First mod?



Hard
00:01:071 (3) - remove repeat, at note at 00:02:071 -
00:06:214 (3,4,5,6,7) - 1 grid down? all of them :<
00:08:499 (3,4,5,6,7) - ^
00:13:071 (6) - add clap to end
00:13:499 (7) - remove clap
00:13:928 (8) - add clap
00:14:214 (9) - remove clap, add finish? and add New combo
00:14:499 (1) - remove NC
00:15:642 (4) - add clap
00:15:785 (5) - remove clap in begin, add to end

^^ those faults keep appearing over and over again in the map. I'm too lazy to list them all. Check the map yourself!
So I'll concentrate on other stuff for now.

00:22:499 - add note
00:40:499 (6) - improve the arc shape.
00:42:214 (3) - remove repeat, add note at 00:43:214 -
Copy paste much starting now.
01:03:642 - add note

Normal
00:03:357 (5,6) - add finish
00:17:642 (2) - improve the shape D:
00:38:214 (3) - end at 00:38:642 -
00:44:499 (5) - add finish
01:14:785 (4) - Move the slider center point 1 grid up
01:19:357 (3) - end at 01:19:785 -
01:25:642 (1,2) - add finish

Easy
00:07:357 (1) - bad spacing (too far)
00:35:928 (3) - end at 00:36:357 -
01:05:071 (1) - bad spacing (too close)
01:17:071 (3) - end at 01:17:499 -
01:19:928 (2) - move to 01:19:785 -


Check the hitsound for all maps twice, make sure to only claps where you can hear the drums play. Otherwise it sounds weird (IMO)
Star for the song...

Hello -kevincela- ^^

[General]

BG: size must be 800x600 or 1024x768

Colors: add color?

Offset: 1 108

Resnap All Notes

[Kiai Mod]

start 00:32:499

finish 00:46:214

start 01:13:642

finish 01:27:357

[Easy]

00:14:214 (3) - new combo

00:14:785 (1) - delete new combo

00:16:499 (2) - new combo

00:17:071 (1) - delete new combo

00:18:785 (2) - new combo

00:23:357 (3) - ^

00:23:928 (1) - delete new combo

00:25:642 (3) - new combo

00:26:214 (1) - delete new combo

00:27:928 (2) - new combo

hmm...nice :3

Star~

Tenshi-nyan wrote:

First mod?



Hard
00:01:071 (3) - remove repeat, at note at 00:02:071 - No
00:06:214 (3,4,5,6,7) - 1 grid down? all of them :< No
00:08:499 (3,4,5,6,7) - ^ No
00:13:071 (6) - add clap to end Done
00:13:499 (7) - remove clap Done
00:13:928 (8) - add clap Done
00:14:214 (9) - remove clap, add finish? and add New combo Done
00:14:499 (1) - remove NC Done
00:15:642 (4) - add clap Done
00:15:785 (5) - remove clap in begin, add to end Done

^^ those faults keep appearing over and over again in the map. I'm too lazy to list them all. Check the map yourself! Done
So I'll concentrate on other stuff for now.

00:22:499 - add note Done
00:40:499 (6) - improve the arc shape. Done
00:42:214 (3) - remove repeat, add note at 00:43:214 - No
Copy paste much starting now.
01:03:642 - add note Done

Normal
00:03:357 (5,6) - add finish Done
00:17:642 (2) - improve the shape D: Done
00:38:214 (3) - end at 00:38:642 - Done
00:44:499 (5) - add finish Done
01:14:785 (4) - Move the slider center point 1 grid upDone
01:19:357 (3) - end at 01:19:785 - Done
01:25:642 (1,2) - add finish Done

Easy
00:07:357 (1) - bad spacing (too far) Done
00:35:928 (3) - end at 00:36:357 - Done
01:05:071 (1) - bad spacing (too close) Done
01:17:071 (3) - end at 01:17:499 - Done
01:19:928 (2) - move to 01:19:785 - Done


Check the hitsound for all maps twice, make sure to only claps where you can hear the drums play. Otherwise it sounds weird (IMO) I'll check it,sorry but i'm not good at hitsounds D:
Star for the song...

ZLOdeuka wrote:

Hello -kevincela- ^^

[General]

BG: size must be 800x600 or 1024x768 Done

Colors: add color? Done

Offset: 1 108 I don't know why,but the notes aren't in rythm after putting this offser D: So for now,i think i won't change it

Resnap All Notes

[Kiai Mod]

start 00:32:499

finish 00:46:214

start 01:13:642

finish 01:27:357

Sorry,but i don't like these kiai

[Easy]

00:14:214 (3) - new combo Done

00:14:785 (1) - delete new combo Done

00:16:499 (2) - new combo Done

00:17:071 (1) - delete new combo Done

00:18:785 (2) - new combo Done

00:23:357 (3) - ^ Done

00:23:928 (1) - delete new combo Done

00:25:642 (3) - new combo Done

00:26:214 (1) - delete new combo Done

00:27:928 (2) - new combo Done

hmm...nice :3

Star~

LOL,it took me very much time to fix all D:
Anyway,thanks for the mod~

Hi

General
Not sure about quality of the song, i think it's to high bitrate

Don't use white combo color, do it little grey (in all diffs) red

Combo2 : 255,243,13

Easy
Lead in = 1.5

Normal
Lead in = 1
OD = 5
01:03:357 (5) - "return" of the slider is there 01:03:785

