forum

Hatsune Miku - "Hetalia Nordic 5" Ban Ban Boo

posted
Total Posts
114
show more
Tanmak
Great.

There is no fixing object.

Good job~

;)
Your message is too short.
Zelos
Well lets get started

Folder:
Clean

General:
0.5 tickrate is no longer allowed (Mint Bunnies diff) I suggest you change it to tick rate 2 like the rest of the difficulties.
Keep your kiai times consistent please

Any mod is a suggestion and can be ignored

Norway + Iceland:
00:22:676 (1,2) - you should vertically align these by moving note 2 slightly over to the right. it makes it neater.
00:30:219 (2,3,4,5,6) - you should horizontally aligh these by moving 3,4,5,6 down a little bit. makes it neater also.
00:59:705 (1,2) - the hiding of the beginning of slider 2 halfway under slider 1 isnt unrankable but it isnt that good looking either, possibly change this?
01:02:448 (1,2) - ^^
01:10:676 (3) - this slider is really unsymmetrical. I decided to fix it for you. it now looks like this

its a teensy bit off but it will definitely do much better. click the code box for the slider code and paste it where its supposed to be in the .osu
352,216,70676,6,0,B|256:296|176:208,2,200,4|0|8

01:20:276 (4,5) - horizontally align the end of 4 with note 5 or vice versa, it would look neater.
01:29:876 (1,2,3) - the spacing here is slightly inconsistent. fix?
01:47:705 (5,6) - not many easy players can read the note under the end of slider 5, I suggest you move it from under 5.

Sweden + Finland:
00:18:562 (1,2,3,4) - this pattern here as some inconsistent distance spacing, you should possibly fix this so that the spacing makes it symmetrical once more.
00:19:934 (5,6) - move 6 to the right 1 grid point so it verticaly lives up with slider 5?
00:55:248 (4,5) - the ends are slightly unstacked, adjust them so that the ends are stacked? it would look neater.
00:59:705 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5) - these are too hard for normal players in my opinion, please change these to something else.
01:27:819 (3,5) - delete slider 5, copy slider 3 and paste it into slider 5s original position so it becomes stacked correctly again.
01:31:248 (1,1) - the 1/1 distance between this spinner and this note might be a bit hard for the Normal players to re-adjust there arms and hit in time.
01:48:048 (4,5,6,7,8) - might be to many half notes for a Normal player to hit but that maybe just my opinion too.

Denmark:
00:45:648 (7,1,2) - inconsistent spacing here. its a bit obvious, might wanna fix.
Thats it on this difficulty, they were much better than the other 2 so far.

Mint Bunnies diff:
01:04:505 (6,1) - these are too close considering previous spacing, people would easily confused it for half notes.
Yes the 2 insanes were better looking

Good Luck!
Topic Starter
Celeste76

Zelos wrote:

Any mod is a suggestion and can be ignored


Sweden + Finland:
I like them that way
01:27:819 (3,5) - delete slider 5, copy slider 3 and paste it into slider 5s original position so it becomes stacked correctly again.
01:31:248 (1,1) - the 1/1 distance between this spinner and this note might be a bit hard for the Normal players to re-adjust there arms and hit in time. I think it's just fine...
Thank you for the mod! I did everything except the above!
tutuhaha
B....BL?!0口0.........
(¯﹃¯)b I like it, so nice~~~~~~~~APH APH lalalala~~~

Norway + Iceland
00:24:048 (1) - end in 00:26:105-to short in easy
00:31:591 (5,6) - change in one slider beacuse in easy 6 is to hard(slider00:31:591 to 00:32:105 is best)
00:37:762 (1) - space
00:41:876 (6) - this slider I think end in 00:42:476 and the add repeat(Return) is good
00:49:419 (1) - Don't Overlapping, put it like this →http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/157531
00:54:219 (1) - Delete, too hard in easy
00:56:962 (1) - end on 00:59:019
01:10:676 (3) - use this↓
352,216,70676,2,0,B|256:264|160:216,2,200,0|4|0
01:23:019 (2) - move 2 to there,too hard in easy
01:31:248 (1) - use this↓
136,112,91248,5,4
72,160,91591,1,4
96,240,91934,1,4
176,240,92276,1,4
200,160,92619,1,4
01:48:734 (6) - Don't overlapping

