ExUsagi wrote:

[why not Coma?]

ExUsagi wrote:

inside

oh dank, kami served your map..!

my mod usually won't affect so many aspect, since you got so many useful from pro modders... haha

==a all i know is, you are working on it's hitsound... maybe you can use hitsound copier... it works, but idk.... backup before copying first~ ~~~~`\ :v \

[General]
i wonder why i can't find better image background for your map, at least with 1024*768 px background... ==a or better image quality... ==a :V

KIAI TIME WHERE? DD: Added a few kiai times.

[Normal]
00:02:121 (2121|4,2455|3) - Longer those LNs, the synth sound is actually long tho.. http://puu.sh/c6FMv.png ok
00:08:788 (8788|5) - add on 4, according to 00:03:455 (3455|5) - aight
02:00:121 (120121|3) - idk what 1/4 spacing for.... make it connected to 02:02:788 (122788|4) - ok
and 02:02:788 (122788|4) - add on 1 i'll keep it that way, prefer to keep it quite empty for the calm part
02:48:621 (168621|2) - o__o? move it to 02:48:788 there is a guitar note there :V
O__O magic, how do you remove that break time? I think it's not enough time for a break
03:27:455 (207455|1,207455|5,207621|5,207621|1,207788|3,207955|3) - http://puu.sh/c6H5D.png no reason, it's just fun to play... x3 Nah, i want to give that impression that there are 2 patterns instead of only one. I like those jacks too.


03:52:455 (232455|2,232621|4,232788|3,232955|2,233121|4,233288|2,233455|4,233788|2,233955|4,234121|3,234288|2,234455|4,234621|2) -
move 2 column to left, it feels not good, when left hand works less than right hand... GG I moved the LN to the left hand instead.
03:54:788 (234788|4,235121|2,235288|4,235455|3,235621|2,235788|4,235955|2,236121|4,236455|2,236621|4,236788|3,236955|2,237121|4,237288|2) -
^ move 1 column.. ==a don't you think it's a bit monotonous ending? just a suggestion if you apply mod above i prefer to keep it on the center, I also added a few notes so it's different than the earlier section.

[Hard]
00:06:121 (6121|5) - ==a i really not understand with those 1/4 spacing... it feels... idk... connect it with 00:06:621 (6621|4) - , and all similar LN ahead ( 01:36:788 (96788|3,97121|4) - and etc ) originally it was just so it would keep consistent between diffs, but i noticed that consistency between diffs is not all that important, changed.

00:54:788 (54788|1,54955|2) - & 00:55:455 (55455|3,55621|4) - ctrl + G ? feels connected to the earlier pattern, keep

02:34:788 (154788|3) - GG can you no... @_@ move that notes to 1 & add on 7, then this LN 02:32:121 (152121|3) - that spacing on longer LN feels not neat.. ==a ): ok, I'LL DO IT JUST BECAUSE IT'S YOU

03:01:121 (181121|4) - move to 6 done

03:30:621 (210621|4) - no cue sound... ==a oops, forgot to delete that one

03:30:788 (210788|2) - GG 1/4 spacing, can you no... =_= :V

[Insane]
00:15:705 - add 1 note? I'm not really mapping the drums here, just resembling them at parts, so no

==a clean... i played this many times before, and i i cant find something.. except the 1/4 spacing on LN ends.. hue Fixed the ones i noticed, i'm going to make a through examination after i finish hitsounding, so if i missed some i'll delete them by then

[why not Coma?]
00:42:121 (42121|6) - add 1 note? I prefer to keep it that way
01:33:121 (93121|4) - ^ same
02:26:455 (146455|6) - ^ same
03:30:788 (210788|2) - those 1/4 spacing.. ;-; :V

some part is 'cool' with 1/4 ln spacing (like when gumi says 'ngayon', or short LNs stream), but most of them feels like 'omg why this 1/4 spacing is here', because the sound is not stopped on that place.. =w=

i also looking forward this map getting ranked... need more enjoyable 7K map.. ;w;

KawaEE wrote:

Hello, moddingsuggest

modding

Column l 1 l 2 l 3 l 4 l 5 l 6 l 7 l

Insane
00:30:621 - move to 4 using the central note here would give it more attention than it needs
00:30:705 - move to 4 ^
00:30:788 - move to 1,7 It's following the guitar, and as far as i know it doesn't change pitch, keeping
01:46:621 - move to 2 aite

