Bonsai wrote:
yf's Insane definitely looks like an Extra to me because there is a lot of technical and/or reading skil needed, firstly all those 1/8-patterns like especially 00:21:216 (1,2) - (where I really don't understand why you'd make that random 1/8 clickable), the spacing of the 1/4-streams (especially those like 01:07:420 (2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - ), or that monstrosity of unpredicatble SV-, rhythm- and spacing-changes at 00:38:624 (1,1,1,2,3,1,1,1,1) -
Those are not elements of an Insane, imo Insanes should maybe introduce one of such complex gameplay elements while still making it easy to read, grasp and play, which those are not. The starrating of this diff is massively underrated, calling it an Insane misleads players even more
(to avoid possible misunderstandings: I don't have anything against the map itself, just the naming of the difficulty ^^)
I didn't name the diff, I respect to guest mappers' choice so that's why it is called Insane, I know the outcome that the star rating of Insane diffs will be relatively low comparing with the actual gameplay after finish mapping my Extra, and I have testplayed the diff during the ranking process. the reading and aiming skill is more difficult then most of the maps as well the song have various snapping and there are wubs in some of the section. Even HW decided to use Another for her diff, not based on the star rating, but the CS5, the technical and reading skill as you said, I believe her diff is more challenging than Yoru's or even yf's
Tbh the star rating is not accurate for this mapset, or I should say starting from HW's till mine. It may be weird if yf's diff is named with Extra, as there is already a "X" icon diff (Myriad of Colors), their difference in star rating is still quite large (4.67 and 5.31), so that's why I kept the diff name, and I think it won't lead to disqualification..?
Actually I don't know if this is helpful or not I have tried to state the actual difficulty for the diff in the description
, I hope players will notice that xD
Anyway thanks for the corcern!
and sorry for my poor english uwuLen wrote:
Reol wrote:
the official video,
0:00 ~ 0:37 -> soundtrack 01. -nil-
I think you need to add on tag -nil-
p/4948908. just add -nil- on tag!
ahh ok