Sweden + Finland
00:31:934 (7) - add one repeat(return)
00:36:391 (5) - ^
00:52:505 (3) - ^
00:55:248 (4) - .....Tail overlapping?
00:59:705 (1-5) - ....I really don't like this.....they look very crowded and ugly D:.......
01:02:448 (1-5) - ^
01:17:362 (2) - change a slider end on 01:17:962 is best than this I think
01:27:819 (3) - use this ↓
280,72,87819,2,0,B|360:48|408:112,1,140,0|8
376,216,88505,2,0,B|296:240|248:176,1,140,0|8
280,72,89191,2,0,B|360:48|408:112,1,140,0|8

Denmark
00:56:962 (1) - too short,change on slider or circle

Mint's Nordic 5 [Insane]
00:21:819 (2) - delete it and put there one circle and then move 3 and 4 on 00:21:991 and 00:22:334
and then add one ciecle on 00:22:676, listen better, right?
01:04:848 (1) - space

Denmark listen like Mint's Nordic 5 [Insane]..
trouble D:
some new Beat↓ I think you need delete some note

Download: Hatsune Miku - Ban Ban Boo (Celeste76) [Denmark2].osu
Mint Bunny

tutuhaha wrote:

Mint's Nordic 5 [Insane]
00:21:819 (2) - delete it and put there one circle and then move 3 and 4 on 00:21:991 and 00:22:334
and then add one ciecle on 00:22:676, listen better, right? What does that even mean? :<
Did all but above. Sorry for making you wait.
Download: Hatsune Miku - Ban Ban Boo (Celeste76) [Mint's Nordic 5 [Insane]].osu
Topic Starter
Celeste76

tutuhaha wrote:

B....BL?!0口0.........
(¯﹃¯)b I like it, so nice~~~~~~~~APH APH lalalala~~~

Norway + Iceland
01:10:676 (3) - use this↓
352,216,70676,2,0,B|256:264|160:216,2,200,0|4|0
01:23:019 (2) - move 2 to there,too hard in easy No.
01:31:248 (1) - use this↓
136,112,91248,5,4
72,160,91591,1,4
96,240,91934,1,4
176,240,92276,1,4
200,160,92619,1,4
It's just fine.

Sweden + Finland
00:31:934 (7) - add one repeat(return) No.
00:55:248 (4) - .....Tail overlapping? I like it that way.
00:59:705 (1-5) - ....I really don't like this.....they look very crowded and ugly D:....... No.
01:02:448 (1-5) - ^^
01:17:362 (2) - change a slider end on 01:17:962 is best than this I think No.
01:27:819 (3) - use this ↓
280,72,87819,2,0,B|360:48|408:112,1,140,0|8
376,216,88505,2,0,B|296:240|248:176,1,140,0|8
280,72,89191,2,0,B|360:48|408:112,1,140,0|8
It's just fine.

Denmark
00:56:962 (1) - too short,change on slider or circle No.
Thank you for the mod! I did everything but the above!
Neptunus
Hey~

General:
NOTE THAT SLIDER TICK RATE OF 0.5 IN Mint's Nordic [Insane] IS UNRANKABLE NOW!! BASED ON THE NEW RULE, ATTENTION PLEASE!

Nice hitsound but the gap between the first 2 diffculties are huge with 1.99 stars vs. 4.44 stars.

