673 (1) - ^, just place it on 01:07:456 (3).
  6. 01:19:978 (1,2,3,4) - Some inconsistent spacing. Also if this was intentional, then you should do the opposite, instead of using lower spacing for every note, use higher because that fits the song much better.
[Normal]:
  1. 00:10:978 (1,2) - I strongly suggest to make a slider out of these two. New players won't be able to hit blue ticks properly.
  2. 00:29:891 (1) - Remove this new combo and place it on 00:31:978 (3) instead. Also remove the new combo from 00:32:499 (1).
  3. 00:46:586 (5) - Perhaps a new combo here? Seeing as you had a new combo almost every stanza after here, this would make this section more consistent.
  4. 00:54:934 (4) - ^
[Easy]:
  1. 00:18:412 (2) - New combo here instead of at 00:17:891 (1).
[Taiko]:
  1. Maybe remove video from this diff? It looks ugly with it: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/153678, check that black bar in the play area.
That's about it.
I find it surprising that a TV Size map has so many red sections, but meh, they need to be done.
Hopefully you respond to this with the changes you made!

Good luck!
Topic Starter
Kogure
All done!
lolcubes: I followed every instruction except the timing stuff and the normal sounds
Timing: I still need to be sure about this lots of red sections, I will try to get a BAT's opinion 'bout this.
Sounds: I didnt change them because on easy diff, there are still those slidertick claps, and I dont want to remove then. Also, if i only edit slider-tick.wav, it may inflict other players' playing skin (if it has other sounds). But if someone else insists to remove them, i will.
Thanks ppl for modding :oops:
SapphireGhost
Hello, there.

[Insane]
00:46:978 (10,1,2) - These two sliders seem to be slightly unsnapped, manually resnap them.
00:55:456 (3) - Slight overlap with the HP bar, here. HP bar overlap is avoided nicely for the rest of the map, so I'd just tweak this slider a bit and it'll look nicer.

[Ozzy's Taiko]
- This taiko felt very nice and not too hard. Good job, sir.
00:43:716 (1) - This spinner is really quite short, would it be possible to do this some other way?

[LuPiiTa's Hard]
- Kiai times are slightly inconsistent on this difficulty. Please resnap the kiai inheriting sections.
00:48:412 (6,1) - Putting a new combo under a stack makes the approach circles look sort of odd, (to me, at least) so I would advise moving (1) elsewhere.

[Normal]
- This difficulty would be more visually appealing without overlaps, and it's not much work to change them. Here's the list:
00:29:890 (6,7) -
00:39:281 (4,1) -
01:12:934 (3,1) -


[Easy]
00:17:891 (4,1) - Same thing about new combos under stacks. Also, (in my opinion) the music at this point merits (4) and (1) being in different positions.
01:19:978 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3) - This pattern bothered me as everything was slightly off-center. Just move it a bit to the right and it'll be all good.

After you've responded to these suggestions, please send me a Forum PM and I'll re-check this!
Topic Starter
Kogure
SapphireGhost's Mod Done!

lolcubes wrote:

Timing: Offsets are a bit funky. Stuff felt mistimed.
Settings I used:
115bpm offset 702
116bpm offset 6962
115bpm offset 10083
115bpm offset 11126
115bpm offset 44503
115bpm offset 77894
115bpm offset 79996
115bpm offset 84160
114bpm offset 88284 - This one is required for taiko. I am not entirely sure about this one though. It felt kinda okay, but I had too much variations. It would be best that taiko had nothing mapped there, then it would be unnecessary, else this would have to be nicely timed. These timings did work somehow, but I am not too confident in this one. I could SS those 9 notes every time with OD8, but every try I had either slightly early or slightly late.
The red ones are missing ones you don't have, rest are just slightly reconfigured.
With these I rarely had a 100 on the map (I could SS it if I give it some tries hehe). If you don't trust these settings, ask a very experienced timer to help you, I think these work good enough though.
It could be just me being bad, but I definitely had problems in insane with your current timings, so you could check them out with a BAT just to be sure.
If a BAT comes by, can he/she tell me if these timings are good? so I can use them. Thanks
SapphireGhost
Small list of things that need to be fixed before bubble:

1
Kiai is still slightly inconsistent. You can see the problems here.

2
Due to your hitcircle overlay, you'll need to have a slider border colour as well. This is so people with (for example) a black slider border colour won't have the problem of it looking odd with your grey hitcircle overlay.
In order to change the slider border colour, open a difficulty, then go to File > Open .osu in Notepad.
Scroll down to the "Colours" section and type "SliderBorder: 213,213,213" without the quotes. (I picked 213,213,213 because that's the colour my image editor said was closest to your hitcircle.)
Save and repeat for all difficulties.

