talked to ProfessionalBox in irc about some things i still had a few concerns with
chatlog
19:32 Doormat: 04:09:562 (2) - 04:10:762 (2) -
19:32 Doormat: you mentioned that timing points on red tick is intentional
19:33 Doormat: but i find that hard to believe when every other 1/2 slider that goes over a white tick has a timing on its slider end
19:33 Doormat: e.g. 04:11:737 (1) - 04:12:937 (2) - 04:14:737 (2) - 04:19:537 (2) - 04:20:137 (1) - 04:21:337 (3) - etc.
19:33 ProfessionalBox: timing point
19:33 ProfessionalBox: wait
19:33 ProfessionalBox: I might have misread that
19:33 Doormat: green lines
19:33 Doormat: yeah
19:33 ProfessionalBox: as wrong snap
19:33 Doormat: no
19:33 ProfessionalBox: lets see
19:33 Doormat: i was talking about green lines
19:34 ProfessionalBox: the green lines are
19:34 Doormat: sorry i probably could've used better wording
19:34 ProfessionalBox: leftovers from the past
19:34 Doormat: o
19:34 ProfessionalBox: I can delete all of the unnecessary ones
19:34 ProfessionalBox: they serve no purpose
19:34 Doormat: no what i'm saying is
19:34 Doormat: shouldn't the green lines on those two sliders i posted
19:34 Doormat: be moved back to the blue tick
19:34 Doormat: before it
19:35 ProfessionalBox: does it change something? the sampleset?
19:35 Doormat: yeah
19:35 ProfessionalBox: oh i know why
19:35 ProfessionalBox: sliderslide1 is muted
19:35 ProfessionalBox: that's why the green line is there?
19:36 Doormat: it's affecting the slider end though
19:36 ProfessionalBox: to mute the slider
19:36 ProfessionalBox: but there are no hitnormal samples on either?
19:36 ProfessionalBox: so it shouldn't matter ?
19:36 ProfessionalBox: or am I drunk
19:36 Doormat: hang on
19:37 Doormat: right now 04:09:487 - is following S:C2
19:37 Doormat: same with 04:10:687 -
19:37 Doormat: every other case after these two has that slider end following S:C1
19:38 Doormat: you don't have a soft-hitnormal2 so it's defaulting to the soft-hitnormal in my custom skin and it makes this really weird sound that seems unintentional
19:38 ProfessionalBox: DDDDDD
19:39 ProfessionalBox: I can add the samplesets there
19:39 ProfessionalBox: is it only those 2
19:39 Doormat: i guess that's the easiest solution LOL
19:39 Doormat: yeah it's only these two which is why i thought it was really weird
19:39 ProfessionalBox: I'll do that
19:39 Doormat: since every other slider end after it follows sampleset 1
19:39 ProfessionalBox: no point in talking about this more
19:39 Doormat: k
19:39 ProfessionalBox: since its such a simple thing lmao
19:40 ProfessionalBox: fixed now
19:40 ProfessionalBox: xd
19:40 Doormat: also this point was ignored 01:39:712 (1) - are the whistles on slider body and slider end intentional?
19:40 Doormat: in the mod
19:40 Doormat: whistle on sliderbody comes off as unintentional
19:40 ProfessionalBox: fixed it
19:40 Doormat: k
19:40 ProfessionalBox: Sing probably missed it
19:40 Doormat: yeah just one thing for sing then lol
19:40 ProfessionalBox: if its a hitsounding thing I can fix taht too'
19:41 Doormat: it's not
19:41 Doormat: it's a rhythm thing
19:41 ProfessionalBox: alrightt
19:32 Doormat: you mentioned that timing points on red tick is intentional
19:33 Doormat: but i find that hard to believe when every other 1/2 slider that goes over a white tick has a timing on its slider end
19:33 Doormat: e.g. 04:11:737 (1) - 04:12:937 (2) - 04:14:737 (2) - 04:19:537 (2) - 04:20:137 (1) - 04:21:337 (3) - etc.
