forum

YoungKillaG - Gohan [Taiko]

posted
Total Posts
69
show more
Topic Starter
Chromoxx

Skeuddy wrote:

Hello, Chromoxx, from my queue
lewd song, бля

Muzukashii
  1. 00:10:874 (39) - k the vocal at that part is at a lower pitch than the one before, so i'll leave d
  2. 00:44:565 (58) - ^ changed, but changed the note before it to d
  3. 00:48:257 (72) - ^ changed
  4. 01:13:640 (149) - ^ not changed, low pitch sound imo
  5. 01:17:025 (161,162,163) - ^, and 01:17:486 - Some note (k) i think it's good as it is
  6. 01:39:716 (227,228) - ^ ^
  7. 00:27:258 - End of spin i think it's fine like that

Swagg Oni
  1. 00:03:952 (25,28) - Swagp following the melody in the background there, so it fits as it is imo
  2. 00:04:875 (29) - k, and 00:05:567 (32,33) - Swap ^
  3. 00:18:489 (91) - ^ changed
  4. 00:24:258 (125) - ^, and 00:24:951 (128,129) - Swap changed
  5. 00:47:334 (104) and 00:47:796 (107) - ^ (change, pls) it's good as it is i think
  6. 00:50:103 (117) - ^ again, following the background melody there
  7. 00:51:949 (127,131) - ^ changed
  8. 00:54:488 (141) and 00:55:180 (145) - ^ no change
  9. 01:01:180 (16) - ^ no change
  10. 01:24:255 (73) - ^ no change
:D
Thx for modding! ;D
Fuel
Hi, M4M from my mod queue.

d = don, red note
k = kat, blue note
D = don finisher, big red note
K = kat finisher, big blue note

mod
General
This new BG doesn't have enough bling I'm sorely disappointed.

I think some of the sliders in the diffs don't really match (being drumrolly in Taiko rather than long and drawn out like in regular osu), but that's just my opinion. I'll just note that I THINK that spinners would be better in most of those places, or following the instrumentals over the vocals. It's also weird how some of the existing spinners end at different points between diffs.

Going from simple 1/4 triplets in Muzu to 1/6 in Oni seems like a bit of a jump :| Apart from that I found most of the diffs pretty fun.

Kantan
00:26:106 (31) - I think a spinner like in Muzu and Oni would be good.
01:02:567 - A d could go here? Could help to emphasise the lyrics in the kiai time.
01:06:260 - ^

Futsuu
01:02:567 - Same as per Kantan.
01:06:260 - ^
01:10:413 (135) - imo if you're following the lyrics more in this section you can remove this d.

Muzukashii
00:26:106 (1) - I think it would be good to make the end of the spinners in this diff and the Oni to be consistent.
00:30:952 - Replace slider with d kkk d?
01:39:606 (224) - This note sounds off-timed. I think it should go on the white tick at 01:39:490.

Swagg Oni
00:28:875 - You could add a 3-note pattern here (kkk?) and other notes after to replace the slider. You appear to be mostly following the instrumental part in this section anyway (replacing the equivalent of 00:30:952 (11) slider in Muzu with other notes).
00:41:683 (74) - Change to d?
00:47:567 (105,106,107,108) - I think the rhythm here should be x xxx instead of xxx x, maybe k ddk?
01:37:183 (32) - I think a spinner here is good. shame it isn't yeahhhh yeahhhh

I lose it every time I finish and then I hear 'swag swag swag' lmao.

Hope it helps :D
Topic Starter
Chromoxx

L1m3s wrote:

Hi, M4M from my mod queue.

d = don, red note
k = kat, blue note
D = don finisher, big red note
K = kat finisher, big blue note

mod
General
This new BG doesn't have enough bling I'm sorely disappointed. YoungKillaG has too much swag to upload pictures that fit the resolution needed for ranking ;w;

I think some of the sliders in the diffs don't really match (being drumrolly in Taiko rather than long and drawn out like in regular osu), but that's just my opinion. I'll just note that I THINK that spinners would be better in most of those places, or following the instrumentals over the vocals. It's also weird how some of the existing spinners end at different points between diffs. i think most of the sliders are ok

Going from simple 1/4 triplets in Muzu to 1/6 in Oni seems like a bit of a jump :| Apart from that I found most of the diffs pretty fun. if this gets brought up again i will make the muzu a bit harder

Kantan
00:26:106 (31) - I think a spinner like in Muzu and Oni would be good. i think the slider is k there
01:02:567 - A d could go here? Could help to emphasise the lyrics in the kiai time. left that note out to leave a break for kantan players
01:06:260 - ^ ^

Futsuu
01:02:567 - Same as per Kantan. changed, i don't think the break is neccesary here in futsuu
01:06:260 - ^ ^
01:10:413 (135) - imo if you're following the lyrics more in this section you can remove this d. changed

Muzukashii
00:26:106 (1) - I think it would be good to make the end of the spinners in this diff and the Oni to be consistent. changed
00:30:952 - Replace slider with d kkk d? i like the slider there
01:39:606 (224) - This note sounds off-timed. I think it should go on the white tick at 01:39:490. if you listen to the drum line you can hear it

Swagg Oni
00:28:875 - You could add a 3-note pattern here (kkk?) and other notes after to replace the slider. You appear to be mostly following the instrumental part in this section anyway (replacing the equivalent of 00:30:952 (11) slider in Muzu with other notes). wanna emphasize the long drawn vocal there
00:41:683 (74) - Change to d? would sound weird
00:47:567 (105,106,107,108) - I think the rhythm here should be x xxx instead of xxx x, maybe k ddk? it flows well the way it is
01:37:183 (32) - I think a spinner here is good. shame it isn't yeahhhh yeahhhh i like the slider more

I lose it every time I finish and then I hear 'swag swag swag' lmao. haha XD that's how it was intended

Hope it helps :D
Thx for modding! :D
Midnaait
Hi, Mod request from PM

[General and Kantan]

You should make an easier oni, because gap is pretty big between the two last diffs