Lastly, see if you can get Doomsday/Lybydose/Cyclone to give you a final timing for this map. After all that, this should be good and bubble-ready (forum PM me when that time comes).
PoochyEXE
I made you a (hopefully) better version of fail-background.png for the skin:
Doomsday
Quick timing check time!

As for the BPM changes, they all seem just fine to me, they work. The only issue that I found at least, was that the timing in general sounded a little early. Adding +10ms to every section sounded better to me.

But that's all I got. On the whole, timing is pretty good.
Topic Starter
Kogure

SapphireGhost wrote:

Small list of things that need to be fixed before bubble:

1
Kiai is still slightly inconsistent. You can see the problems here.

2
Due to your hitcircle overlay, you'll need to have a slider border colour as well. This is so people with (for example) a black slider border colour won't have the problem of it looking odd with your grey hitcircle overlay.
In order to change the slider border colour, open a difficulty, then go to File > Open .osu in Notepad.
Scroll down to the "Colours" section and type "SliderBorder: 213,213,213" without the quotes. (I picked 213,213,213 because that's the colour my image editor said was closest to your hitcircle.)
Save and repeat for all difficulties.

Lastly, see if you can get Doomsday/Lybydose/Cyclone to give you a final timing for this map. After all that, this should be good and bubble-ready (forum PM me when that time comes).
OK all done, waiting for ur response :)

PoochyEXE wrote:

I made you a (hopefully) better version of fail-background.png for the skin:
SPOILER
[attachment=0:ff870]fail-background.png[/attachment:ff870]
Thanks for this and for letting me use ur sliderball, i am really grateful :oops:

Doomsday wrote:

Quick timing check time!

As for the BPM changes, they all seem just fine to me, they work. The only issue that I found at least, was that the timing in general sounded a little early. Adding +10ms to every section sounded better to me.

But that's all I got. On the whole, timing is pretty good.
Thanks a lot! This is what i needed, it sounds better now :D

Updates done! Please Re-download as for today 13/10/11
SapphireGhost
Apparently some stuff got unsnapped on [Ozzy's Taiko] for some silly reason, so go ahead and fix that. Other than that, should be fine.
Topic Starter
Kogure

SapphireGhost wrote:

Apparently some stuff got unsnapped on [Ozzy's Taiko] for some silly reason, so go ahead and fix that. Other than that, should be fine.
Done
SapphireGhost
Fixes were done, experiments were run, all is good.
Bubbled!
PoochyEXE
By the way, which episode is your pause-background.png from? 'Cause I could make you an HD version of that too, if I could just locate the source scene.
Sakura
[Insane]
00:10:988 (1) - New combo to fix spinner combo bug

[Ozzy's Taiko]
HP+1

[Easy]
-----------------------------------------------------------
(Note all these hitsounds are to make your hitsounds consistent throughout kiai, so you either accept all suggestions or reject them all)
00:51:813 (3) - Remove hitsound whistle and add hitsound clap at slider end for consistence.
00:54:422 (4) - Remove hitsound clap and add hitsound whistle for consistence.
00:54:944 (1) - Remove hitsound whistle and add hitsound clap at slider start for consistence, also add Slider finish at slider end.
00:56:509 - Remove hitsound clap from slidertick.
-------------------------------------------------------------
00:58:074 (3) - Remove hitsound whistle and add hitsound finish at slider end.
01:09:552 (1,2,3,4) - Use the same hitsounding you used at 01:05:378 (1,2,3,4) for consistence.
01:15:813 (3,4,5) - I think it would sound cooler if on the repeat you replaced whistles with claps (makes it sound it slightly different since the voice is slightly different as well).

Since all the fixes are metadata, a new combo and hitsounds should be fine for rank after fixes, however bubble needs to pop because of spinner combo bug
Topic Starter
Kogure

Sakura Hana wrote:

[Insane]
00:10:988 (1) - New combo to fix spinner combo bug

[Ozzy's Taiko]
HP+1

[Easy]
-----------------------------------------------------------
(Note all these hitsounds are to make your hitsounds consistent throughout kiai, so you either accept all suggestions or reject them all)
00:51:813 (3) - Remove hitsound whistle and add hitsound clap at slider end for consistence.
00:54:422 (4) - Remove hitsound clap and add hitsound whistle for consistence.
00:54:944 (1) - Remove hitsound whistle and add hitsound clap at slider start for consistence, also add Slider finish at slider end.
00:56:509 - Remove hitsound clap from slidertick.
-------------------------------------------------------------
00:58:074 (3) - Remove hitsound whistle and add hitsound finish at slider end.
01:09:552 (1,2,3,4) - Use the same hitsounding you used at 01:05:378 (1,2,3,4) for consistence.
01:15:813 (3,4,5) - I think it would sound cooler if on the repeat you replaced whistles with claps (makes it sound it slightly different since the voice is slightly different as well).