Norway + Iceland:
To keep consistency, 00:21:305 (3) - newcombo here and cancel newcombo here 00:22:676 (1) -
Again about consistency , you can either newcombo here at00:40:505 (4) - or you can cancel newcombo at 00:45:991 (1) -
Also here 01:46:334 (4) - newcombo here or cancel newcombo at 01:40:162 (1) -

Sweden + Finland
00:47:019 (3,4,5) - spacing problem between 3 and 4 regarding what you have spaced in 00:46:333 (1,2,3) -

Denmark:
01:43:591 (1) - why suddenly put such interval ? I suggest long sliders in this area

Mint's Nordic [Insane]:
01:43:591 (7) - cancel newcombo here and start newcombo here at 01:44:105 (1) -


thats it ,
good luck on ranking~ ;)
Topic Starter
Celeste76

Neptunus wrote:

Hey~
Denmark:
01:43:591 (1) - why suddenly put such interval ? I suggest long sliders in this area I like it the way I did it.
good luck on ranking~ ;)
Thank you for the mod! I did everything but the above!
eldnl
[General]

- I download the song with the video but this is not in the folder, please put the video in the folder and do a full submit. Also use the same video offset in all difficulties, in Denmark difficulty is different.
- You use the same slider velocity in normal, hard and insane, you should fix it.
- Use the same kiai time in all difficulties, actually is different in the insane difficulty.
- Use the same Audio lead-in on all difficulties, is different in the insane difficulty again.

[Mint's Nordic 5 [Insane]]

Slider tick rate 0.5 is unrankable, you should change it to 1.
Can't understand the name of this difficulty, just rename it to "Mint's Nordic 5" but with the "[Insane]" looks really weird, you should change it.
OD 7 is really annoying see lots of 100s = ='.
00:03:476 (5) To be consistent you need a new combo here.
00:07:591 (5) Add a new combo here and remove in the next note, the new combo should be in the white big tick.
00:08:962 (4) ^ Same as above.
00:10:334 (4) ^ Same as above.
00:19:419 (5) Sliders like this are very hard to read, you can't tell when they're going to end, and this feels that the next (1) is in the white tick, If you don't want to change it, please consider this for the future.
00:36:905 (5) The second reverse-arrow of this slider is hidden by the previous hit-burst, you should unstack (4,5).
00:39:476 - A Clap should be here, also you forgot the clap pattern here 00:43:248 because the clap should be in the second and fourth white tick.
00:51:476 - It's better if you end the spinner in the previous white tick (00:51:134) and add a note here.
00:54:219 - The volume down feels really weird, don't fit with the music, If you really want to keep this, up the volume a little in the lower part.
00:56:105 (6) To be consistent with the previous pattern, needs a new combo here.
01:02:105 (1) These slowdown sliders are very hard to read, have the same size as the sliders 1/4, strongly suggest to use 0.75x slowdown and make the slider different.
01:04:848 (1) ^ Same as above, also you can use the same slider.
01:10:676 - You use a wrong clap pattern in this part, please follow this pattern.
01:49:076 (5) Down this note a little, is touching the score bar.

[Denmark]

00:37:419 (7) I suggest to just add a repeat in (7) and delete (8), can't see the reason to make it harder.
00:56:962 - Really short spinner, also the next note is very close to the spinner, the player need recover the control of the cursor, more if is an unexpected short spin, strongly suggest to extend the spin to 00:59:362. Feels better.
01:10:676 (1,2) Spacing error between these sliders.
01:14:791 (7) Needs a new combo here.
01:19:934 (4,5) Spacing error between these notes.

[Sweden + Finland]

If this is the normal difficulty you should reduce the difficulty, I say:
OD-2
AP-1
HP-1
00:26:791 (1) Feels empty, maybe add a finish?
00:47:019 (3,4) Spacing error between these notes.
00:55:934 (5,6) Add a repeat on (5) and delete (6), it's a little hard to read for beginners.
00:59:705 - Really hard pattern to be a normal difficulty, you should change it to something more readable for beginners.
01:32:962 (1) This note is very close to the spin, I suggest to delete this note.
01:42:905 (6,7) Just add a repeat in (6) and delete (7), don't try to make the easier difficulties more harder, make no sense.