"chatlog"
18:12 Midnaait: Now lets start the mod
18:13 Chromoxx: k
18:13 Midnaait: [General]
18:13 Midnaait: add dragon ball z to tags?
18:13 Chromoxx: are you doing chat mod and posting it then?
18:13 Midnaait: yes
18:13 Midnaait: lol
18:13 Chromoxx: ah ok
18:14 Chromoxx: - first chat mod :o i'm new to this
18:14 Midnaait: I'll just do suggestions and stuff
18:14 Midnaait: dont worry
18:15 Chromoxx: should i add dragon ball z spelled together or seperately?
18:15 Chromoxx: or just dbz dragonballz dragon ball z?
18:15 Midnaait: do dbz and dragon ball z
18:16 Chromoxx: ok
18:16 Chromoxx: i also added swag and cash xD
18:16 Midnaait: fine for me
18:16 Midnaait: lol
18:16 Midnaait: ok
18:16 Midnaait: [Kantan]
18:17 Midnaait: 00:18:260 (20) - You could change that to k
18:17 Midnaait: Maybe delete 00:22:875 - ?
18:18 Chromoxx: - deleted
18:20 Midnaait: 01:23:798 - Delete this and the next note for consistency and a little break?
18:20 Midnaait: 01:27:029 - idk about this note, it doesnt follow anything lol
18:21 Chromoxx: - deleted the 2 nores
18:22 Midnaait: And OD 4
18:22 Midnaait: I'm done
18:22 Midnaait: [Futsuu]
18:22 Chromoxx: - there is a sound in the background there so it's valid to keep it, and i don't wanna miss the large white tick there either
18:22 Midnaait: Okay
18:23 Midnaait: did you change OD? just to confirm
18:23 Chromoxx: also put OD4
18:23 Chromoxx: yes, as i said
18:23 Midnaait: Ok, make futsuu OD 4.5
18:23 Midnaait: oh sh*t i gotta go
18:23 Chromoxx: dumb question: how do i do .5? D:
18:24 Midnaait: shift and drag the slider

[Futsuu]

00:27:029 (53,54) - ctrl+g
00:48:029 (94) - Delete to emphasize the finish
00:58:413 - k
01:28:183 - that don there feels weird, considering almost all of the diff has triplets

[MuzuCA$Hi]

rip diff name

00:03:721 (17) - Delete this, might be hard to be in a muzu
Move 00:13:529 - to 00:13:760
00:18:490 - Delete for same reason as above, and to emphasize the finish
00:48:029 (71) - Delete to emphasize kiai

ok for the most part

[Swagg Oni]

00:04:183 (26) - Delete to make a little break
00:25:183 (128,129,130) - kdk or kkd?
00:39:952 - Delete this and make 00:40:183 - k?
00:55:644 (1,1) - Why spinners? You were using big kats on the other diffs lol
01:03:029 (1,1) - ^
01:06:721 (1,1) - ^
01:20:567 - Move this 1/4 to the right?
Topic Starter
Chromoxx

Midnaait wrote:

Hi, Mod request from PM

[General and Kantan]

You should make an easier oni, because gap is pretty big between the two last diffs

"chatlog"
18:12 Midnaait: Now lets start the mod
18:13 Chromoxx: k
18:13 Midnaait: [General]
18:13 Midnaait: add dragon ball z to tags?
18:13 Chromoxx: are you doing chat mod and posting it then?
18:13 Midnaait: yes
18:13 Midnaait: lol
18:13 Chromoxx: ah ok
18:14 Chromoxx: - first chat mod :o i'm new to this
18:14 Midnaait: I'll just do suggestions and stuff
18:14 Midnaait: dont worry
18:15 Chromoxx: should i add dragon ball z spelled together or seperately?
18:15 Chromoxx: or just dbz dragonballz dragon ball z?
18:15 Midnaait: do dbz and dragon ball z
18:16 Chromoxx: ok
18:16 Chromoxx: i also added swag and cash xD
18:16 Midnaait: fine for me
18:16 Midnaait: lol
18:16 Midnaait: ok
18:16 Midnaait: [Kantan]
18:17 Midnaait: 00:18:260 (20) - You could change that to k
18:17 Midnaait: Maybe delete 00:22:875 - ?
18:18 Chromoxx: - deleted
18:20 Midnaait: 01:23:798 - Delete this and the next note for consistency and a little break?
18:20 Midnaait: 01:27:029 - idk about this note, it doesnt follow anything lol
18:21 Chromoxx: - deleted the 2 nores
18:22 Midnaait: And OD 4
18:22 Midnaait: I'm done
18:22 Midnaait: [Futsuu]
18:22 Chromoxx: - there is a sound in the background there so it's valid to keep it, and i don't wanna miss the large white tick there either
18:22 Midnaait: Okay
18:23 Midnaait: did you change OD? just to confirm
18:23 Chromoxx: also put OD4
18:23 Chromoxx: yes, as i said
18:23 Midnaait: Ok, make futsuu OD 4.5
18:23 Midnaait: oh sh*t i gotta go
18:23 Chromoxx: dumb question: how do i do .5? D:
18:24 Midnaait: shift and drag the slider
i answered those in chat

[Futsuu]

00:27:029 (53,54) - ctrl+g changed
00:48:029 (94) - Delete to emphasize the finish changed
00:58:413 - k i think the "up" is at a lower pitch than "shit" so i'll keep the d to emphasize that
01:28:183 - that don there feels weird, considering almost all of the diff has triplets i'd like to keep it in to fully have the "bitch i'm gohan" mapped to

[MuzuCA$Hi]

rip diff name ;w; i cry

00:03:721 (17) - Delete this, might be hard to be in a muzu changed
Move 00:13:529 - to 00:13:760 changed
00:18:490 - Delete for same reason as above, and to emphasize the finish changed
00:48:029 (71) - Delete to emphasize kiai changed

ok for the most part

[Swagg Oni]

00:04:183 (26) - Delete to make a little break changed
00:25:183 (128,129,130) - kdk or kkd? kkd
00:39:952 - Delete this and make 00:40:183 - k? changed
00:55:644 (1,1) - Why spinners? You were using big kats on the other diffs lol i like the spinners more here, they have more swag and make the oni special
01:03:029 (1,1) - ^ ^
01:06:721 (1,1) - ^ ^
01:20:567 - Move this 1/4 to the right? that just sounds weird lol :o
Thx for mod bro! :D
ayyEve
mod for new oni diff.

not that it matters or anything but why do you place the notes all over the place? As a person with ADHD it can get quite annoying. but that's a personal issue of mine so no need to change it, just throwing it out there.

