Recheck,
About the spinner, listen at 25% speed playback (be sure to remove spinner so there is no sound at the end of it to distract you). 01:29:141 is where I consider the volume of music to be equal to 5% in term of osu! hitsound volume. At 01:29:291, there is no sound at all (thus 0% would fit here if it were rankable). Also at about, 01:28:391, you see a clear decrescendo or the music is getting softer, since you used one timing point, the spinner volume stay the same while, the music doesn't. That's why I suggest for you to add some timing point so that the spinner bonus sound sounds more inline with how the music is. Personally, this is how I would do it.
I won't force you through, from what I gather, not many people seem to notice this, but it's something that will make your beatmap more perfect.
[Easy]
00:00:481 (1) - Check all the other diff and you don't have a timing point here, so I'll assume you forgot to remove the timing point here.Remove this timing point so this note is 60% volume, too soft atm.
Forgot to put whistle at begin? Pretty sure I mention these in my earlier mod
00:02:281 (3) - Whistle at begin
00:04:081 (5) - Whistle on repeat
00:07:081 (2) - Whistle on begin and end
Forgot these too?
00:51:491 (3) - This need a whistle at end on it sounds incomplete
01:03:491 (3) - I suggest to add whistle before, but it would be better to do finish at begin like 00:53:891 (1) -
01:05:891 (2) - ^, for consistency with 00:56:291 (3) -
All should be fixed as most have to be with consistency and since you've said they were changed.
[Normal]
00:11:581 (2) - Need a whistle here to finish this hitsound pattern.
00:16:381 (2) - Music doesn't change in anyway, the guitar continues to play the same rhythm so should add a whistle at begin.
00:23:581 (6) - ^
00:37:081 (7) - Get the feeling this curve can be better, try the new circular slider? Change this line
00:47:291 (5,6) - Inconsistency with Hard, either add whistle to the hit circles on red tick in Hard or remove from end here. I prefer removing the whistles.
00:51:491 (5) - Add whistle at end, as it's inconsistent with 01:02:291 (7) - atm (at the moment)
01:06:491 (5) - Whistle on repeat?
01:08:291 (1) - Need a whistle at end if you have one at end of 01:10:691 (1) -
01:14:291 (2) - Sound much better to me if whistle follow only violin, so remove the whistle from begin of this slider
Everything should be fixed except for stuff marked with ?
[Hard]
00:11:581 (3) - Whistle at begin, same as Hard regarding this
00:20:881 (3) - Whistle at end, same reason as above
00:23:581 (5) - Whistle here
00:25:681 (2) - Whistle at end
00:29:281 (6) - You may want to change to this rhythm instead http://puu.sh/1r0hP to follow drums, I hear the drum sounds so it felt weird playing a long slider.
00:37:981 (2) - Sound better to me without whistle
00:49:991 (3) - Whistle at end
01:01:091 (1) - Feel better if no jump on this note, picture so that it's more clear http://puu.sh/1r0mJ. Basically, just move (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) so that there is no jump on this note and adjust following notes. I think this make it play nicer, but your opinion may differ.
01:14:591 (4,5) - Whistle on (4) and on the repeat of (5) [Same whistle pattern as Hard]
01:18:791 (3) - Sound better without whistle at end
All should be fixed except rhythm and pattern suggestions.
Hmm, still some issues, but if you follow everything, hitsound should be perfect now. I'll come back again and hopefully star this. Also one other thing, no video? I always prefer playing with video and I checked if there was a video for this and there was. If you don't know how to encode a video, I can do this for you. Those who dislike video can always use no video mod/download without video anyways so it would be nice for those who prefer playing with it
You can kudosu this post if you find it helpful, good luck!
About the spinner, listen at 25% speed playback (be sure to remove spinner so there is no sound at the end of it to distract you). 01:29:141 is where I consider the volume of music to be equal to 5% in term of osu! hitsound volume. At 01:29:291, there is no sound at all (thus 0% would fit here if it were rankable). Also at about, 01:28:391, you see a clear decrescendo or the music is getting softer, since you used one timing point, the spinner volume stay the same while, the music doesn't. That's why I suggest for you to add some timing point so that the spinner bonus sound sounds more inline with how the music is. Personally, this is how I would do it.