Hard is good
Nice work, starr

All done,thanks

change source to "Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 4"

since I'm a huge fan of this game, I will star this...

just suggestion (T.Tmay be nazi mod)

[General]
you'd better use 1/6 to make notes aligned music
and move notes which on blue lines on red lines

[Easy]
i.e.:00:06:642(2)- move 1/6 on 00:06:690
00:08:928(2)-^
00:11:214(2)-^
00:47:785(2)-^
00:50:071(2)-^
00:52:404(2)-^
00:54:785(2)-move note to 00:54:690-

and Normal also has some the same problems. plz fix it

[Hard]
this diff is good.

/me run..

-maJu:Done!
BakaHuang:For now i won't do this,because first i need to fix the fiming,then i'll see if it's necessary to do so.Kudosu for the help anyways
DarkOkami:I didn't fix so many fixed,but thanks for the suggestion of the spinner!

ya o/

[General]
All diff's "Lead-in 2"

[Easy]
00:13:642 (2) - about here,00:13:357 -
00:25:071 (3) - just stack
00:54:785 (2) - red tick again.

[Normal]
00:04:499 (7) - Remove finish.then,add whistle
00:35:928 (3) - end blue tick?

[Hard]
00:25:928 (1) - here?00:25:785 - If you changed,adjust the later spacing.
01:09:357 (1) - Remove whistle?
01:10:214 (4) - ^
01:22:785 (1) - add finish?
01:23:357 (3) - ^ start slider only
01:25:071 (5) - add finish

nice map :3

-kevincela- wrote:

BakaHuang:For now i won't do this,because first i need to fix the fiming,then i'll see if it's necessary to do so.Kudosu for the help anyways

yeah , I think so.

val0108 wrote:

ya o/

[General]
All diff's "Lead-in 2" Done

[Easy]
00:13:642 (2) - about here,00:13:357 - No
00:25:071 (3) - just stack No
00:54:785 (2) - red tick again. No

[Normal]
00:04:499 (7) - Remove finish.then,add whistle Done
00:35:928 (3) - end blue tick? No

[Hard]
00:25:928 (1) - here?00:25:785 - If you changed,adjust the later spacing. No
01:09:357 (1) - Remove whistle? Done
01:10:214 (4) - ^ Done
01:22:785 (1) - add finish? Done
01:23:357 (3) - ^ start slider only Done
01:25:071 (5) - add finish Done

nice map :3

Thanks~

ho controllato i BPM, è giusto, l'offset sembra un pò in anticipo: prova ad aumentarlo di 10/12 ms <-si sente abbastanza poco la differenza.

EDIT: Doppio offset o BPM leggermente minori di 105, prova con 104,98 BPM , ho notato che prendevo più 100 alla fine

quindi priova questo nuovo Timing:
BPM: 104,98
Offset: 512

ThunderMod

Some suggestions

<<Easy>>

00:55:379 (3) -->> (1) - swap new combo?
01:05:095 (1) - align with (3)?

Rest seems fine.

Thunderstorm wrote:

ThunderMod

Some suggestions

<<Easy>>

00:55:379 (3) -->> (1) - swap new combo? Done
01:05:095 (1) - align with (3)? No

Rest seems fine.

Thanks for the mod!

Hi~

[Timing]

Some of your green timing sections are not stacked properly

[Easy]

00:01:083 (2) - finish
00:21:087 (1) - to my mind, the whistle sound on the slider body don't fit it. If it's your call, ok~
00:25:088 (3) - (nazi) stack properly with (1)
00:28:517 (2) - blah-blah-blah whistle on the slider body, I won't mention it next time
00:38:662 (2) - change finish with whistle
00:42:234 (2) - finish
01:23:384 (2) - ^

[Normal]

00:01:083 (3) - finish
00:42:234 (3) - ^
01:04:238 (5) - remove finish
01:23:384 (3) - finish

[Hard]

00:01:083 (3) - finish
00:23:373 (10) - new combo
00:23:659 (1) - remove nc
00:39:090 (3) - remove finish
00:42:234 (3) - finish
01:27:957 (1) - maybe decrease volume in all diffs

Good luck~

Reiji-RJ wrote:

Hi~

[Timing]

Some of your green timing sections are not stacked properly Done

[Easy]

00:01:083 (2) - finish Done
00:21:087 (1) - to my mind, the whistle sound on the slider body don't fit it. If it's your call, ok~ Done
00:25:088 (3) - (nazi) stack properly with (1) No
00:28:517 (2) - blah-blah-blah whistle on the slider body, I won't mention it next time Done
00:38:662 (2) - change finish with whistle Done
00:42:234 (2) - finish [Done
01:23:384 (2) - ^ Done

[Normal]

00:01:083 (3) - finish Done
00:42:234 (3) - ^ Done
01:04:238 (5) - remove finish Done
01:23:384 (3) - finish Done

[Hard]

00:01:083 (3) - finish Done
00:23:373 (10) - new combo Done
00:23:659 (1) - remove nc Done
00:39:090 (3) - remove finish Done
00:42:234 (3) - finish Done
01:27:957 (1) - maybe decrease volume in all diffs Done

Good luck~

Thanks for the mod~

*BPM: 104,98? Use 105.00. Otherwise, the offset is about 20ms off by the end of the map.