00:18:490 - k?
01:20:106 (49,50,51,52) - why is this 1/3?
00:22:067 - delete? seems like a more "complex" pattern
00:36:721 - finisher? (emphasize the "EH?" lol)
01:17:567 - k? (same as 00:18:490 - )
01:24:490 - d?
01:24:836 - delete

i hope this mod is more helpful than my last one :s
Topic Starter
Chromoxx

mattinator123 wrote:

mod for new oni diff.

not that it matters or anything but why do you place the notes all over the place? As a person with ADHD it can get quite annoying. but that's a personal issue of mine so no need to change it, just throwing it out there.

00:18:490 - k? leaving that out to give a bit of a break, want this to be less crowded than the harder oni
01:20:106 (49,50,51,52) - why is this 1/3? vocals are 1/3 there
00:22:067 - delete? seems like a more "complex" pattern changed
00:36:721 - finisher? (emphasize the "EH?" lol) changed
01:17:567 - k? (same as 00:18:490 - ) same as before
01:24:490 - d? trying to follow the vocals more instead of the background melody in this diff
01:24:836 - delete changed

i hope this mod is more helpful than my last one :s
Thx for mod! :D
-Tenshi-
Hi! M4M request~

[Kantan]
  1. 01:28:394 (114) - This note is unsnapped.
  2. 00:33:029 (40) - Maybe remove this note? Try to avoid too long pattern like this.
  3. 01:19:644 (105) - This should be a d imo.
  4. 01:28:413 (114) - Delete to avoid long pattern and there is no obvious sound to map a note here for a kantan.
  5. 01:31:644 (118) - Why it is not a k? you did d d k almost everywhere else like here 01:27:029 (111,112,113) -

[Futsuu]
  1. 00:20:336 (37) - Consider deleting this note, there is no sound to map and you don't even have a note here on muzu.
  2. 00:22:413 (42) - Remove finisher, there is no high pitch that justify a finisher imo.
  3. 00:24:029 (46) - Remove this note for the same reason as 00:20:336 (37) -
  4. 00:30:490 (59) - Would be better if you move it here 00:30:260 (59) -
  5. 00:31:413 (61) - Remove.
  6. 00:55:183 (108) - Maybe add a d here for consistency? ( You did it here 01:02:567 (123) - )
  7. 01:10:644 (137) - move it here 01:10:413 (137) - sounds way better.

[Muzukashii]
  1. Consider making all your triplets with a same color. Like here 00:01:183 (5) - change to k.
  2. 00:02:798 (12) - Change this to d and this 00:03:029 (13) - to k.
  3. 00:11:336 (39) - Change to k instead of a finisher, the pitch isn't high enought to justify a finisher imo.
  4. 00:17:798 (61) - k here.
  5. 00:30:952 (11) - Remove slider and put notes in this section? Kantan and futsuu have notes here.

[Oni]
  1. 00:24:260 (105) - Change this to k and this 00:24:952 (108) - to d to follow the vocals.
  2. 00:32:567 (18) - k here?
  3. 00:40:183 (53) - move this note here 00:39:952 (53) - sounds better imo.
  4. 01:37:183 (29,30,1) - You should really map this part with notes, i don't know why the ending has to be easier in higher diffs.

[Inner Oni]
  1. You should rename your diff "inner oni" custom name in taiko is not really appreciated.
  2. 00:40:183 (63) - Move this note here 00:39:952 (63) - and change it to d.
  3. 01:37:183 (32,33,1) - Same suggestion as oni.

Omg this song is horrible, my ears are bleeding ;_;
I'm gonna mod your other map when you will have at least modded one of my maps. Anyway good luck for ranking~
Topic Starter
Chromoxx

-Tenshi- wrote:

Hi! M4M request~

[Kantan]
  1. 01:28:394 (114) - This note is unsnapped.
  2. 00:33:029 (40) - Maybe remove this note? Try to avoid too long pattern like this.
  3. 01:19:644 (105) - This should be a d imo.
  4. 01:28:413 (114) - Delete to avoid long pattern and there is no obvious sound to map a note here for a kantan.
  5. 01:31:644 (118) - Why it is not a k? you did d d k almost everywhere else like here 01:27:029 (111,112,113) -
    changed all

[Futsuu]
  1. 00:20:336 (37) - Consider deleting this note, there is no sound to map and you don't even have a note here on muzu.
  2. 00:22:413 (42) - Remove finisher, there is no high pitch that justify a finisher imo.
  3. 00:24:029 (46) - Remove this note for the same reason as 00:20:336 (37) -
  4. 00:30:490 (59) - Would be better if you move it here 00:30:260 (59) -
  5. 00:31:413 (61) - Remove.
  6. 00:55:183 (108) - Maybe add a d here for consistency? ( You did it here 01:02:567 (123) - )
  7. 01:10:644 (137) - move it here 01:10:413 (137) - sounds way better.
    changed all

[Muzukashii]
  1. Consider making all your triplets with a same color. Like here 00:01:183 (5) - change to k.
  2. 00:02:798 (12) - Change this to d and this 00:03:029 (13) - to k.
  3. 00:11:336 (39) - Change to k instead of a finisher, the pitch isn't high enought to justify a finisher imo.
  4. 00:17:798 (61) - k here.
  5. 00:30:952 (11) - Remove slider and put notes in this section? Kantan and futsuu have notes here.
    All changed

[Oni]
  1. 00:24:260 (105) - Change this to k and this 00:24:952 (108) - to d to follow the vocals.
  2. 00:32:567 (18) - k here?
  3. 00:40:183 (53) - move this note here 00:39:952 (53) - sounds better imo.
  4. 01:37:183 (29,30,1) - You should really map this part with notes, i don't know why the ending has to be easier in higher diffs.
    Changed all

