wrongLapis Aoki wrote:
I guess this is the last mod before Celsius checks this..
[General]
- Each and every hitsound should be at least 100ms long. This is a rle and it is done to avoid issues with soundcards. You might want to add some extra silence at the end of the following hitsounds to make them rankable:
- soft-hitclap3.wav 28.46ms
- soft-hitwhistle3.wav 92.34ms (this one has a delay as well, so you should cut the beginning and some silince at the end)
- soft-hitclap3.wav has its peak volume somewhere near the end of the wav file, by the way. If I were you I would chack to make sure it is exactly the way you want it to sound.
- I am not too hapy with the way these difficulties are named. The diffnames are not connected with each other in any way and no visible progression can be seen. While I do agree that they're rankable, I'd rather have more generic difficulty names like Easy/Advanced or fully custom ones like Sleeping/Dancing. This would just make the set seem more consistent.
- 00:20:016 (2) - 00:29:161 (2) - 00:40:589 (3,2) - the circles here don't work with the rhythm you try to introduce. Most of the sliders are build around vocals and this is why the circles feel out of place. Moreover, circles give extra emphasis to those minor beats, whereas beats like 00:42:303 - 00:49:161 - don't even have any clickable objects.
Note: would apply to all similar circles unsupported by the vocals.
Not really satisfied with the way you've used circles in the parts of the song I've mentioned. Apart from that it is quite okay.
[Collapsing]
- 00:20:016 (2) - the same issue as the one I have mentioned on Easy. What happens is that beats like 00:19:444 - which are strong enough get literally no emphasis, whereas something as minor as 00:20:015 - gets a circle (which requires a lot of accuracy to hit and in general gives a lot more feedback than a slidertail).
The best way to solve this is to use 1/2 sliders like this, or just ignore the beats on red ticks completely. - 00:25:159 (3,1) - these are the only two overlaps, so it feels sort of random to have them. I would probably try to avoid them, unless it's done to represent some specific parts of the vocals.
Some slidershapes/patterns are pretty random in terms of shaspes/consistency (take 01:01:734 (3,4) - as an example). Otherwise it's okay.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Best of luck!