[Norway + Iceland]

00:24:048 - End the spinner in the big white tick, fit better with the song and increase the spacing between the spin and the next note.
00:41:876 (6) The repeat in the blue tick don't follow the music, extend the spin to the next white tick and remove (1), it's better. Don't forgot to add a new combo in the next note.
00:56:619 (4) Please don't stack this note and complete the square.
01:22:848 (2) Please don't put notes in the red ticks, it's hard to read for beginners, use a slider here, it's better.

That's all, star and good luck. (:
Topic Starter
Celeste76

eldnl wrote:

[General]

- I download the song with the video but this is not in the folder, please put the video in the folder and do a full submit. Also use the same video offset in all difficulties, in Denmark difficulty is different. There is no video...
- You use the same slider velocity in normal, hard and insane, you should fix it. Does it really matter?

[Denmark]

00:37:419 (7) I suggest to just add a repeat in (7) and delete (8), can't see the reason to make it harder. No.
00:56:962 - Really short spinner, also the next note is very close to the spinner, the player need recover the control of the cursor, more if is an unexpected short spin, strongly suggest to extend the spin to 00:59:362. Feels better. No.

[Sweden + Finland]

If this is the normal difficulty you should reduce the difficulty, I say:
OD-2 -1
00:55:934 (5,6) Add a repeat on (5) and delete (6), it's a little hard to read for beginners. It's just fine.
00:59:705 - Really hard pattern to be a normal difficulty, you should change it to something more readable for beginners. I like it that way.
01:32:962 (1) This note is very close to the spin, I suggest to delete this note. No.
01:42:905 (6,7) Just add a repeat in (6) and delete (7), don't try to make the easier difficulties more harder, make no sense. No.

[Norway + Iceland]
01:22:848 (2) Please don't put notes in the red ticks, it's hard to read for beginners, use a slider here, it's better. It's just fine.

That's all, star and good luck. (:
Thank you for the mod! I did everything except the above!
eldnl


If you don't have the video need to delete it on all difficulties.
-Baby Strawberry-
Hihi~! I was really shocked that u got soooooo many moddings..
anyways, start modding~! here we go~!

General
SPOILER
actually the skin is good, but there are still some problems i think:
http://puu.sh/8Qap this is to big. make it smaller or change it into something else.
http://puu.sh/8QaG make these go up a little bit, since http://puu.sh/8Qb9,i think it is too low..
http://puu.sh/8QbSthis is a llittle bit big compared to other maps. if this is what u want, nvm.
add some decorations at the edgehttp://puu.sh/8QiB
For the diff names, i don't know if they are rankable or not since there's no indication of diff levels.

【Denmark】diff
SPOILER
00:15:819 (1,2,3,4) - DO use the same shape by copy and paste
00:27:819 (4,5,6) - how about this?http://puu.sh/8QcX
00:32:276 (1,3,4) - same shape problem
00:45:991 (1,2,3,4) - move them to be more beautiful
00:52:848 (1) - how about this? http://puu.sh/8Qee
00:54:562 (1,2,3) - too much blocking, separate them a little bit.
00:59:705 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - same shape problem
01:02:448 (1,2,3,4,5) - same shape problem
01:10:676 (1,2) - same shape
01:18:905 (1,3,5,6,7,8) - same shape
01:24:733 (2,3,4) - same shape
01:27:133 (1,2) - how about put these two on the left top corner?
01:28:505 (1,2) - if u did^, put this on the right bottom corner.
01:42:562 (3,4,5) - shape
For all the shape problems, if u could make them all the same by copying, pasting and rotating the best shaped slider, i think u will get a better effect.

