Rohit6 wrote:

hell O
brackets are small suggestions for mostly aesthetics ,can ignore if you want to

[---xxX-RosEnKreuZ-Xxx---]

00:38:941 (7,1) - [Can make 7 either parallel or perpendicular to 1] Eh, I like up/down motion I have. I tried both, didn't really like it too much.

00:49:440 (2,3,4) - Line acceleration makes everything harder to hit man,use some sort of angle here or decrease spacing a bit or you could repeat 01:00:517 (2,3,4) - this Hm..I'll see what I can do with this if others think this is an issue.

01:08:017 (3,6) - [Ehh diagonal sliders dont really look good individually they look better if theyre in a pattern, would suggest curving them a bit or anchoring] 8)

01:16:094 (1,2) - Slider is pointing away from 2 which doesnt fit particularly well here , but the kink is kinda small so it might be okay for now Yeah, the way you motion to play this with that kink lets your cursor move more leftward to hit that next slider.

01:24:633 (2,3,4,5,6) - [Could make the star pattern neater i m o] Fixeddd

01:27:921 - Nice bookmark :^) thx fam it was for a previous mentioning, forgot to remove it. removed now ok

01:37:325 (1,2,3,4,5) - You could try some different patterns with this kind of slidershape because seeing the same pattern gets boring asf
Came up with this. You could try something else though idk that's not a bad alternative, but I think I'll keep what I have for now just cuz ive my ideas rollin' in nawmsayin

01:40:094 - I really dont like how the 1/3 sliders in these sections end on white ticks because beat priority , but if people can sightread it I guess I can let it slide How else to map this? Only 4 1/3 beats, pause at red, and then new measure comes up. It seems like it does fine on its own however.

01:48:402 (1,2,3,4) - Equal spacing is meh for emphasis imo , because the clap isnt getting the best emphasis , I'd suggest increasing spacing from 2->3 for a quick fix It's a little trick at high bpm to just mess with the spacing in that manner. And besides, its following through as rhombus on the background beats. : p

01:54:863 (1,2,3) - [Would look visually more appealing if you lined up 1 with 2 like this ] I guess it does. Fixed

01:57:517 (6,1,2,3) - Spacing is kinda jacked here because the strong->weak ones are having higher spacing than the weak->strong ones which gives emphasis to the wrong objects , would suggest something like 01:56:479 (3,4,1,2,3,4) - this I remapped this section because I didn't like how the emphasis/flow looked.

02:02:248 (1,2,3) - Equal spacing but this is kinda minor ,just reposition 2 a bit ,can also line it up with 1 like this tbh, im only trying to follow how the player would move, aligning it like that would be pretty strict.

02:04:094 (1,3) - [blanket xdd]

02:03:171 (1,2,3) - Inverse spacing again, higher between 2->3 than 1->2 please eh, I equalized the spacing

02:07:786 (1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3) - I dont understand the triangles here, theres no 1-2-3-1-2-3 in the beats or the melody its all 1-2-1-2-1-2 , the slider is okay i think Drums go boom boom boom, violin goes dun-nu-nu-nu-nu, its climax before building into the 2nd half of chorus.

02:09:633 (1,2,3) - I dont understand the huge backsnap to 2, 2 doesnt have enough to justify it imo , you could try this if you want to keep the same objects but rotated or flipped etc It's not that big of a jump. I do it to 'build up' into the repeat slider vocal stuff. also patterns.

02:10:902 (2,3,4) - [Could try this for better visual A E S T H E T I C S ] so nazi...ok

02:13:325 (1,2,3) - [Move 2 in line with 1 to fix minor spacing]

02:14:594 (2,3,4) - [Equal spacing would work better because theres no instruments to support the variable spacing] triangle pattern

02:16:556 (5,2) - [l2stack]

02:16:671 (6) - It would be better if 6 was somewhere towards the left so players can anticipate the triple and the sudden direction change okay, I also remapped a little bit of this section so it doesn't play so ass

02:18:863 (1,2,3) - Line acceleration is kinda awkward here , would suggest some sort of angle I think its ok

02:27:171 (5,6,7,8) - [Possible reading hazard?An NC might work on 8]

02:40:786 (6,1) - Dude what ,please you already know what I'm gonna say :^)

03:08:708 (1,2,3) - The backward snap again , I wouldve understood if it was on the guitar riff but its not so blegh , you should probably change to something thats a little less harsh on backward snapping here trust me, its not that hard to play lol, its pretty close to the slider and factor in leniency.

