Naotoshi wrote:
[normal]
00:05:073 (3) - this is unrankable. guideline≠ruleNote density should consist of mostly 1/1, occasional 1/2, or slower rhythms.this song is 142BPM
Rhythm related guidelines apply to approximately 180 BPM maps.
If your song is drastically faster or slower, some variables might be different. Apply reasonable judgment in these cases.
in my opinion, and lots of other people's opinions, 142 bpm is NOT drastically slower than 180 bpm. therefore, i say that this guideline should not be violated. please change it.
- 1.in my opinion, note intensity is not about the snapping of the note but the time between two notes. one slider one note
- 2."Rhythm related guidelines apply to approximately 180 BPM maps.
If your song is drastically faster or slower, some variables might be different. Apply reasonable judgment in these cases."
whatever, 142BPM is slower then 180BPM,I didn't even violate any guideline
- 3.guideline≠rule. so, this is not unrankable
- 4.in my opinion, only 1/4 rhythm can match this part,so 1/4 repair slider is the best choice.
- 5.this slider is at 00:05:073 - is this song's beginning, not at the end,players have enough time to know this rhythm.
- 6.this slider is starting at 00:05:073 - and ending at 00:05:284 - , just only stay 155ms(OD4 accuracy range is 56ms) ,is this hard????????,players can even put this note as a circle.and plz don't think that beginner players are so noob
regardless of what you say to the contrary, this is 1/4 snap and is therefore breaking a ranking criteria guideline.
[easy]
the spread gap between easy and normal is too big. normal uses extended 1/2 rhythms, occasionally with multiple circles in a row. most gaps in rhythm are 1/2 long.
easy uses mostly 2/1 rhythms and has exclusively 1/1 gaps. the easy is therefore too easy compared to the normal, and you should adjust it as such.
this does not address the issue i'm bringing up, which is that your easy has very simple rhythm while your normal is significantly more complex. yes, your easy uses a lot of 1/1 gaps. your normal regularly uses multiple 1/2 gaps in a row, which makes it much harder than the easy in terms of note density. i recommend you raise the difficulty of the easy by use of occasional 1/2 gaps in the most intense parts of the song, or lower the difficulty of the normal in a similar way.
- about this, i simplified Normal,so the above did not say anything, just waiting for sharlo fix the mod and update it.
let me know when you've responded and fixed the easy - normal spread issue so i can remove this pop.[/quote]