【Mint's Nordic 5】diff
SPOILER
00:06:562 (2,3) - no finish?
00:07:934 (2,3) - no finish?
00:25:591 (1) -from here, i don't think u need to use any whistlers.the whistler is a sharp sound, if u use is at a good point, perfect, i will give u an awesome effect; if u over use it, it will oppositely break your ears. Miku's voice is pretty sharp, so i dont think whistler is suitable for this song, or u may use it at some points but not all the time.
01:09:648 (1) - do it like this?http://puu.sh/8Qib

【Sweden + Finland】diff
SPOILER
btw, is it supposed to be a hard or a normal?
if its a normal, OD -2, remove some notes if possible. if its a hard, u can HR+1or even +2 i think.
00:28:505 (6,7) - same shape
00:50:791 (7,8) - move these 2 up to the same height as 00:50:448 (6)
00:55:248 (4,5) - shape and move the tails be on a same spot
01:21:648 (1,2,3) - personally i dont like this pattern's shape
【Norway + Iceland】diff
SPOILER
i think this is an [easy] diff, so OD-1 or -2
00:23:705 (4) - left a little bit?
00:32:962 (2,3,4) - shape problem
01:03:819 (2) - right a little bit?
01:31:248 (1,2,3,4,5) - make the shape better like a star
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Also for the hit sound,i think u should re-do it in some sections. be careful at some detailed parts such as the shape of a sliders. though they do not have big differences, it Does affect ur map. try to make them in same shapes if possible to see if it make u feel better. ;)
Good Luck :)
Since I am a new modder, all the moddings are ONLY PERSONAL SUGGESTIONS.
Topic Starter
Celeste76

-Baby Strawberry- wrote:

Hihi~! I was really shocked that u got soooooo many moddings..
anyways, start modding~! here we go~!

General
SPOILER
actually the skin is good, but there are still some problems i think:
http://puu.sh/8Qap this is to big. make it smaller or change it into something else.
http://puu.sh/8QaG make these go up a little bit, since http://puu.sh/8Qb9,i think it is too low..
http://puu.sh/8QbSthis is a llittle bit big compared to other maps. if this is what u want, nvm.
add some decorations at the edgehttp://puu.sh/8QiB
For the diff names, i don't know if they are rankable or not since there's no indication of diff levels.
At the moment, I won't be able to fix anything about the skin since my photoshop stopped working. I might do it later though...

【Denmark】diff
00:45:991 (1,2,3,4) - move them to be more beautiful What do you mean about this one?
00:59:705 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - same shape problem Doesn't really matter.
01:02:448 (1,2,3,4,5) - same shape problem This looks fine
01:27:133 (1,2) - how about put these two on the left top corner? It's fine.
01:28:505 (1,2) - if u did^, put this on the right bottom corner. ^
01:42:562 (3,4,5) - shape Looks fine to me
For all the shape problems, if u could make them all the same by copying, pasting and rotating the best shaped slider, i think u will get a better effect.

【Sweden + Finland】diff
btw, is it supposed to be a hard or a normal? It's a normal
if its a normal, OD -2, remove some notes if possible. if its a hard, u can HR+1or even +2 i think. I -1 on OD
00:55:248 (4,5) - shape and move the tails be on a same spot I tried.
【Norway + Iceland】diff
01:31:248 (1,2,3,4,5) - make the shape better like a star It's fine the way it is.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Also for the hit sound,i think u should re-do it in some sections. be careful at some detailed parts such as the shape of a sliders. though they do not have big differences, it Does affect ur map. try to make them in same shapes if possible to see if it make u feel better. ;)
Good Luck :)
Since I am a new modder, all the moddings are ONLY PERSONAL SUGGESTIONS.
Thanks for the mod! I did everything but the above!
SinDemonDragon13
+star <3
wmfchris
Modding here:

[General]
- Your images are mainly in PNG form, and those like BG images can be in large size. Please change it into JPG to reduce the size a bit.
- I think you will need about 1500/2000 audio lead in there.
- If you maintain 3000 lead-in, switch on countdown for all diffs, otherwise close for all of them.
- Inconsistency in preview time for all diff, try to reset it once again.
- Inconsistency for tags in [Nodric 5]
- Please snap all the kiai time start and ending on beats.