*Actually, this would probably be easier to map if you doubled the BPM. Double 105 to 210, and halve the slider velocity/tick rate on each of your difficulties. For example, 1.7 SV on Normal would become 0.85 (hold the ctrl key while changing the slider velocity to get it exact).

*The offset itself is fine.

*This song is in 1/3, so please use 1/3 snap to map with. I went ahead and resnapped parts of [Hard] correctly, and remapped a few places so that you would have something to play with. I also adjusted the BPM/SV/tick rate as mentioned above to show you how it looks.

*Note: You can also use 1/3 decently for Normal/Easy as well, but try to keep things simple with sliders and such. Good luck!

Download: Shoji Meguro - Theme of Junes (-kevincela-) [Correct Snapping].osu

[General]
BPM 105.00
Cut mp3 after 1:35:672

[Easy]

00:22:659 (2) - This blue tick hit might be bit hard for normal, but not a big deal
00:25:088 (3) - I agree about this needs to stack with next (1) or move it down 3/left 1 grid, or move it all the way down to x:344 y:336.
This isn't a problem but currently this looks kinda odd.
00:47:806 (2) - (nazi) 1 grid up
01:02:809 (2,3) - (nazi) 1 grid left


[Normal]

Ok.

[Hard]

00:07:370 (1,2) - Make them symmetrical. just copy the first (1) and do 180 degree rotation.
00:09:942 (repeat) - add clap
00:10:228 (end) - remove clap
00:10:513 (2) - add clap
00:20:230 (3,4) - remove clap on (4) and add it on (3)



Okay nice map and star o.o

sorry for poor modding@

Ok,i'll try to do all this later,but It'll be difficult

Just a note: You really don't need to cut an mp3 unless a big chunk is unmapped. There's only a few extra seconds of silence at the end of this mp3, so it's really unnecessary.

However, if you really want to cut it, then at least use a tool like this to do so without reencoding or messing things up (e.g. the offset).

Derekku wrote:

Just a note: You really don't need to cut an mp3 unless a big chunk is unmapped. There's only a few extra seconds of silence at the end of this mp3, so it's really unnecessary.

However, if you really want to cut it, then at least use a tool like this to do so without reencoding or messing things up (e.g. the offset).

Yes I know,in fact i didn't cut the mp3!
Anyway,I finally done all,remapping some parts x.x
If i did something wrong,tell me and I'll try to fix it.

This is why I use VBR/ABR. If you have silence it doesn't take up much space at all.

I'm very happy to see that you're mapping this song (almost) properly with 1/6ths! These sorts of songs aren't easy.

[hard]
There are some tricky parts that I don't like much.
00:00:512 - this is the introduction of the song. It's in straight eighth notes. Nothing should be in 1/6. Nothing should be on anything other than a red or white note actually. This is why swing songs are so annoying to map.
00:03:940 - here's the drum's pickups into the swing section, where you shouldn't have anything on a red note anymore. If you do, don't map it!
00:06:988 - there is no note here in the music. Sure it fits, but I'm firmly opposed to making up notes unless you have a really good reason to. If you insist on mapping it, could you make this the end of a slider?
00:09:273 - ^. It's probably a good idea to go and check all your 1/6 notes on 25-75% speed.
00:21:845 (5) - recalculate length
00:30:988 (4) - recalculate length. There's probably more. Just go through and keep a look out.

I'll finish this later, stuff came up.

If Derekku modded this map already,then I won't mod it,because it is pointless xD There are no mistakes here - I can say it and I even didn't download it. So,I will just give you a star <3

Giorgos wrote:

If Derekku modded this map already,then I won't mod it,because it is pointless xD There are no mistakes here - I can say it and I even didn't download it. So,I will just give you a star <3

Except I didn't mod it. I only fixed timing and showed the mapper how to properly use 1/3. :v

Ciao a puppi!

General
* On last spinner for all diff, how about the volume fading lower and lower? Like this music fading out
* No tags?

Easy
* Set the Audio Lead-In to "2007" on Notepad to make it same for all diff

00:05:083 (1,2) - Remove circle and extend slider to circle what you place. Example you place at the circle at 00:06:702 and remove, and you extend the slider to 00:06:702. If you do this, this will be easier for beginner player, or it'll be mis-click if the circle place on purple tick
00:07:369 (1,2) - ^
00:11:940 (1) - Can you make 1st and 3rd slidertick are stick together to make neat to look? Like this http://puu.sh/1hwJ
00:21:083 (1,2) - Same issue as 00:05:083 (1,2)
00:34:797 (1,2,3) - This timing pattern are too difficult for beginner player
00:43:940 (3) - Move to X:272 and Y:272. Look upper-right to know what I mean (Nazi)
00:46:226 (1,2) - Same issue as 00:05:083 (1,2)
00:48:511 (1,2) - ^
01:11:369 (1) - Can you make 1st and 3rd slidertick are stick together to make neat to look? Like this http://puu.sh/1hwJ
01:15:940 (1,2,3) - This timing pattern are too difficult for beginner player

