gayYaHao wrote:
Marked
gayYaHao wrote:
Marked
Thanks for mod 'w'Critical_Star wrote:
:)
mod from YaHoo
@chicken
00:47:960 (47960|0,48058|0,48155|2,48252|3) -
00:48:155 (48155|2,48252|3) - those two should be in jack instead of 00:48:058 (48058|2,48155|2) -
00:48:155 (48155|2,48252|3) - those two should be in jack instead of 00:48:058 (48058|2,48155|2) -
01:45:330 (105330|3,105428|3,105525|2,105622|2,105720|3,105817|3) - this still - x
01:45:622 (105622|2,105720|0) - CTRL+J should fix - Above and this one, I want to keep because I made jumphand stream
22:20 YaHao: ok here i am
22:20 YaHao: just realise collab diff, how to irc
22:21 Critical_Star: LOL
22:21 Critical_Star: now u know
22:21 Critical_Star: but i can ask direct to them for your mod
22:22 YaHao: whatever, lets irc first
22:22 YaHao: send me the map via qq can?
22:22 Critical_Star: ok
22:26 Critical_Star: uplopading
22:28 Critical_Star: sent le
22:30 *YaHao is listening to [https://osu.ppy.sh/b/1128525 BlackY - Paradission]
22:31 YaHao: widescreen support in normal
22:31 Critical_Star: metadata should be good
22:31 Critical_Star: closed for all
22:33 YaHao: 00:11:532 (11532|0,11532|1,11824|2,11824|1,12116|2,12116|3,12311|1,12311|2,12506|1,12506|0) - change this part so the player can notice the snaps are changing
22:33 YaHao: 00:12:116 (12116|3,12116|2,12311|2,12311|1,12506|0,12506|1) -
22:33 YaHao: 1/2 trill will work
22:34 Critical_Star: http://puu.sh/t7ECa/5a4a425086.png
22:35 YaHao: cool
22:35 YaHao: 00:59:259 - LN?
22:36 YaHao: 01:02:765 - LN as well? then move this 01:03:739 (63739|1) - to 4th col, make it jack with 01:03:934 (63934|3) - to emphasize the snare drum
22:36 Critical_Star: think i will leave it as 1/1 layering since i catch other sound here
22:36 Critical_Star: hmm
22:37 Critical_Star: 01:02:376 (62376|2) - think i change this as LN then
22:37 YaHao: done
22:37 Critical_Star: http://puu.sh/t7EHp/07c102e261.png
22:39 *YaHao is editing [https://osu.ppy.sh/b/1128525 BlackY - Paradission [CS vs. Spy.R's Orange Lv.9]]
22:40 Critical_Star: 'w'
22:41 YaHao: 00:46:597 (46597|3) - extend this till00:46:986 - ?
22:41 YaHao: same length with 00:46:012 (46012|3) -
22:42 Critical_Star: yep
22:43 YaHao: 00:46:012 (46012|3) - really unbalance
22:44 Critical_Star: i thought they have the same sound here
22:44 Critical_Star: 00:46:012 (46012|3,46597|3) -
22:44 YaHao: i copy the wrong timing
22:44 YaHao: lmao
22:44 Critical_Star: :^
22:45 YaHao: 01:36:661 (96661|3,96954|2,97246|2,97343|3,97441|1,97635|2,97830|3,98025|2,98220|3) -
22:45 YaHao: this i mean
22:46 *YaHao is editing [https://osu.ppy.sh/b/1128526 BlackY - Paradission [WhiteCS vs. BlackFC Vermilion Lv.15]]
22:46 Critical_Star: ok i let him know
22:49 YaHao: 00:47:960 (47960|0,48058|0,48155|2,48252|3) -
22:49 YaHao: 00:48:155 (48155|2,48252|3) - those two should be in jack instead of 00:48:058 (48058|2,48155|2) -
22:50 YaHao: 00:48:252 (48252|0,48350|0) - and not this
22:51 Critical_Star: noted
22:52 YaHao: 01:45:330 (105330|3,105428|3,105525|2,105622|2,105720|3,105817|3) - this still
22:53 YaHao: 01:45:622 (105622|2,105720|0) - CTRL+J should fix
22:53 YaHao: all good
sorry this is my mistake.. I overlooked it, can you help me to fix the tagFeerum wrote:
Greetings and grats on qualify!