[Inner Oni]
  1. You should rename your diff "inner oni" custom name in taiko is not really appreciated. diff name is appropriate for the song
  2. 00:40:183 (63) - Move this note here 00:39:952 (63) - and change it to d. leaving that here
  3. 01:37:183 (32,33,1) - Same suggestion as oni. replaced only the spinner with notes (like in oni)

Omg this song is horrible, my ears are bleeding ;_; lel xD
I'm gonna mod your other map when you will have at least modded one of my maps. Anyway good luck for ranking~ thx <3
Thanks for modding! :D
Sylphi
I'm really sorry but i don't want to mod this map because i don't like like as this song. btw i think it would be fit offset changing to 272 (+12).
Topic Starter
Chromoxx

Underflow wrote:

I'm really sorry but i don't want to mod this map because i don't like like as this song. btw i think it would be fit offset changing to 272 (+12).
;w; - can't handle the swag xD
changed the offset anyway, thanks! :D
Shinsekai-
I'M GOKU'S KID YEAHH YEAHHH


[General]

-Open the Aimod :3

[Kantan]

- change to K 00:03:964 (4) - sound better

[Futsuu]

- change to K 00:03:964 (9) -
-change to k 00:12:272 (21) -


[Muzukashiii]

- add a note 00:00:502 (2) -
- change to K 00:03:964 (18) -
- change to k 00:09:964 (36) -
- add a k 00:10:656 (39) -
- change to k 00:55:195 (100) -

[Oni]

- Change to K 00:03:964 (22) -
-ctrl + g 00:09:733 (41,42) -

[Too much swag for me Oni]

- change to K 00:03:964 (25) -
- ctrl + g 00:09:733 (48,49) -

[Comments]

I'm Goku's Kid SWAGGGG SWAGGGG SWAGGGG luck ranking this XD
Topic Starter
Chromoxx

[_Chichinya_] wrote:

I'M GOKU'S KID YEAHH YEAHHH


[General]

-Open the Aimod :3 fixed

[Kantan]

- change to K 00:03:964 (4) - sound better it's good as it is imo, changed to D tho

[Futsuu]

- change to K 00:03:964 (9) - same as before
-change to k 00:12:272 (21) - changed


[Muzukashiii]

- add a note 00:00:502 (2) - fine as it is
- change to K 00:03:964 (18) - same as before
- change to k 00:09:964 (36) - changed
- add a k 00:10:656 (39) - good as it is
- change to k 00:55:195 (100) - good as it is

[Oni]

- Change to K 00:03:964 (22) - same as before
-ctrl + g 00:09:733 (41,42) - changed

[Too much swag for me Oni]

- change to K 00:03:964 (25) - same as before
- ctrl + g 00:09:733 (48,49) - changed

[Comments]

I'm Goku's Kid SWAGGGG SWAGGGG SWAGGGG luck ranking this XD SWAAAAAAAG
thx for modding! :D
Aldwych
Hi chromoxx.

Mod as requested by pm a long time ago.
Sorry for the huge delay i was so busy with project exams x_x

[General]

Ogod. I already regret.
$w3g $w3g $w333g!

[Kantan]

00:26:118 : Why not extend slider by 1/2 to follow better the "AAAANNNNN" owell.. :<
01:17:810++ : I find this section really calm in terms of mapping compared to the rest of the kantan. You'll probably add some notes imo.

Quite clean diff.

[Futsuu]

00:18:502 : Imo you got some pattern unconsistency which makes the rythm not accurate. If we look on the pattern you do something close, but not similar even in terms of rythm, what you can do is just simply make something like on the picture :

NB : (37) = 00:20:579



This will be way better to follow, play and "enjoy" (if we can really enjoy the music Kappa)

00:25:887 : I would personnaly move it to 00:25:425. That will make the last k more visible, and it makes the whole pattern more consistent with what "i've"
proposed above.
00:35:348 : I don't really understand this pattern imo, i don't find something different about the music, so neither why we have a complete pattern here.
00:36:733 : No k?
01:27:502 : This quadruple is as weird as the music is. Wtf Oo. Well maybe you have to find something else, maybe a slider.
01:36:733 : There's something wrong here, you have double doublets before, and here a single double, so you should delete this note or change the sigle doublets. That's kinda unconsistent tbh.

Imo this diff needs some improvement and self-check, there's some mistakes which create rythm unconsistencies, also some weird pattern choice (yeah teh kkd lel).
Just reming that's an opinion aaaaaa.

[Muzukashii]

00:23:579 : This 3/2 break is kinda weird, maybe adding a k here whould be better imo.
00:26:118 : Well it's weird to go on a spinner while futsuu has a note and kantan a slider lel.
00:54:964 : Go for k instead, that will make the current pattern more logical with the previous k ddd d k pattern.
01:15:502 : Add d? This is so weird without, moreover when there's important beatnotes.
01:35:579 : Why k instead of d? Makes a difference with the previous pattern?
01:38:810 : voice goes higher here, better changing to k tbh.
01:39:387 : Imo the double d is legit because of the beats, but it is so weird right know, you should add a d here, that makes the rythm way better to play.

The more we go on the diffs, ther hardest it goes to map it >.>

[Oni]



Gonna continue later on aaaaa
Don't kd mada fakka
Topic Starter
Chromoxx

Aldwych wrote:

Gonna continue later on aaaaa
Don't kd mada fakka
Damn... I was tired, saw the mod and kd'ed... Rip D:
Just continue in another post, sry about that ;w;
Aldwych
Ok so

[Oni]

00:20:810 : I would add a d here, i'm ok for breaks, but this isn't really a legit place for a break, maybe because of the vocals tbh.
00:23:810 : You can also add a d (for the beats) or k (for the "hey") it's up to you. We're in Oni, so having 1/1 break is enough good.
00:29:348 : ^
00:31:195 : Would add a d here too. Maybe because i would like you to keep a 1/1 break but aaaaaa it's up to you here.
00:32:118 : Since he said twice i'm a sh*t, i would go for a smilliar pattern, d ddkkd x2 is fine imo.
01:05:694 : Adding a d would make this are less boring imo. :<
01:37:195 : This is the only slider and i felt that you should go for another spinner, this kind of vocal you went for a spinner earlier.
01:39:386 : Same as muzukashii.