Unconscious
00:30:621 - move to 2,7 I prefer to keep the jack, so the pattern is more "intense"
01:12:788 - move to 4,6 Intentional jack, I prefer to keep that pattern.
01:57:788 - move to 1,2,5 Guitar doesn't change pitch, keeping.
01:59:955 - move to 4 ok

good luck XD

Narcissu wrote:

[Unconscious]

01:17:455 - delete “77455,-100,4,2,0,30,0,0” nope o-o

02:10:788 - delete“130788,-100,4,2,0,30,0,0” ^

good luck >,

Narcissu wrote:

you must fix it
ohhhhhhh
OHHHHHH
OOOOOOHHHHHHH
jesus i feel really bad right now
fixed fixed fixed fixed fixed

and 03:15:288 (195288|6) - ……you must delete it
yes ok thanks

-Kamikaze- wrote:

Don't you dare to grave this

Blocko wrote:

But I'm pretty sure he'll come back to it once he has more time in his hands.

Tristan97 wrote:

Ugh I hate it when I lose my mods because of accidentally closing tabs.

For Kami's difficulty:

SPOILER

02:09:455 (129455|3) - make this a hold that lasts for a beat Sounds good
02:32:121 (152121|3) - make this a hold that lasts until 02:34:788 I don't want to follow vocal and guitar here with LN, feels nice to just play it with single note imo
03:06:788 (186788|6) - move to column 2
03:09:455 (189455|2) - move to column 7
03:12:121 (192121|4) - move to column 1
04:05:121 (245121|2) - move to column 2 Applied all

Good luck with rank!

Amefurashi- wrote:

WHOAHOAHAOHAOHAOHAOHAOHAOHOA

should i mod?

*Throws ninja stars at Paulnet Paulmrm

schwarzvgrune wrote:

from beat savior's queue
t/265133&start=0

EZ

SPOILER

i'll focus more on balancing for the difficulty
00:34:788 (34788|3,35455|0) - LN is better (and better follow the guitar melody) I do not follow guitar anywhere in this map
you have few LN for EZ, add a couple more for ppl to train
example of placement following the pitch
http://puu.sh/fFnEj/8d0628103e.jpg That looks bad lol

if you do follow the melody, delete 00:36:788 - Not following melody, that's for kick

00:37:455 (37455|2) - move to 1, LN Nope, not following guitar. Added missing note on 00:38:788 - tho

something like this
http://puu.sh/fFnTD/2ef4afa96c.jpg Looks awful, also it's going to be p a i n for newbies

and i don't think this will be considered as overmapping for EZ, so no worries (i think) I don't want to make it as hard for EZ as I can, I want to make it as easy as it can possibly be


00:46:788 - until 00:54:788 - change all to LN, you're following the accompaniments.
or you can revamp the whole section by following the beat instead, it will be better as well because there will be more notes to press did you consider the fact that I don't want more notes to be there? Also no change on LN department

00:58:788 (58788|3) - move to 2 or 1, pitch decrease here even for the beat It's for better trasition into other hand, not following pitch

01:01:455 (61455|2) - to 1 ^
01:01:788 (61788|0,62455|0,63121|0) - to 4 That looks very weird + I would rather not overuse space
01:03:788 (63788|0,63955|2,64121|4) - drag 1x to the right (2 4 6) Nope, looks bad
again because of pitch relevancy of the beat Not focusing on pitch, focusing on patterns

for example if you do follow the beat, delete these
01:28:788 (88788|5,90121|4,90788|6,91455|0) -

and if you decide to follow the main beat with the accompaniment beat in the background, then add aother note for every 4/4 beat for consistency
for example
if you add 01:28:788 (88788|5) -
why not here as well 01:29:455 - 01:32:121 - 01:32:788 - I originally had them mapped, but then decided that sound is not powerful enough to ensure same intensity as in kiai so I removed them


01:28:121 - 01:36:121 - you're mixing the beat and the singer. pick one for consistency.
here i assume you're going to follow the singer *bzzzzzt* I'm following kicks and specific drums, therefore I'm ignoring suggestions below

01:29:288 - add to 3
01:30:788 (90788|6) - move to 3
01:31:121 (91121|2) - mvoe to 2
01:31:955 - add to 4
01:35:121 - add 3
01:35:788 - add 1
01:37:121 - add a note somewhere


and also make them into LN, up until 01:38:788 - (from 01:28:121)

and reposition the note to follow the pitch if you do follow the instrument, be consistent. if you're following the beat, it's pretty easy to guess where and when to place the note so i leave that to you. You might know what I was typing here by now


03:04:121 - until 03:14:788 -
use LN to fill the gap Why would I fill the gap when song almost completely stops here?

