Gens wrote:

[Overall]
-

whymeman wrote:

Did some reconstructing and decided to have only two difficulties for this map.

Whyyyy poor newbies
IMO you need an [Easy].

- Waah lower down the beat volume please.

- There's no Fade-Out on the MP3 which could be a little strange. O_o

[All difficulties]
01:19:67 - Why the fountain?

[Good For Me]
- What's up with the random velocity changes? It's fine though.
02:01:05 (1) - wtf @ reverse arrow

[No Good For Me]
No problems here, except that I'd like to see more sliders on the 2x'd sections.
(What a trip, man. @_@ I won't be FCing this soon)

~ ~ ~

So yeah, not many problems here.
Starred~

Shinde wrote:

All Difficulties
The song has a really heavy beat, but I still feel you have the Hitsounds up too loud. I would take it down between 2 and 3 notches.
I really feel this song needs an easier difficulty. You could even make it shorter and end it at 1:41:195 since an easy-normal difficulty for this song would probably be fairly boring/repetative if you mapped the full 3+ minutes.

General
The Offset seemed fine for me. I was getting between ~4ms late to 2ms early on playthroughs on Good For Me. Color choice for the notes was good and the shades didn't blend into the background, which made me happy.

[Good For Me]
0:44:919 (1) - Try removing this and see if you like the feel of this combo better.
2:48:230 (3,4,5,6,7) - Can you respace this somehow? It looks a bit odd.

I like the use of Kiai spray as a warning. I hate ninja tricky parts/changes so that helped.

[No Good For Me]
All fine to me. Jump spacing kills me.

I liked the use of clap hitsounds. Catchy. ;o I didn't really see much of anything wrong with this though.

Star'd. But seriously, consider adding an easier difficulty. You had 4 before right? I think you should bring the easier of the two back.

Nexy wrote:

I don't like how the normal-sliderslide sounds on Easy & Good. A silent one sounds better in my opinion. You don't have to change it, just wanted to say it D:!

Easy:
The sped up sliders might be too hard for easy.

Good:
03:18:85 (1,2,1,2) - I think these should be removed. Sounds good ending on the spinner.

No Good:
02:41:81 (8) - New combo.

I love No Good for me, so fun ^o^! Awesome map.

whymeman wrote:

And yes, I do wish there was a fade out for the MP3 also, but its the best I can get it for now....

vytalibus wrote:

Offset: 255 ms. (Yes, you're off by +25 ms. The beats are a bit hard to interpret, but here's what I came up with.)
BPM: 145.00 (Apparently, with the offset I gave above, I've managed to get a flat 145 BPM instead.)

Saturos-fangirl wrote:

for some reason the mp3 disappeared. it makes it relli hard to mod so ill come back later k?

mrtn wrote:

timing seems fine to me

[easy for me]
spacing is pretty cramped, I'd space it out some more. easy players will probably click way to fast now.
02:20:53 - reinsert break (Done)

[hard for me] (done)
01:19:75 - speed up in this section is out of place This one should be okay. I wanted it to appear before it starts. Though I do want to make sure the players can see it as well.
02:01:08 - ^ (Checked)
02:54:05 - ^ (Checked)

[no good for me] (done)
the speedups are out place again imo...

good job, starred

Saturos-fangirl wrote:

[Easy]
doesnt play....


[Hard]
the ending is kinda..odd


[No Good]
doesnt play....aghh


T_T i tried...

lukewarmholiday wrote:

Hard For Me

01:56:53 (2,3,4,5) - increase the spacing between 2 and 3 or change where the beats are snapped on the timeline because I had no chance reading that right.

02:10:59 (4,5,1,2,3) - spaced same on board but spaced clearly differently on timeline, is this intentional? (I suppose it is but that is how the distance snap placed it.)

That's all.

Aeon wrote:

hey man ^^ here goes some whymeman style modding

so much stuff to mod xD i hope i didnt forget/mistake anything

[.OSZ checkup] (Checked)

SPOILER

Video: No
Skin: Yes
Size: 5.00 MB / 10.00 MB[PASS]
Source: No [FAIL] [Please add the Source to all difficulties.] I Would add in the source if ther was one ^_^;;. I know the anime-style bg's might be confusing when it comes to this.
Tags: Yes [The Prodigy No Good Start The Dance][PASS]

[Timing] (Checked)

SPOILER

Timing (BPM / Offset): 145.000 / 255 ms[PASS]

[Easy For Me] (Checked)

SPOILER

StoryBoard: No
[Current] Slider Velocity/Tick Rate : 1.0 / 1[PASS]
Distance Snap: x0.8[PASS]
[Current] Objects: 168 ( 122 Circles / 44 Sliders / 2 Spinners )[PASS]
[Current] Max Combo: 262[PASS]
[Current] Max Score: 879,432/10,000,000[PASS]
[Current] Star Rating: 2.51[PASS]
[Current] HP Drain Rate: Lv. 3[PASS]
[Current] Circle Size: Lv. 2[PASS]
[Current] Overall Difficulty: Lv. 4[PASS]

Beat Placement mod

not much to point out here, apart from a few pace changes like this one here 00:51:565(1), this might be a little much
for a beginner, but its not something you NEED to change (Fixed)

01:36:255(3) it would be more within the rhythm if you moved it by half a beat (I think i'll leave this be. It might complicate things...)

needs more hitsounds (Did a touch up on what I missed.)