03:10:555 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,4) - Not 100% sure about this pattern because it seems kinda overspaced because you also use that kind of spacing in kiai , and because they're at 260 bpm I think you should tone it down a bit guitar xd its a buildup

03:19:785 (5) - NC for slowdown indication it's already on a new measure ;;

04:06:861 (1,2,3,4) - Same as 01:48:402 (1,2,3,4) same as before

04:17:938 (1,2,3,4) - [Personally I'd do thisfor a less sharp flow but the one you have is okay as well]

04:32:708 (1,2,3) - [Increase spacing from 2->3] they're equal distance apart

04:37:900 (4) - [Could drop 4 a bit lower for emphasizing that high pitch vocal and ofcourse making 4,2 and 5 in a line like this] sure, yea

04:46:554 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - NCs should be 1-2-1-2 because the huge bashing sound is what youre mapping to which is going 1-2-1-2 ohh fixded

04:49:323 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - sAme as ^ xddd

04:53:015 (1,2,3) - [Could do something better because this looks e.e]

05:19:785 (1,2,3) - Ctrl+g 3 for a more intuitive movement then I'd have to change the whole jumpsss!1 nah but I did it like this for emphasis on vocal and to reset towards center

05:29:015 (1,2,3,4) - The 1's slidershapes doesnt fit well if you wanna keep the rest of the pattern , this might work but the overlap is a bit too risky for such a high bpm , oh well

05:41:015 (1,2,3) - This has the same spacing as 05:41:938 (1,2,3) - but the spacing on the second one is asdf

nokd :^)

fieryrage wrote:

wow you requested a mod and here it is!!!!!

f

bg is not 1366x768 or like any 4:3 / 16:9 resolution scale (you could just resize it to 1024x768 and leave it at that and it should be fine) I still have the original at like 1400 x 1000 but that does't follow anything either. I scaled down cuz wasn't sure if there's a cap on the width.
00:14:669 (2) - you followed 1/2 rhythm and now 1/4 and this threw me off :< might be better as circles so no sliderbreaks Shouldn't be hard to read, but I closed in the DS to make it more readable as 1/4 I guess.
00:20:669 (5) - you silenced the other sliderends but not this one???? woops. Silenced
00:23:336 (6) - ^ same
00:55:325 (3,4) - ctrl+h? idk it felt better to me hmm, I guess this can work
01:13:786 (3,4) - ctrl+g because i hate ugly patterns intentional tho xdd
01:40:556 (3,4) - any slider pattern like these snapped to 1/3 don't really play well to me, might be better off just making it a 4 note circle stream or something like this 01:42:402 (3,4,5) I'll keep this in mind.. but rhythm variation is important
01:54:171 - is there any purpose for this green line oh lol removed
02:16:094 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - ur not saten xd
02:53:132 (6,8) - these two notes don't exist theres no sound there what are u doing pls just make 02:53:017 (5,7) - 1/4 sliders like the other ones before it deleted those two circles.
03:15:862 (1) - this is such a miniscule SV change, i don't really think a NC is necessary here ok I remove NC
03:19:785 (5) - this one on the other hand uhhhhh yeah, wanted to transition into a higher SV this way to promote le xd jumps coming at the end of this section
03:24:401 (3,4,5,6,7) - you said you wanted to add a stream in this map and this is like the perfect place to do it wtf yeah, someone else mentioned this to me irc. This would only be 1/3 streams however so I'll work with this and see how it goes and if it doesn't get implemented, then that's cuz i actually just really suck
03:28:093 (1) - might be better off as a spinner extending until the guitar fades at 03:30:862 I had this as a longer slider before but players got easily confused. I'll keep for now because I don't like the spinner on a similar sounding riff.
05:01:323 (1) - remove nc? sure
05:21:169 (2) - put nc here instead of 05:21:054 (1) I guess
05:35:938 (2) - ^ xd

Hula wrote:

Moderately unfair m4m going on here.