Normal
* I am pretty not sure if placing object in purple ticks is makes average diff mis-click. I think I suggest you to contact to modder/MAT/BAT to figure this out

00:02:797 (4) - New combo?
00:17:654 (2,1,2,3,4) - I think this pattern make a nice flow http://puu.sh/1i4f
00:29:083 (2) - Move 5 grid right to make a nice flow (Nazi)
00:33:654 (4) - Clap?
00:43:940 (4) - New combo?
01:05:654 (2) - Move 1 grid up? (Nazi)
01:11:940 (3) - Redpoint makes this slider are ugly, try right-click one time in redpoint. You should end up like this http://puu.sh/1i9S

Hard
* Actually, I knew about when object has inconsistent spacing from Coordinate System on upper-right, lol

00:16:512 (6) - Inconsistent spacing
00:23:654 (2) - ^
00:25:940 (1) - ^
00:51:940 (3) - ^
01:06:797 (5) - ^

That's all folks

Leorda wrote:

Ciao a puppi!

General
* On last spinner for all diff, how about the volume fading lower and lower? Like this music fading out For this,maybe i'll do later,not now.
* No tags? I don't know what to put in the tags xD

Easy
* Set the Audio Lead-In to "2007" on Notepad to make it same for all diff Done

00:05:083 (1,2) - Remove circle and extend slider to circle what you place. Example you place at the circle at 00:06:702 and remove, and you extend the slider to 00:06:702. If you do this, this will be easier for beginner player, or it'll be mis-click if the circle place on purple tick No
00:07:369 (1,2) - ^ No
00:11:940 (1) - Can you make 1st and 3rd slidertick are stick together to make neat to look? Like this http://puu.sh/1hwJ Done
00:21:083 (1,2) - Same issue as 00:05:083 (1,2) No
00:34:797 (1,2,3) - This timing pattern are too difficult for beginner player No
00:43:940 (3) - Move to X:272 and Y:272. Look upper-right to know what I mean (Nazi) Done
00:46:226 (1,2) - Same issue as 00:05:083 (1,2) No
00:48:511 (1,2) - ^ No
01:11:369 (1) - Can you make 1st and 3rd slidertick are stick together to make neat to look? Like this http://puu.sh/1hwJ Done
01:15:940 (1,2,3) - This timing pattern are too difficult for beginner player No

Normal
* I am pretty not sure if placing object in purple ticks is makes average diff mis-click. I think I suggest you to contact to modder/MAT/BAT to figure this out

00:02:797 (4) - New combo? Done
00:17:654 (2,1,2,3,4) - I think this pattern make a nice flow http://puu.sh/1i4f Done
00:29:083 (2) - Move 5 grid right to make a nice flow (Nazi) Done
00:33:654 (4) - Clap? Done
00:43:940 (4) - New combo? Done
01:05:654 (2) - Move 1 grid up? (Nazi) Done
01:11:940 (3) - Redpoint makes this slider are ugly, try right-click one time in redpoint. You should end up like this http://puu.sh/1i9S Done

Hard
* Actually, I knew about when object has inconsistent spacing from Coordinate System on upper-right, lol

00:16:512 (6) - Inconsistent spacing Done
00:23:654 (2) - ^ Done
00:25:940 (1) - ^ Done
00:51:940 (3) - ^ Done
01:06:797 (5) - ^ Done

That's all folks

Thanks

Hi there~
LOl, this song. I used to hang out at Junes in the game just to listen to the song (I can only barely hear it though..)
Nway, the mods:

I like listening to the song, and since "Everything's great at your Junes", I'll give you a star~
All the best!

General:
interesting beat
easy:
seems ok, nothing to say.
ps: very lovely easy.
normal:
00:19:654 (3) - 1 greed left (greed level 3)
00:47:845 (2) - spacing( not sure is it really a mistake)
01:13:940 (2) - add a note (suggestion)
hard:
00:33:940 (3,4) - one grid down
00:34:416 (5,6) - one greed left
00:55:369 (9) - one greed up (greed level 4)
star for funny music =)

Maybe some minor mod from me as I see not much issues in your map already.

Easy:
Good to go

Normal:
00:17:654 If you make more points instead of 2 on this slider (2) it will look nicer/smoother. It shape seem sloppy ( just IMO)

Hard:
Good to go

[Easy]
00:06:702 (2) - These notes would sound better with claps IMO.
00:08:988 (2) - ^ etc. etc.

Good job.
[Normal]
00:06:702 (3) - Like what I said on easy.
00:08:988 (4) - ^ etc. etc. (lol)

Good job... deja vu...
[Hard]
This is good!


Great job, starred.

Reporting from my queue!

[General]
- First time modding a 1/6 beat snapping map. >_<
- Hope I don't conflict with other modders' mod. (Not sure if you haven't apply recent mods or denied them)
- Maybe some new combo fixes, consider matching new combos with each music segment.

[Easy]
I think some modders have point out regarding purple ticks for an Easy, and you've rejected them, so not touching anymore...BUT...
- 00:11:273 (2) - A clap?
- 00:13:654 (2) - Wouldn't this be on 00:13:559? With a clap?
- 00:22:702 (2) - Consider moving this to 00:22:797(White tick) since in that segment beats are mostly ended on white ticks?
- 00:44:512 (4) - End at 00:44:940 just like what you did in Normal? Also consider hitsounds you did for Normal too.
- 00:54:797 (2) - Move to 00:54:702 for consistency?
- 00:55:369 (1) - Finish as what you did for Normal/Hard?