[Normal For Me] (Checked)

SPOILER

[Current] Slider Velocity/Tick Rate : 1.0 / 1[PASS]
Distance Snap: x0.8[PASS]
[Current] Objects: 214 ( 165 Circles / 47 Sliders / 2 Spinners )[PASS]
[Current] Max Combo: 301[PASS]
[Current] Max Score: 1,262,200/10,000,000[PASS]
[Current] Star Rating: 3.62[PASS]
[Current] HP Drain Rate: Lv. 4[PASS](wouldnt hurt if it was 5)
[Current] Circle Size: Lv. 2[PASS]
[Current] Overall Difficulty: Lv. 5[PASS](wouldnt hurt if it was 6)

Beat Placement mod

00:43:082(4) i think it would sound better if you removed this (Done)

01:04:806(1) reducing the slider by half a beat and adding a note one beat later will great a better rhythm (I'll keep it as it is. I fear that making the map too "straight-forward" would make it boring since it is a less but still simple difficulty.)

02:00:255(3) add 2 notes each of them half a beat later than the other (I think its fine as it is though.)

02:30:048(4) this would sound better if you moved it by half a beat (Thought this may be true, I don't want to make normal more complex than it already is.)

needs more hitsounds (Did a touch up on it)

[Hard For Me] (Checked)

SPOILER

StoryBoard: Yes (the speed up png and slow down pngs have a canvas size much bigger than they need to, reduce the canvas size to have only the necessary elements in them, thus optimizing the image size, also inst the speed up png going slightly up in the animation ?) (I'll get right to it after checking the hitnotes)
StoryBoard: No
[Current] Slider Velocity/Tick Rate : 1.0 / 1[PASS]
Distance Snap: x0.9[PASS]
[Current] Objects: 360 ( 399 Circles / 58 Sliders / 3 Spinners )[PASS]
[Current] Max Combo: 486[PASS]
[Current] Max Score: 4,337,616/10,000,000[PASS]
[Current] Star Rating: 4.26[PASS]
[Current] HP Drain Rate: Lv. 5(i think its a bit low for a hard dificulty why no try 7) (Done - I try to not set it too high to balance the drain with the slider use.)
[Current] Circle Size: Lv. 3[PASS]
[Current] Overall Difficulty: Lv. 7[PASS]

Beat Placement mod

nothing relevant to point out

[No Good For Me] (Checked)

SPOILER

StoryBoard: Yes (02:10:237 the slowdown png animation seems wrong, its coming from the left instead of the usual top, also inst the speed up png going slightly up in the animation ?) (I'll get on it)
[Current] Slider Velocity/Tick Rate : 1.40 / 2[PASS]
Distance Snap: x1.0[PASS]
[Current] Objects: 582 (525 Circles / 53 Sliders / 4 Spinners )[PASS]
[Current] Max Combo: 708[PASS]
[Current] Max Score:12,608,990/10,000,000 [Caution]( the score is higher than the maximim score for ranking, but still since the overall map dificulty is pretty high, not everyone will achieve this score) (I know, but I plan to not mess with this map too much since its already done.)
[Current] Star Rating: 4.98[PASS]
[Current] HP Drain Rate: Lv. 7[PASS]
[Current] Circle Size: Lv. 3[PASS]
[Current] Overall Difficulty: Lv. 9[PASS]

Beat Placement mod

nothing to point out atm

[Final Thoughts]

SPOILER

Great beatmap, full of variety.
Normal For Me dificulty is a bit too easy for a normal song, but that can be fixed with a small change in dificulty settings
Loved the speed up/slow down parts, they realy spice up the maps and make them alot of fun to play. to wrap it up... thw white and gray colors make this map a bit hard to play in tag coop mode, you may or may not change this... eventualy theres going to be tag specific colors anyway

STAR FOR YOU! great job

Aeon wrote:

well your map is pretty much perfect ^^ plus i love the song im sure to spend hours trying to ace this ( i so much love your hard and insane dificulties ) FUN FUN FUN (one of the most fun dificulties i ever played) SERIOUSLY

Zatoichi wrote:

Does this song relate to the background images?