Oh something pop in my mind, can be added custom skin? or it's only SB
~
~
forum
First Οfficial Storyboarding Contest! Deadline August 31
posted
Total Posts
124
Sounds interesting. I'll see if I can round up a group of people and make something incredible.
I hope you guys get enough participants to make this interesting 
Oh this sounds like fun~
I'll give this a go if I have a good idea...
Let's see if I can squeeze my creativity for this.
uh oh clock's ticking now
It's Larto time!
Welp, I tried my best.LuigiHann wrote:
rules are ... complicated
Good luck to all you other applicants.If its just a SB, please make an actual story. (include me if possible)
Please~
Good luck to everybody.
Please~
Good luck to everybody.
Topic Starter
What? It's not that complicated. There are almost no restrictions at all on what you can do with your storyboard, you just pick one of the three maps and goShinde wrote:
Welp, I tried my best.LuigiHann wrote:
rules are ... complicated
You said they're complicated, LH. 
This contest is too smart for me. Also Siriru will win. 
This contest is too smart for me. Also Siriru will win.
Topic Starter
I meant that they were complicated for me to explain. I think the hardest part was "each person can only join one team and each team can only make one SB." If you can understand that you should be golden.Shinde wrote:
You said they're complicated, LH.
about the SB, is the ranking criteria is applied too (SB load, maximum size, etc) ?
EDIT: I failed to see that, I feel ashamed
EDIT: I failed to see that, I feel ashamed
Sallad4ever wrote:
about the SB, is the ranking criteria is applied too (SB load, maximum size, etc) ?
Technical Execution - The quality of the images (including reasonable filesizes and proper cropping), the quality of the code, and the performance of the SB
Topic Starter
I couldn't remember the phrase "SB Load" when I was writing this, so thanks for that. That is what I meant by performance.
unsecured .png detected.. most of my work on osu! stolen
so.. nah thanks
so.. nah thanks
what is this i don't even-SiN- wrote:
unsecured .png detected.. most of my work on osu! stolen
so.. nah thanks
Topic Starter
Are you saying that your work has been stolen, or that you're afraid it will be stolen, or what? I have no idea what you are talking about
I'm still waiting for a response for this "can be added custom skin? or it's only SB"
<3
<3
Topic Starter
I might regret this later, but I'm going to go ahead and say go for it. Skinning is allowed. But it'll be one of those things that the judges aren't going to be judging directly, so it shouldn't impact your score unless it's so amazing or so terrible that it sways the "overall impression" rating. And try to limit it to skinning elements that are directly relevant to your SB, and not just meaningless flair.Astom wrote:
I'm still waiting for a response for this "can be added custom skin? or it's only SB"
<3
Edit: But I will say no to custom hitsounds, since that would change the map itself. Comboburst, spinner, and sectionpass/fail sounds are okay, but any sound that starts with "normal-" or "soft-" or otherwise "hit" is off limits
A good SB looks better with a good Skin so ~LuigiHann wrote:
I might regret this later, but I'm going to go ahead and say go for it. Skinning is allowed. But it'll be one of those things that the judges aren't going to be judging directly, so it shouldn't impact your score unless it's so amazing or so terrible that it sways the "overall impression" rating. And try to limit it to skinning elements that are directly relevant to your SB, and not just meaningless flair.
Edit: But I will say no to custom hitsounds, since that would change the map itself. Comboburst, spinner, and sectionpass/fail sounds are okay, but any sound that starts with "normal-" or "soft-" or otherwise "hit" is off limits
just like the pros at iNiS used to doAstom wrote:
A good SB looks better with a good Skin so ~
"has been" and "will be" (maybe :D)LuigiHann wrote:
Are you saying that your work has been stolen, or that you're afraid it will be stolen, or what? I have no idea what you are talking about
sry i was in hurry
Seams to be ineteresting.
I will follow this topic first before I do something.
I will follow this topic first before I do something.
Here another question, or a request, can we use a BG? or can you give one for each song?
Topic Starter
Make your own!Astom wrote:
Here another question, or a request, can we use a BG? or can you give one for each song?
But yeah, making (or at least finding?) a background that goes with your SB is sort of part of the contest... I suppose if you make an SB that doesn't use or require a background image then you won't be penalized for not including one, but in cases like that it's generally preferred that you make some kind of "preview background" that gets shown on the song select menu, and then you can have it disabled during the map (Yes, I just made that thread so that I could link to it here. Needed to be done eventually).
If you end up just taking some wallpaper or fanart from a website, please make a note of where you got it from. Like I said before I don't think we need in-game credits (unless you want to add them), but I'm thinking that some kind of listing of sources will be required as part of the entry process. Not gonna be super picky, just need to be able to tell which elements are user-made and which elements come from elsewhere.