Playtest was fine.

[Swagg Oni]

Sawg takes two g? Oo
Better rename into Swagger Oni so :>

00:28:887 : Why a slider here? Oo
00:31:887 + : Same remarks as Oni.
00:36:733 : Unconsistency with Oni. Finisher missing (i guess).
01:04:887 : Same as Oni, well in the end it seems that this part is quite the same as 01:27:041, so you can do something like that too hue.
01:37:195 : Keepo.
01:37:387 : Keepo²

Nothing much to say.

This is definitively a hard music to map ;w;

Merry xMas and gl hf for rank. :>
Nardoxyribonucleic
Hello, this was posted in TNA in round 13 but was unfortunately declined.

Reasons of rejection

  1. OD is too high for the relatively low BPM.
  2. Base SV is not calibrated to 1.4 in Kantan, Muzukashii, Oni and Swagg Oni.
  3. The end of the song (from 01:39:964 to 01:47:348 - ) is not mapped.
  4. Kantan has some issues such as the lack of 4/1 breaks from 00:13:195 to 01:19:656 - and dull rhythm in the kiai (excessive d d k usage)
  5. Whole Futsuu revolves around d d k | d d k | d d k patterns with inconsistent 1/2 usage overall
  6. In Muzukashii, 1/4 notes are used in the wrong place. For example, 00:01:656 (5,6,7) - the triplet would be more representative in 00:00:964 (3,4) - . Also, percussion hits are randomly alternated between don and kat, resulting in the inconsistency of hitsounds.
  7. Spread is a bit unbalanced from Kantan to Muzukashii.

If you have any question, you can PM me or any TNA member :)
Topic Starter
Chromoxx

Nardoxyribonucleic wrote:

Hello, this was posted in TNA in round 13 but was unfortunately declined.

Reasons of rejection

  1. OD is too high for the relatively low BPM.
  2. Base SV is not calibrated to 1.4 in Kantan, Muzukashii, Oni and Swagg Oni.
  3. The end of the song (from 01:39:964 to 01:47:348 - ) is not mapped.
  4. Kantan has some issues such as the lack of 4/1 breaks from 00:13:195 to 01:19:656 - and dull rhythm in the kiai (excessive d d k usage)
  5. Whole Futsuu revolves around d d k | d d k | d d k patterns with inconsistent 1/2 usage overall
  6. In Muzukashii, 1/4 notes are used in the wrong place. For example, 00:01:656 (5,6,7) - the triplet would be more representative in 00:00:964 (3,4) - . Also, percussion hits are randomly alternated between don and kat, resulting in the inconsistency of hitsounds.
  7. Spread is a bit unbalanced from Kantan to Muzukashii.

If you have any question, you can PM me or any TNA member :)
This is actually really helpful, a lot of specific stuff was brought up but i'd like to talk again about the end of the song not being mapped.
Thx for going a bit more into detail with this! :D
See u again next year when all of this is fixed ;)
roufou
Kantan:
00:06:272 - add a k on this, I know you'll disagree at first but I promise you it won't sound worse after my next few suggestions
00:08:118 - remove this
00:09:964 - and add a d here possibly, I won't go into too much detail on these mods but I hope you can see how it's better? I like it a lot more, and it is also more consistent with the rest of the map
00:03:964 - optional but I'd add a kat here, it seems to fit the change in voice more than a huge don

Futsuu:
00:05:810 - I like this part better as d d k d k d k, I'd remap it or something, the ddk seems very out of place and unecessary and the d I added seems higher priority than the one in ddk
00:19:887 - I think a note here would be ok, your choice
00:22:425 - should be a k imo, also optionally remove the next don
00:25:656 - I don't like the two dons here, remove?
01:28:195 - why is this here?

Muzukashii:
00:24:041 - remove this, or put it to the "hey" at the 1/1 beat before (I recommend removing)
01:39:502 - I'm kind of fine with the dd D but I'd prefer just making the pattern d d k d k k d

Oni:
00:51:502 - I feel this is better as a k, fits vocals more imho
01:19:079 - this is a bit awkward, remove imo
01:39:502 - I'd still do k k D instead of dd D but it's more fine in oni than muzu

Swagg Oni:
00:05:810 - I think this part sounds better as d d k d k k d, and also seems more consistent
01:00:502 - k?
01:39:502 - same as oni and muzu

kind of short mod, the map has potentional but has some smaller issues that I think this mod will help you fix
Topic Starter
Chromoxx

Aldwych wrote:

Hi chromoxx.

Mod as requested by pm a long time ago.
Sorry for the huge delay i was so busy with project exams x_x

[General]

Ogod. I already regret.
$w3g $w3g $w333g!

[Kantan]

00:26:118 : Why not extend slider by 1/2 to follow better the "AAAANNNNN" owell.. :< i think it's good as it is tbh
01:17:810++ : I find this section really calm in terms of mapping compared to the rest of the kantan. You'll probably add some notes imo. i think it's good might change something tho

Quite clean diff.

[Futsuu]

00:18:502 : Imo you got some pattern unconsistency which makes the rythm not accurate. If we look on the pattern you do something close, but not similar even in terms of rythm, what you can do is just simply make something like on the picture : done that

NB : (37) = 00:20:579



This will be way better to follow, play and "enjoy" (if we can really enjoy the music Kappa)

00:25:887 : I would personnaly move it to 00:25:425. That will make the last k more visible, and it makes the whole pattern more consistent with what "i've"
proposed above. okikoki
00:35:348 : I don't really understand this pattern imo, i don't find something different about the music, so neither why we have a complete pattern here. made it to k d k
00:36:733 : No k? i like to leave that one unmapped here to add a break and have the "eh" sound standing alone
01:27:502 : This quadruple is as weird as the music is. Wtf Oo. Well maybe you have to find something else, maybe a slider. it fits the vocals, so it stays for now ^^
01:36:733 : There's something wrong here, you have double doublets before, and here a single double, so you should delete this note or change the sigle doublets. That's kinda unconsistent tbh. changed it up

Imo this diff needs some improvement and self-check, there's some mistakes which create rythm unconsistencies, also some weird pattern choice (yeah teh kkd lel).
Just reming that's an opinion aaaaaa.

