hi there!
red = strongly recommend or unrankable
black = suggestion
[General]
- I couldn't find the metadata online, but at least add のんのんびより (japanese for no non biyori) as source
- no breaks in song, so uncheck "Letterbox during breaks"
[Easy]
General comments:
- add more variety of slider shapes, it's kinda repetitive with all the straight sliders imo.
- along those same lines, adjust slider shape to incorporate more symmetry and blanketing into map.
Map:
- 00:08:980 (1,2,3) - Hard for beginners. at least use DS=0.7x so it's similar to the rest of the map
- 00:10:352 (1) - maybe rotate by 30 degrees for better flow
- 00:14:466 (4) - move down for better flow
- 00:18:581 (4) - take 00:16:523 (2) - and ctrl+j for symmetry
- 00:19:952 (5) - move clap from slider head to slider tail
- 00:21:323 (1,2,3) - actually, why do your claps change from offbeats to downbeats?
- 00:39:838 (3) - take 00:37:781 (1) - and ctrl+j for symmetry
[Normal]
General comments:
- NCs seem random to me. Please use NCs on downbeats and end of phrases (00:15:838 (3) - 00:35:038 (5) - 00:37:781 (3) - etc...)
- 00:13:095 - downbeats are very strong and should be mapped with something clickable in your case, the rhythm is quick enough that at least every other downbeat from 00:10:352 (1) - (00:13:095 , 00:15:838 , 00:18:581 , 00:21:323 , etc...) needs something clickable
- 00:18:581 - ^
- 00:40:523 - ^
- 00:46:009 - ^
etc... I think you get the point.
Sorry, I didn't look at flow and aesthetics for this diff because I feel a lot of rhythms need reworking.
[Hard]
Turn on DS, a lot of your rhythms are not intuitive because the spacing is wrong
Change HP drain rate to 5
- 00:10:352 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,1) - DS please, otherwise rhythms are confusing
- 00:13:095 (1) - imo this should be a slider to follow vocals
- 00:13:095 (1,2) - either way, DS problem here
- 00:14:466 (5,6) - ^
- 00:15:838 (1,2) - ^ etc... (I'll stop comment on these types of DS, but it occurs throughout the entire map)
- 00:17:895 (6,7) - rhythm suggestion to follow vocals better
- 00:19:952 (5) - NC here and remove NC at 00:20:809 (1) -
- 00:24:066 (1,2,3) - DS pretty please
- 00:25:438 (5,6) - ^
- 00:30:923 (3,4,5) - the mapping is much tamer than 00:19:952 (5,6,7,1,2,3,4) - even though the song is the same in both parts. please match song intensity with mapping intesity
- 00:32:295 (1,2) - suggest you use a 1/1 slider here since you're following piano for the rest of song
[Insane]
- 00:15:495 (1) - remove NC and add NC at 00:15:838 (2) -
- 00:19:952 (1) - add finish? I can here it in the song lol
- 00:21:323 (1) - ^
- 00:22:523 (7,1) - ctrl+g rhythm (something clickable on downbeat)
- 00:30:923 - needs something clickable here
- 00:32:295 (1) - could maybe add finish here
- 00:36:409 (1,2) - maybe change these to 1/1 sliders and add notes at 00:36:923 and 00:37:609 - but ok if you don't
- 00:47:381 (1,2) - ^
Wow...flow, NC, DS, slider shape... they're all much, much better than your easier diffs! Please try to apply some of these principles to the rest of your mapset!
[Xtra]
General comments:
SV 1.3x is pretty weak for an xtra. Suggest you bump up to 1.6~1.7x
Your spacing keeps getting bigger even though nothing in the song suggests it x.x Please fix
Map:
00:08:980 (1,2,3,4,5) - either curve this or make 00:09:495 (1,2,3,4,5) - straight for consistency
00:10:352 (1) - Too much clap for me (like twice as much). Either remove claps on beats 1 and 3 or remove claps on beat 2 and 4.
00:13:609 (3,4,5) - DS, this should be on top of 00:14:466 (2) - imho
00:51:323 (7) - I always feel these 1/4 sliders should come in pairs. change 00:51:152 (5,6) - to a slider?
