When google gives you a full mod
Very little that actually needs changing here tbh, these are more suggestions from me than have too's.
[General]
[Cup]
[Salad]
[Platter]
[Rain]
[Everlasting Love]
Very little that actually needs changing here tbh, these are more suggestions from me than have too's.
[General]
- 02:41:208 - 02:48:065 - HS volume too high in this section imo.go would reduce all by 10-15%
- Pretty big diff spike from platter to rain. possible to nerf rain a bit and buff platter a bit?
[Cup]
- 00:10:994 (2) - feels a bit underemphasised with all the right to left movement. maybe reverse direction at 00:10:351 (1) - so it goes left left right left
- 00:13:780 (1,2,3) - percussion hit at 00:14:422 (2) - is a bit underemphasised imo. would reverse dicretion at to instead to create some emphasis here
- 00:44:637 (1) - why not move back to 00:44:208 (3) - so theres some emphasis on this ending note
- 03:03:494 (1,2) - would reduce this spacing a bit more, since vocal is swallowed. would use 0.7x imo.
- 03:10:565 (2) - intensity is a bit higher than 03:09:708 (1) - so maybe take the anchor and move it a bit more to the left so the pattern has a bit more spacing.
- 03:38:422 (2,1) - feels a bit under emphasised after the harder to hit 03:38:422 (2) - would either increase spacing between these two or use a simpler pattern for 03:38:422 (2) - and a harder pattern for 03:39:280 (1) - to create some epmhasis.
- 04:05:208 (1,2) - would tilt 1 a bit more vertical, as it is now 1 feels like it should be on a significantly stronger beat than 04:06:065 (3,4) - which i dont feel is true
- 04:40:351 (3) - preffer a 1/2 repeat here instead of your 1/1 slider.
- 04:40:351 (3) - make this a reverse direction repeat instead maybe. making the new vocal line stand more out. feels like these beats are more connected to the section before than they should.
- 05:42:065 (3) - ctrl + h and move to the right side maybe? feels a bit underemphasised imo.
[Salad]
- 00:05:851 (2,3,4) - maybe reduce spacing a bit? almost a need to tap dash somewhere here to catch everything.
- 01:52:780 (3,1) - jump seems a bit high spaced, but didnt have any problems catching it either, sooo... maybe reduce spacing a bit?
- 02:41:208 - 02:42:922 (1) - HS volume too high in this section would reduce all by 10-15%
- 03:08:637 (1,2) - spacing here is too low imo. vocals are clear here.
- 03:23:208 (2,1,2,3) - ^
- 03:56:637 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - this whole section is walkable if you are precise eanogh. is that the point? if not i would buff distance a bit where suitable.
- 04:09:922 - 04:34:137 - this whole section is almost walkable too, think there is like 5 must dash places in the kiai. why not add more clear dashes on places like 04:13:351 (3,1) - ?
- 04:37:780 - 05:03:494 - okay so pointing this out here, after a few attempts i managed to play this entier section without touching my dash at all. Meaning its entierly possible to buff some spacings to make the diffrence between walk and dash more clear in this kiai. I feel having adequate spacing for dashes is a good thing to make it more visually clear to new players what is a walk and what is a dash. also spacing variety makes for more fun maps.
- 07:08:422 (5,1) - after a long section of regular walk spacing this dash comes up and might be hard to interprite as a dash after so long without a dash. would buff distance a bit to make that more clear.
[Platter]
- 00:45:708 (4,5) - and 00:46:672 (4,5) - feels pretty underemphasised imo. Why not reverse direction for the slider to create a bit more movement to emphasise the sound? goes for all the stream into slider patterns in this section tbh
- 03:23:422 (3,4,1,2,3) - feel beats instead of sliders fits more, looks a bit weird to have slider trail between one and not the other.
- 04:58:672 (2) - HS way to strong on the head here, sticks too much out without any significant sound.
- 04:58:672 (2) - ^
- 05:26:208 (5,6,7,8,1) - this entier stream section has the significant direction change on the downbeats which is logical... except this one where the direction change comes after the downbeat. i would change the shape of the stream and move it to the other side of 05:26:530 (8) - for a more concistent pattern.
[Rain]
- 00:05:101 (4,5) - spacing maybe a bit high
- 00:11:637 (3,4,5) - preffer same spacing between all of these isnatead of longer between 00:11:851 (4,5) -
- 00:29:637 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - is a bit too dense imo. reduces impact of other more fitting 1/8 streams like section at 01:41:208 -
- 01:41:530 - HS is a bit low on beats like this one in the section imo. feels a bit weird to hit something when i get no audio feedback.
- 02:18:922 - while stream is not hard and it is fitting i feel this note density is just too much for a rain.
- 03:04:351 (3) - tail feels a bit underemphasised here. maybe add a red anchor on the slider tick and make the slider go back to the left after the tick for a little movement on the tail hit
- 03:44:208 (9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16) - would preffer if you mapped these sections as 1/4 rhythm and the rest of the stream as 1/8. Making these sections stand out a bit more with some rhythmical diffrences aswell as HS diffrence.
- 06:26:208 (4,5,6,7,8) - this 1/8 sticks a bit too much out for my comfort. i would maybe map a 1/8 stream for the notes before too (06:25:780 (1,2,3) -) but might get a bit intense. reducing hitsound a bit might work too, so it stands less out.
- 06:53:637 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - same as point above. it seems like your following the sound starting at 06:53:208 - but only map the 2nd half with 1/8 streams, which seems a bit odd to me.
[Everlasting Love]
- 00:03:494 - 00:17:208 - this section gets a bit repetetive by the end. i was gona suggest some pattern use like the ones you use after 00:17:208 - but seems like you wanted to map it more concistently instead. i'll still suggest mapping each of the sections (00:03:494 - 00:17:208 - and 00:17:208 - 00:29:208 - ) with a higher incrase in intensity towards the end so you can add a bit more variety to the patterns in the intro. Meaning something like 00:12:708 (6,7,8,9,10) - this towards the end of the first section should be mapped more like 00:19:565 (4,5,6,7,8) - and vice versa
- 01:58:780 (5) - would preffer if this slider was a bit curved like 01:54:922 (1) - so you get this nice, straight curve straight curve pattern. (01:53:637 (5) - 01:54:922 (1) - 01:57:065 (5) - )
- 03:24:065 (5) - feels underemphasised imo. pretty strong sound but no diffrence in flow or spacing to indicate that.
- 03:25:780 - would map this beat too