[Muzukashii]

00:23:579 : This 3/2 break is kinda weird, maybe adding a k here whould be better imo. idk... i think it's fine tbh.
00:26:118 : Well it's weird to go on a spinner while futsuu has a note and kantan a slider lel. i have the spinners starting from muzu because they are more intense
00:54:964 : Go for k instead, that will make the current pattern more logical with the previous k ddd d k pattern. i think d sounds better
01:15:502 : Add d? This is so weird without, moreover when there's important beatnotes. i'll try it out... feels a bit weird to me with the d tho
01:35:579 : Why k instead of d? Makes a difference with the previous pattern? because the pitch is higher here than the previous pattern and it makes for more diversity
01:38:810 : voice goes higher here, better changing to k tbh. no voice there lol
01:39:387 : Imo the double d is legit because of the beats, but it is so weird right know, you should add a d here, that makes the rythm way better to play. that's kinda hard tbh but idk....
i'm reworking some other stuff going by the TNA reject post
The more we go on the diffs, ther hardest it goes to map it >.>

[Oni]



Gonna continue later on aaaaa
Don't kd mada fakka
Surono
its nigga or real asean medefekeh.. dem teh intre nuts....

3D1t:

*Nak, apa yang kau lakukan??? XD dem memakai Bahasa lol
|
v
snz
;;;:;\zm.,MZUOWU2OPOE938298E8
Ascendance
man this map is shit
Catgirl

Ascendance wrote:

man this map is shit
hi ascendance i'm in your hate club

also hot damn
this map
Shinsekai-
when?
Topic Starter
Chromoxx

Aldwych wrote:

Ok so

[Oni]

00:20:810 : I would add a d here, i'm ok for breaks, but this isn't really a legit place for a break, maybe because of the vocals tbh. the break is okay tbh, keeping too long consistent rythms becomes boring
00:23:810 : You can also add a d (for the beats) or k (for the "hey") it's up to you. We're in Oni, so having 1/1 break is enough good.
00:29:348 : ^ i feel like the breaks here make for better buildup throughout the song
00:31:195 : Would add a d here too. Maybe because i would like you to keep a 1/1 break but aaaaaa it's up to you here. emphasis on the vocal
00:32:118 : Since he said twice i'm a sh*t, i would go for a smilliar pattern, d ddkkd x2 is fine imo. heavier drum beat at the end of the second pattern, that's why it's longer
01:05:694 : Adding a d would make this are less boring imo. :< don't really see it fitting in there anywhere and one triplet won't do much good anyways imo
01:37:195 : This is the only slider and i felt that you should go for another spinner, this kind of vocal you went for a spinner earlier. spinnere'd
01:39:386 : Same as muzukashii. isn't weird tho

Playtest was fine.

[Swagg Oni]

Sawg takes two g? Oo
Better rename into Swagger Oni so :>

00:28:887 : Why a slider here? Oo fixed
00:31:887 + : Same remarks as Oni. current pattern gives more emphasis to the strong drum beat at the end of kkkkd
00:36:733 : Unconsistency with Oni. Finisher missing (i guess). removed finisher in oni
01:04:887 : Same as Oni, well in the end it seems that this part is quite the same as 01:27:041, so you can do something like that too hue. mapping the vocals only there for higher emphasis on the single hits
01:37:195 : Keepo. fixed
01:37:387 : Keepo²

Nothing much to say.

This is definitively a hard music to map ;w;

Merry xMas and gl hf for rank. :>
nearly 1 year late but thx
Topic Starter
Chromoxx

agu wrote:

Oni:
00:51:502 - I feel this is better as a k, fits vocals more imho yeah, changed
01:19:079 - this is a bit awkward, remove imo moved it 1/1 backward to make a ddd before the last k
01:39:502 - I'd still do k k D instead of dd D but it's more fine in oni than muzu dd D fits better imo

Swagg Oni:
00:05:810 - I think this part sounds better as d d k d k k d, and also seems more consistent current pattern emphasizes strong sounds in the music more imo
01:00:502 - k? no
01:39:502 - same as oni and muzu keeping here too

kind of short mod, the map has potentional but has some smaller issues that I think this mod will help you fix
kantan-muzu went through major changes so applying those doesn't make much sense here

tfw applying mods from 1 year ago... #nostalgic
iloveyou4ever
swaGG Oni
Aldwych
OBOI
tasuke912
Hi
[ General]
  1. Difficulty spread issue: Between M and O seems huge relatively. Muzukashii can be harder (or Oni easier).
  2. Where is instrumental version
  3. OD should be higher in higher difficulties. (eg: 3-4-5-5-6)
  4. Adjust hitsound volume
[ Kantan]
  1. 00:53:348 (55) - How about moving this note to 2/1 tick right?
  2. 01:37:195 (105) - I think slider doesn't fit to the song well, since vocal is ... It's hard to get 1/4 rhythm anyway
  3. 00:33:502 (31) - Add finisher as well as F, M?