Hope that helps and PM me if you have any questions about my mod!
red = strongly recommend or unrankable
black = suggestion
[General]
- I couldn't find the metadata online, but at least add のんのんびより (japanese for no non biyori) as source
- no breaks in song, so uncheck "Letterbox during breaks"
[Easy]
General comments:
- add more variety of slider shapes, it's kinda repetitive with all the straight sliders imo.
- along those same lines, adjust slider shape to incorporate more symmetry and blanketing into map.
Map:
- 00:08:980 (1,2,3) - Hard for beginners. at least use DS=0.7x so it's similar to the rest of the map
- 00:10:352 (1) - maybe rotate by 30 degrees for better flow
- 00:14:466 (4) - move down for better flow
- 00:18:581 (4) - take 00:16:523 (2) - and ctrl+j for symmetry
- 00:19:952 (5) - move clap from slider head to slider tail
- 00:21:323 (1,2,3) - actually, why do your claps change from offbeats to downbeats?
- 00:39:838 (3) - take 00:37:781 (1) - and ctrl+j for symmetry
[Normal]
General comments:
- NCs seem random to me. Please use NCs on downbeats and end of phrases (00:15:838 (3) - 00:35:038 (5) - 00:37:781 (3) - etc...)
- 00:13:095 - downbeats are very strong and should be mapped with something clickable in your case, the rhythm is quick enough that at least every other downbeat from 00:10:352 (1) - (00:13:095 , 00:15:838 , 00:18:581 , 00:21:323 , etc...) needs something clickable
- 00:18:581 - ^
- 00:40:523 - ^
- 00:46:009 - ^
etc... I think you get the point.
Sorry, I didn't look at flow and aesthetics for this diff because I feel a lot of rhythms need reworking.
[Hard]
Turn on DS, a lot of your rhythms are not intuitive because the spacing is wrong
Change HP drain rate to 5
- 00:10:352 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,1) - DS please, otherwise rhythms are confusing
- 00:13:095 (1) - imo this should be a slider to follow vocals
- 00:13:095 (1,2) - either way, DS problem here
- 00:14:466 (5,6) - ^
- 00:15:838 (1,2) - ^ etc... (I'll stop comment on these types of DS, but it occurs throughout the entire map)
- 00:17:895 (6,7) - rhythm suggestion to follow vocals better
- 00:19:952 (5) - NC here and remove NC at 00:20:809 (1) -
- 00:24:066 (1,2,3) - DS pretty please
- 00:25:438 (5,6) - ^
- 00:30:923 (3,4,5) - the mapping is much tamer than 00:19:952 (5,6,7,1,2,3,4) - even though the song is the same in both parts. please match song intensity with mapping intesity
- 00:32:295 (1,2) - suggest you use a 1/1 slider here since you're following piano for the rest of song
[Insane]
- 00:15:495 (1) - remove NC and add NC at 00:15:838 (2) -
- 00:19:952 (1) - add finish? I can here it in the song lol
- 00:21:323 (1) - ^
- 00:22:523 (7,1) - ctrl+g rhythm (something clickable on downbeat)
- 00:30:923 - needs something clickable here
- 00:32:295 (1) - could maybe add finish here
- 00:36:409 (1,2) - maybe change these to 1/1 sliders and add notes at 00:36:923 and 00:37:609 - but ok if you don't
- 00:47:381 (1,2) - ^
Wow...flow, NC, DS, slider shape... they're all much, much better than your easier diffs! Please try to apply some of these principles to the rest of your mapset!
[Xtra]
General comments:
SV 1.3x is pretty weak for an xtra. Suggest you bump up to 1.6~1.7x
Your spacing keeps getting bigger even though nothing in the song suggests it x.x Please fix
Map:
00:08:980 (1,2,3,4,5) - either curve this or make 00:09:495 (1,2,3,4,5) - straight for consistency
00:10:352 (1) - Too much clap for me (like twice as much). Either remove claps on beats 1 and 3 or remove claps on beat 2 and 4.
00:13:609 (3,4,5) - DS, this should be on top of 00:14:466 (2) - imho
00:51:323 (7) - I always feel these 1/4 sliders should come in pairs. change 00:51:152 (5,6) - to a slider?
Hope that helps and PM me if you have any questions about my mod!