[Normal]
- 00:14:226 (5) - Just stating inconsistent new combos compared with other difficulty.(Or probably me being picky, ah haha)
- 00:59:273 (3,4) - A slight jump reported by AImod. Ignore this if that's intended/you think it's fine as it is now.

[Hard]
- As some previous mods mentioned, some inconsistency in applying new combos.
- 00:10:797 (3) - Clap at the end instead of the repeating point?(Consider use clap as custom slidertick sound by adding a timing section at 00:11:083 - 00:11:131 to match previous clap pattern too)
- 00:12:131 - Consider adding a beat here?
- 00:13:083 (6,7) - Intended distance between the pair of sliders?
- 00:17:654 (2,3) - Intended distance between the pair of sliders?
- 00:21:845 (5) - Add a clap at the end of this slider?
- 00:39:845 (3) - Consider deleting this beat?
- 00:39:940 (4,5) - Intended jump?
- 00:53:273 - Consider adding a beat here?
- 00:54:226 (6,7) - Intended distance between the pair of sliders?

I like how you are hitsounding the music.
Don't kudosu me if you felt my mods are useless!

Thanks,i fixed the major part of the mod!

Hi, here's my mod ^^


☆~Easy~☆

*00:13:654 (2) : Move to 00:13:559
00:36:416 (3) : Move end to 00:36:369
*00:54:797 (2) : Move to 00:54:702
01:17:559 (3) : Move end to 01:17:512
01:26:131 (5) : Move to 01:26:083

*it's ok but I think they are big trap for easy dif.


☆~Normal~☆

01:15:940 (1,2,3) : Try this


☆~Hard~☆

Nice beat ^^


Pleasant song, nice beatmap ^_^
☆~Star~☆

Sorry for delays.

Ah,Persona,awesome.

I'dd add SMT to Tags as well.

01:27:369 - End your map here?

[Easy]
00:05:083 (1) - Finish?
00:39:654 - I'd add a note here too.
00:46:226 (1) - Finish?
00:55:369 (1) - Fix distance here.
01:20:797 - Note?

[Normal]
00:06:702 (3) - Fix distance,it shouldn't be equal between (1,2,3).
00:14:226 (1) - Finish?
00:50:131 (3) - Same issue about distance.
01:08:416 (3,4,5) - ^
01:21:654 (5) - Finish?

[Hard]
00:34:416 (5) - Fix distance.
00:36:226 (4,5,6) - ^
01:15:559 (6,7) - ^

Nice difficulty,catchy rhytm.

I like it,have my star.

Easy
00:11:940 (1) - make like this http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/72217 , pm me ingame if you can't make it perfectly symmetrical
01:11:369 (1) - ^
00:47:797 (2,2,2,2) - snap to red ticks.

Normal
Nothing of note.

Hard
00:25:940 (1,2,3,4,5) - Pentagon can be more fluid.
01:16:797 (2) - This sounds strange.

Hi -kevincela- sorry for the delay

[General]
- This guide will help you a lot if you wanted to make your slider perfect I guaranteed
- the full title of the game is "Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 4" you don't need the SMT, remove it from the source and place it in the tags

[Easy]
00:01:083 (2) - well the end is very awkward cause it's on 1/2 beat later after the actual beat. My suggestion is (1) remove 1 repeat then add circle at 00:02:083 or (2) change 00:01:083 (2) into circle then add slider from 00:01:654 until 00:02:083. I strongly suggest you to do this cause this part is like the catchphrase of this music
00:42:226 (2) - ^
01:23:369 (2) - ^
01:27:940 (1) - this spinner is very redundant and not needed. 01:27:369 (6) is enough as the ending
some 1/3 note worries me but it's fine, an easy doesn't mean you can't use a 1/3 :P

[Normal]
00:01:083 (3) - same as Easy, beside this is normal you don't have to make it too simple~
00:02:512 (x) - maybe add a circle here while you're at it
00:06:226 (2,3) - it'll be more player friendly if you make this into slider first. There are many notes like this cause the music is repeated so I suggest something like using slider for the first part (00:08:512 (3,4), 00:10:797 (3,4), 00:13:083 (2,3)) then circle on the 2 part. Well it's your choice
00:14:512 (2) - too much whistle, remove the ones in the start and end
00:15:369 (3) - I suggest to shorten this into the same length as 01:05:654 (2)
00:19:940 (4) - ^
00:42:226 (3) - same as Easy
00:43:654 (x) - add circle here too
01:11:940 (3) - shorten this slider by 1/3 to 01:12:416
01:23:369 (3) - uhh yeah you know it
01:27:940 (1) - same as Easy