  4. 00:37:195 (36) - Finish would be good for emphasis (All difficulties)
[ Futsuu]
  1. 00:36:733 - k?
  2. 00:39:733 - Try moving this note to 00:38:810 - for making consistent rhythm with next patterns?
  3. 01:17:810 - Finish? You used it at Kantan

  4. 01:17:810 (43) - Add finish to emphasize the sound? (All diffs)
[ Muzukashii]
  1. As I said in general, M-O seems huge. Try to make more triplets!
[ Oni]
  1. 00:03:502 (20) - I prefer k here :p
  2. 00:17:810 (76,77,78) - ^
  3. 00:17:464 (74) - Remove it for consistency.
  4. 00:38:348 (44) - I'd recommend to remove it, this pattern seems too long for the calm part.
  5. 00:42:041 (63) - ^
  6. 01:20:118 (49,50,51,52) - Simple rhythm would be better

  7. 01:30:733 - This part is very similar as Swagg Oni. You should try to make more difference
[ Swagg Oni]
  1. 00:26:118 (1) - has longer length than other difficulties, it is intentional?
Bad song :v))
Call me back when you are done
Topic Starter
Chromoxx

tasuke912 wrote:

Hi
[ General]
  1. Difficulty spread issue: Between M and O seems huge relatively. Muzukashii can be harder (or Oni easier). buffing muzu
  2. Where is instrumental version
  3. OD should be higher in higher difficulties. (eg: 3-4-5-5-6) fixed
  4. Adjust hitsound volume i don't really feel like there is a need for volume changes in this song, so i'd rather leave the hitsound volume at 100% so that people can choose the volume they like for themselves
[ Kantan]
  1. 00:53:348 (55) - How about moving this note to 2/1 tick right? oo nice
  2. 01:37:195 (105) - I think slider doesn't fit to the song well, since vocal is ... It's hard to get 1/4 rhythm anyway i feel like this is a good way to emphasize the long vocal and i prefer the slider to a spinner here, since it emphasizes the full length more
  3. 00:33:502 (31) - Add finisher as well as F, M? add

  4. 00:37:195 (36) - Finish would be good for emphasis (All difficulties) no really strong sound here so i'll leave it
[ Futsuu]
  1. 00:36:733 - k? i prefer leaving a break here to emphasize the background music kicking in again on the next hit, also i feel like the "heh" is emphasized more by not mapping it here and letting the players hear the sound instead of having just one more 1/1 note
  2. 00:39:733 - Try moving this note to 00:38:810 - for making consistent rhythm with next patterns? ok
  3. 01:17:810 - Finish? You used it at Kantan added

  4. 01:17:810 (43) - Add finish to emphasize the sound? (All diffs) added
[ Muzukashii]
  1. As I said in general, M-O seems huge. Try to make more triplets! added some 1/3 and also buffing some pattern lengths in general, 1/3 should make it technical enough to spread with the Oni and i don't want to overmap too much 1/4 here
[ Oni]
  1. 00:03:502 (20) - I prefer k here :p yeah k is good
  2. 00:17:810 (76,77,78) - ^ changed
  3. 00:17:464 (74) - Remove it for consistency. ye, changed the thing before to d k d too
  4. 00:38:348 (44) - I'd recommend to remove it, this pattern seems too long for the calm part.
  5. 00:42:041 (63) - ^ removed both
  6. 01:20:118 (49,50,51,52) - Simple rhythm would be better made some 1/4 instead to make it more expectable, keeping the weirder 1/3 for swagg oni

  7. 01:30:733 - This part is very similar as Swagg Oni. You should try to make more difference it fits to the music, it isn't identical and fits well in the context to the map so i think it's okay tbh
[ Swagg Oni]
  1. 00:26:118 (1) - has longer length than other difficulties, it is intentional? shortened (:
Bad song :v)) #quality
Call me back when you are done
thx man! :D
tasuke912
The song is weird, but beatmap is well-made actually.

Bubbled!
IControl
I think the bg could be improved if you added sun glasses
Hypello
Swagg Oni
00:27:964 (1,2,3,4,5) - change to k k k d d
00:30:272 (10,11,12) - change to kkk
00:32:579 (23,24,25) - change to kkd
00:36:733 (47) - finisher? xD
01:06:272 (5) - change to k
01:08:579 (1,2,3,4,5) - change to K K K K K?
01:13:195 (18) - kkd 1/4
01:27:041 (1) - remove or k
lol funny map
Volta
hi, here's m4m as requested

[Kantan]
00:18:733 - i think finisher here is good to give emphasis, like the higher diffs
>00:17:810 - and remove this finisher

[Futsuu]
00:59:348 (65,66,67,68) - how about change to D-kdk, good to emphasis the first note
> 01:01:195 (69,70,71,72) - and change to kdd-k, if want some variation

[Muzukashii]
00:59:348 (88,89,90,91,92) - how about change to D-d-k-d-k, good to emphasis the first note

[Oni]
00:03:964 - consider to add finish like lower diffs? consistent with 00:18:733 - too
> 00:18:502 - hmm why no k here?
> 00:50:810 - add k?
> 01:18:041 - and maybe delete this if you feel the sequence will be too long

00:58:425 - remove finish? sounds not strong enough to emphasis. no finish in lower diffs
> 00:59:348 - and put finisher here instead?
> 01:09:502 - i'd suggest to remove finish here too

00:50:810 (100) - change to d can emphasis the next gohan imo

[Swagg Oni]
00:03:964 - consider to add finish like lower diffs? consistent with 00:18:733 - too

00:58:425 - remove finish? seems wrong place to emphasis. no finish in lower diffs
> 00:59:348 - and put finisher here instead?
> 01:09:502 - i'd suggest to remove finish here too

00:50:579 (119,120) - try to swap? it would suits the vocal better

tasuke912 wrote:

The song is weird
Topic Starter
Chromoxx

aEoNNzR- wrote:

Swagg Oni
00:27:964 (1,2,3,4,5) - change to k k k d d current pattern fits better imo
00:30:272 (10,11,12) - change to kkk no
00:32:579 (23,24,25) - change to kkd no
00:36:733 (47) - finisher? xD the notes isolation emphasizes it enough imo
01:06:272 (5) - change to k no
01:08:579 (1,2,3,4,5) - change to K K K K K? no, sounds weird
01:13:195 (18) - kkd 1/4 sounds weird
01:27:041 (1) - remove or k d suits better imo
lol funny map
thx for modding, i couldn't really understand your reasoning behind your suggestions since you didn't explain them really
Topic Starter
Chromoxx

Volta wrote:

hi, here's m4m as requested

[Kantan]
00:18:733 - i think finisher here is good to give emphasis, like the higher diffs added
>00:17:810 - and remove this finisher removed