So, i just have a little objection about the Tags.
I can see you got most of the Tags probably from this wiki side.I think following Tags should not be in the Beatmap:This are complete different songs and most, when not all, are by different artists. The only thing that these song's share is a vocal sample (according to the wiki website)
HAPPY☆LUCKY☆YEAPPY
New York EVOLVED
ULTRA HAPPY MEGAMIX
VISION
超越してしまった彼女と其を生み落した理由
Have you any other reason why you have these tags? When yes, please explain it to me!
Kuo Kyoka wrote:
new world recordalso you forgot to add KONAMIyou can kill me now
to be honest i can't really find if there is any wrong with it.Valentrixe wrote:
hi
[WhiteCS vs.BlackFC Vermillion Lv.15] i am sad u cross me out :<
- 00:02:376 (2376|1,2376|0) - i don't get it, what're you trying to follow? the synth? the next double should be on 00:02:668 - then, since 00:02:571 - contain no synth, only bass (if i'm right), and you need to add double in 00:02:473 - if you actually following the bass. choose one of them
- 00:01:986 (1986|3) - ??? what's this? you skipped all the same sound in 00:08:220 - , you can just use single note to follow the main synth like 00:02:084 (2084|1,2181|2,2278|3,2863|2,2960|1,3058|0) - , and ignoring the idkwhatitscalled in 00:01:986 (1986|3)
- 00:02:765 (2765|3) - if you do agree with ^ , then the only reason to add this note is to following the lower synth, which you're not following in 00:02:668 - , so better delete this note, otherwise, add note in every blue line in this section
- 00:03:155 - i would be more appreciate if you copy the exact pattern in 00:01:598 - since the melody is actually same. the music itself is repetitive in this part
- 00:04:226 (4226|1) - inconsistent with previous stanza
- 00:07:148 (7148|1,7343|0) - what are these notes is stand for? ugh
- 00:10:265 (10265|1,10558|0) - no significant change in the music but why did you make it different with previous stanza?
asdfasdfasdf take a quick look on the rest of the map and i found a lot of errors
00:33:934 (33934|1,34129|1,34324|1,34519|1,34713|1,34908|1,35103|1,35298|1,35687|1,35882|1,36077|1,36272|1,36467|1,36661|1,36856|1,37051|1) - this anchor in example, does it really feel hard to play? is just a common stream with LN here so i cant really avoid that
00:35:687 (35687|1,35785|2,35882|1,35882|3,35980|2,36077|1) - these have different melody with 00:36:467 (36467|1,36564|2,36661|1,36661|3,36759|2,36856|1) - but why they have the same pattern? i know but i choose a balance snare stream here instead of catching the melody, this shouldnt be a big problem
and why no hold in 00:42:116 - ? i am emphasizing 00:42:506 (42506|0,42506|1,42603|2,42603|3,42798|2,42798|1,42993|1,42993|0,43187|0,43187|1) - this melody with double here, so i didnt use any LN here
.. 00:46:597 (46597|3) - should be end at 00:47:376 there is another long sound here u can heard till 00:47:571 -
01:13:285 (73285|0,73285|2,73285|3) - looks like randomly placed triple for me it is main melody + kick here u can see i used triple at 01:14:843 - 01:16:402 -
asfasdfsdf bad stream i am really sorry if this stream plays bad for you, at least it play pretty nice for me.