Topic Starter
For convenience, I've added zip files including the mp3s and the relevant winning maps as downloads to the first post. Hopefully this will make it easier for people to get started.
I'm okay too?loli0000 wrote:
还行吧
nopeX-Ray wrote:
It's Larto time!
How about photography? I took a picture of the venue used in Scott Pilgrim where they performed Black Sheep but I have no idea who did the artwork on the building itself. I'm guessing that falls into the "not super picky" bucket?LuigiHann wrote:
Like I said before I don't think we need in-game credits (unless you want to add them), but I'm thinking that some kind of listing of sources will be required as part of the entry process. Not gonna be super picky, just need to be able to tell which elements are user-made and which elements come from elsewhere.
I don't think I can join in and SB my own map...
...Not that I am actually that great at SBing, though I've done...a lot. *cough*Gensou*cough*
...Not that I am actually that great at SBing, though I've done...a lot. *cough*Gensou*cough*
I don't see why not. Also imo storyboarding (writing the code) is pretty much the easiest partLilac wrote:
I don't think I can join in and SB my own map...
...Not that I am actually that great at SBing, though I've done...a lot. *cough*Gensou*cough*
I find that's the easiest part as well. Images are the worst...awp wrote:
I don't see why not. Also imo storyboarding (writing the code) is pretty much the easiest partLilac wrote:
I don't think I can join in and SB my own map...
...Not that I am actually that great at SBing, though I've done...a lot. *cough*Gensou*cough*
Topic Starter
Yeah that's fine, you took the photoawp wrote:
How about photography? I took a picture of the venue used in Scott Pilgrim where they performed Black Sheep but I have no idea who did the artwork on the building itself. I'm guessing that falls into the "not super picky" bucket?LuigiHann wrote:
Like I said before I don't think we need in-game credits (unless you want to add them), but I'm thinking that some kind of listing of sources will be required as part of the entry process. Not gonna be super picky, just need to be able to tell which elements are user-made and which elements come from elsewhere.
Good luck :3 <3
oh god I need Chinese ver.
It's supposed to use pictures from internet (and note the source)
or all elements have to be created by ourselves
I need to understand this...
It's supposed to use pictures from internet (and note the source)
or all elements have to be created by ourselves
I need to understand this...
Topic Starter
Either. Or both. Make your own images or use web images in any combination, just make a note of which ones you made and where you got the ones you didn't. Make sense?Komeiji Yuki wrote:
oh godI need Chinese ver.
It's supposed to use pictures from internet (and note the source)
or all elements have to be created by ourselves
I need to understand this...
ok , get it . ThanksLuigiHann wrote:
Either. Or both. Make your own images or use web images in any combination, just make a note of which ones you made and where you got the ones you didn't. Make sense?Komeiji Yuki wrote:
oh godI need Chinese ver.
It's supposed to use pictures from internet (and note the source)
or all elements have to be created by ourselves
I need to understand this...
Topic Starter
Ok cool. How's everybody else doing? Making progress?
verrrry slowwwwwlyLuigiHann wrote:
Ok cool. How's everybody else doing? Making progress?
should be done by September or October
Topic Starter
Looks like the judges will be myself, Card N'FoRcE, and jericho2442, if anybody was wondering about that.
Also if anybody wants to make a compelling argument that the deadline should be pushed back farther, now would be the better time to do that. Once we get close to the deadline I won't be willing to move it.
Also if anybody wants to make a compelling argument that the deadline should be pushed back farther, now would be the better time to do that. Once we get close to the deadline I won't be willing to move it.
I request pushing the deadline; maybe by a month or two. Of course, I always request these, and sometimes I slack off too much that I ever get it completed to the new deadline, but I really want to try something out + I didn't get a chance to enter the mapping contest.
Anyways, I see that some people (including me) are working very slowly, I don't think I"ve seen any submissions, unless they are holding them back for some reason.
Anyways, I see that some people (including me) are working very slowly, I don't think I"ve seen any submissions, unless they are holding them back for some reason.
If the amount of submissions are low as of this point, then a deadline extension would be an ideal choice...
Over here, we haven't gotten to the actual work yet and are still in the planning stages. I don't know what this should say about work ethic, but if it seems that a good amount of the potential contenders don't seem to have things ready in time, then yeah...
One month or so should do.
Over here, we haven't gotten to the actual work yet and are still in the planning stages. I don't know what this should say about work ethic, but if it seems that a good amount of the potential contenders don't seem to have things ready in time, then yeah...
One month or so should do.