[Hard]
Hmm for the spacing in the kiai section try using 1.1 or 1.2. The current spacing of 1 DS (Distance Spacing) is too little and didn't really give any impression of a spacing change
00:01:083 (3) - I guess you forgot the finish?
00:10:797 (3) - don't really like the clap at the repeat
00:13:559 (7) - the spacing is too close from the previous note
00:18:131 (3) - ^
00:28:226 (1) - ^ well not too close
00:42:226 (3) - add finish please
00:45:559 (4,5,6,7) - you can use jump here if you wanted to make it Hard :P
00:54:702 (7) - um the spacing
00:57:940 (1) - the slider body overlap badly with the previous slider, I suggest to move it down
01:19:369 (3) - the previous slider in the first kiai use finish in the beginning and the repeat so I suggest to add it here too
01:27:369 (7) - change to finish please
01:27:940 (1) - same as Easy
There are no fixed pattern in the hitsounds here but it works

Is it just me or the part in kiai time is kinda like christmas song :?
anyway nice map, keep workin on it an Good Luck~
Star

hi

[General]
- cool rhythm

[Easy]
<00:02:797> (4) don't do stack in easy
<00:32:512..> exchange this combo with next one, since spacing is small and newbie players could misread a 1.5-beat spacing after a 2-beat
<01:24:369> (3) x:76 y:256

[Normal]
<00:22:226> (4) hitsound = clap, x, finish instead
<01:12:416> hmm, i would say end it on white line

[Hard]
<00:02:797> (6,1) switch new combo, maybe you dont want (6) stacked if you fixed combo color
<00:48:988> add note for consistency
<00:57:654> (5) spacing error? may be confusing

star, cute one

Hi~ My mod here. All below are just suggestions.

[Hard]
Nice~ fine for me

[Normal]
00:02:083 (4,5) - a bit hard for the first occurrence of this rhythm in a normal. Replace with slider?
00:08:226 (2,3) - move up to the end of 00:09:654 (1) ? might have to move 00:08:988 (4) around a bit to fix spacing afterwards
00:14:226 (1) - right 2 grids?
00:21:654 (3) - replace with a slider ends at 00:21:845 ?
00:43:940 (1,2) - swap new combo
01:13:654 (1,2,3,4) - spacing increase patterns? not in a normal I suppose x.x please make them evenly spaced

[Easy]
00:22:797 (2) - move to 00:22:702 for consistency
00:25:083 (2) - move to 00:24:988 for consistency

Nice mapset, star~

Hello!!!!

On Easy...

At 00:04:512 (6): One grid up.
At 00:14:226 (1): One grid left and one grid down.
At 00:51:178 (1): One grid right.
At 00:53:083 (1). One grid up.

On Normal...

At 00:29:083 (2): One grid up and one grid right.
At 00:33:083 (2): One grid up and space the next note and slider too.
At 00:37:178 (1): Uh... One grid left then snap the others...?

Oh Hard...

Maybe... Next time.

That's it. Make sure you correct the snapping, okay?

Star and thank you.

Persona 4 ~ Nice map +Star!

dont add me into your thank list, plz, really~

I enjoy the music and the hard diff, fit song perfectly. I have to say, usually a map take so many ppl modded, only stuffs left here for any futher mod are styles and nazi. So you may not will to change most things I point out, Im ok with it. Dont bother by that.

Normal
00:30:131 (1) - I think slider like this would be hard, making it a long slider with the next beat would be a solution.


Hard
I would like to use slider tick 2
00:20:797 - you have some same parts, like this, I think maybe add a note here? No sure, up to you.
01:15:940 (1,2) - I think make it like 01:13:654 (1,2,3) - would be better

Not much mod, so no kds plz.

[general]
mp3 - 224 kbps?

[Hard]
00:00:512 (1) - left 1 grid
00:32:226 (8) - down 1 grid
01:20::797 (2,5) - stack?

[Normal]
00:40:226 - (2,3) (2): x:88, y:272 (3): x:144 y:320

nice sounding >A<
not much to mod

star~

hi~
suggestion here~
[Easy]

1. 00:08:988 (2) - 1 grid right
2. 00:44:511 (5) - spacing.
3. 00:47:845 (2) - 1 grid right and up. so it is in the middle of slider.
4. 00:48:511 (1) - 1 grid left
5. 01:06:797 (2) - 2 grid right and 1 grid up ?
6. 01:13:083 (2) - spacing.
7. 01:15:940 (1) - ^
8. 01:18:226 (1) - ^

fine in normal and hard ~
star

Ok, finally going to get to this, though I expect problems to be few.

Easy:
(mostly stylistic b/c I like symmetry)
00:06:702 (2) - Looks weird just slightly off of vertically aligned to the end of (1).
00:07:369 (1) - Have the center of this align with 2.
00:30:226 (1) - Why not fit this against the curve from (1)?
00:34:083 (2) - Align to center of (1)
01:06:797 (2) - ^
01:15:226 (2) - ^

Normal:
00:25:654 (4) - Align to (3)

Hard:
00:12:131- Add a note?
00:48:702- Add a note?
00:53:273- ^

Nice tune and map, though the 1/3rd beat took some adjusting to. Starred!

\:D/

lovely song that brings me back a lot of memories of that game
not much to mod, every diff is good to me
~star

k start modding.