03:51:455 (231455|3) - LN ends at 03:52:121 - LN is for drumroll and it ends exactly there

04:12:788 (252788|2) - ^ 04:13:455 - ^

for EZ overall its good and pretty balanced already, you have issues with beat / melody consistency, don't follow both at the same phase, try to stick to one for each phase (the phase usually is around 4 x 4/4 or 8 x 4/4 beats, minus some irregularities.

arviejhay wrote:

maybe add "filipino" to tags
because she sings tagalog?

no kudosu.

bakabakemono wrote:

Umm sorry paul I will mod your map one week later because I have to preparing national exam

bakabakemono wrote:

Hi Paul! Sorry for 2 weeks delay orzorzorz. Here your mod as requested from Moddar Huehue Team Mania.

These mods are only suggestion, so feel free to reject it!

Column: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
[General]

1. Bg size should be 1024 x 768 or 1366 x 768

[Unconscious]

1. 00:11:455 (11455|1) - move to 1? since this noise is same with this 00:11:788 - nah that's for the snare
2. 00:16:121 (16121|6,16288|6,16455|6,16621|6) - remove? its weird you use this part triplet but the others aren't, like: It's there to add intensity since a new guitar harmony was introduced in the song.
   
   1. 00:05:455 (5455|3,5455|2,5621|3,5621|1,5788|3,5788|1,5955|1,5955|3) -
   2. 00:06:788 (6788|1,6788|3,6955|1,6955|3,7121|1,7121|3,7288|3,7288|1) -
   3. etc
3. 00:17:455 (17455|5,17621|5,17788|5,17955|5) - ^
4. 00:18:788 (18788|4,18955|4,19121|4,19288|4) - ^ and also applied in others part
5. 00:28:455 (28455|4) - remove? its weak sound (hi hat) Keeping, it's a bit more consistent this way imo
6. 00:37:121 (37121|3) - ^
7. 00:39:121 (39121|4) - ^
8. 00:40:621 - add one more note? kick The kick is not very strong so i'm going to keep expressing it with one note
9. 00:41:955 - ^
10. 00:44:455 (44455|3) - remove, idk what sound you follow but its inaudible Same sound as 00:44:788 (44788|0) - , I decided to express the whole thing in two notes because there's a pretty strong change in intensity and volume on 00:44:788 -
11. 01:15:288 (75288|3) - move to 3? just suggestion for comfortability between those LNs ._. I like the way the jacks fits in there, keeping.
12. 01:17:455 - add more note here for additional cymbal, for consistency with this part 01:22:788 - okie
13. 01:36:455 - add note at 3 for hihat not mapping the hi-hats in this section of the music
14. 01:48:455 (108455|2,108788|6) - remove? inaudible vocal pitch following the guitar here
15. 01:49:788 - add two notes here, for snare Did something else for this and other parts with a missing snare.
16. 01:52:455 (112455|3,112455|2) - rearrange these notes, because it has different sound with next notes not sure what you mean here
17. 01:54:621 (114621|5) - remove, ghost note it's actually following the guitars
18. 01:55:121 (115121|2,115121|4) - same case with 01:52:455 -
19. 02:10:788 - add more notes, you did it here 02:16:121 - okie
20. 02:16:705 - missing kick? add notes pretty sure i only hear a low hi-hat there, keeping
21. 02:31:288 - ^ okie
22. 02:44:455 - add notes at 7, it has same sound with next notes okie
23. 03:17:205 - missing hihat, add one note not mapping the hi-hats here
24. 03:39:205 (219205|4) - remove, ghost note okie
25. 03:41:621 (221621|5) - ^might sound stupid but this note is actually expressing the voice lol

[Insane]