Since all the fixes are metadata, a new combo and hitsounds should be fine for rank after fixes, however bubble needs to pop because of spinner combo bug
Thanks, i didnt notice the spinner stuff. Also I followed ur hitsounds instructions.
Sakura
Well changes were minor so, it sounds def. better now

Ranked!
SapphireGhost
I will not miss the new combo bug again.
I will not miss the new combo bug again.
I will not miss the new combo bug again.
I will not miss the new combo bug again.
I will not miss the new combo bug again.
I will not miss the new combo bug again.
I will not miss the new combo bug again.


Congratulations!
NixXSkate
Congrats K o g u r e! you got a ranked map! :)
DerekMcD
Oh!!!! Congrats on your first beatmap!!!!!
PoochyEXE
Congratulations on a well-deserved ranked map!
Kiddo-Kun
Congratulations~
vivere
Congrats K o g u r e for get your first map ranked!!

---

Felicidades! :>
spboxer3
Congratz~;)
Mismagius
Can someone explain me what's wrong with the map just to know what's up with the rating? I don't see any reason on it to be 6.4.
LuPiiTa
Finally!!
Congratz~!! Felicidades \>w</
OzzyOzrock
uh oh
UH OH
NOOOO
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
PORQUE
QWHYYYYYYY
WUWSGUODS`
EDIT: overracting

Gratz :D
Xakyrie
Congrats K o g u r e, I'm so happy for you. :oops:

and, uh...



juss sayin'.
Sallad4ever
I actually like the map and the song too so don't mind the low rating, Kogure
congratz on the rank
PoochyEXE

Blue Dragon wrote:

Can someone explain me what's wrong with the map just to know what's up with the rating? I don't see any reason on it to be 6.4.
My best guess is a small handful of people who play every newly-ranked map and then go "I can't FC the hardest diff so I'll give it a 1 out of frustration." If you look at recently-ranked maps, there seem to be a small handful of 1's on nearly every map. There's a correlation between the number of votes a map has and its rating, too. Looks like there are a few (around 10) people (jerks!) who have been giving nearly every newly ranked map a 1 right away, after which the rest of the players give fairly high ratings and gradually dilute out those initial 1's.

This map's been gradually drifting upwards in the past couple hours, too. When I first looked at it (about 2 hours after it was ranked), it was a 6.0. 3 hours later, it was a 6.4. Another 3 hours later, it was a 6.8. Now it's at 6.9. I predict it'll break 8.0 while the beatmap listing still says "needs X votes" (and it certainly deserves to).

Also, curse you Ozzy for making such a magnificently hard-yet-not-unreasonably-so Taiko diff. XD I just spent the last two hours playing it over and over before finally FC'ing it, because I knew I can FC it if I try, but I just kept picking up a couple misses each time.
Charles445

Blue Dragon wrote:

Can someone explain me what's wrong with the map just to know what's up with the rating? I don't see any reason on it to be 6.4.
Looking at the map, I actually don't know why.

Only about two parts have readability issues and... uh, maybe the 1/4 sliders during streams at random points? That's all I can tell, other than the map being a tad rectangular (which is normal for a first map)

Yeah this definitely deserves a higher rating. Either way, it's only at 52 votes so anything goes. (current rating is 7.8)
eldnl
Every non-cute anime song have low rating.
IkkiMinami
Good
Topic Starter
Kogure
/)^3^(\
Finally this stuff got ranked, thanks guys for supporting me and to all who helped me to get to this point.
About the rating, i will not pay attention to that for now, i am just to happy i wont let that affect me :D

Commenting two days after rating coz of some internet problems ewe
Mikarunoel131_DELETED
Congratulations ^-^ ( I know I am a bit to late TTvTT ) Have fun in Osu! x3
kudonto
mazimaziniomorroi
:oops: :oops: :oops: :oops: :oops: :oops: :oops: :oops:
Please sign in to reply.

New reply