[General]

1. unify the lead in to 2000
2. Consider a silence slider.(sliderslide.wav)

[Easy]

1. PLEASE snap ALL the GREEN LINES
2. 00:01:645(2)-add a whisle at the end of the slider?
3. 00:11:940(1)-umm...Could you make this slider more beautiful?
4. 00:35:369(1)-add a whistle here.
5. 00:37:083(1)-This slider is too close to the previous slider.Make sure you are follow the distance snap when you are mapping a easy difficulty.
6. 01:09:654(1)-This slider...just feel a bit weird.Could you make it more regularly?
7. 01:16:512(1.2)-Use whistle to instead of CLAP.It doesn't fit the music now.

[Normal]

1. PLEASE snap ALL the GREEN LINES
2. 00:08:512(3)-umm..Don't stack here?
3. 00:220:988(1)-I know you're follow the music here.But consider it is a Normal difficulty.Newbie will scare with the short slider also it will make confused to newbie.So maybe change an another rhythm?
4. 00:30:131(1)-^ Same.
5. 00:35:369(1)-add a whistle at the end of the slider.(I won't note this again)
6. 0:05:654(2)-The beginning of the slider is invisible due to skin elements (300 100 50 )
7. 01:11:940(3)-Weird slider!!INDEED.

[Hard]

1. PLEASE snap ALL the GREEN LINES
2. [00:11:266(3)-Use a whistle to instead of clap
3. 00:30:988(4)-Weird slider...Fell free to change it or not.
4. 00:38:226(3)-Maybe make this slider like (1)-?
5. 01:16:797(2)-This slider doesn't fit the music :<
6. 01:26:178(x)-I prefer add a beat here.

That's all.Star.

._. Late modding,sorry.
---------------------------------
[General]
OFFSET:525

IMO, notes on these lines maybe more suitable instead of 1/3 lines.

[Easy]
AR+1
00:03:369 (5) - make it look better.

[Normal]
00:38:226 (3) - make it look better.
----------------------------------
Other things look nice~
Star~☆

Sorry,but the offset i have now is fine,and the song is in 1/3,so the mayor part of the notes are 1/3.
Thanks for the mod,anyway~

Go kevin

[General]

1. Remove the useless letterbox, there's no break in your map.

[Easy]

1. Imo purple(1/3) and blue(1/4) ticks notes shouldn't be circles on an easy since they're hard to hit, just a suggestion.
2. 00:04:226 - Add a note?
3. 00:24:988 (2,1) - Fix the spacing here
4. 01:15:940 (1,2,3) - ^

[Normal]

1. Approach rate +1?
2. 00:13:083 (2,3,4) - Fix the spacing here.
3. 00:15:369 (3,1) - ^
4. 00:24:797 (3,4) - ^
5. 00:28:226 (1,2) - ^
6. 00:32:797 - Add a circle?
7. 00:40:511 (3,1) - Fix the spacing here.
8. 00:58:226 (2,3) - ^
9. 01:06:797 (3,1,2) - ^
10. 01:09:369 (1,2) - ^
11. 01:21:654 (5,1) - ^

[Hard]

1. Approach Rate is too slow, +1 please. It's really a pain to hit the stacks with AR7 ;_;
2. 00:13:940 (8) - Fix the stack of this note. (You can delete the note and then replace it under the slider to make a perfect stack)
3. 00:54:702 (7,8) - Same thing about the stack.

That's all, have a star o/

ok

Here's the mod:

General

1. One of the only things I'm skeptical about is the 1/3 hits. It's seems more fitting to snap it to the 1/2 divisor. Use 50% playback rate to check. Or get a BAT to help.
2. Some sliders aren't symmetrical enough....

[Easy]

1. 00:05:083 (1) - make symmetrical like [img=http://puu.sh/1Pxh]this[/img]
2. 00:07:369 (1) - ^
3. 00:48:511 (1) - a bit offscreen
4. 01:03:369 (3) - 1 grid right

[Normal

1. 00:01:083 (3) - add finish at the end of the slider
2. 01:23:369 (3) - ^

Haha, nice beats.... Star!

[Hard]:

1. 00:04:797 (6,1) - spacing
2. 00:10:797 (3,1) - ^
3. 00:21:845 (5,6) - ^
4. 00:23:083 (9,1,2) - ^
5. 00:32:512 (1,2,3) -
6. 00:35:940 (3,4,5,6) - ^
7. 00:51:940 (3,1,2) - ^
8. 01:13:083 (6,7,1) - ^

lol nice music for rhythm game, star~

Hi^^

I found only:

Hard:
00:59:559 (5,6) make it in the same line as (7)[00:59:940]

No kudosu, pls! ^^

Star:)

Hi~

Normal
00:26:797 (2) - I think this clap on the end doesn't sound good
00:42:226 (3) - Finish on start may be fine

Hard
00:10:797 (3) - Clap on the end

That's all o.o"
Sorry i couldn't find anything more.
Love the map and song Star~

General

224 kbps is unrankable. Use a sound editing program to reencode it to 192.

Easy

00:00:512 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Suggestion: Most of your song is small 2-3 length combos. This seems out of place going up to 6. Add new combo for note 4?

00:05:083 (1) - This isn't entirely symmetrical. Take the last move point and move it 1 unit to the right and that should fix it.

00:09:654 (1,2) - I rather like the snap 0.83 as its used here. Apply 0.83 here 00:11:940 (1,2) - ? In any case make both areas spaced with the same snap as they are the same rhythm.