1. 00:05:038 - missing kick, add note these notes are for the guitar, not mapping the kicks here
2. 00:07:371 - ^
3. 00:07:955 - add one more note, its kick
4. 00:12:705 - missing kick, add note
5. 00:15:705 - ^
6. 00:16:038 - ^
7. 00:18:455 - remove one, one note is enough for hi hat :p mapping the guitar here
8. 00:27:788 - missing kicks around this part, add at note at 00:27:788 - 00:27:871 - 00:27:955 - same as the last part
9. 00:33:121 - ^ same case
10. 00:33:955 - add note, it has same kick sound with this 00:33:788 - not mapping kicks here, mapping the hi-hats in the first column
11. 00:40:621 - add double notes here, it has kick sound aaaa not mapping kicks
12. 00:40:955 (40955|3) - inaudible sound, remove following the guitar here
13. 00:41:288 - missing kicks? nah
14. 00:41:955 - ^
15. 00:44:288 - ^
16. 01:07:955 - ^
17. 01:08:038 - ^
18. 01:10:621 - ^
19. 01:10:705 - ^
20. 01:22:288 - ^ just suggestion -> http://puu.sh/hnQGn/3c4d9641e1.jpg hi-hats and snares here
    argh missing kicks everywhere xD
21. 01:54:621 (114621|5) - remove, inaudible sound same as unconscious
22. 02:31:288 - missing kick okie, you're right this time :V
23. 03:39:205 (219205|1) - remove, ghost note ghost note sniped

[Hard]

1. 00:18:288 - add note at 3 and then 00:18:121 (18121|6,18288|6,18455|6,18621|6) - remove, inaudible sound not following the kicks here
2. 00:24:121 - add more notes, cymbal okie
3. 00:36:955 (36955|5,37288|5) - remove, inaudible sound imo guitars here
4. 01:08:538 (68538|2,68705|2) - remove, no kicks there following the guitar
5. 01:11:205 (71205|2,71371|2) - ^
6. 01:43:538 - missing kick, add note. and then 01:43:621 - remove one to reduce star difficulty there's a 1/4 snare too, but i prefer to keep it chordy like that instead of adding 1/4s here
7. 01:43:871 - ^ and then 01:43:955 - ^
8. 01:54:788 - add one note for loud cymbal sound added two
9. 01:57:455 - ^
10. 02:10:788 - add two notes, loud cymbal sound okie
11. 03:28:121 - ^
12. the last kiai's patterns are too hard for this diff imo. you should remove several notes thereeh, i'm kinda going to keep the density, i moved a few unnecessary jacks and also some notes for less column bias though

Damn this took 3 hours xD will mod Normal and Easy tomorrow (maybe). Sorry can't help much ;w;

bakabakemono wrote:

aww will remod all diff... sorry for inconvenience

-Kamikaze- wrote:

I've never done a psytrance remix of COMA

Kruzon wrote:

i come to collect kudosu

maki easy

00:19:621 (19621|5) - move to 00:19:455 (19455|5) - better readability added a note there instead
00:20:955 (20955|2) - move to 2, column 2 felt quite empty and more comfortable altering hand from mid column okay
00:23:455 (23455|1) - ctrl + h nope, reverse pattern of 00:21:455 (21455|4,21705|4,21955|4,22121|5) -

00:27:788 (27788|3) - move to 3
00:28:788 (28788|2) - move to 4 ok

00:32:121 (32121|4) - move to 7, same like 00:29:455 (29455|6) - diffrent beuildup to that note and col 5 is really empty here
00:33:121 (33121|2) - move to 6 intentional two notes on one hand pattern
00:33:621 (33621|5) - move to 1 ^

00:39:455 (39455|5,39621|4,39788|3,39955|2,40121|1) - i don't think this stair is suitable for an easy, refer to normal difficulty for answer normal does not accent those drums and my diff is build around drums only for the most part so this is good. unless you find an easier pattern I am not getting rid of that.

00:43:455 (43455|4,43955|2) - ctrl + h, easy to follow when it follow the descending flow from previous notes 00:42:121 (42121|4,42788|3,43455|2) - it's not connected to these notes in any way and this is so far apart that it won't make any diffrence so I'm keeping that

00:45:455 (45455|4) - move to 6, better readability ???????? how is that worse to read
00:46:788 (46788|2,47455|0,48121|6) - ctrl + h, pitch relevancy ok

00:49:455 (49455|4) - move to 6 ok
00:50:788 (50788|5) - move to 2 to 5

00:52:121 (52121|1) - move to 5 no
00:52:788 (52788|4) - move to 1 no

01:01:121 (61121|4) - suggest follow vocal pitch for better emphasis, therefore move to 7 at what point did I follow vocal to make you suggest emphasizing it's pitch?
01:02:455 (62455|0,63121|0) - move to 6, then 2 you should take a look at the structure of this part beforehand.