01:27:791 - 25% volume
01:28:091 - 20% volume
01:28:391 - 15% volume
01:28:691 - 10% volume
01:28:991 - 5% volume
This represent what I mention above perfectly (decrescendo, no sound in music at the end...)
01:28:091 - 20% volume
01:28:391 - 15% volume
01:28:691 - 10% volume
01:28:991 - 5% volume
This represent what I mention above perfectly (decrescendo, no sound in music at the end...)
[Easy]
00:00:481 (1) - Check all the other diff and you don't have a timing point here, so I'll assume you forgot to remove the timing point here.Remove this timing point so this note is 60% volume, too soft atm.
Forgot to put whistle at begin? Pretty sure I mention these in my earlier mod
00:02:281 (3) - Whistle at begin
00:04:081 (5) - Whistle on repeat
00:07:081 (2) - Whistle on begin and end
Forgot these too?
00:13:081 (3) - Maybe whistle here...00:25:081 (1) - Add a whistle at begin
00:15:481 (1,2) - Whistle at begin of (1) and on (2) It may sound nicer to do a low volume finish ta begin of (1) like 00:17:881 (1) -
00:18:781 (2) - Whistle at begin
00:22:681 (3) - Whistle here
00:51:491 (3) - This need a whistle at end on it sounds incomplete
01:03:491 (3) - I suggest to add whistle before, but it would be better to do finish at begin like 00:53:891 (1) -
01:05:891 (2) - ^, for consistency with 00:56:291 (3) -
All should be fixed as most have to be with consistency and since you've said they were changed.
[Normal]
00:11:581 (2) - Need a whistle here to finish this hitsound pattern.
00:16:381 (2) - Music doesn't change in anyway, the guitar continues to play the same rhythm so should add a whistle at begin.
00:23:581 (6) - ^
00:37:081 (7) - Get the feeling this curve can be better, try the new circular slider? Change this line
452,164,37081,2,0,B|492:128|484:72|432:40|384:72,2,160,8|8|8,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0to
452,164,37081,2,0,P|492:128|484:72|432:40|384:72,2,160,8|8|8,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0Then remove two anchor points so that you only have three, for example http://puu.sh/1r05m
00:47:291 (5,6) - Inconsistency with Hard, either add whistle to the hit circles on red tick in Hard or remove from end here. I prefer removing the whistles.
00:51:491 (5) - Add whistle at end, as it's inconsistent with 01:02:291 (7) - atm (at the moment)
01:06:491 (5) - Whistle on repeat?
01:08:291 (1) - Need a whistle at end if you have one at end of 01:10:691 (1) -
01:14:291 (2) - Sound much better to me if whistle follow only violin, so remove the whistle from begin of this slider
Everything should be fixed except for stuff marked with ?
[Hard]
00:11:581 (3) - Whistle at begin, same as Hard regarding this
00:20:881 (3) - Whistle at end, same reason as above
00:23:581 (5) - Whistle here
00:25:681 (2) - Whistle at end
00:29:281 (6) - You may want to change to this rhythm instead http://puu.sh/1r0hP to follow drums, I hear the drum sounds so it felt weird playing a long slider.
00:37:981 (2) - Sound better to me without whistle
00:49:991 (3) - Whistle at end
01:01:091 (1) - Feel better if no jump on this note, picture so that it's more clear http://puu.sh/1r0mJ. Basically, just move (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) so that there is no jump on this note and adjust following notes. I think this make it play nicer, but your opinion may differ.
01:14:591 (4,5) - Whistle on (4) and on the repeat of (5) [Same whistle pattern as Hard]
01:18:791 (3) - Sound better without whistle at end
All should be fixed except rhythm and pattern suggestions.
Hmm, still some issues, but if you follow everything, hitsound should be perfect now. I'll come back again and hopefully star this. Also one other thing, no video? I always prefer playing with video and I checked if there was a video for this and there was. If you don't know how to encode a video, I can do this for you. Those who dislike video can always use no video mod/download without video anyways so it would be nice for those who prefer playing with it
You can kudosu this post if you find it helpful, good luck!