00:17:083 (2) - I don't like how unsymmetrical this is. Please move the move points around until both sides of the slider are the same distance away from the note in the middle. Also perhaps keep the snap 0.8 in mind. I think the start of the slider is too close to satisfy the 0.8 snap.

00:41:654 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Add new combo to note 4 for same reason.

01:22:797 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - New combo to note 4.

Normal

00:17:654 (2) - I think this would look better if it was center with note 1.

00:53:083 (1) - Center around note 5?

Hard

00:22:512 (6,7) - This looks closer than it should be. It's 0.87 and the other segments are 0.92.

00:42:226 (3) - Center better around that note?

00:48:797 (2,3) - Use 0.91 or 0.92?

00:53:369 (2,3) - 0.87 is too close.




Nice map. Star

Fixed part of the mod,and...I've just verified if the song was 224 kbps,but i saw that the bitrate was only 190 kbps o.o

Ircmodded, fixed only a new combo inconsistency.



EDIT: The bitrate of the mp3 is fine.
Is a VBR with an average of 190kbps and a peak of 224kbps, so it's rankable.

Thank you so much

Okay, on normal, here's some things I think you should fix:
-15:335 - Make that repeating slider shorter, it goes on too long and it doesn't fit the beat
-22:40 - This one seems to be the same as the first one, so make it shorter. Unless it's supposed to be like that and there's some kind of beat I'm not hearing?
-126:41 - It's a little bit off with the drums here, I guess it's fine if you really like it, but what I would recommend is circle, triple-repeat, circle. That might not make sense in the way I'm saying it but go mess with it some more.

Other than that, I think you're good to go Good luck.

Sorry,I won't fix Your mod,but thanks anyway~

The Name of the Music is "Junes Theme", performed by Shoji Meguro.

I don't know if it turns the map unrankable, talk with Card N' Force before pop your bubble.

Btw, your map is good, Star~

Katsuri wrote:

The Name of the Music is "Junes Theme", performed by Shoji Meguro.

I don't know if it turns the map unrankable, talk with Card N' Force before pop your bubble.

Btw, your map is good, Star~

I've talked with cnf about this,and i'm ok about changing the name,so i gave you kudosu for the help

Katsuri wrote:

The Name of the Music is "Junes Theme", performed by Shoji Meguro.

I don't know if it turns the map unrankable, talk with Card N' Force before pop your bubble.

Btw, your map is good, Star~

This is something that should be discussed between the mapper and the ranking BAT and is not reason for popping. The fact that he did simply shows that you got lucky.

Shiirn wrote:

Katsuri wrote:

The Name of the Music is "Junes Theme", performed by Shoji Meguro.

I don't know if it turns the map unrankable, talk with Card N' Force before pop your bubble.

Btw, your map is good, Star~

This is something that should be discussed between the mapper and the ranking BAT and is not reason for popping. The fact that he did simply shows that you got lucky.

Well,I talked about this with cfn and we decided to change the name,i know this isn't really an unrankable issue,but I thought it was better to fix this.

Good

More Persona 4! Star~

The sliders could definitely use some cleaning (make them more symmetrical, remove sharp corners, etc), but if you really don't want to fix them, I am fine with keeping most of them the way they are.

Easy:
Normal mod:
00:37:083 (1) - the sharp corners in this curve don't look that great, so I suggest you stretch out the sliders a bit and make the curves a bit more shallow for a better look imo
01:09:654 (1) - Was this slider meant to have whistle during sliding? I don't recall other slider following similar beats having the whistle.
I suggest you add a spinner somewhere in the difficulty to prevent people from having ties in the highscore.

Combo mod:
00:57:654 (3,1) - remove 1's new combo and add a new combo to 3 to follow your pattern of having a new combo every 2 measures (2 tall white bars)
00:59:940 (3) - new combo for the same reason as the one above
01:06:797 (2,1) - remove 1's new combo and add a new combo to 2 to follow your pattern of having a new combo every 2 measures (I know this leaves a combo with only 1 note in it, but this way follows the music better and is consistent with the previous sections)
01:09:083 (2,1) - remove 1's new combo and add a new combo to 2 to follow your pattern of having a new combo every 2 measures

Normal:
Normal mod:
00:26:797 (2) - the slightly sharp corner on this slower don't look that great to me, so I advise the same thing as I did on Easy

Combo mod:
I would like it if the combos were consistent with easy since I believe those fit better (places such as 00:25:654 (4,1) and 00:27:940 (3,1)) Since you are consistent though, I won't complain further

Hard:
Normal mod:
01:04:511 (1,2) - why are these 2 notes not aligned?

Combo mod: same as normal

============================
Most of the things I have posted are small aesthetic changes, so nothing major. Still, little things add up, so I recommend you try to fix as many things as possible, including the things I just made a blanket statement about. I guess I can consider this map for ranking after fixing, but I am still unsure about that. For now, Star!

Thanks,I fixed all the mod,and I tried to make some slider shapes better

After a few more combo mods and talking about note alignments, I think this map is ready for a rank.

milk D:

Gratz!

bella kevin

sing by nanako over & over to make her feel less lonley
congratz for the rank~

Thanks for the congratulations,and thanks for who modded my map or helped me