I would also be in favor of a one month extension. I'm participating in the contest and haven't been able to make much progress yet either due to other obligations. I'm sure that the extra time would make us all happy. =)
Yeah I'm in the same situation as everybody, an extension will be perfect 
Two months to seriously buckle down and complete a storyboard would be enough time if I just put in 2 hours a night, but I've really been slacking off. I'm not going to beat around the bush, I've clocked almost 200 hours on P4. For those who are still in school (I'd wager 95% of the population at least) this gives the rest of summer vacation to work on it.
As for me, I just need to be more diligent. I'll make use of the time though, I promise that much.
As for me, I just need to be more diligent. I'll make use of the time though, I promise that much.
Topic Starter
How are people talking about the number of submissions? There are zero submissions because, unless I've missed something, there's no way to submit anything. But yeah, obviously nobody has posted a finished SB in this thread, so if people are actually working on stuff then I have no problem extending to a late-August deadline.
I'll update the first post of the thread tomorrow with the extension, along with the submission process and the confirmed judges.
I'll update the first post of the thread tomorrow with the extension, along with the submission process and the confirmed judges.
I wish you luck for all the people who are doing Ernst. Bonus points if you can SB names of people's mapping techniques I took.
florianu
florianu
depends on scale and experienceflorianu wrote:
Let's face it, two months are enough to draw all the OSU game!
how long does it take you to draw 300 images?
Topic Starter
Deadline officially extended. Sorry for the delay
Why are you complaining, do you want this to be a competition with only one or two entries.florianu wrote:
LuigiHann wrote:
Deadline officially extended. Sorry for the delay
OMG
I'm thankful for this extension as I have been gone a lot of the time when this competition has been up and before I was away I didn't have a idea yet, having one month should probably be enough for me to finish my idea.
Wasn't this a contest?LuigiHann wrote:
Deadline officially extended. Sorry for the delay
I'm look forward to Astom's, S i R i R u's and -SiN-'s work
Topic Starter
Yeah, a contest. Not a race. Take the time and make it count. I hope to see high quality SB's, especially given the deadline extension.Astom wrote:
Wasn't this a contest?LuigiHann wrote:
Deadline officially extended. Sorry for the delay
Is there a list of teams? I like to see who is participating :L
Topic Starter
If you'd like to submit an entry, I've made a thread with the rules for doing so, in that thread. Check it out.
viewtopic.php?f=9&t=60407&p=991167
viewtopic.php?f=9&t=60407&p=991167
Topic Starter
We are extremely close to the deadline, where is everybody
You already have one entry lol
So we could at least have a winner
So we could at least have a winner
Don't worry I bet everyone's just leaving it to the last minute like good responsible people.
I bailed partway into August, or maybe a week before thatLuigiHann wrote:
We are extremely close to the deadline, where is everybody
I know, I'm probably disappointing a number of people. Too much drawing, for me.
I was gonna troll or something but then I decided I don't have enough skill for even that.
where is people?
Scrapped my idea+ working on other stuff that's more important than this imo.LuigiHann wrote:
We are extremely close to the deadline, where is everybody
I rather just make SB when I get a nice idea to I map I mapping. (Also I suck at being soicial and teamwork so I didn't collaborated with anyone and nobody asked me)
I was going to make a joke one in 9 hours but I have to work. I'll try to make one in 2-3 once I get back for gits and shiggles.
Ideas for storyboards are very difficult unless you have complete control over the song you choose, and I didn't like any of the songs which is why I didn't bother signing up for serious.
Ideas for storyboards are very difficult unless you have complete control over the song you choose, and I didn't like any of the songs which is why I didn't bother signing up for serious.
I have something done 95%, and am serious about finishing it... hopefully I can finish it in the next.... 4-5 hours D:
EEEDIT: Extending the deadline to 11:59 pacific time giving the west coast the rest of the day, NOW THAT WOULD BE AWESOME
EEEDIT: Extending the deadline to 11:59 pacific time giving the west coast the rest of the day, NOW THAT WOULD BE AWESOME
They started at GMT, so it just fair to every participant if the deadline is set to GMT too. Just to be fair to eastern Sbers too.eee wrote:
EEEDIT: Extending the deadline to 11:59 pacific time giving the west coast the rest of the day, NOW THAT WOULD BE AWESOME
Suggestion: Allow late submissions of up to 12 hours with a slight score penalty. After all, the contest has been running for a few months, it can wait another half day if necessary. It'd be prudent to give procrastinators just a bit more breathing room, if only to diversify the entry field. Because I don't think judging exactly one entry was what you were looking for.
2 entries o/
Just to say something, 3 months are more than enough time for make a SB, I know than most of us are busy but just accept it was enough time.