01:03:788 (63788|0,63955|2,64121|4) - press ctrl + G, then shift them 1 time to the right
01:05:121 (65121|6) - move to 1

01:06:121 (66121|2) - move to 5
01:06:288 (66288|1) - move to 3
01:08:121 (68121|5) - move to 5, improve readability when considered sequence of stairs from 01:06:788 (66788|0,67038|1,67288|2,67455|3) - no to all, same reason

01:12:788 (72788|2) - move to 1, column consistency what consistency do you even mean

01:27:788 (87788|6) - move to 4
01:28:121 (88121|3,88121|5) - move to 1 and 7 respectively, wider gap gives more emphasis for current loudness + climax changed diffrently

01:29:788 (89788|5,90121|4,90455|3) - shift them 1 time to the left ok
01:31:121 (91121|2) - move to 4 ok
01:32:455 (92455|6) - move to 6 no
01:34:121 (94121|3) - move to 2, mirroring 01:32:455 (92455|5) - no

01:34:621 (94621|3) - move to 6
01:35:455 (95455|1,96121|5) - move to 4, then 2
01:36:788 (96788|6,97455|0) - ctrl + h I like my patterning there so no

01:40:121 (100121|2,100455|2) - move them to 2 ok
01:40:788 (100788|4,101121|4) - move them to 6 ok

01:48:788 (108788|3) - could be a long note to represent drum roll, and placed on 1 or 7 for readability I do not like the idea of long note coming into double and I like those notes places on spacebar
02:10:788 (130788|5,130788|3) - better gives wider gap instead, moves to 1 and 7 respectively I disagree, removed gap entierly

02:19:121 (139121|2) - move to 6
02:19:788 (139788|5) - move to 3 no to both

02:21:121 (141121|0,141455|3,141455|1) - well you know what to do Moved 02:21:455 (141455|1) - to 3

02:23:121 (143121|1,143455|2,143788|3) - ctrl + h repatterned
02:26:455 (146455|4,146788|2) - move to 6, then 2 no
02:42:788 (162788|5,163121|6) - ctrl + h ok
02:43:455 (163455|3,163621|2,163788|1) - same
02:44:121 (164121|4) - move to 2
02:45:121 (165121|4) - move to 6
02:48:538 (168538|4) - move to 3 repatterned on my own

02:58:121 (178121|5,178288|4,178455|3,178621|2,178788|1) - could be easier
03:01:455 (181455|2) - move to 2
03:03:455 (183455|1,183455|2) - shift 1 time to the left repatterned on my own as well

03:16:788 (196788|2) - move to 7 n
03:18:121 (198121|6) - move to 3 n
03:22:455 (202455|6) - move to 2 n
03:22:788 (202788|2,202788|4) - move them to 1 and 7 respectively n
03:23:455 (203455|0,204121|3) - shift 3 times to the right o
03:24:788 (204788|6,204788|3) - move to 3 and 5 respectively o
03:25:788 (205788|6,206121|1) - move to 2, then 3 o
03:26:455 (206455|5,206788|2,207121|4) - move to 5, 6, then 7 o

03:37:288 (217288|2) - move to 2 ok
03:38:455 (218455|1) - move to 3 moved to 1

03:49:455 (229455|3,229455|1,230121|4,230121|0) - make them symmetrical I see no reason to
03:50:788 (230788|5) - move to 1 no

03:54:121 (234121|5) - move to 3 no
03:54:788 (234788|2) - move to 7 no
03:55:455 (235455|6) - move to 6 no
03:58:121 (238121|1,238121|6) - move to 1 and 4 respectively no
03:59:455 (239455|0) - move to 7 no
04:00:121 (240121|2,240788|4) - move to 5, then 6 no
04:01:455 (241455|1,241621|1) - move to 7 no
04:02:788 (242788|0) - move to 3 no
04:05:121 (245121|1) - move to 1 no

04:06:121 (246121|2,246455|0) - shift them 2 times to the left dude are you high, why are you telling me to move a column 1 note left??????????
04:06:788 (246788|2) - move to 2 and we're back to no's
04:07:121 (247121|1,247455|4,247788|5) - move them to 7, 6, then 5 done diffrently
04:08:121 (248121|2,248121|4) - move to 1 and 7 respectively please
04:08:788 (248788|0) - move to 3 no

