1. aru's Taiko (5 stars, 513 notes)
2. Gintoki (4.94 stars, 209 notes)
3. Kagura (4.21 stars, 151 notes)
4. Shinpachi (1.77 stars, 106 notes)

NoHItter wrote:

General
While some sliders look good aesthetically, a lot are still not so aesthetically appealing.i was going for original not aesthetically appealing

Shinpachi
00:39:337 (1) - IMO, it would be better if you just start the spinner here. nah i dont like the way that flows
00:41:889 (1) - Too close to the previous spinner. ......no it aint
00:43:802 (1,2,3,1,2,3) - Too repetitive IMO. Maybe you could think of other patterns other than stacking these? since its a easy, ive mader this place abit easier to give the player a break after the spinner
00:58:793 (1) - Move 1/2 later, (shorten the spinner to make it end at the same time) fixed
01:01:664 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5) - This part is kind of surprising as there is a sudden shift in time between notes. IMO make these parts sliders to give players time to adapt. this part is easy, it just gives the player something to help improve there skill abit, a simple break beat like this aint too much for a easy

Kagura
00:13:821 (2) - IMO don't stack these. (They are 1/1 compared to the rest of the stacks which are 1/2) true fixed

Gintoki
00:17:011 (1) - Sudden jump >.> got a second opinion and we both think this jump is good
00:25:622 (x) - Hitsound doesn't fit IMO. sorry i dont agree
00:46:035 (x) - ^^

Great map.

arien666 wrote:

[Shinpachi]
00:02:339 (4) - [Suggestion] I think Hexagon-going-pattern would be better ;_; http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/39021 not really my style
00:06:805 (2) - [Nazi] Umm... Move fixed dot 1 grid left like http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/39022 :3? nah
00:39:660 (1) - [Suggestion] It seems better if this starts from 00:39:979 :3 it becomes shorter for a easy diff then, if another person agree's i will change it

[Kagura]
01:15:545 (5,6,7) - Umm... Spacing but I dunno about jump ;_; wow i missed that, thanks alot

[Gintoki]
Nice diff :3

[aru's Taiko]
I hope that NBGI takes Gintama songs again ;_;



Dunno but
It's good song anyway :3
Good luck XD

ps. Don't give kudosu for this reply orz

Combo1 : 215,81,84
Combo2 : 150,180,211
Combo3 : 123,85,157

lovhin456 wrote:

Hi ~

General;
- Audio lead-in of 1500 for all diffs ?? nah
- Use these colors ?? nah

Combo1 : 215,81,84
Combo2 : 150,180,211
Combo3 : 123,85,157

- Disable countdown on all diffs. is not used.sure

Shinpachi;
- 00:17:650 >> Replace this with a slider that starts here and ends at 00:17:969 ?? that would break the flow im doing
- 00:31:047 >> Remove new combo then new combo to the next note .........there aint even a note at this pont
- 01:22:084 >> End kiai time here sure

Kagura;
- Good

Gintoki;
- 00:25:226 ~ 00:26:103 >> Could you lower the sound a little in this part ?? sure
- 00:45:561 ~ 00:46:518 >> Here too ^ sure
- Great diff !!:3

Aru's Taiko;
- Sounds great

* Star ~

vytalibus wrote:

<Hitsounds>
I'd boost normal-hitnormal2's volume up considerably. It's barely audible, and switching from the first custom soundset to the second doesn't feel right with this almost-inaudible sound riddled throughout. upped it some, but i dont really wanna up it more because it will break the effect i was after

[Shinpachi]
00:41:893 (1,2,1,2,3,1,2,3) - This part feels dull. I know this is supposed to be the easiest difficulty, but three stacks like these make it feel like I'm being dragged through this. second person to say this so fixed

Other than those, nice map.

James2250 wrote:

Make audio lead-in closer to 2 seconds? Seems to start pretty fast at the moment made it one and a hlaf
You mean for the slider ticks to be so noticeable right? (especially on first part) pretty much yea
Personally I would prefer all the spinners to be extended and silenced where the lyrics end instead of a finish atm, but its fine as it is srry dont agree with this

Shinpachi:
Nice

Kagura:
Nice

Gintoki:
Nice

aru's Taiko:
01:22:244 (1,10,1) - hey I didn't know AIMod pointed that bug out...cool. The spinner didn't create a new combo after it (prob doesn't matter for taiko) but fix anyway~ fixed

Really nothing to complain about
Good job~

James2250 wrote:

aru's Taiko:
01:22:244 (1,10,1) - hey I didn't know AIMod pointed that bug out...cool. The spinner didn't create a new combo after it (prob doesn't matter for taiko) but fix anyway~

Teta wrote:

I looked over the map and didn't find anything wrong.
I really liked the custom hitsounds, so here's a pretty star for you, Jeri!
Also, i sugested taking a look at a custom slider tick at a Sushi's map. Orz.

James2250 wrote:

Random Alace timing check (cuz I wasn't sure)

BPM: 188.000
Offset: 407

Call me back and I can prob bubble~

Rukarioman wrote:

General:
- Source: Yorinuki Gintama-san; why that? didn't all the previous maps of that anime have only the source "Gintama"? Please explain this.

On April 5, 2010, TV Tokyo stations began airing high-definition reruns of older episodes of Gin Tama under the title Yorinuki Gin Tama-san

do your research
Shinpachi:
Tick rate 2 looks a bit spammy on this diff. Maybe go for 1 in this one? nah
Otherwise fine.^^

Kagura:
Nothing

Gintoki:
Nthing either.

aru's Taiko:
Everything seems fine here too.

Yeah nothing much to say^^, pretty good mapset.