Requested via discord.
Kudosu only when helpful!
General
- Add the preview point to Reimu's Salad please.
- Platter diff is missing "hareimu" in its tags.
- You've got 2 images in your beatmap folder. I am not sure which one you wanna use as your bg picture (the .png has the better resolution), but the other image should be deleted.
- The audio file bitrate is too high atm, it must be between 128 kbps and 192 kbps but the bitrate of your mp3 is currently at 255 kbps. I don't know where to get another mp3, so sorry that I can only point it out.
- Is slider tick rate 2 really necessary? It makes the diffs much more dense, which is no gain for the mapset imo. Especially Cup is too dense imo. I would prefer a tick rate of 1 instead of 2 for the mapset.
- HP spread is currently 4/3/5, doesn't make 3/4/5 much more sense?
- AR spread is currently 5/7/8. I've played Cup with AR 6 and think that it plays well so making the AR spread 6/7/8 for a more linear AR spread is better imo.
Cup
- 00:00:806 (1,2,1,2,3,4) - Plays really repetitively, how about making 00:02:035 (1,2) - both curved to change it up a bit? It fits the music well imo.
- 00:03:614 (1) - It would fit the music way better to curve the slider instead of making it straight (I really like how you did the pattern at 00:08:701 (2,1) - ).
- 00:11:859 - It would fit your Cup to add here a note, makes it more consistent with previous parts.
- 00:13:964 (3,4) - Way too big distance for a Cup, please nerf the distance (it also makes no sense emphasizing-wise to make this distance so big while having almost no distance between 00:14:491 (4) - and 00:14:842 (1) - ).
- 00:19:929 (4,5,1) - I think it fits the music and the rhythm of the map better to make 00:19:929 (4,5) - vertical and curve 00:20:456 (1) - .
Reimu's Salad
- 00:05:894 (5,6,7,1) - Emphasizing is a bit questionable here. You always did a jump towards the downbeats but not here, instead you made a big gap between 00:05:894 (5) - and 00:06:245 (6) - while ignoring the sound at 00:06:157 - . I think it is much better to map a very simplistic stream pattern from 00:05:894 - to 00:06:245 - and make a dash to 00:06:421 (1) - or mapping the stream until 00:06:333 - instead while making no dash at all.
- 00:20:456 (1) - What is this slider supposed to do? It doesn't produce movement but may look confusing to a low level player. Maybe you can make the slidershape more obvious regarding its function?
- 00:24:315 - The jumps that come after this note are pretty spicy (the one before the break and the ones after the break). Making them just a bit easier fits better imo but that's only a personal preference.
Platter
Salad and Platter are really nice, Cup could definitively benefit from more mods imo. Good Luck!- 00:04:315 (2) - Should be more horizontal to introduce more movement (right now it is awful to play imo and is inconsistent with similar upcoming spots). Just move the whole map up to the point more to the left so that you've got the space that you need to tilt the slider more.
- 00:06:333 (8,1) - How about making this a dash? Fits the intensity of the song imo.
- 00:31:596 (9,1,2) - Same as 00:06:333 (8,1) - + I would extend 00:31:683 (1) - to a 1/2 slider and make a hyper to 00:32:035 (2) - to fit the song better or at least move 00:32:035 (2) - more the left.