04:09:121 (249121|1,249455|5) - ctrl + h ok
04:10:121 (250121|4,250288|5,250455|6) - 6, 4, 2 no, no, no
04:10:788 (250788|1,250788|3) - 1, 7 what is up with you and 17 chords, give me a break
04:12:121 (252121|6,252288|5,252455|4,252621|3,252788|2) - ctrl + h no more
04:13:455 (253455|4,253455|5) - 1, 7 salvation

- mod ends -

well um, i'll just mod this one. in return you can just mod 1 of my difficulty named Nocturne. Thank you

Ascendance wrote:

M4M Requested by -Kamikaze-. I don't play much 7K so my mod will be on basic playability, hitsounds, or consistency issues. Pardon in advance on my english. First actual mania mod >< if it's good I'll come back and mod the other diffs

7K = |1|2|3|4|5|6|7|

Maki's Easy

Thoughts before modding: In my opinion, there are many spots where there could be added notes without increasing difficulty. Some parts just seem very lackluster where there is potential for placement notes. That is intentional, but let's see what you've got

00:07:788 (7788|5) - move to 6 to keep pattern similar to the previous one here 00:04:788 (4788|1,5121|5) - which has the same sound. I prefer doing diffrent patterns so it's more varied and fun

00:13:455 (13455|3) - maybe consider turning this into a triple (?) col 3|4|5 because of the downbeat emphasis I might turn it into a double, but I feel like it doesn't need any more emphasis as it is the intro still and layering is kinda soft. Not going to use a triple in any setup though

00:23:455 (23455|1) - consider moving this to col 4, and create a pattern similar to this maybe 00:22:788 (22788|2,23038|2,23288|2,23455|1) - is a mirrored pattern of 00:21:455 (21455|4,21705|4,21955|4,22121|5) - and I really dislike the idea of having 2 notes at the end of LN in this diff

00:30:121 (30121|0,30621|2) - Swap these positions? 00:30:621 (30621|2) - seems to be a bass / very low note so it makes more sense okay

00:32:788 (32788|1,33121|2) - same here I think okay

00:35:788 - seems very empty, you could maybe add a note here.. I do not want to accent that drum here and to be honest I quite like that empty feeling it gives

01:38:788 (98788|2,99121|2) - consider turning the patterns like these into this since you are not creating singles for all 3 notes, it may be better to emphasize the first note and the last note as such. Now I would place notes for all 3 notes but it would be too hard, so I'm accenting what I can and I wish to stick with it

01:48:788 (108788|3) - LN for drumroll that ends at 01:49:455 - ? okay, removed one note at the end as well

02:00:121 (120121|3) - Starting here, I feel like you could turn this section into LN because of the long sustained notes. done that

02:32:121 (152121|3) - LN I want to leave this place empty as a rest point where you don't really have to concentrate and hold any buttons

03:28:121 (208121|3) - LN would be a nice finish to this segment you created, stopping it on a single note feels kind of anticlimactic nice idea!

Sorry if my mod is useless... very few experience with 7K so maybe I have some ideas wrong...

Nivrad00 wrote:

BN check

General

Remove gumi from tags cus it's in the artist field
You can go ahead and add tagalog as mentioned earlier

00:24:121 - Unconscious has two green lines on top of each other here. Didn't someone point this out already? Nah, it was another green line.
04:13:455 - also here fixed both

bg has a weird aspect ratio. I found a high-quality version online and cropped it to 1024x768 if you wouldn't mind replacing it http://puu.sh/pTLZ7.png (make sure the old one gets deleted) okie

Difficulties

Maki's Easy
02:48:538 - why is this on a 1/4
04:07:038 - I mean honestly

Normal
http://puu.sh/pTQpb.png you must have thought you were mapping 4k here maybe
00:34:788 (34788|0) - accidental normal-hitwhistle? yep
01:17:455 - crash pls crashed
01:22:788 - how come this is a double but not 01:17:455 - oops someone else did this not me
02:16:121 - and 02:10:788 - same stop messing with my map dog
01:38:788 - to 02:00:121 - there are no hitsounds except soft-hitnormal in this entire time span P. my dog deleted all of it, here i re-hitsounded it
02:10:788 - crash crashed
03:37:455 - ghost busted
03:58:288 (238288|1) - why not put this on the 1/1 like 03:59:455 - and 04:00:788 - i have no idea, this was probably an accident when i was editing this some time