I totally agree with ziin, ideas for SBs that aren't under your totally control is just hard, is not the same than make a diff., SB is much more close to creativity and make something creative from something than you probably don't fully like is realy hard.ziin wrote:
I was going to make a joke one in 9 hours but I have to work. I'll try to make one in 2-3 once I get back for gits and shiggles.
Ideas for storyboards are very difficult unless you have complete control over the song you choose, and I didn't like any of the songs which is why I didn't bother signing up for serious.
I'm not against late submissions, but they deserve a penalty like akrolsmir says, is just not fair for people trying to finish in time.akrolsmir wrote:
Suggestion: Allow late submissions of up to 12 hours with a slight score penalty. After all, the contest has been running for a few months, it can wait another half day if necessary. It'd be prudent to give procrastinators just a bit more breathing room, if only to diversify the entry field. Because I don't think judging exactly one entry was what you were looking for.
Just to say something, 3 months are more than enough time for make a SB, I know than most of us are busy but just accept it was enough time.
Beuchi, Kirby, and I planned on entering, but things came up and we weren't able to. ):
florianu
Go Astom team, you guys got my full support! o/
Congrats on the wins you two! I probably shouldn't have given up on ernst with 30 minutes left, but I felt it was cheesy to submit a joke SB which literally took me 3 hours to make/think up then win because I was unopposed.
I suggest if you do allow late entries, still grade them accordingly, but give the wins to the people who actually made it on time.
I suggest if you do allow late entries, still grade them accordingly, but give the wins to the people who actually made it on time.
I feel bad because there was no SB submission for Ernst.
I fell bad for all, I just want forget this contest.Lilac wrote:
I feel bad because there was no SB submission for Ernst.
To be honest, I would have liked to join in as well...the problem is that I'm not sure who else would join...
florianu
Hopefully the ones that were submitted will still be good though.
ahhhhhh, i want to enter but.....
it's just like "something is wrong, it's more fun when i make SB of the song i know pretty well" and suddenly become lazy
*hear wind climbing (ooo good song, okay time to watch the PV.... after 5 minutes i gave up)
*(searching black sheep in youtube). . .after 5 minutes...."i gave up, i can't make SB of this"
*(searching Ernst.....) yay! this song will do....the next day...
......
making SB halfway and stopped . . .(suddenly out of ideas)
it's just like "something is wrong, it's more fun when i make SB of the song i know pretty well" and suddenly become lazy
*hear wind climbing (ooo good song, okay time to watch the PV.... after 5 minutes i gave up)
*(searching black sheep in youtube). . .after 5 minutes...."i gave up, i can't make SB of this"
*(searching Ernst.....) yay! this song will do....the next day...
......
making SB halfway and stopped . . .(suddenly out of ideas)
florianu
There still needs judging to happen, but im not sure how will that be handled considering the low ammount of submissions, even if all 3 are winners judges need to define a 1st,2nd,3rd place
That's what team Kirbeuchi was planning on doing. ):!Lilac wrote:
I feel bad because there was no SB submission for Ernst.
florianu
I think the mistake was forcing those songs lol
yeahyeahyeahhh wrote:
I think the mistake was forcing those songs lol
I don't know about Ernst (that was the VG music one, right?) but the Japanese and American songs were excellent candidates for storyboarding. I think the real problem is most people don't realize that a good storyboard requires far more time and effort than making a good beatmap.yeahyeahyeahhh wrote:
I think the mistake was forcing those songs lol
If you weren't expecting to spend at least 40 hours on it you probably weren't gauging it properly (or just planning to rip everything from somewhere).
I personally knew the effort required, I just wasn't sure whether or not I'd run out of motivation before asset development was complete (I did).
Topic Starter
Locked the submission thread up, but I know I personally won't have time to look at the entries until sometime next week. I'm a bit saddened by the overall lack of interest. I do think that next time we do an SB contest, it'll have to be more of an "iron chef" style contest, where there's some specific object or theme that you have to work into your SB, but you can choose whatever song you want. Seems like that would give people enough freedom without making it too easy to submit random existing storyboards.
I've completed my storyboard, but I'll keep the incomplete one as my submission.
http://www.mediafire.com/?l1bs1o0dympwb32
If any of the judges would kindly mod this new one, then please do so; I'm not enforcing any mod of this one, my intentions are for anyone that is wondering how it concludes...
http://www.mediafire.com/?l1bs1o0dympwb32
If any of the judges would kindly mod this new one, then please do so; I'm not enforcing any mod of this one, my intentions are for anyone that is wondering how it concludes...
I could have helped them. Though I'm wondering what they actually did.Derekku wrote:
That's what team Kirbeuchi was planning on doing. ):!Lilac wrote:
I feel bad because there was no SB submission for Ernst.
Considering I copied both of their mapping into Ernst...ololol.