i like the jack idea to follow the main synth tho, but this stream need more consistency check
in fact, this diff DOES need more consistency check -- maybe it have a different note usage at some part since this is a collab diff, where we might used different way to map here
First, you MUST not decide that map is bad or not with only your playability.Valentrixe wrote:
hi
[WhiteCS vs.BlackFC Vermillion Lv.15]
- 00:02:376 (2376|1,2376|0) - i don't get it, what're you trying to follow? the synth? the next double should be on 00:02:668 - then, since 00:02:571 -contain no synth, only bass (if i'm right), and you need to add double in 00:02:473 - if you actually following the bass. choose one of them - I didn't follow drum, I followed main piano and there's definitely has a sound that I followed
- 00:01:986 (1986|3) - ??? what's this? you skipped all the same sound in 00:08:220 - , you can just use single note to follow the main synth like 00:02:084 (2084|1,2181|2,2278|3,2863|2,2960|1,3058|0) - , and ignoring the idkwhatitscalled in 00:01:986 (1986|3) - Seems you never read what I intended, I mainly use 2 notes which has just piano, I never 2 note'd on drum in this part as you can see.
- 00:02:765 (2765|3) - if you do agree with ^ , then the only reason to add this note is to following the lower synth, which you're not following in 00:02:668 - , so better delete this note, otherwise, add note in every blue line in this section - I didn't agree with mod on above and there's just a synth.
- 00:03:155 - i would be more appreciate if you copy the exact pattern in 00:01:598 - since the melody is actually same. the music itself is repetitive in this part - For hand balance and it will be boring if I just use same pattern on above too.
- 00:04:226 (4226|1) - inconsistent with previous stanza 00:02:668 - If you mean here, they are liternally different. 00:04:226 (4226|1) -This part has more strong syhtn than 00:04:226 (4226|1) - here. In my personal opinion, even I could feel the difference while playing
- 00:07:148 (7148|1,7343|0) - what are these notes is stand for? ugh Should I explain about it? even it isn't ghost note and unreasonable notes?
- 00:10:265 (10265|1,10558|0) - no significant change in the music but why did you make it different with previous stanza? - I feel the drum is getting more stronger from 00:10:168 - here.
asdfasdfasdf take a quick look on the rest of the map and i found a lot of errors
00:33:934 (33934|1,34129|1,34324|1,34519|1,34713|1,34908|1,35103|1,35298|1,35687|1,35882|1,36077|1,36272|1,36467|1,36661|1,36856|1,37051|1) - this anchor in example, - I really have no idea why this is an error. Just heavy pattern is an error? Look, there's loooong LN and we have only 3 columns and wants to emphasis the kick and synth both. So I thought and thought again and made this pattern and I ever didn't feel this pattern is awkward and uncomfortable or unbalanced or etc.
00:35:687 (35687|1,35785|2,35882|1,35882|3,35980|2,36077|1) - these have different melody with 00:36:467 (36467|1,36564|2,36661|1,36661|3,36759|2,36856|1) - but why they have the same pattern? I have no idea what I should reply on this mod. I do think that it won't be a problem. No issue on playable and nothing awkwardness and unrankable issues. This is just unreasonable.
and why no hold in 00:42:116 - ? - This one is not my part so I'll leave it to CS
.. 00:46:597 (46597|3) - should be end at 00:47:376 There's sound like dubstep which finishs on 00:47:571 - here with strong bass.
01:13:285 (73285|0,73285|2,73285|3) - looks like randomly placed triple for me - This is also not my parts but I guess CS didn't want to make jack with triple+double. As you can see, when there are many doubles, CS didn't used triple but when there are not many doubles, CS used triple, this is my guessing.
asfasdfsdf bad stream
i like the jack idea to follow the main synth tho, but this stream need more consistency check
in fact, this diff DOES need more consistency check --
Kuo Kyoka wrote:
also i find it kinda funny when you said you didn't feel any unbalanced issue in the pattern when the pattern need to press 8 times 1/2 notes in the same lane twiceFresh Chicken wrote:
First, you MUST not decide that map is bad or not with only your playability. | i didn't judged it by its playability, i judged it by its consistency
Second, inconsistency is due to of this map is collab. CS and I have definitely different style and I even think that is the charming point of collab (Can feel which part made by who or who) | and yeah when i talking about consistency i didn't compare your part with cs part, i'm talking about inconsistecy in your own part
I think you should consider what mapper intended before you do a mod.