[Whatever it's called]
Not my sort of map personally. soz m8. I obviously can't focus on everything this map, so ye, you get certain points being brought up and maybe others being entirely ignored, but doesn't mean they won't exist if someone else brings them up .

AR is 10, just because 10 is perceived as skill and shit. Challenge people with lower ARs man, and also bring it into the range of people who can't read ar10, ar9.5 is a good competitor, whilst keeping it stupidly high but still within the realms of playability for people. Eh, I don't really care all too much about doing things "for the player" but rather just map how I perceive the music to be.

00:15:336 (3) - Soft whistle? You changed to using soft whistles for the vocals, then didn't bother with this one.
00:15:836 (1) - soft whistle start
00:16:502 (3) - Soft whistle start
00:20:669 (5) - Soft whistle start
00:22:502 (3) - Soft whislte
00:23:002 (5) - Soft whistle.
K, i'm gonna stop with the soft whistle spam suggestions. Basically I think here, you should use the soft whistles on the starts of vocals, that's what you were doing, but then missing out vocals for no reason . yeah...idk hitsounding not my forte

01:05:017 (1,2,3) - All of a sudden this spacing, it's a very big jump in difficulty, when there's nothing to justify it in the music from the previous times you mapped this.
01:06:863 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - In this violin section, You adopt 3 ways how to map the violin rhythm, this level of variation, takes away structure from the map, since you change how you map the rhythm every bar, despite it sounding the same. IMO, the first two bars should be the same pattern, slider spam is perfectly fine here and better than those circles, since I feel like it emphasises the violins more. I can agree with this. I fixed up the few that got rekt by my rhythm.

01:40:556 (3,4) - Why map this 1/3 as sliders? You would never know this 1/3 ever existed, these look like bog standard 1/4 sliders, and especially in a map like this, 1/3 shouldn't be undermapped cos it's hard or something lol. Later on, you map it like this 01:42:402 (3,4,5) - . This is kind of a key/unique feature of the song, so you should aim to have this represented very consistently, which it isn't being right now. tl;dr 1/3 sliders undermap this something rhythm and look like the normal 1/2 sliders. Personally I don't think it's really a big issue to include 2 1/3 sliders. But I will start with something easier to give the player a visual cue that there is 1/3 sliders here by using a 1/3 repeat.

At 01:54:171 - You could try something like this? I think it's cool. Add those 3 circles, cool as fuck I was actually very heavily considering doing this and I may or may not in the future. Only reason I don't have them now is because these jumps are brutal and it fits the music well to emphasize and end it off at the final jump and prepare before getting into crazy. (Also because the player can reset position or rest or w.e idk)

02:05:940 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - I find these boring to play, they shout lazy to me, Why not have some sort of rotating square business going on? the pattern at the end of the kiai does some batshit crazy things. I find this interesting BabyRage. Before, I used a 1/1 slider ordeal and rotating 120s, but I think this does a better job at building up into more deathjumps.

02:32:478 (3) - Soft whistle - Basically apply what I said to do at the start of the mod with those soft whistles and hitsounds. Basically, hitsound vocals or don't, don't stop half way through a pattern pls.

02:47:479 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3) - Overmap, and not exciting overmap either, it's just a bunch of fullscreen squares.

03:25:170 (7) - why not stream like earlier? Probably will end up making streams out of this section seeing as how most people want it and I think it works well too. Just gotta find a way to do it first.
03:34:554 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2) - This is mind numbing. At least map this with shapes or something. Currently they're super randomly placed on the playing field I'll consider fixing this. Might just make anti-jumpy single taps or something.

04:12:631 - Apply that thing at 01:54:171 - if you accept it

04:46:554 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - Why are you suddenly NC spamming? Remove NC spam, it adds nothing except increased difficulty of reading. And it unnecessarily messes with HP drain. yknow, I dont know why this had to be complicated in the first place. I had weirder NC's before but I'll just keep it at one.


Sorry, bored of song now, good luck and stuff.