forum

Banshi - Kotonoha

posted
Total Posts
54
show more
Chaoslitz
heyy

[General]
  1. Can add tags "NIZI-RINGO" "NIZI" "RINGO"
[Easy]
  1. 00:58:606 - Missing normal samples
  2. 01:10:414 - Missing whistle
[Normal]
  1. 00:34:191 (3) - It is not a good idea to skip those white ticks but following drum in red only in this pattern, it will confuse beginners and cannot follow the rhythm properly
  2. 01:14:882 - I think this should be S:C1 instead of S
  3. 01:14:244 (1,2) - They should be snapped to 1/3 instead =3=
[Hard]
  1. 00:39:776 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - I think it is better to follow the ds snap instead of placing in this way, also it may be too harsh for players to hit the triples after holding those 1/4 reverse for so long lol
  2. 01:31:478 (3,4,5,6,7,8) - yea still think it is a bit harsh >_>, i think two 1/4 reverse sliders would be better
  3. 01:55:095 (1,2,3) - ye same thing about the ds
[Aia's Insane]
  1. 00:31:797 (8) - 00:37:542 - 00:58:606 - Missing normal sampleset
  2. 00:59:563 (3,7) - ^
  3. 01:14:244 (1,2) - same as normal, should be snapped to 1/3
  4. 01:17:595 - 01:18:074 - missing whistle
  5. 01:31:478 (4) - Ctrl+g becuase it is now in opposite direction
  6. 01:40:095 - are hitsounds missing starting from here till kiai?
[Night]
  1. 00:27:170 (8,9,10,11) - would be nice if they are symmetric = 3= (you can blanket 00:27:329 (9) under 00:25:893 (2)'s end to do the symmetric)
  2. 01:47:436 (1) - that whistle slide :v you dont need whistle in the slider body

call me back when nao rebubbled it =w=/
Topic Starter
Nozhomi
Fixed everything from your suggestions Chaoslitz thanks a lot ><
Waiting for Aia about small things you pointed for her, since I fixed hitsounds already.
Fixed since was basically really small changes but important one.

Updated~
Nao Tomori
reconfirmed snapping stuff >.>
Chaoslitz
Qualified~
Topic Starter
Nozhomi

Speedranking is real.

Big thanks Chaoslitz and Nao ♥
schoolboy
you forgot to give nao kds
Topic Starter
Nozhomi

Komore wrote:

you forgot to give nao kds
Gosh I should stop forgetting that thx lol
Luel Roseline

Nozhomi wrote:

Komore wrote:

you forgot to give nao kds
Gosh I should stop forgetting that thx lol
Nao + Metadata Miss Nerf
sry patch. It's golden time now.

01:40:893 - Add timingpoint with volume 45%
Topic Starter
Nozhomi

Luel Roseline wrote:

Nao + Metadata Miss Nerf
sry patch. It's golden time now.
Could you explain me what is wrong with the current one ? Because I don't see anything wrong with metadata right now. If you talk about adding other artists on tags, I don't think they're accurate since they're part of album but not the song.

Luel Roseline wrote:

01:40:893 - Add timingpoint with volume 45%
Why ? I did increase by 10% each time, would be not coherent to add one only for this.
IamKwaN
I could not spot any flaws in metadata, please elaborate.
alacat
Luel Roseline
ala hype
IamKwaN
that bandcamp page only states Banshi though
alacat
Why only take the metadata from that page? The artist name is ばんし/Banshi from circle website and these images. p/6032064


http://banbanshi.web.fc2.com/new1.html
Topic Starter
Nozhomi
So as I said to alacat, https://osu.ppy.sh/s/469334 this map used the same source for metadata and no one complained about it, so should be fine.
Still if you think the japanese name of Banshi should be used because more accurate, I won't mind ofc.

Waiting for your final word.
IamKwaN
It's because whenever there's an official page showing only Banshi, then I'm fine with that.

I leave the decision to you too, alacat.
alacat
I know that is official page. But if we use "Banshi/Banshi" on the artist field, it will be ignored CD cover and original name. I couldn't confirm "Banshi/Banshi" on other sites (Circle and Artist website). p/6032064
So we have to change to ばんし/Banshi for artist in my opinion.
Topic Starter
Nozhomi
And fixed :3
alacat
ok~
Ora
gr8 set noz ^^
tit
Looks good, keep going.
Please sign in to reply.

New reply