[Futsuu]
00:59:348 (65,66,67,68) - how about change to D-kdk, good to emphasis the first note did D kkd
> 01:01:195 (69,70,71,72) - and change to kdd-k, if want some variation changed

[Muzukashii]
00:59:348 (88,89,90,91,92) - how about change to D-d-k-d-k, good to emphasis the first note changed

[Oni]
00:03:964 - consider to add finish like lower diffs? consistent with 00:18:733 - too added
> 00:18:502 - hmm why no k here? i felt it emphasized the next D better but since it's clearly audible in the music i added it
> 00:50:810 - add k? added k on 01:17:579 - since this is what you meant
> 01:18:041 - and maybe delete this if you feel the sequence will be too long deleted

00:58:425 - remove finish? sounds not strong enough to emphasis. no finish in lower diffs removed
> 00:59:348 - and put finisher here instead? added
> 01:09:502 - i'd suggest to remove finish here too strong sound there so i'm leaving that one

00:50:810 (100) - change to d can emphasis the next gohan imo i feel like the triple k adds more emphasis somehow

[Swagg Oni]
00:03:964 - consider to add finish like lower diffs? consistent with 00:18:733 - too added

00:58:425 - remove finish? seems wrong place to emphasis. no finish in lower diffs removed
> 00:59:348 - and put finisher here instead? added
> 01:09:502 - i'd suggest to remove finish here too strong sound so leaving this one

00:50:579 (119,120) - try to swap? it would suits the vocal better changed

tasuke912 wrote:

The song is weird
very nice mod, thank you! :D
Volta
alright, map have better emphasis now.

QUALIFIED!
Raiden
I dream that one day, the memes shall be kept where they belong, and not in the official content of an actual serious rhythm game.

Midnaait

Raiden wrote:

I dream that one day, the memes shall be kept where they belong, and not in the official content of an actual serious rhythm game.

Serious rhythm game
lul
Alex3i2
I hate this song
zeeeq_old

Midnaait wrote:

Raiden wrote:

I dream that one day, the memes shall be kept where they belong, and not in the official content of an actual serious rhythm game.

Serious rhythm game
lul
Serious rhythmeme game
lul
Surono

Raiden wrote:

I dream that one day, the memes shall be kept where they belong, and not in the official content of an actual serious rhythm game.

😂🔫
Stefan

Raiden wrote:

I dream that one day, the memes shall be kept where they belong, and not in the official content of an actual serious rhythm game.

Oh? So people should only map +250 BPM crap and electro trash? I am not feeling this way.

I haven't checked the map itself so I can't judge the quality but if the quality exist, then I feel sorry for everyone not being so open to accept other genres than:
-) any songs of any rhythm games - which sounds 70% of the time the same
-) anime
-) the same rock bands over and over again, speaking of stuff such as DystopiaGround or Dragonforce

You should know by yourself to avoid these maps if they do not hit your taste.
roufou
I can see why people get annoyed by 30~ second songs being ranked "frequently", and I can see people getting annoyed by "meme" songs getting voted as top 5 best maps of the year, but I don't really see a problem with this song being ranked. Maybe this song would be weird in a game which isn't run by the community and has officially charted songs by a team, but osu! is run by the community and there's other options everywhere and you can install whatever map you want.

I'll also mention that Jubeat added PPAP as a song, just as a fun thing to add to the side of this.

Just my opinion on this as a genuinely think this is an amusing map.
Pachiru
Most of maps are always the same nowadays, so if those people are doing some meme song that go out from usual stuff, then let them do it, everyone is mapping anime stuff as Stefan said, even if I don't like it, I would never say that is "full of shit" as you said, Raiden.

Respect other tastes.
Raiden

Stefan wrote:

Raiden wrote:

I dream that one day, the memes shall be kept where they belong, and not in the official content of an actual serious rhythm game.

Oh? So people should only map +250 BPM crap and electro trash? I am not feeling this way.

I haven't checked the map itself so I can't judge the quality but if the quality exist, then I feel sorry for everyone not being so open to accept other genres than:
-) any songs of any rhythm games - which sounds 70% of the time the same
-) anime
-) the same rock bands over and over again, speaking of stuff such as DystopiaGround or Dragonforce

You should know by yourself to avoid these maps if they do not hit your taste.
I do the last thing you mentioned, as in, avoid the maps if they don't fit* my taste on a daily basis. But it seems that's pretty useful to ignore, right? Otherwise you would not be able to post this short pseudo-lecture.

I'd rather have anime generic songs than this... thing that some dare call a song, with little to no harmony put in its composition, and with the only purpose of being funny in a rather stupid way. I'm all in for memes, I have said it several times. The only problem is when they are brought in places they do not belong at all, such as the ranked section which consists of OFFICIAL osu! content.

Is that what you'd want to see on a serious company or a mildly serious project? I doubt that project has much success.

Not only has this immediate repercussion on the mild outrage that it has caused (somewhat massive downvote wave), but also in a bigger picture scene. Taiko is nothing more than a joke/non-existant mode to a vast majority of osu! playerbase already. Do you really think having these... things in our ranked section is going to make us any good? Not if you ask me. And I'm pretty sure you hinted at me with the "the same rock bands over and over again". I'll just invite you to take a look at my graveyard and/or unsubmitted maps. You'll probably notice Dragonforce takes less than 5% of my rock/metal songs.

As for rhythm game songs and anime, I do agree with you and share that point of view, regardless of the fact that those are at least harmless for our image.

Just as in real life, keep the leisure time apart from the work. It's called priorities.

Merry christmas to all of you.

edit: @Pachiru, that was a meme from SpongeBob Squarepants & Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance. Didn't say they were full of shit. Don't assume things if you do not understand the context.
Arphimigon
osu! shouldn't be treated as a serious rhythm game, but as a community game made for the fun of the community itself, so let them make stuff that can please each other. This can please parts of the community that don't get pleased often, and I see that as a pure positive.
Topic Starter
Chromoxx
This is getting a bit too dramatic lol
_Illustrious_
Is a shit map
Surono

SUPERGLB05 wrote:

Is a shit map
not to map please, but song (?).
Please sign in to reply.

New reply