Yes, no KDs
Regarding meta - disscussed this with PandaHero who's quite familiar with PIU franchise. here's what we got - https://m.facebook.com/piufiestaex/Delis wrote:
the beatmap link almost 666666
[General]
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pump_It_Up_(video_game_series)#2011_Fiesta_EX
I can't really find the official source of the song so I pull a wikipedia out, and so apparently the "A" in the title needs to be uncapitalized
http://www.piugame.com/piu.prime/piu.pumpitup/en/3_piu.history.php
also the game title should be capitalized everything?or rather PUMP IT 2011 UP FIESTA EX according to what I only can find clearly is the logo
[Insane]
00:50:754 (1,2) - this is probably the only one pattern that I had a hard time to read it properly. would just decrease the spacing each other a bit or another nc on 00:51:087 (2) - also can stand out that the pattern more and so people can care of it. alright I added extra NC + decreased spacing as much as I could cause I can't get them any closer, otherwise it will overlap pretty ugly with 00:50:087 (10,11,12,13,14) and 00:51:920 (4)
[Easy]
next time you should stick to distance snap really xD inconsistent spacing doesn't really look great ohh um okay lol I can't really see much difference though, cause visually the different spacing between objects should be clearly readable even for novices. But okay, I'll use DS next time.
00:37:421 (1) - pretty nazi but if you move this circle like 2 pixel left it actually improves the flow and the quite small gap in spacing. fixed!
Thank you, Delichan!!!Delis wrote:
[Hard]
00:52:754 (3) - this rhythm feels sad that followed neither the drums or the vocals, would shorten it to 1/2 and a circle at 00:53:254 - to fit the rhythm around more accurately. sure
01:33:921 - think forgot a whistle for the piano nono that's the whistle rhythm
thank youDelis wrote:
the beatmap link almost 666666
[Normal]
00:09:587 (2) - 26 degree looks too much when your sliders are usually around 15 degrees, especially it's a longer slider.
made a 15 degrees here
00:14:421 (4) - would do a 1/2 slider instead here, the drums here are more intense than anywhere else in this section. and so the rhythm 00:15:421 (2,3) - can be swapped since I'm pretty sure your rhythm here is relying on the drums not the vocals.
I agree about 1/2 slider, but disagree about swaping rhythm, I mapped a vocal in this combo
00:30:921 (5) - to be honest would stick to the drum at 00:31:087 - the reason could be the same as above but you didn't really tend to follow the pianos.
oh yeah, your rhythm iis better
01:22:754 (1,2,3,4,2,3) - spaming 1/1 stacks all of sudden? having more movements for cursor would be more interesting as it's still in the kiai. this might go to the last kiai as well.
Dunno, I think these stacks are cool
02:24:087 (1,2) - something that is more comfortable to aim such as 02:22:754 (1,2) - is absolutely a better way to represent the "only vocals" part here.
changed
some of 30 degree looking sliders occassionally look quite out of place, prob you should look through for it. 00:31:254 (6) - is one for the example.
oke but I can't see problem in it
Voli wrote:
yo, cool map and song, just a couple of structure things i noticed before this gets pushed to qualifiedFreestyle gl! and welcome back to the mapping hood thanks a lot
- 00:21:421 (1) - this one feels underwhelming compared to your usual patterning with these (ex. 01:06:754 (1) -
). Usually you map these patterns with some sort of flowbreak and increased spacing, but here 00:21:421 (1) - doesn't stand out much and the jump to 00:21:921 (2) - feels too much :p consider ctrl+g on that last one? I got what you mean, but that's the first jumpy section of the map, so I wanted 00:20:754 (11,12) to flow into this carefully, I even thought to stack slider end of (12) to start of the (1) slider lol anyway, overall I like this particular pattern so I'd like to leave it as it is.- 00:22:587 (5) - that strong vocal is on a sliderend here? not sure if you want that (as its the only one mapped like this throughout the entire map i think) fully re-arranged this pattern. thanks.
- 00:50:754 (1) - i feel like you can give this some more emphasis, with the big sv change the jump from 00:50:587 (15) - feels rather underwhelming. How about this? https://voli.s-ul.eu/yCQKUfmi.png uhhh, doesn't look good to me now, but I guess I had to change it. fixed.
- 01:22:754 (1) - separate this note/place it further away from the rest of the pattern cuz of the huge finish and new combo? example: https://voli.s-ul.eu/e0uKjHhm.png that's a nice suggestion, I changed that.
- ^ same goes for notes like 02:08:088 (1) -, check through the map if you can find places like this if you apply it changed that as well
- sometimes the beat pairing feels a bit wrong: 02:33:254 (1,2) - are paired in this pattern but according to the song 02:33:421 (2) - should be placed further away. Same goes for notes like 02:28:087 etc. yeah, gotcha, I agree that the downbeat should start the combo and be a jump-to note, but in this case I just see no way to re-arrange this pattern without losing the flow and overall reworking of whole loop :\ so if it's possible, I'll just leave it like this so far but gonna keep ur suggestion in mind for future.
- 01:56:754 (1,2,1,2) - I don't really understand the NCing here o.o whats the deal with that? well that's a pretty common combo pattern in my map, where I point out double-circles jump patterns. there're many of such in this particulap map and in my other maps generally
Title: 남자답게
Romanised Title: Like A Man
Voli wrote:
After researching I finally found the official CD cover. The song is 05. on this tracklist.imgFront
Back
icebeam maybe address this and other counterarguments first before going off on your own spiel behind your philosophy on the "necessity of metadata" and whatnot. i love your map, but its sad to see you make such a pointless argument over a rather insignificant change in the long run. just get it over with and move on..Doyak wrote:
Also if you think you can rely on that CD, it shows outsider (all lowercase) and I guess you don't want to follow it.
maps have already been taken down from download and mp3 removed due to DMCA, who's to say suing isn't a plausible optionIceBeam wrote:
no one's gonna even sue you anyway, so adding extra fields and guidelines which make an already extremely tiring ranking process even more complicated is a really wise and well-thought decision, right?
because koreans also play this gameIceBeam wrote:
and finally, why shouild I see a foreign alphabet which is unreadable for me when I play my own map? I find this offending and dissapointing for my gaming experience.