Hard
00:43:288 - guitar pitch changes here Honestly i didn't want to change this and was about to use the drums as an excuse, but it's obvious the drums are not what's being followed here. It's... hard to actually fit the actual pitch here and I don't want to change any of the earlier or later patterns. I decided to distort the PR a bit and just follow some other pattern that would fit well here too.
01:25:955 (85955|4) - smh BAD DOG
02:19:288 (139288|4) - smh x2 both very fixed yes hmm
03:26:788 - this LN pattern looks really underwhelming when it doesn't have single notes like Insane and Unconscious I added two more, should at least help
03:30:455 (210455|3) - you gotta decide whether you want this LN to have a length of 1/2, 3/4, or 1/1 beat. it's inconsistent across the difficulties and across the three choruses inconsistency fixed AND decided to go for the safest route
03:30:038 - also you gotta decide whether you want this to start on the beat or slightly below it cus that's not consistent either ^
03:30:788 (210788|2) - you could make this end a 1/4 early to match all the other LNs in this part decided to do the opposite, after all, if i didn't it would be inconsistent with the other difficulties wink, made all the other LNs end a 1/4 later

Insane
00:46:621 (46621|5) - probably not supposed to be a crash yeah it's supposed to be a whistle, uncrashed
01:06:455 - this inconsistency with Unconcious is bothering me. Everything else around here is exactly the same as Unconscious. How did this LN get changed?? i actually have no idea how that happened, it's a mystery, fixed anyway
03:29:288 (209288|3) - probably not supposed to be a clap unclopped, whistled
01:17:455 - crash pls bandicooted
02:10:788 - crash

Unconscious
01:17:455 - crash pls no, jk yes
01:22:955 (82955|0) - this is unacceptable sir move it to the second lane immediately ok ):
02:10:788 - crash maybe, i mean yes
01:24:455 - missing drum-hitclap drum-hitclogged
01:43:121 - why no note on the second lane it was my other dog, joey
03:41:455 (221455|4) - I have a feeling this should be a crash, not a drum-hitclap joey stop pissing in the keyboard
03:51:455 - this pattern looks like an angel u be talkin shit about my angelic d.va? ...or should i say e.va?

I encourage you to check over everything yourself before the qualify because there's no way I caught everything. Those mis-snaps on Easy and Hard really shouldn't be there by the time you call a BN. will do

I gotta put in my 2 cents about your charting style here

This map seems to break every mapping convention that the mania community has developed. I mean look at this thing on Insane:
04:02:121 (242121|0,242121|4,242205|1,242288|2,242288|0,242371|6,242455|5,242455|4,242538|3,242621|5,242621|2,242705|6)
It looks like an amoeba. Or like a cat threw up, walked a couple steps, and threw up again. The odd spacing makes it hard to follow the rhythm, both hands have to awkwardly come in on a 1/2 or 1/4 snap, and there's no visual pattern. that was actually a victim of porting some patterns from unconscious and removing/moving some notes haha, i thought about changing it but i just went "can't be that bad" at the time, changed it to something more linear but still tricky.

But even though these things are usually the hallmark of an inexperienced mania mapper, spoon definitely knows what he's doing. He ignores the "meta" not because he hasn't figured it out, but because he has his own way of creating nuance through anchors, laning, pitch, etc. The result is chord jacks, brackets, and other interesting finger contortions that you can't find elsewhere. I can say what I want about cat vomit, but spoon's style has persevered through a deluge of mainstream mapping to provide some desperately-needed variety in the pool of ranked maps. that was a fun read

You should fix the cat vomit pattern though

Bubble coming your way as soon as you respond to my suggestions
oh no BOYYYY we gotta wait one month for that because i'm stupid

Nivrad00 wrote:

BN check

Maki's Easy
02:48:538 - why is this on a 1/4 shit man, if I knew
04:07:038 - I mean honestly I was prob drinking a lot or something


Bubble coming your way as soon as you respond to my suggestions

alacat wrote:

hey where is from "feat." ? Ranked map ?

I checked the metadata of this song 2 years ago : https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/3990490

The artist name should be "ensou ft. GUMI" according the official.