Get good.
Look at it like this, your Top Play is a 4.37* map and you got mere 94% Acc on it.
There are two different kind of plays you can look at:
Plays that you are theoretically capable of pulling off but the chance is kinda low.
Plays that you can pull off with relatively high consistency because you're better than the map.
The consistency level of a player is almost always significantly lower compared to what they have as their Top Plays.
Generally speaking:
The higher the weighted acc of a player the closer his consistency level is to his Top Plays.
Look at this guy for example:
https://osu.ppy.sh/u/4260009This guy is a fucking beast and I've seen him FCing maps on sightread that I had trouble with FCing myself despite 1k pp difference. He could have much more pp if he just submitted plays with good combo and imperfect acc. His Top Plays are all plays that he can re-FC within very few tries without exceptions even though he might have trouble to SS them again.
You on the other hand have low accuracy which means that the majority of your top plays you were struggling at maintaining control over the map and hitting everything correctly. They're almost all plays that are not common to do for you.
This is not necessarily a problem as there are players that have strong FC-capabilities without having good accuracy at the same time but generally speaking you should rethink the expectations you have of yourself when playing maps.
It's probably a good idea to get buttthurt if you have trouble to FC a 3.5* map and to dig in and practice that one but it's kind of nonsense to get upset about being unable to FC maps that would land in the upper half of your Top Plays.