Well I don't get the meaning of difficulty names orz

[Nodric 5]
00:03:476 (1,2,3,...) - maintain 0.7x spacing
00:21:305 (7) - new combo here
00:22:162 (3) - clap
00:24:048 (8) - finish instead of clap
00:38:105 (3) - down 1 grid to make it symmetrical
00:47:534 (1,2,3,4) - down a bit to make it symmetrical around the center :3
00:54:905 (5,2,2) - remove clap to fit with bass
00:56:105 (1,6) - remove NC (new combo) on (1), NC on (6)
01:12:734 (4,5,6,1) - well I don't think this fits with increasing spacing

[Denmark]
00:18:391 (7) - clap?
00:23:019 (2,3,...7) - finish on (2,4,6) rather on (3,5,7) as the music sounds like that
00:35:019 (1,2) - remove finish on the whole slider, finish on the beginning note only
01:42:562 (4,5,6) - not suggested to place like this because no one knows what slider shape is hidden under another slider on the first sight, which confuses player.

[Sweden]
00:19:934 (5) - touched the score bar so not suggested to put like this. Try to put (1,2,3,4) in square/rhombus shape, then place (5,6) in a flatter shape?
01:15:819 (6) - right 1 grid

It's nice to see some older hitsound style which sounds well there. I think there could be more variation like the beginning of [Nodric 5], and there're many arrangements that contain minor spacing problems which can be fixed by your current grid level so I'll suggest you to fix it by yourself.

...wait this is graveyarded? orz

Feel like my modding skill improved a lot since my last mod here 14 months ago
Topic Starter
Celeste76

wmfchris wrote:

Modding here:

[General]
- Your images are mainly in PNG form, and those like BG images can be in large size. Please change it into JPG to reduce the size a bit. I'll do that when I get on a different computer :3
- I think you will need about 1500/2000 audio lead in there. Is it all right if I ask what this means?
- If you maintain 3000 lead-in, switch on countdown for all diffs, otherwise close for all of them.

Well I don't get the meaning of difficulty names orz Oh, they're the names of the characters in the background xP
Thanks so much for the mod! Mint Bunny will do her mod later. I did everything except for the above?
wmfchris
Song setup -> audio -> music track - audio lead-in
osu! gameplay plays the song from 00:00:00. So if the music starts to early, players' reaction time for the first note may not be enough, then we need audio lead-in. If we hv 2000ms of audio lead-in, we have 2000ms of blank before music starts from 00:00:00. It's suggested that you should at least leave ~2-2.5 seconds before the first note comes.
Mint Bunny
Download: Hatsune Miku - Ban Ban Boo (Celeste76) [Mint's Nordic 5].osuSorry for the wait, did everything he suggested. Will change audio lead in when Celeste decides so it can be consistent.
Topic Starter
Celeste76

Mint Bunny wrote:

[attachment=0:a66e8]Hatsune Miku - Ban Ban Boo (Celeste76) [Mint's Nordic 5].osu[/attachment:a66e8]Sorry for the wait, did everything he suggested. Will change audio lead in when Celeste decides so it can be consistent.
I'm changing the audio lead in to 2000 :3
Topic Starter
Celeste76

wmfchris wrote:

Song setup -> audio -> music track - audio lead-in
osu! gameplay plays the song from 00:00:00. So if the music starts to early, players' reaction time for the first note may not be enough, then we need audio lead-in. If we hv 2000ms of audio lead-in, we have 2000ms of blank before music starts from 00:00:00. It's suggested that you should at least leave ~2-2.5 seconds before the first note comes.
Thanks so much for clearing that up!
Mint Bunny

Celeste76 wrote:

Mint Bunny wrote:

Sorry for the wait, did everything he suggested. Will change audio lead in when Celeste decides so it can be consistent.
I'm changing the audio lead in to 2000 :3
Mhmm~

Download: Hatsune Miku - Ban Ban Boo (Celeste76) [Mint's Nordic 5].osu
BanchoBot
This modding thread has been migrated to the new "modding discussions" system. Please make sure to re-post any existing (and unresolved) efforts to the new system as required.
Please sign in to reply.

New reply