19:33 ProfessionalBox: timing point
19:33 ProfessionalBox: wait
19:33 ProfessionalBox: I might have misread that
19:33 Doormat: green lines
19:33 Doormat: yeah
19:33 ProfessionalBox: as wrong snap
19:33 Doormat: no
19:33 ProfessionalBox: lets see
19:33 Doormat: i was talking about green lines
19:34 ProfessionalBox: the green lines are
19:34 Doormat: sorry i probably could've used better wording
19:34 ProfessionalBox: leftovers from the past
19:34 Doormat: o
19:34 ProfessionalBox: I can delete all of the unnecessary ones
19:34 ProfessionalBox: they serve no purpose
19:34 Doormat: no what i'm saying is
19:34 Doormat: shouldn't the green lines on those two sliders i posted
19:34 Doormat: be moved back to the blue tick
19:34 Doormat: before it
19:35 ProfessionalBox: does it change something? the sampleset?
19:35 Doormat: yeah
19:35 ProfessionalBox: oh i know why
19:35 ProfessionalBox: sliderslide1 is muted
19:35 ProfessionalBox: that's why the green line is there?
19:36 Doormat: it's affecting the slider end though
19:36 ProfessionalBox: to mute the slider
19:36 ProfessionalBox: but there are no hitnormal samples on either?
19:36 ProfessionalBox: so it shouldn't matter ?
19:36 ProfessionalBox: or am I drunk
19:36 Doormat: hang on
19:37 Doormat: right now 04:09:487 - is following S:C2
19:37 Doormat: same with 04:10:687 -
19:37 Doormat: every other case after these two has that slider end following S:C1
19:38 Doormat: you don't have a soft-hitnormal2 so it's defaulting to the soft-hitnormal in my custom skin and it makes this really weird sound that seems unintentional
19:38 ProfessionalBox: DDDDDD
19:39 ProfessionalBox: I can add the samplesets there
19:39 ProfessionalBox: is it only those 2
19:39 Doormat: i guess that's the easiest solution LOL
19:39 Doormat: yeah it's only these two which is why i thought it was really weird
19:39 ProfessionalBox: I'll do that
19:39 Doormat: since every other slider end after it follows sampleset 1
19:39 ProfessionalBox: no point in talking about this more
19:39 Doormat: k
19:39 ProfessionalBox: since its such a simple thing lmao
19:40 ProfessionalBox: fixed now
19:40 ProfessionalBox: xd
19:40 Doormat: also this point was ignored 01:39:712 (1) - are the whistles on slider body and slider end intentional?
19:40 Doormat: in the mod
19:40 Doormat: whistle on sliderbody comes off as unintentional
19:40 ProfessionalBox: fixed it
19:40 Doormat: k
19:40 ProfessionalBox: Sing probably missed it
19:40 Doormat: yeah just one thing for sing then lol
19:40 ProfessionalBox: if its a hitsounding thing I can fix taht too'
19:41 Doormat: it's not
19:41 Doormat: it's a rhythm thing
19:41 ProfessionalBox: alrightt
i'm satisfied with most of the reasonings that you guys provided, but yeah get sing to go over this last point because that 3/4 reverse slider really feels off compared to the rest of that sectionSing wrote:
03:07:312 (1) - this 3/4 reverse slider feels really off with the rest of the section; why suddenly switch to vocals here when you were mapping to synths before and after this? i think it's more appropriate to map to the white/red ticks of the synth for this section ive been prioritizing mapping the vocals over the synth, as seen in 03:02:512 (1,2) - ,and 03:04:312 (2,2,2) - , it just so happens that 03:07:312 (1) - is the only place here where the vocals dont land on the red tick, so i emphasized it through this long slider, whilst ignoring the synth for this short time. I could do 1/2 sliders instead to hit both but i think it would add too much intensity to a part that should be downtime from the kiai anyways i don't really agree with your logic here; it sounds more like the vocals land on 03:07:462 - rather than the blue tick. musically 03:07:312 - is the same as 03:02:512 - so the rhythm choices you use should be similar to reflect that